Derby 1 Charlton 0 - Post Match Views
Comments
-
10 days ago?! 10 minutes before kick off the predictions thread was full of absolute thrashings!GretnaGreenAddick said:Listening to the game, it did not sound at all like we played as badly as Saturday or badly in general.
We got beaten 1-0 by a late goal from a team 10 days ago most fans would have predicted us laying down for on both occasions.
1 -
Well that sir is fair enough.
One in 7 would not be acceptable for me!1 -
Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.4 -
I couldn't listen tonight, what was the formation? From the line up I assumed we played 4-4-2 as we did in every other game?ValleyGary said:
Possession and style are different.Dazzler21 said:Apparently they had 18 shots to our 6
6 shots all game is woeful.
They had 8 on target to our 2, Maybe Pope deserves more credit than I gave from the commentary.
I think the rose tinting is taking over on some of you lot though.
We are not playing this lovely football you all seem to think we are. Our possession reflects this!
We do need a decent partner for Vetokele and Bob needs a better plan B than putting our big lump slow CB's up front.
Lots of love Ex Rose Tinted Dazzler
We can be organised, let teams play in front of us and then play fast passing football, be attractive and effective when we do get it.
Tonight wasn't our strongest side and we played just one striker.
We played a different team/formation against Derby at home, scored 3 and still had less possession.
Think you are being over critical.0 -
Millwall away season before last 0 shots1
-
Five games in fifteen days, with a relatively small squad will have an effect. Maybe the last two games have demonstrated that? I'm not too upset by the loss. At least we didn't have to suffer extra time aswell.
Reinforcements needed though to ensure our first choice 18 is strong, not just our first eleven.2 -
Brentford... Only conceded due to a deflection, unlucky with Harriott's missDazzler21 said:
I wasn't depressed last season as expectations hadn't been built up.DeeBee said:
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha. Christ i'd hate to see how depressed you were last season.Dazzler21 said:Apparently they had 18 shots to our 6
6 shots all game is woeful.
They had 8 on target to our 2, Maybe Pope deserves more credit than I gave from the commentary.
I think the rose tinting is taking over on some of you lot though.
We are not playing this lovely football you all seem to think we are. Our possession reflects this!
We do need a decent partner for Vetokele and Bob needs a better plan B than putting our big lump slow CB's up front.
Lots of love Ex Rose Tinted Dazzler
Didn't expect much else. Probably highlights the need for a couple players. Onto saturday
That's 2 poor performances in a row, though only one seemed to really matter as we snuck a result out of the other one.
Brentford - Poor - I really don't get why people thought that was a good point?
Colchester - V.Good
Wigan - Good
Derby - Strong upfront, poor at the back.
Huddersfield - V.Poor, but Lucky
Derby - Poor
Colchester... Very good but against 10-men.. easy
Wigan Athletic / Derby County... Very good, Wigan looked very pretty with their possession yet did nothing else with it, can have all the possession you like but if you dont score (or cant stop the other team from scoring you dont deserve to win)
Huddersfield... Poor but didnt stop trying to score and got our just reward
Derby... Cant comment as wasnt there and am sure you werent either Dazzler3 -
concentrate on the league5
-
Let's wait and get some reports / players marks in from those at the game before we knee jerk react to a team that had five changes from Saturday. A late goal won it from an apparent iffy referring decision now where have we been involved in that ............oh hang on a minute. If there were weaknesses, it will have probably confirmed what BBB knew already that he needs a couple more to bolster the squad. We go again on Saturday in the bread and butter stuff.0
-
How many of those games have you actually seen?Dazzler21 said:
I wasn't depressed last season as expectations hadn't been built up.DeeBee said:
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha. Christ i'd hate to see how depressed you were last season.Dazzler21 said:Apparently they had 18 shots to our 6
6 shots all game is woeful.
They had 8 on target to our 2, Maybe Pope deserves more credit than I gave from the commentary.
I think the rose tinting is taking over on some of you lot though.
We are not playing this lovely football you all seem to think we are. Our possession reflects this!
We do need a decent partner for Vetokele and Bob needs a better plan B than putting our big lump slow CB's up front.
Lots of love Ex Rose Tinted Dazzler
Didn't expect much else. Probably highlights the need for a couple players. Onto saturday
That's 2 poor performances in a row, though only one seemed to really matter as we snuck a result out of the other one.
Brentford - Poor - I really don't get why people thought that was a good point?
Colchester - V.Good
Wigan - Good
Derby - Strong upfront, poor at the back.
Huddersfield - V.Poor, but Lucky
Derby - Poor
0 - Sponsored links:
-
What do we know ahead of Saturday... that Harriott.. Wilson.. Gomez.. Fox.. Morrison.. Moussa.. all probably wont start (Half of tonights squad).
Derby lost to our First Team and seriously struggled to beat our 2nd Team too... Huge clap on the back for Bob Peeters getting the Squad to perform like that.2 -
Too true about tonight, just going by the commentary. One sounded like he was saying we played well the other made it sound like we were awful.ForeverAddickted said:
Brentford... Only conceded due to a deflection, unlucky with Harriott's missDazzler21 said:
I wasn't depressed last season as expectations hadn't been built up.DeeBee said:
Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha. Christ i'd hate to see how depressed you were last season.Dazzler21 said:Apparently they had 18 shots to our 6
6 shots all game is woeful.
They had 8 on target to our 2, Maybe Pope deserves more credit than I gave from the commentary.
I think the rose tinting is taking over on some of you lot though.
We are not playing this lovely football you all seem to think we are. Our possession reflects this!
We do need a decent partner for Vetokele and Bob needs a better plan B than putting our big lump slow CB's up front.
Lots of love Ex Rose Tinted Dazzler
Didn't expect much else. Probably highlights the need for a couple players. Onto saturday
That's 2 poor performances in a row, though only one seemed to really matter as we snuck a result out of the other one.
Brentford - Poor - I really don't get why people thought that was a good point?
Colchester - V.Good
Wigan - Good
Derby - Strong upfront, poor at the back.
Huddersfield - V.Poor, but Lucky
Derby - Poor
Colchester... Very good but against 10-men.. easy
Wigan Athletic / Derby County... Very good, Wigan looked very pretty with their possession yet did nothing else with it, can have all the possession you like but if you dont score (or cant stop the other team from scoring you dont deserve to win)
Huddersfield... Poor but didnt stop trying to score and got our just reward
Derby... Cant comment as wasn't there and am sure you weren't either Dazzler
Hard to know whose views to follow!
1 -
Official line is that Pope carried the ball out of his area, i believe.PragueAddick said:Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.
Did sound strange though.0 -
I should probably do this today - I normally wait to hear, but I hate how long those reports take on midweek away games!RedChaser said:Let's wait and get some reports / players marks in from those at the game before we knee jerk react to a team that had five changes from Saturday. A late goal won it from an apparent iffy referring decision now where have we been involved in that ............oh hang on a minute. If there were weaknesses, it will have probably confirmed what BBB knew already that he needs a couple more to bolster the squad. We go again on Saturday in the bread and butter stuff.
0 -
on the match thread someone reported that the FK was for Pope taking the ball outside of his area just after the time wastingPragueAddick said:Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.0 -
Thought somebody had clarified that it was for carrying the ball out of his area?PragueAddick said:Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.
Anyway, best not get hung up on the ref, you'll have the Huddy fans back foaming at the mouth ;-)
0 -
Really? I understood it was a dead ball situation.GretnaGreenAddick said:
Official line is that Pope carried the ball out of his area, i believe.PragueAddick said:Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.
Did sound strange though.
the young guy summarising alongside Terry Smith was asking "how does the ref decide where exactly outside the box the free kick takes place?" which obviously is not a question if the offence was that he carried it over the line.
Something seriously amiss here.
1 -
don't worry about it PA as we got far more than we deserved from the ref on Saturday0
-
@Dazzler21 First players marks just in from lacole not one mark below 6 and this summary;
'Overall beaten by a better (and very good) team. No shame and a performance we can be proud of.'1 - Sponsored links:
-
Ok..that bit I get, if this was the case. But when did you see a keeper booked for time wasting while fanning around with a goal kick, and then the oppo given a free kick on the six yard line?lancashire lad said:
on the match thread someone reported that the FK was for Pope taking the ball outside of his area just after the time wastingPragueAddick said:Surprised no one is mentioning the quite perplexing decision by the ref that led to the goal.
Keeper time wasting; booked; ok; but then Derby awarded a free kick outside the penalty area?
WTF?
When did that rule kick in?
From the sound of it , neither manager was aware of this rule. McLaren was laughing his head off.
0 -
We had our decent cup run last year. Normal service has been resumed. Judging by the match thread sounds like we were under the cosh for a bit and could have been done by more than the one but for some good keeping by Pope who ends up giving away the FK for their goal. Derby are a decent team and we lack a bit strength in depth. Bring on the Tesco bags.0
-
Bring on the Tesco bags ?0
-
1
-
Well done for holding your hands up not many would.Dazzler21 said:Too slow @RedChaser I got there first.
I'm willing to admit I listened to the wrong commentator.1 -
I get that point too, but there is a difference between refs missing things, they are human, and have shamefully little assistance, and making relatively cold-blooded decisions which appear to have no basis in the laws of the game. I'm just going on what I heard from the Charlton Live guys but it sounds seriously odd, and Bob Peeters was massively unhappy.lancashire lad said:don't worry about it PA as we got far more than we deserved from the ref on Saturday
0 -
Praise from an opposition fan as well.
http://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/63672/great-fans-hope-you-do-well#latest1 -
I was under the impression Tucadean played upfront with Moussa in a deeper role than Vetokele would play.....so a 4-5-1.Scoham said:
I couldn't listen tonight, what was the formation? From the line up I assumed we played 4-4-2 as we did in every other game?ValleyGary said:
Possession and style are different.Dazzler21 said:Apparently they had 18 shots to our 6
6 shots all game is woeful.
They had 8 on target to our 2, Maybe Pope deserves more credit than I gave from the commentary.
I think the rose tinting is taking over on some of you lot though.
We are not playing this lovely football you all seem to think we are. Our possession reflects this!
We do need a decent partner for Vetokele and Bob needs a better plan B than putting our big lump slow CB's up front.
Lots of love Ex Rose Tinted Dazzler
We can be organised, let teams play in front of us and then play fast passing football, be attractive and effective when we do get it.
Tonight wasn't our strongest side and we played just one striker.
We played a different team/formation against Derby at home, scored 3 and still had less possession.
Think you are being over critical.
Perhaps someone there can tell us more.0 -
Pope was taking longer than ten seconds for every drop kick. So long that I started timing him on the stadium clock. 12 seconds was shortest. So I guess it must be a foul if he exceeds this time limit. But if it's a direct free kick then, if was in his area, it's a pen? If he's outside then it's for the linesman to call handball, and I didn't see a flag! And why didn't we hoof it and not try to dribble it away when we got possession from the free kick?0
