Attention: Please take a moment to consider our <a href="http://forum.charltonlife.com/home/termsofservice">terms and conditions</a> before posting.

I am going to say it!! Yes I am, Nathan Jones......................

1…169170171172174

Comments

  • NabySarr said:

    Good to see the majority of fans are still backing him 
    So you want Jones in but you don’t like his football? 

    How are you squaring this circle
  • Can't imagine any NJ team playing attractive football. His football is pretty awful to watch but you can excuse it if the results are okay.

    Budget certainly not the only issue.

    Things have to improve.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    NabySarr said:

    Good to see the majority of fans are still backing him 
    So you want Jones in but you don’t like his football? 

    How are you squaring this circle
    The football is shite, but we wouldn’t be able to get a better manager than Jones in. It’s the same view as the majority of others, the football is shit but we don’t have the players for any better 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    Can't imagine any NJ team playing attractive football. His football is pretty awful to watch but you can excuse it if the results are okay.

    Budget certainly not the only issue.

    Things have to improve.
    He’s played attractive football in the past when he’s had the players to do it, the problem is he doesn’t have the players to do it so has to play the football terrorism we see each game 
  • NabySarr said:
    Can't imagine any NJ team playing attractive football. His football is pretty awful to watch but you can excuse it if the results are okay.

    Budget certainly not the only issue.

    Things have to improve.
    He’s played attractive football in the past when he’s had the players to do it, the problem is he doesn’t have the players to do it so has to play the football terrorism we see each game 
    When did he play attractive football? 
  • ns9
    ns9 Posts: 165
    That was obviously atrocious today, but I would still be firmly behind NJ. What do people expect with a net spend of £1.5m this summer and main owner(s) seemingly wanting out?

    Two things can be right at the same time - we are in dreadful form, but I still think he’s the right man. 18th and above would be progress, and I would still fancy him to deliver that. I think he’s a good manager and he’s been let down 
  • Alwaysneil
    Alwaysneil Posts: 14,844
    He is partly letting himself down. Why play our defensive formation against a team shipping goals? It is this kind of unfathomable decision making that pisses people off
  • NabySarr said:
    Can't imagine any NJ team playing attractive football. His football is pretty awful to watch but you can excuse it if the results are okay.

    Budget certainly not the only issue.

    Things have to improve.
    He’s played attractive football in the past when he’s had the players to do it, the problem is he doesn’t have the players to do it so has to play the football terrorism we see each game 
    When did he play attractive football? 
    His first stint at Luton was quite attractive 
  • Willo
    Willo Posts: 76
    Uboat said:
    If we sack Nathan Jones the best candidate to appoint him is probably Nathan Jones unfortunately
    That’s just not true though… 

    again people who are saying who do we replace him with. Thats not our job to find the right person
    Sorry, but that’s such a cop out. Presumably you say it because you can’t 
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 52,508
    I'd love to work out how many people are on a merry go round each season of calling for Jones' head then stating something along the lines of "we outperformed our ability" without admitting they've been wrong. 

    I feel like the criticism of performances are fair, but we seem to turn it around every season so far. 

  • Sponsored links:



  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 52,508
    edited October 17
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
  • NJ getting sacked doesn't solve anything, we haven't got the players to play 'good football' at this level
  • Is Jones too loyal to some of his coaching staff?

    I wouldn't know where to point the finger but there are surely improvements to be made in that department.
  • Arsenetatters
    Arsenetatters Posts: 6,461
    Team with one of the lowest budgets in the league play like team with one of the lowest budgets in the league.

    Not saying Jones tactics or management are helping, but who seriously thinks anyone is going to really do any better with what we have?
    Be hard pushed for anyone to do any worse as well 


    Based on what? We could be bottom of the table with no wins and -12 goal difference.

    Again not defending Jones but we have to face up to the reality that our squad, for this level, is so so poor. 

    Thats what the budget we have has given us.

    I honestly don’t see anyone coming in and being able to change that.
    For someone who is not defending him. You are doing a great job of defending him. Jones out. But it is not going to happen.
    It will happen, but way too late to keep us up this season IMHO

  • Dazzler21 said:
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
    Apart from the fact that the quoted post was from over a year ago and at the time I did name multiple options. 

    Carlos Corberan is available, championship experience and a promotion to boot 
  • Willo said:
    Uboat said:
    If we sack Nathan Jones the best candidate to appoint him is probably Nathan Jones unfortunately
    That’s just not true though… 

    again people who are saying who do we replace him with. Thats not our job to find the right person
    Sorry, but that’s such a cop out. Presumably you say it because you can’t 
    How far back did you have to go for this you weapon 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    Dazzler21 said:
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
    Apart from the fact that the quoted post was from over a year ago and at the time I did name multiple options. 

    Carlos Corberan is available, championship experience and a promotion to boot 
    You’re joking right? There is absolutely no chance Carlos Corberan would come and manage us. He’s just been the Valencia manager ffs why would he come and join a championship struggler 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    I’m still waiting for someone to suggest a realistic upgrade on Jones. I’ll be waiting a while because I don’t think there is one at the moment 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    Carlos Corberan ffs 😂 might as well say Pep Guardiola because it’s got about the same chance of happening 
  • 2121
    2121 Posts: 1,928
    Find it too hard and early to be in the jones out brigade, he got us up and kept us up, plus we started well and this is a long long season. 

    But he does make some questionable tactical decisions, im sure everyone else has mentioned them so no point repeating.

    my issue, is he blames the players (even whilst stating he takes responsibility), that could become toxic. Jose mourinho was the master of taking any heat away from the players, master - jones is not. 


  • Sponsored links:



  • NabySarr said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
    Apart from the fact that the quoted post was from over a year ago and at the time I did name multiple options. 

    Carlos Corberan is available, championship experience and a promotion to boot 
    You’re joking right? There is absolutely no chance Carlos Corberan would come and manage us. He’s just been the Valencia manager ffs why would he come and join a championship struggler 
    It’s entirely feasible. Look a Hull City’s manager, he came from managing in the Turkish top flight and dynamo Zagreb before that to one of the relegation favourites in the championship. 
  • DubaiCAFC
    DubaiCAFC Posts: 2,600
    Not sure many want Jones to go, but people are frustrated because this is a strong squad, just feels like being aloud to go and play. Also they don’t know if they are attacking or defensive at the moment. Caught in between. It is a worry at the moment.. Watford and Burnley are poor, low in confidence and we got 1 point and never really had a go at them. If we go at them, get an early goal it could been a few goals and we could have kicked on.
    He needs to get this low budget thing out of his head and believe in the players 
  • 2121
    2121 Posts: 1,928
    Tbf we also wont be the first or last fans to think we know how to solve all the problems, maybe he is doing what he can with a load of players punching above their weight 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    DubaiCAFC said:
    Not sure many want Jones to go, but people are frustrated because this is a strong squad, just feels like being aloud to go and play. Also they don’t know if they are attacking or defensive at the moment. Caught in between. It is a worry at the moment.. Watford and Burnley are poor, low in confidence and we got 1 point and never really had a go at them. If we go at them, get an early goal it could been a few goals and we could have kicked on.
    He needs to get this low budget thing out of his head and believe in the players 
    It really isn’t a strong squad at all. It is one of the worst in the league 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 6,696
    NabySarr said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
    Apart from the fact that the quoted post was from over a year ago and at the time I did name multiple options. 

    Carlos Corberan is available, championship experience and a promotion to boot 
    You’re joking right? There is absolutely no chance Carlos Corberan would come and manage us. He’s just been the Valencia manager ffs why would he come and join a championship struggler 
    It’s entirely feasible. Look a Hull City’s manager, he came from managing in the Turkish top flight and dynamo Zagreb before that to one of the relegation favourites in the championship. 
    Absolutely no chance I’m sorry. A Turkish owner hiring a Turkish manager from a league smaller than the championship vs us hiring a manager that last managed one of the biggest clubs in Spain. Corberan is a great manager and would be an upgrade on Jones, but he would just laugh if we offered him the job. It’s a silly suggestion and not realistic 
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 28,976
    NabySarr said:
    DubaiCAFC said:
    Not sure many want Jones to go, but people are frustrated because this is a strong squad, just feels like being aloud to go and play. Also they don’t know if they are attacking or defensive at the moment. Caught in between. It is a worry at the moment.. Watford and Burnley are poor, low in confidence and we got 1 point and never really had a go at them. If we go at them, get an early goal it could been a few goals and we could have kicked on.
    He needs to get this low budget thing out of his head and believe in the players 
    It really isn’t a strong squad at all. It is one of the worst in the league 
    Agreed. This is not a strong squad. 
  • cs1986
    cs1986 Posts: 1,631
    NabySarr said:
    FAVADDICK said:
    NabySarr said:
    Team with one of the lowest budgets in the league play like team with one of the lowest budgets in the league.

    Not saying Jones tactics or management are helping, but who seriously thinks anyone is going to really do any better with what we have?
    Be hard pushed for anyone to do any worse as well 


    Based on what? We could be bottom of the table with no wins and -12 goal difference.

    Again not defending Jones but we have to face up to the reality that our squad, for this level, is so so poor. 

    Thats what the budget we have has given us.

    I honestly don’t see anyone coming in and being able to change that.
    For someone who is not defending him. You are doing a great job of defending him. Jones out. But it is not going to happen.
    I’m not defending him, I wouldn’t care if they sacked him tonight.

    But I’ve also got the ability to look past the person and realise that our issues are far deeper than him.

    Shame others just seem to kid themselves that everything would all of a sudden be different/better.

    Exactly. Remove Jones and we still won’t have a midfield capable of progressing the ball, and we still won’t have anyone of the right hand side that’s any good. The manager isn’t the problem here 






    I think your abit deluded if you don’t think the manager is the problem 
    I think you’re more deluded if you think being 16th with this squad and budget is a sackable offence. What did people expect this season to be like? 
    I expected us to actually have a go at winning games especially against a team thats been absolutely pumped last 2 weeks. I would rather go out and lose trying to win than losing playing negative anti football. Jones has no balls.
  • cs1986
    cs1986 Posts: 1,631
    FAVADDICK said:
    NabySarr said:
    FAVADDICK said:
    NabySarr said:
    Team with one of the lowest budgets in the league play like team with one of the lowest budgets in the league.

    Not saying Jones tactics or management are helping, but who seriously thinks anyone is going to really do any better with what we have?
    Be hard pushed for anyone to do any worse as well 


    Based on what? We could be bottom of the table with no wins and -12 goal difference.

    Again not defending Jones but we have to face up to the reality that our squad, for this level, is so so poor. 

    Thats what the budget we have has given us.

    I honestly don’t see anyone coming in and being able to change that.
    For someone who is not defending him. You are doing a great job of defending him. Jones out. But it is not going to happen.
    I’m not defending him, I wouldn’t care if they sacked him tonight.

    But I’ve also got the ability to look past the person and realise that our issues are far deeper than him.

    Shame others just seem to kid themselves that everything would all of a sudden be different/better.

    Exactly. Remove Jones and we still won’t have a midfield capable of progressing the ball, and we still won’t have anyone of the right hand side that’s any good. The manager isn’t the problem here 






    I think your abit deluded if you don’t think the manager is the problem 
    I think you’re more deluded if you think being 16th with this squad and budget is a sackable offence. What did people expect this season to be like? 
    I expect to turn up to a team that have shipped 9 goals in the last 2 games and not play 8 defensive players and actually attack them, and that isn’t just this game either we’ve been so poor for the last couple of months, playing the same atrocious football every week
    It is truly aids to watch. I couldnt agree more. Are we sure Nathan Jones aint French... he fucking surrenders before a balls kicked.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 23,668
    NabySarr said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    You're right of course Aberystwyth. You can't replace a manager, just like you can't sack one. But you want the ability to demand a sacking...
    Therefore, If you can call for a sacking you better be able to call out a replacement. Nobody is saying you have to pay them but at least name one. 
    Apart from the fact that the quoted post was from over a year ago and at the time I did name multiple options. 

    Carlos Corberan is available, championship experience and a promotion to boot 
    You’re joking right? There is absolutely no chance Carlos Corberan would come and manage us. He’s just been the Valencia manager ffs why would he come and join a championship struggler 
    He supposedly turned down Watford this week 
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 52,508
    edited October 17
    I don't really get why after the last 20 years people think we can attract better. 

    Who have we had that has been a genuinely good manager since Curbishley left? Powell? Bowyer?