Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Nathaniel Chalobah signs a one year deal

123578

Comments

  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 17,614
    In what world is that Lloydy?
  • Kips
    Kips Posts: 722
    In what world is that Lloydy?
    Looks a bit too cheerful for NJ too. Not sure I've ever seen his nashers. 
  • msomerton
    msomerton Posts: 3,613
    wmcf123 said:
    SDAddick said:
    If there's any greater indicator of how progressively more deranged football fans get over the close season it's talking about a midfielder who was part of the squad that survived that season and going from 'we should sign an improvement on that player' to 'we are guaranteed to get relegated if he plays'. I was thinking about some of our best results last season; Blackburn, Coventry, Birmingham and Hull at home, Ipswich, Boro and Leicester away, Conor Coventry started all but two of those and played in all except the Hull game. He's a decent player who we need more competition for and there will be games where he's more or less suited depending on who we play. He's not some bargain bin Matt Smith we picked up in desperation. Football fans are getting so much weirder every year about their own players
    A well deserved defense of Coventry. I agree I think he gets slated far too much. He is limited at certain things, but what he does, getting into pressing lanes, breaking up play, retaining possession, he does well. And as I mentioned in my post, I do think he still has another gear to go up. 

    It's worth remembering he was hurt from around the turn of the year with a hip injury, which is part of why we got Coady in. I thought in the first half of the season he looked to be at the standard necessary, and I've not seen much since that to make me believe he's anything other than a bottom half Championship midfielder. Which is, coincidentally, what we are. 

    I think Chalobah could be better than Cov. I also think Cov as a broader range of passing than we've seen from him--which he's shown glimpses of in pre-season. But I think Chalobah and Coventry as competition for a spot, and maybe deployed as a defensive two on ocassion, represents good squad strength and depth for where we are.

    Combine this with Mesik/Bell/Edwards at LB, Ramsay/McNamara at RB, a litany of CBs, and Godden, Leaburn, Kelman, Mbick up front and TC/Grant/Alli on the LW and we have some decent ability and depth in certain areas. We obviously know we need another 8 and a RW. But you can see this squad taking shape and I think it's one that, if we stay healthy and if we adapt well to a new system of play and if we continue to see improvements from some key players like Coventry, Leaburn, Kelman, TC (if he stays) Koumentio, and Ramsay, then I think we could push for kind of 12-15th, which to me would be a big success.

    There is still a decent amount of upside in this squad, both from younger players/players newer to the level like Leaburn, Mbick, TC, and Kelman, but there's also upside in terms of health for the likes of Burke, Chalobah, and Bell--all of whom are undoubtedly Championship players when fit. But unlike last season, we have cover for those three, just as we have cover for the young players, which to me might be the biggest improvement for this squad.
    How on earth did we beat Ipswich 3-0 with that line up? Macca, Bell at wing back , Doc and Cov , Tanto up front .  Frightening 
    Sheer luck they were not 3-0 by 30  Mins in.. 
  • ro_addick
    ro_addick Posts: 337
    Valley11 said:
    fenaddick said:
    Valley11 said:
    Talal said:
    Welcome Nathaniel (but when was the last time we signed a player and said 'great signing IF he stays fit' and he actually stayed fit?)
    Amari Bell. This time last season. Arguably POTS
    I love Bell but it's very hard to argue he stayed fit
    Is it? He made 49 apps last season in all comps. 
    Wow. 49 apps to his credit. Clearly a veritable IT wizard and tech entrepreneur of global proportions.
  • jimmymelrose
    jimmymelrose Posts: 10,466
    msomerton said:
    wmcf123 said:
    SDAddick said:
    If there's any greater indicator of how progressively more deranged football fans get over the close season it's talking about a midfielder who was part of the squad that survived that season and going from 'we should sign an improvement on that player' to 'we are guaranteed to get relegated if he plays'. I was thinking about some of our best results last season; Blackburn, Coventry, Birmingham and Hull at home, Ipswich, Boro and Leicester away, Conor Coventry started all but two of those and played in all except the Hull game. He's a decent player who we need more competition for and there will be games where he's more or less suited depending on who we play. He's not some bargain bin Matt Smith we picked up in desperation. Football fans are getting so much weirder every year about their own players
    A well deserved defense of Coventry. I agree I think he gets slated far too much. He is limited at certain things, but what he does, getting into pressing lanes, breaking up play, retaining possession, he does well. And as I mentioned in my post, I do think he still has another gear to go up. 

    It's worth remembering he was hurt from around the turn of the year with a hip injury, which is part of why we got Coady in. I thought in the first half of the season he looked to be at the standard necessary, and I've not seen much since that to make me believe he's anything other than a bottom half Championship midfielder. Which is, coincidentally, what we are. 

    I think Chalobah could be better than Cov. I also think Cov as a broader range of passing than we've seen from him--which he's shown glimpses of in pre-season. But I think Chalobah and Coventry as competition for a spot, and maybe deployed as a defensive two on ocassion, represents good squad strength and depth for where we are.

    Combine this with Mesik/Bell/Edwards at LB, Ramsay/McNamara at RB, a litany of CBs, and Godden, Leaburn, Kelman, Mbick up front and TC/Grant/Alli on the LW and we have some decent ability and depth in certain areas. We obviously know we need another 8 and a RW. But you can see this squad taking shape and I think it's one that, if we stay healthy and if we adapt well to a new system of play and if we continue to see improvements from some key players like Coventry, Leaburn, Kelman, TC (if he stays) Koumentio, and Ramsay, then I think we could push for kind of 12-15th, which to me would be a big success.

    There is still a decent amount of upside in this squad, both from younger players/players newer to the level like Leaburn, Mbick, TC, and Kelman, but there's also upside in terms of health for the likes of Burke, Chalobah, and Bell--all of whom are undoubtedly Championship players when fit. But unlike last season, we have cover for those three, just as we have cover for the young players, which to me might be the biggest improvement for this squad.
    How on earth did we beat Ipswich 3-0 with that line up? Macca, Bell at wing back , Doc and Cov , Tanto up front .  Frightening 
    Sheer luck they were not 3-0 by 30  Mins in.. 
    This was the only match my eldest son attended last season. He's never seen us lose. He always claims that he is controlling the match with his mind, and tells me not to worry. Ipswich away was the first time that I actually began to wonder if he really does exercise some kind of mental mind power over events.
  • CAFCsayer
    CAFCsayer Posts: 10,881
    arny23394 said:

    We are ruining the planet so people can make utter guff like this
    Can't work out if this is a massive whoosh or if chatgpt is one step ahead and knows Holsgrove is signing 😂 


  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 2,793
    🐐
  • fenlandaddick
    fenlandaddick Posts: 2,302


    Hardly recognise them from that angle. 
  • stonemuse
    stonemuse Posts: 35,027
    Chalobah looking good today 

  • Sponsored links:



  • MickeyBennett
    MickeyBennett Posts: 817
    Cheat code
  • CHG
    CHG Posts: 4,577
    Running the show 
  • 2121
    2121 Posts: 1,775
    Commentator

    ‘Even the cheltenham fans are applauding chalobah’

    😂
  • Fumbluff
    Fumbluff Posts: 10,570
    He is looking very good but let’s remember it’s only Cheltenham. 
  • BartramBlitz
    BartramBlitz Posts: 700
    What a lovely player to watch. We need to rotate him to keep him fit.
  • CharltonKerry
    CharltonKerry Posts: 3,105
    Not bad, in fact bloody classy 
  • Addickhead86
    Addickhead86 Posts: 1,209
    Have to say my heart sank when I saw we had him on trial, given his last stint at Wednesday and injures. Guess I'm Mr. Idiot today.
  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,652
    Got out-muscled once....apart from that, superb
  • J BLOCK
    J BLOCK Posts: 8,569
    Absolute miles between him and the rest of our centre mids. A dominant ball player and exactly what we’ve been crying out. Keep him fit and he will be the difference maker for our season. Get someone alongside him that is at his level and this season is comfortable. 
  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 1,013
    Hopefully mwamba can be a capable understudy and we get some one else alongside him. 

    Ran the show for the first 45, for the second half match fitness probably came into play and they likely found a way to keep him out of the game. 

  • Sponsored links:



  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 15,016
    Very much looked like a player who hadn't regularly completed 90 minutes in years. Looked so good in that first half but he was absolutely spent the second. I can see why Jones left him on to try and force more fitness into him but we'd better get that new CM in sharpish because I don't think we'll be seeing any Saturday-Tuesday-Saturday runs out of Chalobah and he's shown what a different a player like him can make
  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,652
    Very much looked like a player who hadn't regularly completed 90 minutes in years. Looked so good in that first half but he was absolutely spent the second. I can see why Jones left him on to try and force more fitness into him but we'd better get that new CM in sharpish because I don't think we'll be seeing any Saturday-Tuesday-Saturday runs out of Chalobah and he's shown what a different a player like him can make
    Or maybe just needs to build up his match fitness?
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 73,109
    Very much looked like a player who hadn't regularly completed 90 minutes in years. Looked so good in that first half but he was absolutely spent the second. I can see why Jones left him on to try and force more fitness into him but we'd better get that new CM in sharpish because I don't think we'll be seeing any Saturday-Tuesday-Saturday runs out of Chalobah and he's shown what a different a player like him can make
    Or maybe just needs to build up his match fitness?
    It's a issue when you are both trying to build up match fitness in a player AND you're also trying to protect them. 

    For the last 2 years, was Chuks ever truly match fit?
  • Dizzle
    Dizzle Posts: 5,223
    Really impressed with Chalobah, really need to keep him fit. A level above everyone else 
  • SDAddick
    SDAddick Posts: 15,095
    Said it many times now, and I've been saying it since he was about 16, but when he's fit he's mustard. Brilliant first half. Kind of tired second half but that's to be expected. Coventry alongside him providing some running looked a very promising double pivot. Lovely burst forward for the second goal as well. 
  • Mendonca In Asdas
    Mendonca In Asdas Posts: 23,039
    I’m trying to not go over the top with excitement as we’ve been here before many times, and we know he’s injury prone, so in the back of your mind you’re wondering , how long will he last?

    First half he was outstanding, I remember not so long ago , we had Bakinson who scored and looked really good for about 3 games, and then tailed off.

    If he can play like that every week, we’d have some player on our hands.


  • Starinnaddick
    Starinnaddick Posts: 4,658
    He has always been an excellent player, according to Wiki he was playing for Chelsea reserves when he was still a schoolboy. If he could ever maintain a top level of fitness he would not be playing for us. NJ needs to take a softly softly approach with him but I'm sure he knows that. 
  • ButtleJR
    ButtleJR Posts: 1,807
    Know someone who was tasked with marking him for Southampton academy and he still says he's the best player he's ever played against. Couldn't get near him. 
  • Addicksi
    Addicksi Posts: 365
    He purrs along like a classic car running the midfield. We all know they can breakdown, just hopefully not too often. 
  • crookester
    crookester Posts: 1,652
    Very much looked like a player who hadn't regularly completed 90 minutes in years. Looked so good in that first half but he was absolutely spent the second. I can see why Jones left him on to try and force more fitness into him but we'd better get that new CM in sharpish because I don't think we'll be seeing any Saturday-Tuesday-Saturday runs out of Chalobah and he's shown what a different a player like him can make
    Or maybe just needs to build up his match fitness?
    It's a issue when you are both trying to build up match fitness in a player AND you're also trying to protect them. 

    For the last 2 years, was Chuks ever truly match fit?
    He wasn't but it seemed like Chuks' body had shutdown by then. I don't know if Chalobah is at that point.