Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
League One (non-Charlton) 2024/25 January transfer window
Comments
-
DyerConsequences said:1
-
With AC gone maybe after years of speculation it’s Hayden Mullins time to step up to the plate.0
-
Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
Will Grigg had scored 19 goals in this league the season before Sunderland bought him. He wasn’t getting much game time in the Championship so Wigan let him go. He was all but guaranteed to score goals at Sunderland as well.
To say he was already done when the three previous seasons at this level he had scored 20, 25 and 19 is a stretch I think. They bought high and they got stung.
Not guaranteed the same will happen with Wrexham but they are overpaying and they are taking a risk.
2 -
https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/cgmyn4mwxmvo
Lincoln sign striker Joe Gardner on loan from Nottingham Forest0 -
Chunes said:Braziliance said:killerandflash said:Braziliance said:killerandflash said:Braziliance said:killerandflash said:£2m if true for Sam Smith is is ridiculous sum for a 3rd division club to pay. The Jay Stanfield deal shouldn't be allowed to make such sums seem normal
Yes I want us to be competitive, but I don't blame our owners for not paying those sort of fees.
If Leaburn was to go, it wouldn't be to a L1 side.
It's unlikely he goes to a league1 club, but my point was, if Birmingham or Wrexham came in for Leaburn for a £3 million bid, I doubt you'd say it's ridiculous. Sam Smith holds a similar value to Reading that Miles does to us.
The fees spent in the championship are absurd now, that will only filter down to this league. There will be clubs who are ambitious (Birmingham, Huddersfield, Wrexham) who will want to keep up with this.
2 million for one of the best strikers in the league and arguably a promotion rivals best player, at 26 years old is a good deal. I'd be made up if that was us. Instead we are celebrating rectifying poor transfer decisions.
Unfortunately if you aren't willing to spend this kind of money, or at the very least big wages, you'll get left behind in modern football. It isn't 2012 anymore. That's about the going rate for a good striker and won't raise many eyebrows.
But it does filter down, and it isn't a big fee nowadays. I'd be more surprised if it was less. One million for instance would be a bargain for Sam Smith in this market.
I don't feel like we can say big spending has been normalised in this league, because it's mostly just Brum, and they're just one team. Otherwise it's a big fee spent here or there, spread over the last decade.
I think we will see a fair few multi million deals potentially as the years go on. Which is why I think in this current market, Smith is a good deal for Wrexham0 -
Callumcafc said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
Will Grigg had scored 19 goals in this league the season before Sunderland bought him. He wasn’t getting much game time in the Championship so Wigan let him go. He was all but guaranteed to score goals at Sunderland as well.
To say he was already done when the three previous seasons at this level he had scored 20, 25 and 19 is a stretch I think. They bought high and they got stung.
Not guaranteed the same will happen with Wrexham but they are overpaying and they are taking a risk.
I still think using that as an argument every single time doesn't hold much weight. It's a bit of an extreme example.
Sunderland are a big club and had big ambitions. It didn't work out, that's football. It was still a sign of intent.
For the Will Grigg example of a club spending money and it not working out, I can list a load of examples of clubs who don't spend and stagnate.1 -
Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.0 -
North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.1 -
Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.2 -
fenaddick said:Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.
Yup came through their academy. Completely understandable him going back there.2 - Sponsored links:
-
fenaddick said:Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.
I'd more so look at us in that instance. Players go where the money is first. We didn't beat Readings offer at the time by the sounds of things, it is what it is, again.
0 -
-
Braziliance said:fenaddick said:Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.
I'd more so look at us in that instance. Players go where the money is first. We didn't beat Readings offer at the time by the sounds of things, it is what it is, again.7 -
🗞️ Wrexham are after Jay Rodriguez.The Welsh club have reportedly prepared a package worth £15k a week plus add ons to try and lure the Burnley forward to the Racecourse Ground.0
-
fenaddick said:Braziliance said:fenaddick said:Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.
I'd more so look at us in that instance. Players go where the money is first. We didn't beat Readings offer at the time by the sounds of things, it is what it is, again.
He's gone because their owner is an asset stripper and Sam Smith has been offered a better wage deal by Wrexham.
That's the more likely scenario, and that's from Reading fans I've actually spoke with, not just made guesses that put our club in a better light.0 -
Braziliance said:fenaddick said:Braziliance said:fenaddick said:Braziliance said:North Lower Neil said:Braziliance said:Callumcafc said:Sorry but there is no world in which a League One club paying 2 million for Sam Smith is a good deal. At best it's a fair deal, at worst it will be Will Grigg at Sunderland all over again.
Sam Smith is the third highest rated striker in the league, only behind Kone and our Leaburn, is on 11 goals (4th highest, may finish top scorer) with just under half a season to go, can play a versatile role, in his prime years, and they've signed him from a league rival.
So there is a world where you can say it isn't, but on paper, in this transfer market*, that's a good signing.
Each to their own, I'd be buzzing if we signed Sam Smith, he'd walk into this team and be a great option for us 👍🏻
May and Smith with Leaburn to return from injury would have been a very good partnership last season.
You're right though, May and Smith would have been a class front two, goals for days. Shame.
I'd more so look at us in that instance. Players go where the money is first. We didn't beat Readings offer at the time by the sounds of things, it is what it is, again.
He's gone because their owner is an asset stripper and Sam Smith has been offered a better wage deal by Wrexham.
That's the more likely scenario, and that's from Reading fans I've actually spoke with, not just made guesses that put our club in a better light.4 -
Pull your finger out Charlton, why the hell aren't we offering a 35 year old striker £15k p/w? Seems prudent and in keeping with our general strategy if you ask me5
-
https://readingfc.co.uk//news/2025/january/31/sam-smith-departs-for-wrexham/
The Club can confirm that forward Sam Smith has completed a transfer to League One side Wrexham for an undisclosed fee.Whilst the club was not actively seeking to sell Sam, the significant offer payable by Wrexham will help support the essential short-term finances required to run the club.5 -
One positive thing (for us) is that this significantly weakens Reading. Wrexham are out of reach anyway but Stockport & Reading both losing key players in the window is very helpful5
-
fenaddick said:One positive thing (for us) is that this significantly weakens Reading. Wrexham are out of reach anyway but Stockport & Reading both losing key players in the window is very helpful14
- Sponsored links:
-
If we were about to spend £2m on a player from Reading I’d much rather it be Tyler Bindon. Massive centre half and only 20 years old, bags of potential.Wouldn’t happen because he’s going up a league at minimum if he does move.6
-
Worth noting that when Sunderland signed Will Grigg, it was after they had lost top scorer Josh Maja earlier in the window to Bordeaux for a significant fee, so it wasn't a cherry on the cake signing, but a direct replacement.0
-
Stevenage have signed Hanlan on loan from Wycombe
https://x.com/StevenageFC/status/1885359013833171285?t=R_aSFlzepU5NWVjgqfAO2w&s=19
Believe that makes us now the only club to have not signed a player? Or one of two1 -
Braziliance said:Stevenage have signed Hanlan on loan from Wycombe
https://x.com/StevenageFC/status/1885359013833171285?t=R_aSFlzepU5NWVjgqfAO2w&s=19
Believe that makes us now the only club to have not signed a player? Or one of two
0 -
Yeah Reading is the other club yet to do anything inward. I assume under the terms of their embargo they can replace Smith though.0
-
YannTheMann said:Pull your finger out Charlton, why the hell aren't we offering a 35 year old striker £15k p/w? Seems prudent and in keeping with our general strategy if you ask me
It does clear up another myth about squad size though. I think Wrexham have 10 more players on their books or so than us, with a higher wage bill, yet they're still spending transfer fees and spending 15k a week on one player.
So much for all the theories behind budgets and squad sizes. "Trim the squad" was the repeated phrase. More waffle.
Fair play Wrexham, National League in 22/23, and now in a genuine promotion race to the championship two seasons later and spending some serious cash.
1 -
guinnessaddick said:Braziliance said:Stevenage have signed Hanlan on loan from Wycombe
https://x.com/StevenageFC/status/1885359013833171285?t=R_aSFlzepU5NWVjgqfAO2w&s=19
Believe that makes us now the only club to have not signed a player? Or one of twoMarcusH26 said:Yeah Reading is the other club yet to do anything inward. I assume under the terms of their embargo they can replace Smith though.
So other than Reading, who have an owner who hates them more than Roland hates us, has signed a player.0 -
Brendan Wiredu might be off to Wigan, very good signing for them.
🚨 BREAKING: Wigan Athletic are expected to make one more permanent signing before the Monday deadline.Fleetwood Town’s Brendan Wiredu is a player Latics may look to go back in for, after an initial bid earlier in the window was knocked back.#wafc | #ftfc [@PKendrickWIG]
https://x.com/WAFCVision/status/1885440469896732856?t=VRKJAMa1jW_j46OihjRduA&s=19
Would have still loved him back here, he'd be tailor made for that back 3. If not a very good versatile option.0 -
Braziliance said:Brendan Wiredu might be off to Wigan, very good signing for them.
🚨 BREAKING: Wigan Athletic are expected to make one more permanent signing before the Monday deadline.Fleetwood Town’s Brendan Wiredu is a player Latics may look to go back in for, after an initial bid earlier in the window was knocked back.#wafc | #ftfc [@PKendrickWIG]
https://x.com/WAFCVision/status/1885440469896732856?t=VRKJAMa1jW_j46OihjRduA&s=19
Would have still loved him back here, he'd be tailor made for that back 3. If not a very good versatile option.2 -
You sign good players when they become available, that's what our greatest manager did.
£600k for a club captain that has league 1 experience, can play multiple positions and is in his mid 20s is a no brainer.
You need to prepare for form, competition, fatigue. He'd have been an excellent signing. We still don't know if Small is going to sign which would leave a vacancy in our back 5 and a lack of competition.
Fair play to them, good pick up.0