Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

MATCH THREAD (+post p20) : Charlton Athletic V Bromley : BSM Trophy : Tues 12 November 2024 KO 19:00

1192021222325»

Comments

  • JohnnyH2 said:
    JamesSeed said:
    Crusty54 said:
    My eyes must be playing me up as well as the poster on here who said he didn't step on to the pitch from his viewpoint 7 rows back. 

    Can everyone see Nathan step on to the pitch from the video posted? It looks to me he's a step outside his managers area but not over the touchline.

    No VAR lines to confirm obviously 🙄

    Watching on Sky, some posters didn't realize that Miles Leaburn's goal took a deflection when you saw the posts on CL. 

    Edit: Just heard Fleming do the after match interview so all about encroachment.
    He was standing outside the pitch but the ball came towards him off the ground and he raised his right leg to bring it down. His foot was inside the pitch when he impacted the ball.
    Not sure how you can say that with such certainty when having watched the video a few times it's not clear at all whether he was inside the pitch at all. If anything I thought it looked more like he was just off the pitch.
    It's all very odd, but I guess it doesn't really matter, in the great scheme of things.
    He probably can say it with certainty as he like me was there and watched it
    Unless you were sitting side on to the touchline, and concentrating entirely on when and where Jones kicked the ball I doubt you had a perfect view of the incident, and even then the naked eye can be misleading.

    I suspect it's like the incident in the last World Cup where the Japan player crossed the ball when it looked like it had gone out of play, when Hawkeye showed the ball was 2% in.

  • JohnnyH2 said:
    JamesSeed said:
    Crusty54 said:
    My eyes must be playing me up as well as the poster on here who said he didn't step on to the pitch from his viewpoint 7 rows back. 

    Can everyone see Nathan step on to the pitch from the video posted? It looks to me he's a step outside his managers area but not over the touchline.

    No VAR lines to confirm obviously 🙄

    Watching on Sky, some posters didn't realize that Miles Leaburn's goal took a deflection when you saw the posts on CL. 

    Edit: Just heard Fleming do the after match interview so all about encroachment.
    He was standing outside the pitch but the ball came towards him off the ground and he raised his right leg to bring it down. His foot was inside the pitch when he impacted the ball.
    Not sure how you can say that with such certainty when having watched the video a few times it's not clear at all whether he was inside the pitch at all. If anything I thought it looked more like he was just off the pitch.
    It's all very odd, but I guess it doesn't really matter, in the great scheme of things.
    He probably can say it with certainty as he like me was there and watched it
    Unless you were sitting side on to the touchline, and concentrating entirely on when and where Jones kicked the ball I doubt you had a perfect view of the incident, and even then the naked eye can be misleading.

    I suspect it's like the incident in the last World Cup where the Japan player crossed the ball when it looked like it had gone out of play, when Hawkeye showed the ball was 2% in.

    I was 4 rows back, centre circle
  • Off_it said:
    JohnnyH2 said:
    JamesSeed said:
    Crusty54 said:
    My eyes must be playing me up as well as the poster on here who said he didn't step on to the pitch from his viewpoint 7 rows back. 

    Can everyone see Nathan step on to the pitch from the video posted? It looks to me he's a step outside his managers area but not over the touchline.

    No VAR lines to confirm obviously 🙄

    Watching on Sky, some posters didn't realize that Miles Leaburn's goal took a deflection when you saw the posts on CL. 

    Edit: Just heard Fleming do the after match interview so all about encroachment.
    He was standing outside the pitch but the ball came towards him off the ground and he raised his right leg to bring it down. His foot was inside the pitch when he impacted the ball.
    Not sure how you can say that with such certainty when having watched the video a few times it's not clear at all whether he was inside the pitch at all. If anything I thought it looked more like he was just off the pitch.
    It's all very odd, but I guess it doesn't really matter, in the great scheme of things.
    He probably can say it with certainty as he like me was there and watched it
    Where were you sitting? 
    4 rows back centre circle, saw enough, and certainly more than the stream shows
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!