Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Greg Docherty
Comments
-
I know , I try and be positive on someone and i shouldn’t because they’re all shit
I see shit each week with an ok defence but attacking wise its wank
5 good mins from Docherty and I got a hard on but nope don’t believe the hype we are junk as in we will be league one next year3 -
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.4 -
Done well at other clubsCallumcafc said:
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.
utter shit with us8 -
Why do we care that Allan Campbell has been integral to Luton's season a number of years ago when he's put in one of the worst performances I've seen in a long time?Callumcafc said:
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.
Excusing mediocrity.14 -
It was less than 18 months ago, not “a number of years”.
All the comments on Campbell after Rotherham were that he came on and helped control and change the game.
One poor performance today and he’s suddenly no better than Louie Watson.0 -
Just another bizarre Charlton signing. Looked to be one of the best players in the league a few seasons ago, could cope at a Championship level, came with nothing but praise from Hull fans, yet he looks so ordinary.
It's so frustrating.0 -
Maybe we shouldn’t decide how good a player is or isn’t after their first six weeks at a new club.Braziliance said:Just another bizarre Charlton signing. Looked to be one of the best players in the league a few seasons ago, could cope at a Championship level, came with nothing but praise from Hull fans, yet he looks so ordinary.
It's so frustrating.
Dobson was dropped a month or so into his time with us for not being good enough and everyone had written him off too.
9 -
"Docherty... told our paper earlier this month that being utilised in a more attacking role was a key attraction to signing for Charlton on a free transfer.
Asked about that at the weekend, Jones said: 'Well I’ve got people inside the club who don’t think he can play as an eight – it’s lucky I make my own decisions!' "
This was from the SLP following the Bolton game. Seems like it may have been a bit premature.
Two ways of looking at it I suppose: he's learning a new role and will take time to adjust, or he's being asked to play a role he's not suited to.
Dobson looked like he was transitioning brilliantly from the sitting role to playing in a more advanced position by the end of last season, so maybe Jones can achieve the same with Docherty. New club, new position and taking on the captaincy is a lot to ask, and we're not even ten games in yet. Hopefully things start to click soon.
8 -
I expected more from him but there’s still a long way to go this season.
So much work has clearly been put into getting our defensive structure and organisation right. It does feel it’s come at a cost of our play in possession and in attack.7 -
On the basis of what I've seen, i.e. home games, its Doc or A campbell vying for the same spot, not both together. Coventry has been top man lying deeper and Berry seems to operate more naturally a little further forwards and can keep us in possession when the hoof ball out of defence doesn't get flicked onwards by Gas.
You can take your pick which one of Doc or Campbell should be dropped after yesterday's shit show. They both need a kick up the backside by Jonesy. If Mitchell can get so harshly dropped after not putting a foot wrong so can anyone, even if they're the skipper.
1 - Sponsored links:
-
Is it excusing mediocrity? Or is it maybe being able to look at a player who has played 112 minutes for us, one of them a start and thinking that maybe the player with nearly 200 appearances across the Championship and Scottish Premier League and has never played below that level might have more to offer than his first league start showed? We always do this on here and it goes in cycles. People were doing it about Terry Taylor when he was thrown unfit into a rubbish team and got injured again, plenty calling him shit and saying they never wanted to see him play again, but one decent banter cup appearance and people are begging for him to start alongside Coventry (who was also another failed signing last season after not immediately settling into a patchwork team). Maybe Campbell is completely busted (like Tyreece was, check the abuse he got last season and compare it to now) or maybe he's come into a team struggling to impose itself in midfield and was the wrong choice for the game. It's not excusing mediocrity to look at players with decent pedigree, which is exactly what people have been crying out for instead of L2 hopefuls and players with bad injury records, and think that a bad performance doesn't necessarily have to mean that's all they have to give, but players aren't allowed bad form or a bad appearance, they're 'shit' immediately. I'm disappointed with Docherty so far but I hate this stupid idea that you're somehow complicit in the team not being promoted by September by refusing to want to be the first to race onto the internet and complain so you can say you were the first to say that player was rubbish. In the meantime we're 4th and 3 points off top spot but you'd think we were in the relegation places the way people are carrying onSELR_addicks said:
Why do we care that Allan Campbell has been integral to Luton's season a number of years ago when he's put in one of the worst performances I've seen in a long time?Callumcafc said:
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.
Excusing mediocrity.
23 -
Top post Garry. Couldn't agree more3
-
I feel like Allan Campbell must have enough about him to do better than he did yesterday. Similar for Docherty and the way he's been playing.
At the same time, how many players have come here with 'pedigree', rave reviews etc. and put in awful performances in a red shirt.
The only metric that really matters is how well they play for us.
2 -
Or maybe the only metric is winning points whomsoever plays.
It is telling how forceful the condemnation of TC was last season. Now he ought to be one of the first names on the team sheet along with Ramsey, Lloyd Jones and, ahem, Alex Mitchell.1 -
It worries me that most of players we are moaning about have all played for NJ at previous clubs. I am sure he likes players he trusts, but there is a limit.
He drops Mitchell, a good defender but keeps an aging midfield who does not command the middle of the pitch0 -
Its only A.Campbell who has played previously for Jones that has been overly moaned about after yesterday isnt it?0
-
Aging midfield is harsh. Campbell is 26 and Docherty is 28.ross1 said:It worries me that most of players we are moaning about have all played for NJ at previous clubs. I am sure he likes players he trusts, but there is a limit.
He drops Mitchell, a good defender but keeps an aging midfield who does not command the middle of the pitch4 -
What's the point of a midfield if just going to lump the football..2
-
I think he’s ok but not spectacular. He does lots of little things that break up play and helps out Ramsay quite well defensively. Can’t remember a huge amount he’s done on the ball because we don’t play the ball through our midfield for some weird reason. Looks to have a decent shot on him though, will probably score a couple of long range goals this season
0 -
Why are they so slow?crookester said:
Aging midfield is harsh. Campbell is 26 and Docherty is 28.ross1 said:It worries me that most of players we are moaning about have all played for NJ at previous clubs. I am sure he likes players he trusts, but there is a limit.
He drops Mitchell, a good defender but keeps an aging midfield who does not command the middle of the pitch0 - Sponsored links:
-
exactly this.DubaiCAFC said:What's the point of a midfield if just going to lump the football..0 -
Subbed off in the Blackpool match that we lost, benched for the next two that we still lost, think it's time he came back in personally, for Anderson12
-
We have been better with him in the team4
-
Only slightly better still doesnt provide much in terms of leadership assists or goals which our WHOLE midfield seems to suffer from0
-
New signings need time. Is he with his family, is he on a hotel, these could affect performance. Different training techniques, different facilities at the training ground (worse probably) and playing a slightly different role and tactics all mean players need time to settle.
2 -
When Jones bought him in he said Docherty would play forwards and get us goals.
Docherty is 28 yrs old and has a record of 21 goals in 300 games. That averages at say 3 a season across 45 games.
He is, I assume, a defensive midfielder being asked to play an attacking role.
It doesn't make sense to me.6 -
Go back a year and if someone had said Hector is no better than Innis you’d have been on here telling us about his record at Fulham. A year later and it’s not unreasonable to say Hector was no better for us than Innis. Just because a player was once good doesn’t mean they always will be. We’ve had a bad habit in recent years of signing players just as their form goes off a cliff. Once upon a time you could point to players like Simon Francis (and quite a few others) and say there was something wrong with us because players would be bad here but good again when they left. That trend has ended and now they seem to turn bad here and then stay bad and drop down the leagues. If these players we’ve signed are all decent Championship players, why did no one in the championship want them? The early signs are it’s because they’re not championship standard anymore.Callumcafc said:
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.4 -
I’m sure that’ll turn out to be the case for some of them.Exiled_Addick said:
Go back a year and if someone had said Hector is no better than Innis you’d have been on here telling us about his record at Fulham. A year later and it’s not unreasonable to say Hector was no better for us than Innis. Just because a player was once good doesn’t mean they always will be. We’ve had a bad habit in recent years of signing players just as their form goes off a cliff. Once upon a time you could point to players like Simon Francis (and quite a few others) and say there was something wrong with us because players would be bad here but good again when they left. That trend has ended and now they seem to turn bad here and then stay bad and drop down the leagues. If these players we’ve signed are all decent Championship players, why did no one in the championship want them? The early signs are it’s because they’re not championship standard anymore.Callumcafc said:
This is insanity. You’re talking nonsense after one disappointing result.Oh Eddie Youds... said:It’s the same shit every year. We ship out a load of players each summer & replace them with other shit players.
Is Ahadme any better than Connor Wickham?
Is Docherty any better than Albie Morgan?
Is Alan Campbell any better than Louis Watson?
Is Gillesphey any better than Terrell Thomas?
Is REG any better than Hector?
Honestly don’t think there is much difference in many of the above changes (some look much worse than what we had previously!)
We just go round and round recycling players that are not good enough to get us out of this league.Of the five examples you’ve given, four that we have now are obviously better than the alternatives you’ve listed.- Docherty integral to Hull winning this league and made regular appearances in the Championship, Albie mid table fodder at this level.- Alan Campbell integral to Luton’s Championship promotion, Louis Watson can’t find a club.- Gillesphey integral to Plymouth winning this league, Terrell’s struggling at League 2 Carlisle.- REG an important piece in Rotherham’s promotion out of this league, Hector clearly past it and can’t find a club.
- Ahadme isn’t a better player than Wickham but CW spends more time on the physio’s table than Chuks.
Allan Campbell though only turned 26 in the summer. He played regularly when Luton won the Championship playoffs. It didn’t work out at Millwall, but they went through 3 managers. At his age I find it hard to believe he’s coasting as we’ve seen players do in the past.
I think we’re not seeing the best of some of these players and the style is a big factor. The midfield watch the ball fly over their heads all game. Ahadme isn’t the target man we needed. TC plays like the winger he is. Even when the midfield do get on the ball, they’re all similar types of players. We don’t keep the ball long enough and then pass quick enough at the right times to get the wing backs into dangerous areas to create chances. It’s no wonder only the defending has looked good at times this season, while our attacking play has rarely impressed.6 -
Agreed, but nobody is using that argument when talking about Ahadme.Todds_right_hook said:New signings need time. Is he with his family, is he on a hotel, these could affect performance. Different training techniques, different facilities at the training ground (worse probably) and playing a slightly different role and tactics all mean players need time to settle.2 -
Interesting isn't it. I've noticed that too, there's 953 comments on Ahadme's thread and 239 on this one. Given their playing history and the fact Docherty is far more experienced as well as being our captain I've been more disappointed with his performances. Ahadme definitely gets the worst of it on here thoughredbuttle said:
Agreed, but nobody is using that argument when talking about Ahadme.Todds_right_hook said:New signings need time. Is he with his family, is he on a hotel, these could affect performance. Different training techniques, different facilities at the training ground (worse probably) and playing a slightly different role and tactics all mean players need time to settle.5
