Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
***Naby Sarr signed on 5 year deal*** (Ed. Gone)
Comments
-
‘We thought he was just a central defender from Charlton’.
Guess the commentators don’t watch a lot of football.0 -
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh11 -
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh0 -
I think Bogle is a League One footballer low on confidence. Sarr's movement and finish for his winner today was...well let's not be rash here, but...6
-
Never a dull moment with Naby...1
-
Wait did he score both their goals? Did he play the whole game up front?0
-
Yep Sarr so much better a baller than Bogle. Scored as many goals in 1 game as Bogle has all season. Defending for the goal they conceded was tough.
0 -
Yup, a pinpoint header from a corner then a QPR equaliser carbon copy for the winner. Very happy for himcantersaddick said:Wait did he score both their goals? Did he play the whole game up front?7 -
-
Do me a favouraddick1956 said:
Sarr is Championship plus .Addick Addict said:
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh1 - Sponsored links:
-
He's definitely a championship quality player, scored 2 goals today in a team that's exactly mid table in the championship2
-
Naby is a technically gifted footballer who lacks concentration and switches off. He reminds me a bit of David Luiz so far as those traits are concerned but is obviously not in the same class.
I struggle with Bogle as I really do not see what he brings to the table. Not every striker has to be prolific but they have to offer something - Carl Leaburn certainly wasn't but he could hold the ball up, bully centre backs and bring other players into the game. Bogle does none of that very well and that is probably the reason why we are the 7th club he has played for in the last four years during which time he has scored just 13 goals.0 -
They're not directly comparable players.
One is an attacking, goal scoring and assisting CB in the championship, the other a low scoring forward in League 1.
4 -
Two cracking goals from Naby. A solid header from a corner that you’d expect of a decent centre-half and then a cracking take, control and left foot shot into the top of the net that only Charlton fans might expect. He’s a great lad and a good Championship footballer.5
-
He has Championship quality, but some will never rate him because they expect a centre back to be solid and reliable over anything else. Clearly there are managers out there who disagree, they want ball playing defenders and accept the risk that style brings and the weaknesses those type of players can often have.7
-
To be fair by that logic you would say the same about Bonne. But Sarr is easily championship quality for meaddick1956 said:
You are having a laugh. He is in the Championship. We are not. Work it out.J BLOCK said:
Do me a favouraddick1956 said:
Sarr is Championship plus .Addick Addict said:
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh0 -
Great goals, really pleased for him2
-
Ah yes, that well known fact that if a player is playing in the championship, whilst his old team are in league one, then he is definitely, 100%, absolutely a ‘Championship + player’.addick1956 said:
You are having a laugh. He is in the Championship. We are not. Work it out.J BLOCK said:
Do me a favouraddick1956 said:
Sarr is Championship plus .Addick Addict said:
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh
Same with Bonne too?“Work it out” haha behave0 -
Sarr has the technical ability to play in the premier league.
The fact he is prone to lapses in concentration, getting caught out of position, ball watching etc is the reason he is not playing in the premier league.
Him standing there in the 91st minute at the Den ball watching as the bloke just jumped over him to score still pisses me off.4 - Sponsored links:
-
What about when he cuts across the right winger with a perfect tackle, then swings in an inch perfect cross for T*ylor to score against Forest?Chris_from_Sidcup said:Sarr has the technical ability to play in the premier league.
The fact he is prone to lapses in concentration, getting caught out of position, ball watching etc is the reason he is not playing in the premier league.
Him standing there in the 91st minute at the Den ball watching as the bloke just jumped over him to score still pisses me off.
Or when he steps forward from defence to intercept the ball, plays the ball out wide right and continues his run, and as the ball is crossed back into the box he ghosts in unmarked to tap home and win the game?
That's the problem with us fans, we're too fickle, we're too caught up about derby games and the passion of moments that out clouds our judgements. The lad has great technical ability for a centre back, and would waltz into our defence this season (and probably waltz through it and score if we ever played against him too)
He's championship quality, end of6 -
Josh Parker, Martin Craniecafcsinger said:
To be fair by that logic you would say the same about Bonne. But Sarr is easily championship quality for meaddick1956 said:
You are having a laugh. He is in the Championship. We are not. Work it out.J BLOCK said:
Do me a favouraddick1956 said:
Sarr is Championship plus .Addick Addict said:
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh0 -
Parker went up as a squad player at Wycombe who probably never expected to even be challenging for promotion from League 1.wmcf123 said:
Josh Parker, Martin Craniecafcsinger said:
To be fair by that logic you would say the same about Bonne. But Sarr is easily championship quality for meaddick1956 said:
You are having a laugh. He is in the Championship. We are not. Work it out.J BLOCK said:
Do me a favouraddick1956 said:
Sarr is Championship plus .Addick Addict said:
I totally agree with you but that does rather make Bogle Conference South at best!Leuth said:
Naby Sarr is about 15 times the footballer Bogle isAddick Addict said:
Now here's a difficult one for you - Bogle or Naby up top? And you can't have both playing in coming to that answer!Leuth said:We should have used him as a striker more often tbh
Cranie's a bad example. No doubt poor for us in 08/09, but he's been there ever since, aside from one season in League 1 and another in the Prem. Clearly someone who improved after we had him on loan.1 -
Where did i say he wasn't championship quality? The very fact he's a first team regular for a championship side tells us that he is.sam3110 said:
What about when he cuts across the right winger with a perfect tackle, then swings in an inch perfect cross for T*ylor to score against Forest?Chris_from_Sidcup said:Sarr has the technical ability to play in the premier league.
The fact he is prone to lapses in concentration, getting caught out of position, ball watching etc is the reason he is not playing in the premier league.
Him standing there in the 91st minute at the Den ball watching as the bloke just jumped over him to score still pisses me off.
Or when he steps forward from defence to intercept the ball, plays the ball out wide right and continues his run, and as the ball is crossed back into the box he ghosts in unmarked to tap home and win the game?
That's the problem with us fans, we're too fickle, we're too caught up about derby games and the passion of moments that out clouds our judgements. The lad has great technical ability for a centre back, and would waltz into our defence this season (and probably waltz through it and score if we ever played against him too)
He's championship quality, end of
I've literally said he has the technical ability to play in the premier league but his lapses in concentration are why he isn't.
4 -
great finish for the second. Poor positioning a couple of times in the highlights. Sums up nabby really. Brilliant and poor in the same breathe1
-
This season stats
Naby Sarr
18 league starts , 3 league goals , 1698 mins football (excluding injury time mins) = 566 mins per goal= a goal every 6.29 games
Macaulay Bonne
9 league starts + 13 substitute appearances , 2 league goals , 972 mins football (excluding injury time mins)= 486 mins per goal = a goal every 5.4 games
Lyle Taylor
13 league starts + 9 substitute appearances, 4 league goals, 1301 mins football (excluding injury time mins)= 325 mins per goal = a goal every 3.61 games3 -
-
Sarr should have been coached as a defensive midfielder. He is a liability at centre back but would and could be a superb midfielder playing in front of the back four and pinging balls across the park from there.
Never understood why he isn't used like this.5 -
Yeah, Patrick Viera, eat your heart out.RodneyCharltonTrotta said:Sarr should have been coached as a defensive midfielder. He is a liability at centre back but would and could be a superb midfielder playing in front of the back four and pinging balls across the park from there.
Never understood why he isn't used like this.
1 -
anyone else boring enough to add all the percentages (back off terriers that's my game) up to make sure it made 100stackitsteve said:0
