Savings and Investments thread

1…436437439441442…449

Comments

  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 
    There is very likely (almost guaranteed) a rate rise on the 5th November but in the longer term rates will be reducing. I'm expecting base rate to be at or even below where we are now by the end of next year. 
  • bobmunro
    bobmunro Posts: 22,238
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 24,980
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    Agree with all of that.
    The reason I opted for a 4.5% one year option is because it was with the Nationwide BS.
    Plenty of slightly better offers online as you point out but I don't know enough about them .
    I prefer to use the Nationwide as I can walk into their Orpington branch and they set it all up for me.
  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 1,151
    Any particular reason people are choosing cash over bonds? Considering you can get very good yields on bonds nowadays. 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 24,980
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
    For a financial adviser I think you are completely wrong. 
    Without getting into an argument let's leave it here and see how it plays out.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    Just in the process of switching banking to Investec, currently their savings rates are pretty good and they have some linked accounts to the current account 1 month/3 month which may up to 4%. There's a couple of places paying over 5% on a 1 year, Oak North and Close brothers.

    Any particular reason people are choosing cash over bonds? Considering you can get very good yields on bonds nowadays. 
    Because the bond capital can go down.
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
    For a financial adviser I think you are completely wrong. 
    Without getting into an argument let's leave it here and see how it plays out.
    Don't know why you think it would lead to an arguement 🤷‍♂️. I'm just going by what a few investment managers have said at recent webinars I've attended.  We all could be wrong - all really depends on things outside the Bank's control, like Trump & Putin. 
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    I was at an economics panel event last Thursday with some energy market analysts an exec from octopus and a FT journo.

    Their assessment is that the fossil fuel crisis is yet to actually fully hit and will properly bite in the EU next year. Its actually should be a lot worse but effects have been mitigated so far. Unless the war reaches a sudden swift resolution.
    There reasons this were that western leaders have been able to top up global supply by releasing reserves onto the global market and so mitigating the worst of the price rises. Reserves will be too low next year for them to be able to continue to do that and so fuel prices will skyrocket. And also that global demand was able to drop significantly as the crisis hit largely because China was quite easily able to drop its demand for fossil fuels by 75% as the crisis hit. They have been over buying massively since 2022 and have huge reserves. This combined with their rapid decarbonisation means they have effectively calculated that their reserves plus what they are buying (25% of last years demand) can see them through until they no longer need mass amounts of fossil fuels. This has prevented prices rising further and has luckily isn't a temporary situation. 
    There are other things that could offset it. UAE leaving OPEC this year has helped and its looking like they'll dump a load extra onto the market next year. 

    But they unanimously agreed the worst of the crisis is yet to come. This will cause inflation and likely rate rises - though as I've said before using interest rates in response to inflationary pressures caused by offshore supply shocks is terrible economics and is basically shooting yourself in the face. But the BoE needs to attempt to maintain the illusion it has any control. 

    On rates there is also the point that before the war it was expected that we would have 4 rate cuts this year to the extent where that was built into the BoE forecasts. As such by not cutting rates this year we have already had an effective rate rise compared to the counterfactual. 

  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    I was at an economics panel event last Thursday with some energy market analysts an exec from octopus and a FT journo.

    Their assessment is that the fossil fuel crisis is yet to actually fully hit and will properly bite in the EU next year. Its actually should be a lot worse but effects have been mitigated so far. Unless the war reaches a sudden swift resolution.
    There reasons this were that western leaders have been able to top up global supply by releasing reserves onto the global market and so mitigating the worst of the price rises. Reserves will be too low next year for them to be able to continue to do that and so fuel prices will skyrocket. And also that global demand was able to drop significantly as the crisis hit largely because China was quite easily able to drop its demand for fossil fuels by 75% as the crisis hit. They have been over buying massively since 2022 and have huge reserves. This combined with their rapid decarbonisation means they have effectively calculated that their reserves plus what they are buying (25% of last years demand) can see them through until they no longer need mass amounts of fossil fuels. This has prevented prices rising further and has luckily isn't a temporary situation. 
    There are other things that could offset it. UAE leaving OPEC this year has helped and its looking like they'll dump a load extra onto the market next year. 

    But they unanimously agreed the worst of the crisis is yet to come. This will cause inflation and likely rate rises - though as I've said before using interest rates in response to inflationary pressures caused by offshore supply shocks is terrible economics and is basically shooting yourself in the face. But the BoE needs to attempt to maintain the illusion it has any control. 

    On rates there is also the point that before the war it was expected that we would have 4 rate cuts this year to the extent where that was built into the BoE forecasts. As such by not cutting rates this year we have already had an effective rate rise compared to the counterfactual. 

    I totally agree with the last paragraph & was what I was being told at the end of last year  - that rates would be cut this year, ending between 3%-3.25% by xmas. 

    The BOE has said that their long term aim is for the base rate to be slightly above inflation. If their inflation target is 2% (ridiculous target set by Gordon Brown 25 years ago) then base rate would be around 2.25%-2.5%. With inflation now at 3.5% then the base rate increasing to 4% next month makes sense. 

    But as above - rate hikes to curb inflation only works if inflation is consumer led - like in the late 80's & early 90's. Inflation atm is producer led- although this will feed through to consumer led inflation by way of wage increase demands, esp by the unions next Spring. 

    One thing that is confirmed is that most benefits & Public sector pensions will be going up next April by 3.5%. Even if the Triple lock on the State Pension is downgraded to a Double lock then the State Pension will also increase by 3.5%. 



  • Sponsored links:



  • Carter
    Carter Posts: 14,848
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 53,469
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
    The majority consensus is 4 x 0.25% base rate increases over the next 12 months, with the first rise possibly next month.

    This has been predicted for weeks.
    I’m staggered you are unaware.

    Obviously anything could happen and likely dependent on the Iran “war”.
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
    The majority consensus is 4 x 0.25% base rate increases over the next 12 months, with the first rise possibly next month.

    This has been predicted for weeks.
    I’m staggered you are unaware.

    Obviously anything could happen and likely dependent on the Iran “war”.
    The first rise isn't possibly next month its baked on next month.

    And I don't know where it's been predicted there will be another 3 rate rises next year- certainly not from the fund management groups I've listened to over the past few weeks & months. I have read & seen the 4x rate rises on SM posts - YouTube & the like. But I think I'd trust a senior fund manager looking after billions over a Youtuber with no financial expertise.

    But lets leave it there & see who's right in 12 months time  
  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 10,022
    Completely agree with Canters on the "bad economics" of using interest rates in the scenario we are currently in. 

    I have for a while thought that using the tax system is a better way to cool the economy. Originally I thought dynamic PAYE/broader tax etc could be the answer (whilst reducing government debt) but appreciate not rising rates could lead to imported inflation etc. 

    I feel consumers get screwed the most. I did some reading on this and saw Keynes suggested a "compulsory deferred savings" model where rather than destroying wealth (raising interest rates extracts money from mortgage holders and permanently transfers that money to commercial banks as profit or to cash savers as a yield, yet another thing for boomers to smile about!), the model would effectively add a couple percent onto PAYE which would be locked away in an account with your name on it, which can later be accessed either through pension or a later date. Thus cooling the economy without screwing the consumer. 

    Interest rate rises are just another way for the elderly to win, and young debt loaded mortgage holders to lose, I think that generation has probably had enough "winning", too much in my opinion. 

    But also, in scenarios like what we currently see which I would argue is more supply side than demand side, raising interest rates perversely would further reduce investment at a time where we need it more than ever (a lot of it to fix these supply side issues surrounding energy, be that green or any other type). Making borrowing more expensive for the companies that will get us out of trouble seems bizarre to me. 

    Finally, if the government mandates that these savings have to go on government debt, that would give the treasury a stable cheap source of financing. 

    The down sides are the currency collapsing, it missing people who have wealth and pay CGT (maybe increase those rates dynamically or do something similar?) but these are all details...   :D

    Basically a long way of me saying I don't like interest rate rises, replace them with something better!
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 22
    Huskaris said:
    Completely agree with Canters on the "bad economics" of using interest rates in the scenario we are currently in. 

    I have for a while thought that using the tax system is a better way to cool the economy. Originally I thought dynamic PAYE/broader tax etc could be the answer (whilst reducing government debt) but appreciate not rising rates could lead to imported inflation etc. 

    I feel consumers get screwed the most. I did some reading on this and saw Keynes suggested a "compulsory deferred savings" model where rather than destroying wealth (raising interest rates extracts money from mortgage holders and permanently transfers that money to commercial banks as profit or to cash savers as a yield, yet another thing for boomers to smile about!), the model would effectively add a couple percent onto PAYE which would be locked away in an account with your name on it, which can later be accessed either through pension or a later date. Thus cooling the economy without screwing the consumer. 

    Interest rate rises are just another way for the elderly to win, and young debt loaded mortgage holders to lose, I think that generation has probably had enough "winning", too much in my opinion. 

    But also, in scenarios like what we currently see which I would argue is more supply side than demand side, raising interest rates perversely would further reduce investment at a time where we need it more than ever (a lot of it to fix these supply side issues surrounding energy, be that green or any other type). Making borrowing more expensive for the companies that will get us out of trouble seems bizarre to me. 

    Finally, if the government mandates that these savings have to go on government debt, that would give the treasury a stable cheap source of financing. 

    The down sides are the currency collapsing, it missing people who have wealth and pay CGT (maybe increase those rates dynamically or do something similar?) but these are all details...   :D

    Basically a long way of me saying I don't like interest rate rises, replace them with something better!
    This is a really interesting conversation. And what you suggest is an interesting idea. Not one I've thought about before really. I know it's theoretically possible to cool an economy through the tax system but I'm not aware of any examples of where its been done. I think there are 2 issues. 1) tax systems are incredibly complicated and so it's really hard to predict the outcomes and effects e.g. Higher tax can actually increase investment because it becomes a tax write off. 2) it would be massively unpopular as people would see it as a cash grab by government taking advantage of a crisis even though as you say the alternative is massive excess profits by the banks. 

    My wider issue is with the idea that you need to cool an economy as a response to an external (abroad) supply shock. Cooling an economy is a demand side tool and would work against consumer demand led inflation.   However for a supply side shock you need a supply side solution. In situations like these I am of the opinion that the only real option is to ride it out (as harsh as it seems) in the short term do what you can to protect consumers from the shock. In the medium term invest heavily in solutions to prevent this sort of shock having such a large impact in future. In this case that's renewables, nuclear, storage, plastic alternatives, grid infrastructure etc. 
  • Jints
    Jints Posts: 3,706
    bobmunro said:
    I had an isa come up for renewal this week.
    Ive taken the option of a one year at 4.5%.

    A two or three year option would have given me 4.6 or 4.7 %.
    But I can see interest rates rising over the next 12 months and I reckon this time next year a 12 month isa will be paying 5% or more. 
    All guesswork of course but that's what I've done. 

    Investec are currently paying 4.95% for a Cash ISA on a one year fix. Not sure whether or not the almost certain November interest rate rise has already been factored in to that percentage, but with forecasters predicting the possibility of four 0.25% rises next year then over 5% on a Cash ISA is almost certain.

    Investec are also paying 5% on a one year fix savings account - and First Active (Nat West) were paying 4.55% fixed for 12 month on an instant access account. That's down to 4.05% now as I believe they were knocked over in the rush!

    It's a good time for cash savers at the moment - however not so good for mortgage payers who I feel for as the squeeze on them at the moment is scary.


    No idea what forecasters you have been watching/ reading........weather ones perhaps ?

    Thee are not going to be 4× 0.25% rate increases next year. As I said earlier, rates are more likely to fall than rise next year.
    The majority consensus is 4 x 0.25% base rate increases over the next 12 months, with the first rise possibly next month.

    This has been predicted for weeks.
    I’m staggered you are unaware.

    Obviously anything could happen and likely dependent on the Iran “war”.
    The first rise isn't possibly next month its baked on next month.

    And I don't know where it's been predicted there will be another 3 rate rises next year- certainly not from the fund management groups I've listened to over the past few weeks & months. I have read & seen the 4x rate rises on SM posts - YouTube & the like. But I think I'd trust a senior fund manager looking after billions over a Youtuber with no financial expertise.

    But lets leave it there & see who's right in 12 months time  
    FWIW, I've read predictions of 3 or 4 rate rises (including next month's) in the Times, FT and Economist.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Huskaris said:
    Completely agree with Canters on the "bad economics" of using interest rates in the scenario we are currently in. 

    I have for a while thought that using the tax system is a better way to cool the economy. Originally I thought dynamic PAYE/broader tax etc could be the answer (whilst reducing government debt) but appreciate not rising rates could lead to imported inflation etc. 

    I feel consumers get screwed the most. I did some reading on this and saw Keynes suggested a "compulsory deferred savings" model where rather than destroying wealth (raising interest rates extracts money from mortgage holders and permanently transfers that money to commercial banks as profit or to cash savers as a yield, yet another thing for boomers to smile about!), the model would effectively add a couple percent onto PAYE which would be locked away in an account with your name on it, which can later be accessed either through pension or a later date. Thus cooling the economy without screwing the consumer. 

    Interest rate rises are just another way for the elderly to win, and young debt loaded mortgage holders to lose, I think that generation has probably had enough "winning", too much in my opinion. 

    But also, in scenarios like what we currently see which I would argue is more supply side than demand side, raising interest rates perversely would further reduce investment at a time where we need it more than ever (a lot of it to fix these supply side issues surrounding energy, be that green or any other type). Making borrowing more expensive for the companies that will get us out of trouble seems bizarre to me. 

    Finally, if the government mandates that these savings have to go on government debt, that would give the treasury a stable cheap source of financing. 

    The down sides are the currency collapsing, it missing people who have wealth and pay CGT (maybe increase those rates dynamically or do something similar?) but these are all details...   :D

    Basically a long way of me saying I don't like interest rate rises, replace them with something better!
    Interesting. Just on one point about the older generation winning (if rates go up), don’t forget that many of those also saw interest rates rocket to double digit %. I can remember when I started work the panic of those with mortgages (which were all variable in those days) on how it was going past their monthly income and the huge numbers that ended in repossessions as they could no longer afford and many had debt still even after repossession as houses were worth less than the mortgages they owed. It wasn’t all plain sailing.

    when I first mortgaged in around 92 rates were still around 9.5%.


  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,869
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 1,151
    Would taxes cool inflation without triggering a recession like the interest rate rises post covid managed to do? I don’t think so, somehow. It would also only work if the government doesn’t then spend the money it takes (putting it back into the economy) which is a bit like asking a toddler not to eat a sweet when you leave the room. 
  • bobmunro
    bobmunro Posts: 22,238
    Rob7Lee said:
    Huskaris said:
    Completely agree with Canters on the "bad economics" of using interest rates in the scenario we are currently in. 

    I have for a while thought that using the tax system is a better way to cool the economy. Originally I thought dynamic PAYE/broader tax etc could be the answer (whilst reducing government debt) but appreciate not rising rates could lead to imported inflation etc. 

    I feel consumers get screwed the most. I did some reading on this and saw Keynes suggested a "compulsory deferred savings" model where rather than destroying wealth (raising interest rates extracts money from mortgage holders and permanently transfers that money to commercial banks as profit or to cash savers as a yield, yet another thing for boomers to smile about!), the model would effectively add a couple percent onto PAYE which would be locked away in an account with your name on it, which can later be accessed either through pension or a later date. Thus cooling the economy without screwing the consumer. 

    Interest rate rises are just another way for the elderly to win, and young debt loaded mortgage holders to lose, I think that generation has probably had enough "winning", too much in my opinion. 

    But also, in scenarios like what we currently see which I would argue is more supply side than demand side, raising interest rates perversely would further reduce investment at a time where we need it more than ever (a lot of it to fix these supply side issues surrounding energy, be that green or any other type). Making borrowing more expensive for the companies that will get us out of trouble seems bizarre to me. 

    Finally, if the government mandates that these savings have to go on government debt, that would give the treasury a stable cheap source of financing. 

    The down sides are the currency collapsing, it missing people who have wealth and pay CGT (maybe increase those rates dynamically or do something similar?) but these are all details...   :D

    Basically a long way of me saying I don't like interest rate rises, replace them with something better!
    Interesting. Just on one point about the older generation winning (if rates go up), don’t forget that many of those also saw interest rates rocket to double digit %. I can remember when I started work the panic of those with mortgages (which were all variable in those days) on how it was going past their monthly income and the huge numbers that ended in repossessions as they could no longer afford and many had debt still even after repossession as houses were worth less than the mortgages they owed. It wasn’t all plain sailing.

    when I first mortgaged in around 92 rates were still around 9.5%.



    Not having that - boomers are to blame for everything!

    I jest of course - same old, same old. 

    UK Mortgage & Base Rate Trends by Era
    • The 1980s (High Inflation Era):
      • Average UK mortgage interest rates hovered around 11% to 14% (mean rate for the decade was roughly 11.9%).
      • The Bank of England base rate peaked at 17% in late 1979/1980 and remained high through economic volatility. 
    The 1990s (Recession & ERM Crisis):
    • Standard variable mortgage rates peaked sharply around 14% to 15.4% in 1990 as the base rate hit 15%, before gradually declining.
    • The decade average for UK mortgage rates dropped to around 7.9%. 
    The 2000s (Pre-Crisis Stability & Crash):
    • Mortgage rates stabilized and averaged around 5.2% across the decade.
    • Typical two- and five-year fixed rates sat between 4.5% and 6.5% until the 2007–2008 global financial crisis triggered emergency interest rate cuts by Bank of England
    The 2010s (The Low-Rate Decade):
    • Fueled by quantitative easing and a near-zero base rate (held at 0.5% for years), the decade average for UK mortgages fell to 2.6%.
    • Typical fixed deals dropped as low as 2% to 4%.
    The 2020s (Pandemic Lows to Post-Inflation Rise):
    • 2021: Hit record lows with rates dipping down to 1.5%–3% (base rate dropped to 0.10% in March 2020).
    • 2022–2023: Central banks raised rates rapidly to combat inflation, with the Bank of England base rate peaking at 5.25% in August 2023.
    • 2024–2026: Rates moderated as the Bank of England cut the base rate down to 3.75% by late 2025. Current typical UK mortgage deals generally range between 4% and 6% depending on the product and LTV (Loan-to-Value) tier.
    We bought our first property in 1985 and at it's peak we were paying nearly £700 a month in mortgage (including an endowment premium!). My take home pay in 1985 was around £750 a month (and that was working six days every week). My wife worked full-time then and we managed to just about live on her pay - no savings, no holidays (our first family holiday was when the boys were 5 and 7 in 1996 - a week in a caravan in Devon)., no eating out, no £5 coffees from Starbucks on the way to work, no new mobile phones every couple of years, one clapped out car until I got my first company car in 1989 - even then still just one car. Our first child was born in 1989 - child care so my wife could return to her full-time job? You're having a laugh - I would get home from work around 7.30pm and my wife left at 8pm to start her night-shift at Tescos and as she returned home the next morning I was just about to leave for work. We survived by saving what little we could and buying outright what we needed for the house and family - not on credit cards.

    Tell the kids that today and they won't believe you.

    House price inflation in London and the south-east is a problem - there is no denying that. But 75% of the population do not live in London and the south-east. We bought our current house in 2008 and in the intervening 18 years it has risen in value by about 60% - that's a Compound Annual Growth Rate of about 2.6%.

    I'm not complaining now of course (I wasn't complaining then - we just got on with it) - we are now very comfortable. Hey ho, I thought we'd had enough of winning!

    House You were lucky to live in a house We used to live in one room all  twenty-six of us no furniture alf the floor was missing and we were all  uddled


  • Sponsored links:



  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 1,151
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
    If we stick to the triple lock it will bankrupt the country. Thems the breaks after GFC and Covid, unfortunately. Which is why making sure you’re on top of your private pension as young as possible is the best possible thing you can do for yourself.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 22
    bobmunro said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Huskaris said:
    Completely agree with Canters on the "bad economics" of using interest rates in the scenario we are currently in. 

    I have for a while thought that using the tax system is a better way to cool the economy. Originally I thought dynamic PAYE/broader tax etc could be the answer (whilst reducing government debt) but appreciate not rising rates could lead to imported inflation etc. 

    I feel consumers get screwed the most. I did some reading on this and saw Keynes suggested a "compulsory deferred savings" model where rather than destroying wealth (raising interest rates extracts money from mortgage holders and permanently transfers that money to commercial banks as profit or to cash savers as a yield, yet another thing for boomers to smile about!), the model would effectively add a couple percent onto PAYE which would be locked away in an account with your name on it, which can later be accessed either through pension or a later date. Thus cooling the economy without screwing the consumer. 

    Interest rate rises are just another way for the elderly to win, and young debt loaded mortgage holders to lose, I think that generation has probably had enough "winning", too much in my opinion. 

    But also, in scenarios like what we currently see which I would argue is more supply side than demand side, raising interest rates perversely would further reduce investment at a time where we need it more than ever (a lot of it to fix these supply side issues surrounding energy, be that green or any other type). Making borrowing more expensive for the companies that will get us out of trouble seems bizarre to me. 

    Finally, if the government mandates that these savings have to go on government debt, that would give the treasury a stable cheap source of financing. 

    The down sides are the currency collapsing, it missing people who have wealth and pay CGT (maybe increase those rates dynamically or do something similar?) but these are all details...   :D

    Basically a long way of me saying I don't like interest rate rises, replace them with something better!
    Interesting. Just on one point about the older generation winning (if rates go up), don’t forget that many of those also saw interest rates rocket to double digit %. I can remember when I started work the panic of those with mortgages (which were all variable in those days) on how it was going past their monthly income and the huge numbers that ended in repossessions as they could no longer afford and many had debt still even after repossession as houses were worth less than the mortgages they owed. It wasn’t all plain sailing.

    when I first mortgaged in around 92 rates were still around 9.5%.



    Not having that - boomers are to blame for everything!

    I jest of course - same old, same old. 

    UK Mortgage & Base Rate Trends by Era
    • The 1980s (High Inflation Era):
      • Average UK mortgage interest rates hovered around 11% to 14% (mean rate for the decade was roughly 11.9%).
      • The Bank of England base rate peaked at 17% in late 1979/1980 and remained high through economic volatility. 
    The 1990s (Recession & ERM Crisis):
    • Standard variable mortgage rates peaked sharply around 14% to 15.4% in 1990 as the base rate hit 15%, before gradually declining.
    • The decade average for UK mortgage rates dropped to around 7.9%. 
    The 2000s (Pre-Crisis Stability & Crash):
    • Mortgage rates stabilized and averaged around 5.2% across the decade.
    • Typical two- and five-year fixed rates sat between 4.5% and 6.5% until the 2007–2008 global financial crisis triggered emergency interest rate cuts by Bank of England
    The 2010s (The Low-Rate Decade):
    • Fueled by quantitative easing and a near-zero base rate (held at 0.5% for years), the decade average for UK mortgages fell to 2.6%.
    • Typical fixed deals dropped as low as 2% to 4%.
    The 2020s (Pandemic Lows to Post-Inflation Rise):
    • 2021: Hit record lows with rates dipping down to 1.5%–3% (base rate dropped to 0.10% in March 2020).
    • 2022–2023: Central banks raised rates rapidly to combat inflation, with the Bank of England base rate peaking at 5.25% in August 2023.
    • 2024–2026: Rates moderated as the Bank of England cut the base rate down to 3.75% by late 2025. Current typical UK mortgage deals generally range between 4% and 6% depending on the product and LTV (Loan-to-Value) tier.
    We bought our first property in 1985 and at it's peak we were paying nearly £700 a month in mortgage (including an endowment premium!). My take home pay in 1985 was around £750 a month (and that was working six days every week). My wife worked full-time then and we managed to just about live on her pay - no savings, no holidays (our first family holiday was when the boys were 5 and 7 in 1996 - a week in a caravan in Devon)., no eating out, no £5 coffees from Starbucks on the way to work, no new mobile phones every couple of years, one clapped out car until I got my first company car in 1989 - even then still just one car. Our first child was born in 1989 - child care so my wife could return to her full-time job? You're having a laugh - I would get home from work around 7.30pm and my wife left at 8pm to start her night-shift at Tescos and as she returned home the next morning I was just about to leave for work. We survived by saving what little we could and buying outright what we needed for the house and family - not on credit cards.

    Tell the kids that today and they won't believe you.

    House price inflation in London and the south-east is a problem - there is no denying that. But 75% of the population do not live in London and the south-east. We bought our current house in 2008 and in the intervening 18 years it has risen in value by about 60% - that's a Compound Annual Growth Rate of about 2.6%.

    I'm not complaining now of course (I wasn't complaining then - we just got on with it) - we are now very comfortable. Hey ho, I thought we'd had enough of winning!

    House You were lucky to live in a house We used to live in one room all  twenty-six of us no furniture alf the floor was missing and we were all  uddled

    I'm not disagreeing with any of this and as I've said many times before I don't want to get into the generation vs generation debate as I think its incredibly unhelpful, its used as a wedge issue and pits "ordinary people" (however you define that) against other ordinary people which isnt the issue facing society/the economy right now. 

    But I will say what your analysis of the situation above doesnt account for is twofold affordability impacts. 1) the affordability issue with getting on the housing ladder in the first place. Relative to average income deposits are significantly higher than they have ever been before. 2) the affordability of housing costs generally whether mortgage or renting (before even getting on the housing ladder). There is a lot of analysis out there that shows despite the high interest rates you mention above monthly housing costs are (and have been for 6 years now) a much higher proportion of average incomes than they were for any sustained period in the time periods you mention. This is less about housing and more about wage surpression. 

    Again not saying your analysis is wrong but rather that it is incomplete.
  • bobmunro
    bobmunro Posts: 22,238
    edited October 22
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
    If we stick to the triple lock it will bankrupt the country. Thems the breaks after GFC and Covid, unfortunately. Which is why making sure you’re on top of your private pension as young as possible is the best possible thing you can do for yourself.

    The current benefits system will bankrupt the country, not the State Pension*

    The number of people falsely claiming Personal Independence Payments and Carer's Allowance has reached a ridiculous level and has to be changed so that only those in genuine need get the assistance. Also people being paid not to work when they are perfectly capable of working is total bollocks. Those who know me know I'm left of centre and I'm a firm believer in a welfare state - but it is now taking the piss.

    *State Pension is NOT A BENEFIT. It is based on the number of years an individual has made contributions and as such is just like any other pension - State or private. The level it is at is a joke compared to the contributions made during a working life and as @valleynick66 says the triple/double lock can be looked at when the State Pension reaches an appropriate level.
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,869
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
    If we stick to the triple lock it will bankrupt the country. Thems the breaks after GFC and Covid, unfortunately. Which is why making sure you’re on top of your private pension as young as possible is the best possible thing you can do for yourself.
    Hence I said triple / double lock and adjusting further once a level reached. 
  • bobmunro
    bobmunro Posts: 22,238
    edited October 22
    I'm not disagreeing with any of this and as I've said many times before I don't want to get into the generation vs generation debate as I think its incredibly unhelpful, its used as a wedge issue and pits "ordinary people" (however you define that) against other ordinary people which isnt the issue facing society/the economy right now. 

    But I will say what your analysis of the situation above doesnt account for is twofold affordability impacts. 1) the affordability issue with getting on the housing ladder in the first place. Relative to average income deposits are significantly higher than they have ever been before. 2) the affordability of housing costs generally whether mortgage or renting (before even getting on the housing ladder). There is a lot of analysis out there that shows despite the high interest rates you mention above monthly housing costs are (and have been for 6 years now) a much higher proportion of average incomes than they were for any sustained period in the time periods you mention. This is less about housing and more about wage surpression. 

    Again not saying your analysis is wrong but rather that it is incomplete.

    I was responding to a comment @Huskaris made, not you Canters.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    bobmunro said:
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
    If we stick to the triple lock it will bankrupt the country. Thems the breaks after GFC and Covid, unfortunately. Which is why making sure you’re on top of your private pension as young as possible is the best possible thing you can do for yourself.

    The current benefits system will bankrupt the country, not the State Pension*

    The number of people falsely claiming Personal Independence Payments and Carer's Allowance has reached a ridiculous level and has to be changed so that only those in genuine need get the assistance. Also people being paid not to work when they are perfectly capable of working is total bollocks. Those who know me know I'm left of centre and I'm a firm believer in a welfare state - but it is now taking the piss.

    *State Pension is NOT A BENEFIT. It is based on the number of years an individual has made contributions and as such is just like any other pension - State or private. The level it is at is a joke compared to the contributions made during a working life and as @valleynick66 says the triple/double lock can be looked at when the State Pension reaches an appropriate level.
    I agree that the state pension is not a benefit (though it is part of the welfare system) but it also a categorical fact that it is not related to contributions at all. There is now less than a 2% link between contributions and the state pension - this is possibly the biggest myth about our tax system. You should read/listen to what Helen Miller director of the IFS says on this. 

    I agree that our state pension is too low - its one of the lowest in Europe. 

    However, its a mathematical fact that the triple lock will bankrupt the economy if allowed to continue for enough time. Anything with guaranteed exponential growth and an ageing population will do that.

    There are also a hell of a lot of myths out there about the benefit system.  As a proportion of GDP the welfare bill is the same as it was at any point under Thatcher (generally considered a low benefit era). The state pension and pension aged benefits is now more than 55% of the total welfare bill whereas in the Thatcher era it was 40-45% therefore the working aged and children and disabled spend on the welfare bill as a proportion of the economy is lower than it was in the so called "low benefit" era. Real terms average amounts are also lower than in that era too. 

    As for benefit fraud despite the ongoing media narrative the scale of it is much smaller than it makes out. Estimated to be 2.2% of spend up to about 6.8bn (inclidng both claimant and official error) more than £1b is spent each year on preventing and investigating this. Compare this to the tax gap which is estimated at between 60-120bn but gets far less resource (DWP has 3.5x more staff on this than HMRC has on tax fraud/compliance etc). I think once again we are being led into looking in the wrong direction.

    Now I'm not saying that there isnt a problem here - of course there is. But I think the blunt instrument of cutting benefits either amounts of entilement criteria (that has now been used over 48 times since 2010) simply doesnt work. We've shown that it doesnt work ober the last 16 years. We need to fundamentally fix the hostile economic conditions that people are forced to live in, we need to rebalance the economy away from multinational corporations, provate eqiuty and the financialised economy and towards people and small business in the real functional economy. If we do that rather than blindly pursueing growth at any cost it will fundamentally change peoples conditions which drives people into work and will fix both the mental health crisis and support people through the sickness crisis leading them back to larger participation in society and therefore work.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    bobmunro said:
    I'm not disagreeing with any of this and as I've said many times before I don't want to get into the generation vs generation debate as I think its incredibly unhelpful, its used as a wedge issue and pits "ordinary people" (however you define that) against other ordinary people which isnt the issue facing society/the economy right now. 

    But I will say what your analysis of the situation above doesnt account for is twofold affordability impacts. 1) the affordability issue with getting on the housing ladder in the first place. Relative to average income deposits are significantly higher than they have ever been before. 2) the affordability of housing costs generally whether mortgage or renting (before even getting on the housing ladder). There is a lot of analysis out there that shows despite the high interest rates you mention above monthly housing costs are (and have been for 6 years now) a much higher proportion of average incomes than they were for any sustained period in the time periods you mention. This is less about housing and more about wage surpression. 

    Again not saying your analysis is wrong but rather that it is incomplete.

    I was responding to a comment @Huskaris made, not you Canters.
    Ohh I know mate, wasnt taking any kind of issue with that part of the post but do have to state clearly that I'm not looking to stoke that generation vs generation debate as I think its unhelpful (and someone on here accused me of being ageist for presenting this type of analysis!) - I just wanted to complete the picture a little as felt you presented one side but not the full story.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm4g1zrl2nrqo

    Changing the subject slightly - whilst everyone knows I am opposed to drilling for new oil and gas and opposed to the Jackdaw approval announced yesterday - there are some interesting bits of information coming out with the announcements at the moment. 

    This article got my attention. I welcome the creation of the energy wealth fund for investing the reciepts from North sea oil and gas - though in reality this is far too little and 50 years late. The bit that really got my ears up was around the analysis of what could have been if we had done this since we started drilling in the north sea. The Treasury analysis estimates that this would be around £1tn if it had been done from the start. However this for me misses the key point that is the biggest issue with how the north sea resources have been used. The analysis only includes the receipts the UK government did actually recieve from North Sea oil and gas - not what they were actually worth. Rights were sold to private compaies for around 20% of their actual value. If we had adopted the Norway model and had a state owned energy production and supply company that would operate these for us and thus recive 100% of the benefits. As such the estimate of the £1tn wealth fund is an underestimate by a factor of 3 or 4 once costs are taken into account. This shows the real cost the short term decision making that prevailed in the 80s, 90s and early 2000's. Its a huge shame and missed opportunity. 

    Same goes for housing. If 20% of the money raised from selling council houses under right to buy was reingfenced to be re-invested in council housing Ad infinitum then we would be sitting on another £1tn asset. 

    Shame.
  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,540
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm4g1zrl2nrqo

    Changing the subject slightly - whilst everyone knows I am opposed to drilling for new oil and gas and opposed to the Jackdaw approval announced yesterday - there are some interesting bits of information coming out with the announcements at the moment. 

    This article got my attention. I welcome the creation of the energy wealth fund for investing the reciepts from North sea oil and gas - though in reality this is far too little and 50 years late. The bit that really got my ears up was around the analysis of what could have been if we had done this since we started drilling in the north sea. The Treasury analysis estimates that this would be around £1tn if it had been done from the start. However this for me misses the key point that is the biggest issue with how the north sea resources have been used. The analysis only includes the receipts the UK government did actually recieve from North Sea oil and gas - not what they were actually worth. Rights were sold to private compaies for around 20% of their actual value. If we had adopted the Norway model and had a state owned energy production and supply company that would operate these for us and thus recive 100% of the benefits. As such the estimate of the £1tn wealth fund is an underestimate by a factor of 3 or 4 once costs are taken into account. This shows the real cost the short term decision making that prevailed in the 80s, 90s and early 2000's. Its a huge shame and missed opportunity. 

    Same goes for housing. If 20% of the money raised from selling council houses under right to buy was reingfenced to be re-invested in council housing Ad infinitum then we would be sitting on another £1tn asset. 

    Shame.
    You never miss an opportunity to bring politics into everything. Please don't. This is a thread on savings and investment. 
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,869
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm4g1zrl2nrqo

    Changing the subject slightly - whilst everyone knows I am opposed to drilling for new oil and gas and opposed to the Jackdaw approval announced yesterday - there are some interesting bits of information coming out with the announcements at the moment. 

    This article got my attention. I welcome the creation of the energy wealth fund for investing the reciepts from North sea oil and gas - though in reality this is far too little and 50 years late. The bit that really got my ears up was around the analysis of what could have been if we had done this since we started drilling in the north sea. The Treasury analysis estimates that this would be around £1tn if it had been done from the start. However this for me misses the key point that is the biggest issue with how the north sea resources have been used. The analysis only includes the receipts the UK government did actually recieve from North Sea oil and gas - not what they were actually worth. Rights were sold to private compaies for around 20% of their actual value. If we had adopted the Norway model and had a state owned energy production and supply company that would operate these for us and thus recive 100% of the benefits. As such the estimate of the £1tn wealth fund is an underestimate by a factor of 3 or 4 once costs are taken into account. This shows the real cost the short term decision making that prevailed in the 80s, 90s and early 2000's. Its a huge shame and missed opportunity. 

    Same goes for housing. If 20% of the money raised from selling council houses under right to buy was reingfenced to be re-invested in council housing Ad infinitum then we would be sitting on another £1tn asset. 

    Shame.
    Hindsight is a wonderful thing.