Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Playoffs Guaranteed Minimum - Good Friday

16768697173

Comments

  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 36,024
    fenaddick said:
    If we're going to worry about dropped points then the Peterborough game is the obvious one. But in reality that isn't how it works, over a whole season you will end up pretty much where you deserve. Our late charge has probably come one, maybe two games too late but it's been a hell of a try
    Dropping 5 points at home to Mansfield and Crawley, two of the worst teams in the league is more obvious for me. Peterborough away is a tricky game. 
  • Chizz
    Chizz Posts: 28,341
    Dunno... I'm still cautious of facing Wycombe.

    Despite sounding like a bit of a twat post-match; Dodds wasn't wrong when he said that they conceded four soft goals against us (I think the only one I'd be really "happy" with conceding was Berry's), and they've got to put it down as a blip because they've been so defensively strong since he's joined the club.

    Its going forward where they suddenly don't look a threat and wouldnt worry me as much.

    Wycombe or Stockport I fear are two Play-Off opponents that could easily get decided on a penalty shootout.
    The phrase "we conceded four soft goals" hides an awful lot wrong with a performance. Especially when the facts (7 shots on target to 2) spell out the fact it wasn't just "soft" goals that resulted in the thrashing. 
  • CAFCTrev
    CAFCTrev Posts: 5,978
    Chizz said:
    Dunno... I'm still cautious of facing Wycombe.

    Despite sounding like a bit of a twat post-match; Dodds wasn't wrong when he said that they conceded four soft goals against us (I think the only one I'd be really "happy" with conceding was Berry's), and they've got to put it down as a blip because they've been so defensively strong since he's joined the club.

    Its going forward where they suddenly don't look a threat and wouldnt worry me as much.

    Wycombe or Stockport I fear are two Play-Off opponents that could easily get decided on a penalty shootout.
    The phrase "we conceded four soft goals" hides an awful lot wrong with a performance. Especially when the facts (7 shots on target to 2) spell out the fact it wasn't just "soft" goals that resulted in the thrashing. 
    "we lost 7 nil, but it was 7 soft goals so technically we drew 0-0"
  • guinnessaddick
    guinnessaddick Posts: 28,645
    Plenty of twists & turns in the last couple of games for everyone. Hopefully the footballing gods repay us for the late Barnsley goal against Brentford that sent us down.
  • flyingkiwiDK
    flyingkiwiDK Posts: 5,723
    edited April 22
    I hope and believe we will go up but I’m also worried that the current owners don’t have a pot to piss in and we’ll see an immediate return to League 1 thanks to a total lack of investment in the squad.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,164
    Charlton chat starting at 2:00

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_mL_U8H_xQ
  • peterreeves
    peterreeves Posts: 1,062
    I hope and believe we will go up but I’m also worried that the current owners don’t have a pot to piss in and we’ll see an immediate return to League 1 thanks to a total lack of investment in the squad.
    This is spot on... No point in going up via automatic or Wembley if we then drop down again.

    We've not seen any depth to the owners pockets at all and two loans in the January window is hardly a statement of any intent.

    We all remember the wonderful feeling when Bauer scored the winning goal but getting relegated a season later was a real blow.

    I'd love to see our Owners say that they're proud of the Manager, Team and Fans and that if we get promoted funds will be there. Clearly this is utterly blue sky thinking on my part but this Board has been very quiet and I'm not impressed and feeling reassured. 
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 4,891
    I hope and believe we will go up but I’m also worried that the current owners don’t have a pot to piss in and we’ll see an immediate return to League 1 thanks to a total lack of investment in the squad.
    This is spot on... No point in going up via automatic or Wembley if we then drop down again.

    We've not seen any depth to the owners pockets at all and two loans in the January window is hardly a statement of any intent.

    We all remember the wonderful feeling when Bauer scored the winning goal but getting relegated a season later was a real blow.

    I'd love to see our Owners say that they're proud of the Manager, Team and Fans and that if we get promoted funds will be there. Clearly this is utterly blue sky thinking on my part but this Board has been very quiet and I'm not impressed and feeling reassured. 
    disagree. Even a single season is worth it otherwise we will dwindle  and fade. 
  • robroy
    robroy Posts: 4,428
    We will also keep our better players 
  • IdleHans
    IdleHans Posts: 10,971
    I hope and believe we will go up but I’m also worried that the current owners don’t have a pot to piss in and we’ll see an immediate return to League 1 thanks to a total lack of investment in the squad.
    This is spot on... No point in going up via automatic or Wembley if we then drop down again.

    We've not seen any depth to the owners pockets at all and two loans in the January window is hardly a statement of any intent.

    We all remember the wonderful feeling when Bauer scored the winning goal but getting relegated a season later was a real blow.

    I'd love to see our Owners say that they're proud of the Manager, Team and Fans and that if we get promoted funds will be there. Clearly this is utterly blue sky thinking on my part but this Board has been very quiet and I'm not impressed and feeling reassured. 
    disagree. Even a single season is worth it otherwise we will dwindle  and fade. 
    And all our noisy owners have been a shambles
  • Sponsored links:



  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,164
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 36,024
    I hope and believe we will go up but I’m also worried that the current owners don’t have a pot to piss in and we’ll see an immediate return to League 1 thanks to a total lack of investment in the squad.
    Who funded the 14m we lost last year?
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,635
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    Alfie May was under contract. 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,164
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    Alfie May was under contract. 
    Sure but NJ and May didn’t get on. Those players above all look (currently) like they’d run through brick walls for NJ
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 4,891
    fenaddick said:
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    Alfie May was under contract. 
    Sure but NJ and May didn’t get on. Those players above all look (currently) like they’d run through brick walls for NJ
    Whereas Chuks is the brick wall for other teams to run in to ! 🙂
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,781
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Let's not be doom and gloom about losing players before we even know what's going to happen.

    We lost our two best players from last season and have jumped up the table from 16th to 2nd-5th.

    In NJ we trust.
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Let's not be doom and gloom about losing players before we even know what's going to happen.

    We lost our two best players from last season and have jumped up the table from 16th to 2nd-5th.

    In NJ we trust.
    It's not doom and gloom, it's just a promotion is always very welcome to avoid the risk of losing your better players or at least getting good fees for them. 

    TC would be worth close to 10 million if he has this season in the championship. Unlikely to command that fee in league 1
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 11,164
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
    To an extent I agree but I have a feeling we’re less of a selling club than we’ve been conditioned to be in recent times. I certainly don’t think we would sell even 50% of the names mentioned in one window, I just don’t think Jones would take it 
  • Sponsored links:



  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,863
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
    99.9% of all football clubs are selling clubs, that's how football operates unless you're Real Madrid.

    We're also a buying club, hence the likes of Ramsay, Jones, Mannion joining us from smaller clubs as they see us as a step upwards (and bigger payers).
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,635
    Had a quick look again at the play off timings & thinking that if we get 3rd then travelling to 6th place team shouldn't be too bad, seeing as its either going to be Orient or Reading. A 12.30 kick off at either is a lot better than going to Stockport or Bolton /Blackpool (if they had made the play offs). 

    Any other permutations might be better known after Saturday, but even then I think 2nd to 5th wont be sorted out until the final day.

    But if we play Wycombe I'm going for tickets in the home end 😉.
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 36,024
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
    To be fair unless you're Real Madrid or Barcelona that is pretty much every club. Even Man Utd lost Ronaldo. Liverpool are league champions and are likely to lose Trent. Forest are having their best season in a generation, in a cup semi final and could get into the CL and there's talk of Gibbs-White going to Man City.

    It's always disappointing to lose your best players but it's not something that bothers me too much, because it's hypocritical. As an example, will i be sorry if Ramsay goes? Yes obviously. Was i sorry for Harrogate when they lost him to us? Absolutely not.
  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 13,924
    Cant believe people are talking about how pointless golfaddick said:
    Had a quick look again at the play off timings & thinking that if we get 3rd then travelling to 6th place team shouldn't be too bad, seeing as its either going to be Orient or Reading. A 12.30 kick off at either is a lot better than going to Stockport or Bolton /Blackpool (if they had made the play offs). 

    Any other permutations might be better known after Saturday, but even then I think 2nd to 5th wont be sorted out until the final day.

    But if we play Wycombe I'm going for tickets in the home end 😉.
    Reading would be a better allocation too, rest of them have tiny grounds. 
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,781
    Reading give me anxiety. I don’t want to deal with being sucked into their against the odds story / fairytale. And they actually have a bizarrely strong home record too.
  • CAFC_boi
    CAFC_boi Posts: 271
    Reading’s first 11 is as good as any in League One - they just have zero squad depth, as shown by the fact that Billy Bodin is their main attacker on the bench. As long as their starting 11 stay fit then they’ve got a chance. 
  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,231
    edited April 23
    Reading give me anxiety. I don’t want to deal with being sucked into their against the odds story / fairytale. And they actually have a bizarrely strong home record too.

    Reading would be the under the radar side if they are in the Play offs with their off field woes and it them or Orient for the 6th place with the rubbish end of the season of Bolton and Huddersfield.
  • Dunno... I'm still cautious of facing Wycombe.

    Despite sounding like a bit of a twat post-match; Dodds wasn't wrong when he said that they conceded four soft goals against us (I think the only one I'd be really "happy" with conceding was Berry's), and they've got to put it down as a blip because they've been so defensively strong since he's joined the club.

    Its going forward where they suddenly don't look a threat and wouldnt worry me as much.

    Wycombe or Stockport I fear are two Play-Off opponents that could easily get decided on a penalty shootout.
    Agreed it was similar to our Peterborough loss, we went down early and then started chasing the match leaving ourselves open for soft goals
  • Braziliance
    Braziliance Posts: 8,359
    edited April 23
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
    99.9% of all football clubs are selling clubs, that's how football operates unless you're Real Madrid.

    We're also a buying club, hence the likes of Ramsay, Jones, Mannion joining us from smaller clubs as they see us as a step upwards (and bigger payers).
    fenaddick said:
    There is never a bad time to be promoted. 

    If we don't go up, we are going to get absolutely raided. Very difficult to build a team in league1. 

    You think the likes of Ramsay, Small, Campbell, Coventry, Jones etc fancy another season of this when they've all proven they can probably make the step up? 

    Let's just win these 2 and see where we are at 
    Doesn’t hugely matter what Ramsay, Campbell, Coventry, Jones fancy as they’re under contract and it’s not their choice. TC had bids turned down for him in January and Jones chose to stay too
    We are a selling club, always have been, always will be. 

    Doesn't matter if a player is on a 10 year deal. If a bigger club comes in for our players, we will struggle to keep them.

    Promotion is very important if we want to avoid a mini rebuild.
    To be fair unless you're Real Madrid or Barcelona that is pretty much every club. Even Man Utd lost Ronaldo. Liverpool are league champions and are likely to lose Trent. Forest are having their best season in a generation, in a cup semi final and could get into the CL and there's talk of Gibbs-White going to Man City.

    It's always disappointing to lose your best players but it's not something that bothers me too much, because it's hypocritical. As an example, will i be sorry if Ramsay goes? Yes obviously. Was i sorry for Harrogate when they lost him to us? Absolutely not.
    Gents comparing us to La Liga giants is a bit extreme, and going a bit off topic. 

    I've got to say of all the players mentioned, we didn't buy any of them? No fees apart from Ramsay, which would have been a very small fee. 

    The point was, there is never a bad time to get promoted, as all it does is increase your clubs value, your revenue, your players value, your clubs interest and the list goes on. 

    It's extremely difficult to build a long term promotion side in league 1 as the championship vultures start circling, as we are already seeing with our better players. 

    Our history shows that we are very much a selling club, and cannot be compared to the likes of Liverpool, Man United etc as they're such extreme examples and on a different level revenue wise.

    Back to the original point, there is never a bad time to get promoted, we need promotion.
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 36,024
    CAFC_boi said:
    Reading’s first 11 is as good as any in League One - they just have zero squad depth, as shown by the fact that Billy Bodin is their main attacker on the bench. As long as their starting 11 stay fit then they’ve got a chance. 
    Could say the same for us though with Hylton on our bench. if Godden gets injured we're going to struggle.