Savings and Investments thread

1…438439441443444…449

Comments

  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,869
    I do think a valid comparison to observe on mortgage sums is the multiple you can / could ever borrow. 

    From recollection it used to be something like a maximum of 2.5 x joint income (maybe 3 x sole?) 

    Now of course you can borrow more and for longer to make it affordable and reflect property values. 

    So whilst we can produce statistics to show the percentage of spend housing utilises its not the whole story. 

    On balance though it’s always a struggle for any generation to get on the housing ladder and tough choices on where/ how to spend your income. 
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    I do think a valid comparison to observe on mortgage sums is the multiple you can / could ever borrow. 

    From recollection it used to be something like a maximum of 2.5 x joint income (maybe 3 x sole?) 

    Now of course you can borrow more and for longer to make it affordable and reflect property values. 

    So whilst we can produce statistics to show the percentage of spend housing utilises its not the whole story. 

    On balance though it’s always a struggle for any generation to get on the housing ladder and tough choices on where/ how to spend your income. 
    Completely agree. A large part of the differential on multipliers for mortgages comes down to interest rates. When it was the 2.5 or 3x interest rates were high single/low double digit. With a big enough deposit 6x now is not unheard of.

    Each generation has had different difficulties, but I don’t recall a time it was ever easy. I find people are quick to look at someone age 50’s/60’s outcomes but aren’t interested in the choices or journey to get there.

    No one generally cares for 4-5 years I worked 3 jobs sometimes up to 100 hours a week whilst living in the cheapest bedsit in East London (when east London was a sh1t hole). Or Bob and his wife were ships that passed in the night tag teaming whilst looking after children with zero luxuries, no holidays and likely like me no car. Or my parents generation who would get married, rent a room for 5 years whilst they tried to save the deposit and beg the building society for a mortgage (my dad likened it to doing the knowledge) and when finally doing so had to move 30 miles out to something they could afford.
    Grand parents who bathed once a week in a tin bath in the garden!

    Tough times are nothing new, different yes, and maybe today is harder than some other times, but anyone who thinks the 60-90’s were easy needs to give their head a wobble (I’d say probably mid to late 90’s were likely one of the easier). 
  • LargeAddick
    LargeAddick Posts: 34,824
    Rob7Lee said:
    I do think a valid comparison to observe on mortgage sums is the multiple you can / could ever borrow. 

    From recollection it used to be something like a maximum of 2.5 x joint income (maybe 3 x sole?) 

    Now of course you can borrow more and for longer to make it affordable and reflect property values. 

    So whilst we can produce statistics to show the percentage of spend housing utilises its not the whole story. 

    On balance though it’s always a struggle for any generation to get on the housing ladder and tough choices on where/ how to spend your income. 
    Completely agree. A large part of the differential on multipliers for mortgages comes down to interest rates. When it was the 2.5 or 3x interest rates were high single/low double digit. With a big enough deposit 6x now is not unheard of.

    Each generation has had different difficulties, but I don’t recall a time it was ever easy. I find people are quick to look at someone age 50’s/60’s outcomes but aren’t interested in the choices or journey to get there.

    No one generally cares for 4-5 years I worked 3 jobs sometimes up to 100 hours a week whilst living in the cheapest bedsit in East London (when east London was a sh1t hole). Or Bob and his wife were ships that passed in the night tag teaming whilst looking after children with zero luxuries, no holidays and likely like me no car. Or my parents generation who would get married, rent a room for 5 years whilst they tried to save the deposit and beg the building society for a mortgage (my dad likened it to doing the knowledge) and when finally doing so had to move 30 miles out to something they could afford.
    Grand parents who bathed once a week in a tin bath in the garden!

    Tough times are nothing new, different yes, and maybe today is harder than some other times, but anyone who thinks the 60-90’s were easy needs to give their head a wobble (I’d say probably mid to late 90’s were likely one of the easier). 
    Quite right. They had this discussion on Radio 2 yesterday. In the past people went through rationing, then we suffered through power cuts, then interest rates in double digits etc etc. It's never been easy for most. The current generation think they are the most hard done. Boo boo.
  • Carter
    Carter Posts: 14,848
    I don't like comparing hardships, generational ones are especially spiky. All I can go on is my lived experience and what I see first hand people I know doing. 

    What I will say is the temptations and bitty purchases now seem to be viewed as necessary expense when I struggle to make an argument to defend that. There is always a choice. The daily/bi-daily spends on lunch, coffee, takeaway is a lot more convenient now. When I began working the option for breakfast, drinks or lunch on the job were the stuff of gastrointestinal hellscapes. Burger van, petrol station or god forbid the site cafe staffed by an old gypsy woman smoking as she cooked, handled money, cleaned (pppppffffttttt) and cooked exclusively with vegetable oil and lots of it. So bringing a pack up was not only cost effective it was the only way of steering clear of dysentary or just ingesting faecal matter during your lunch break 

    Buying property is hard, it was hard 20 years ago and I heard all the tales of sacrifice and how I had it easy, that interest rates were criminally low, that my generation had credit cards etc. Ironically I'd have a lot of these conversations at work as I spent so much fucking time there trying to earn more to buy the cheapest kitchen I could from homebase to for myself iver about 2 months as I was living in a building site and never had enough time to do this stuff as a novice as I was working all the time.

    Getting ahead in life financially is the ultimate struggle for the ultimate goal. Financial freedom, not just security, freedom to tell arsehole bosses to get knotted, to pursue painful purpose before you are too old to do anything other than watch daytime TV, moan about whatever the media feeds you, paint the occasional watercolour, you get the picture. 

    Its a struggle and the I don't think its entirely unhealthy, I'm nothing if not resilient and stoic and the same can be said for a huge number of people dragging themselves out of bed each day, slogging to and from a job that eats their time and youth but keeps them in heated shelter and fed. 

    Flask of shit instant coffee or tea, pack up, owning a older car, taking on extra work/side hustling, taking a look at the subscriptions nibbling away at your take home. The one I'd be wary of is compromising too much on holidays, we all need a break but even that now with social media can easily be done in a very affordable way by pet-sitting for people at home or abroad in different locations, house-swaps for example 


  • RaplhMilne
    RaplhMilne Posts: 4,815
    Just like to say people, thoroughly enjoying this discussion thanks to the contributors. I am savvy enough to understand what is being said. However, not clued up enough to initiate my own thoughts other than those already shared. I doubt many football forums have such a lively educational debate, on this subject matter. 

    Would just throw in my own bit of life experience. In the late 70,s 1977 onwards I worked for the Woolwich Building society in General Gordon Square. Each branch had a weekly mortgage allocation, for the branch manager to dispense as he saw fit. So for example Dartford had £220,000. Which in those days would likely fund 10-15 loans. If Dartford after its allocation had say £3,000 surplus, this was returned to a Central fund. By the way, the surplus was not that they didn’t have customers waiting to borrow, just that the small £3,000 sum couldn’t fill a customer need. People were waiting weeks for their mortgage money to be available, and completion dates were virtually always set, on when your lender could give you the funds. 

    Part of my job on a Monday was to add up all the small returns from every branch of the Woolwich, which could run into a couple hundred thousand. Then on a Tuesday, branch managers would ring me an basically beg for an additional allocation from the returned pot. To help a customer who was, going to lose their property or desperately needed early completion. I was a god like figure, distributing these funds like they were my own. I’m sure none of them knew they were talking to a junior boy in the office who was 20 years old.

    Basically, I just did first come ,first served as my appropriation model. But, knowing I could say NO… made me all powerful.






  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 24,980
    My first purchase was a one bedroom flat in Croydon,  to say it was a culture shock coming from Chelsfield is an understatement. 
    But it was all I could afford. 
    When I did manage to buy a house in Chelsfield I was working at Cray Vall paper mills.
    For the next 4 years I worked every bit of overtime I was offered. 
    When I had my holidays instead of going holiday I spent my time labouring for various builder mates I had.
    Things got a bit easier when I got married as we then had two wages coming in every month. 
    But as soon as our two kids we're born my wife gave up work for 5 years. 
    By then I was working in the Fire brigade. 
    I can promise you that a fireman's wage cannot support 4 people plus pay a mortgage and all that goes with it.
    I made plenty of sacrifices by giving up golf etc and instead went back to working with my builder mates at every opportunity. 
    In total we went about 10 years without a foreign holiday and used to have a week on the coast somewhere. 
    I know exactly how hard it is for today's generation to get on the property ladder as I have two grown up children of my own.
    But people of my generation had to make plenty of sacrifices ourselves and I can assure you it wasn't as easy as some are suggesting. 
  • Jints
    Jints Posts: 3,706
    bobmunro said:
    Carter said:
    That has always genuinely blown my mind how the state pension and benefits rise regardless yet a few years ago me and my colleagues had to strike to eventually get 3% which cost us more in lost pay for the strike days than we gained that year


    Simply because (in the case of pensioners) they are a group which have no choice / means to otherwise protect their income  / affordability. They have a finite income which they can no longer influence. 

    Moreover though it stems from a time when our state pension was ridiculously small and annual rises were minimal sums leading to real ‘pensioner poverty’. It’s about righting that wrong. 

    The answer I feel is to stick with the triple / double lock until pensions reach what is considered a fair / the right amount and then limit increases to inflation only. Certainly it needs to persist until the tax free allowances are recalibrated. 
    If we stick to the triple lock it will bankrupt the country. Thems the breaks after GFC and Covid, unfortunately. Which is why making sure you’re on top of your private pension as young as possible is the best possible thing you can do for yourself.

    The current benefits system will bankrupt the country, not the State Pension*

    The number of people falsely claiming Personal Independence Payments and Carer's Allowance has reached a ridiculous level and has to be changed so that only those in genuine need get the assistance. Also people being paid not to work when they are perfectly capable of working is total bollocks. Those who know me know I'm left of centre and I'm a firm believer in a welfare state - but it is now taking the piss.

    *State Pension is NOT A BENEFIT. It is based on the number of years an individual has made contributions and as such is just like any other pension - State or private. The level it is at is a joke compared to the contributions made during a working life and as @valleynick66 says the triple/double lock can be looked at when the State Pension reaches an appropriate level.
    It can easily be shown that this is wildly inaccurate.  You can buy 10 years of NI contributions for about £9,000. This will get you an additional pension of £3,000 a year triple locked. If you were to get an inflation protected annuity, £9K would get you maybe £500 a year

    To buy a £12k a year annuity you would need to spend £200k
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    This is exactly the conversation I was trying to avoid. As I said before all I was saying was that to take interest rates over time alone as the key metric misses the affordability part. You have to look at the whole picture.

    I think part of the picture is relative difference in the price of "luxury's" to essentials. For example a TV was a year worth of saving now they are much more accessible and multiple could be bought with a single months savings. Whereas essentials like groceries, travel etc now make up a larger proportion of peoples monthly outgoings than ever before. So you can have the appearance of having luxuries - particularly to those who lived through the period when these things were much more inaccessible and expensive - whilst also having massive pressure on your income. 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    Right......

    I used to live in a shoebox in middle of the road. work 28 hours a day, 6 days a week for tuppence h'penny a week....  




  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 23
    Carter said:
    I don't like comparing hardships, generational ones are especially spiky. All I can go on is my lived experience and what I see first hand people I know doing. 

    What I will say is the temptations and bitty purchases now seem to be viewed as necessary expense when I struggle to make an argument to defend that. There is always a choice. The daily/bi-daily spends on lunch, coffee, takeaway is a lot more convenient now. When I began working the option for breakfast, drinks or lunch on the job were the stuff of gastrointestinal hellscapes. Burger van, petrol station or god forbid the site cafe staffed by an old gypsy woman smoking as she cooked, handled money, cleaned (pppppffffttttt) and cooked exclusively with vegetable oil and lots of it. So bringing a pack up was not only cost effective it was the only way of steering clear of dysentary or just ingesting faecal matter during your lunch break 

    Buying property is hard, it was hard 20 years ago and I heard all the tales of sacrifice and how I had it easy, that interest rates were criminally low, that my generation had credit cards etc. Ironically I'd have a lot of these conversations at work as I spent so much fucking time there trying to earn more to buy the cheapest kitchen I could from homebase to for myself iver about 2 months as I was living in a building site and never had enough time to do this stuff as a novice as I was working all the time.

    Getting ahead in life financially is the ultimate struggle for the ultimate goal. Financial freedom, not just security, freedom to tell arsehole bosses to get knotted, to pursue painful purpose before you are too old to do anything other than watch daytime TV, moan about whatever the media feeds you, paint the occasional watercolour, you get the picture. 

    Its a struggle and the I don't think its entirely unhealthy, I'm nothing if not resilient and stoic and the same can be said for a huge number of people dragging themselves out of bed each day, slogging to and from a job that eats their time and youth but keeps them in heated shelter and fed. 

    Flask of shit instant coffee or tea, pack up, owning a older car, taking on extra work/side hustling, taking a look at the subscriptions nibbling away at your take home. The one I'd be wary of is compromising too much on holidays, we all need a break but even that now with social media can easily be done in a very affordable way by pet-sitting for people at home or abroad in different locations, house-swaps for example 


    I have a similar story over the last few years. I've worked weekends and summers since school and all through uni - paid for myself to not need to take as much mainenance loan. Worked my ass off to get on a top grad scheme, worked my ass off there to get promotions etc. Both my wife and I have been in the top 5% of earners for our age from age 24 till now (32). I've laboured on building sites at the weekends as well as doing my own house up DIY. Never bought coffee (dont drink the stuff) always taken my own lunch etc. no Avo toast. Have never bought a car (we still have the one my wife spent £1500 and her parents spent £1500 on when she was 19 - we will run it till it dies). Have never bought a TV we have my in laws old one that is 15 years old but works fine. All our tech is second hand refurbs. Have had a bunch of side hustles - still have a few digital ones that give us about £800 each passive each year. I have refinished and sold second hand furniture. The only areas our spending has increased compared to when we first started renting when we started our grad schemes is our mortgage and costs of doing our house up, and travel/hobbies/life experiences which are so valuable. 

    What I want to say is despite all that there is absolutely no way we would have been able to do this without family help. Whether that was the 6 months living rent free with the in laws during covid which boosted our deposit. Some inheritance from my grandparents and gifts from both parents. There was no ammount of cutting back that could have been enough to get us on the ladder without that family help. Even as high earners if we had to stay renting that whole time our deposit just wouldnt have got us anything commutable to our work. And thats where I feel the issue comes in. Those without the good family support systems just get stuck. I see it with friends - my wifes uni group for example - Cambridge educated chartered civil engineers - those with family support are doing fine. Those without are stuck renting one bed flats with their partners. I've seen the word inheritocracy banded about - I think its a good way of explaining it once you ake it clear its not actually about the inheritance when they die but the support they are able to give you when they are alive that alters the trajectory of your life.

  • Sponsored links:



  • clb74
    clb74 Posts: 10,877
    edited October 23
    I think some of us seem to forget the older generations have kids and grandkids.
    These older generations after doing their 40 years hard graft , some are now helping the kids/grandkids financially.
    Not just a few quid sometimes tens of thousands of their hard earned cash to help the kids get on the housing ladder.
    The older generation after doing their hard graft , looking after the grandkids a couple of days a week so their kids don't have to pay childcare.
    Got me thinking this thread last night.
    Family member 70 years old.
    Sold their house to give the 2 kids a step onto the housing ladder.
    Both given tens of thousands each.
    This couple also have the grandkids a couple of days a week.
    They at 70 well 65 at the time , moved into a pokey 1 bed retirement home so their two kids could get onto the housing ladder.
    Ive mentioned before in 1998 being able to buy a 2 bed flat while working at sainsburys on £12k a year.
    Yes getting on the property ladder was easier, but I still didnt have a pot to piss in even working 6 days a week.
    So I shouldn't think theirs many of the older generations gloating at how hard it is for the younger generation.
    I should think most hope it will be easier for the next generation.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    clb74 said:
    I think some of us seem to forget the older generations have kids and grandkids.
    These older generations after doing their 40 years hard graft , some are now helping the kids/grandkids financially.
    Not just a few quid sometimes tens of thousands of their hard earned cash to help the kids get on the housing ladder.
    The older generation after doing their hard graft , looking after the grandkids a couple of days a week so their kids don't have to pay childcare.
    Got me thinking this thread last night.
    Family member 70 years old.
    Sold their house to give the 2 kids a step onto the housing ladder.
    Both given tens of thousands each.
    This couple also have the grandkids a couple of days a week.
    They at 70 well 65 at the time , moved into a pokey 1 bed retirement home so their two kids could get onto the housing ladder.
    Ive mentioned before in 1998 being able to buy a 2 bed flat while working at sainsburys on £12k a year.
    Yes getting on the property ladder was easier, but I still didnt have a pot to piss in even working 6 days a week.
    So I shouldn't think theirs many of the older generations gloating at how hard it is for the younger generation.
    I should think most hope it will be easier for the next generation.
    Nail on the head - this is exactly the point. It shouldnt need to be like this, but it is the only way to see your kids get ahead. 
  • LargeAddick
    LargeAddick Posts: 34,824
    edited October 23
    What I don’t get is youngsters these days saying I can’t get on the housing ladder, blah blah but they’d happily upgrade their phone and be paying £60pm on a contract and then upgrade when the new model comes out or make sure their first car is a brand new one at £300 a month or have three takeaways a week etc etc. Not saying this applies to everyone but I’m sure most could be a bit more frugal elsewhere, make cut backs and then put more aside for a deposit. Back in the day I was working in a bank but still delivered Indian takeaways three nights a week for extra cash. It’s about making sacrifices.
  • RaplhMilne
    RaplhMilne Posts: 4,815
    Right......

    I used to live in a shoebox in middle of the road. work 28 hours a day, 6 days a week for tuppence h'penny a week....  


    LUXURY,  we lived in old paper bag in gutter….worked 32 hours a day 7 days a week in Mill and paid Mill owner a penny for the privilege. 


  • Carter
    Carter Posts: 14,848
    Carter said:
    I don't like comparing hardships, generational ones are especially spiky. All I can go on is my lived experience and what I see first hand people I know doing. 

    What I will say is the temptations and bitty purchases now seem to be viewed as necessary expense when I struggle to make an argument to defend that. There is always a choice. The daily/bi-daily spends on lunch, coffee, takeaway is a lot more convenient now. When I began working the option for breakfast, drinks or lunch on the job were the stuff of gastrointestinal hellscapes. Burger van, petrol station or god forbid the site cafe staffed by an old gypsy woman smoking as she cooked, handled money, cleaned (pppppffffttttt) and cooked exclusively with vegetable oil and lots of it. So bringing a pack up was not only cost effective it was the only way of steering clear of dysentary or just ingesting faecal matter during your lunch break 

    Buying property is hard, it was hard 20 years ago and I heard all the tales of sacrifice and how I had it easy, that interest rates were criminally low, that my generation had credit cards etc. Ironically I'd have a lot of these conversations at work as I spent so much fucking time there trying to earn more to buy the cheapest kitchen I could from homebase to for myself iver about 2 months as I was living in a building site and never had enough time to do this stuff as a novice as I was working all the time.

    Getting ahead in life financially is the ultimate struggle for the ultimate goal. Financial freedom, not just security, freedom to tell arsehole bosses to get knotted, to pursue painful purpose before you are too old to do anything other than watch daytime TV, moan about whatever the media feeds you, paint the occasional watercolour, you get the picture. 

    Its a struggle and the I don't think its entirely unhealthy, I'm nothing if not resilient and stoic and the same can be said for a huge number of people dragging themselves out of bed each day, slogging to and from a job that eats their time and youth but keeps them in heated shelter and fed. 

    Flask of shit instant coffee or tea, pack up, owning a older car, taking on extra work/side hustling, taking a look at the subscriptions nibbling away at your take home. The one I'd be wary of is compromising too much on holidays, we all need a break but even that now with social media can easily be done in a very affordable way by pet-sitting for people at home or abroad in different locations, house-swaps for example 


    I have a similar story over the last few years. I've worked weekends and summers since school and all through uni - paid for myself to not need to take as much mainenance loan. Worked my ass off to get on a top grad scheme, worked my ass off there to get promotions etc. Both my wife and I have been in the top 5% of earners for our age from age 24 till now (32). I've laboured on building sites at the weekends as well as doing my own house up DIY. Never bought coffee (dont drink the stuff) always taken my own lunch etc. no Avo toast. Have never bought a car (we still have the one my wife spent £1500 and her parents spent £1500 on when she was 19 - we will run it till it dies). Have never bought a TV we have my in laws old one that is 15 years old but works fine. All our tech is second hand refurbs. Have had a bunch of side hustles - still have a few digital ones that give us about £800 each passive each year. I have refinished and sold second hand furniture. The only areas our spending has increased compared to when we first started renting when we started our grad schemes is our mortgage and costs of doing our house up, and travel/hobbies/life experiences which are so valuable. 

    What I want to say is despite all that there is absolutely no way we would have been able to do this without family help. Whether that was the 6 months living rent free with the in laws during covid which boosted our deposit. Some inheritance from my grandparents and gifts from both parents. There was no ammount of cutting back that could have been enough to get us on the ladder without that family help. Even as high earners if we had to stay renting that whole time our deposit just wouldnt have got us anything commutable to our work. And thats where I feel the issue comes in. Those without the good family support systems just get stuck. I see it with friends - my wifes uni group for example - Cambridge educated chartered civil engineers - those with family support are doing fine. Those without are stuck renting one bed flats with their partners. I've seen the word inheritocracy banded about - I think its a good way of explaining it once you ake it clear its not actually about the inheritance when they die but the support they are able to give you when they are alive that alters the trajectory of your life.
    Unfortunately maybe for the discussion I see that as one of those things. I know people who have had a few quid from parents, I know a few people who might as well had their parents buy the place for them, bail them out. That is life, all situations and people are different. I agree things are a lot easier with help from family if that help is available however. Moving away from where you grew up like me and plenty others have had to do is a mitigating factor in making house purchasing more realistic even if it means eating a longer commute if you work up town 


  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    What I don’t get is youngsters these days saying I can’t get on the housing ladder, blah blah but they’d happily upgrade their phone and be paying £60pm on a contract and then upgrade when the new model comes out or make sure their first car is a brand new one at £300 a month or have three takeaways a week etc etc. Not saying this applies to everyone but I’m sure most could be a bit more frugal elsewhere, make cut backs and then put more aside for a deposit. Back in the day I was working in a bank but still delivered Indian takeaways three nights a week for extra cash. It’s about making sacrifices.
    I link it to maturity. I see a lot of our grads & apprentices doing this, fast forward 5 years and they tend to have worked out the wasted money (and time).
    I try to guide them from day 1, about 2/3rds are sensible and tend to have saved their deposits within 4-5 years. Its normally around that time the other 1/3rd realise when they see their peers start to buy.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    What I don’t get is youngsters these days saying I can’t get on the housing ladder, blah blah but they’d happily upgrade their phone and be paying £60pm on a contract and then upgrade when the new model comes out or make sure their first car is a brand new one at £300 a month or have three takeaways a week etc etc. Not saying this applies to everyone but I’m sure most could be a bit more frugal elsewhere, make cut backs and then put more aside for a deposit. Back in the day I was working in a bank but still delivered Indian takeaways three nights a week for extra cash. It’s about making sacrifices.
    Few things on this:

    1) I think the prevelance of this sort of behaviour is much rarer that is popular to make out. I'm at the top end of the age range we are talking about but throughout all the stages of my life from uni groups, sports clubs, grad schemes and now hiring and leading teams of 30+ people in their 20's I have genuinely seen very few people like this. Most people allow themselves luxury in one or two aspects of their live depending on their priorities and then scrimp on the rest.

    2) as I said above the price of these percieved luxuries relative to income has dropped like a stone in the last 20 years whereas the price of essentials (groceries, housing, bills, travel) relative to income has skyrocketed so the perceptions from people who were "young" before that change dont reflect reality

    3) for some people if they have no family help and arent top earners the goal seems so far away that its not really worth making the sacrifices for. E.g. A starbucks coffee is £2.55 cuting out 2 a week would save you £265.20 a year. Thats not gonna make a difference to a deposit. It'll be inflated away in less than that year. Very possible to make all the possible sacrifices for a year only to end up further from the goal than you started. So whats the point might as well go all nihilistic enjoy life. Why worry about a future when its looking increasingly certain we wont have one.
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 5,869
    The Budget

    So I’m wondering if the budget is again going to be a damp squib of tweaks and twiddles after all. 
    The ‘mood music’ currently feels like it won’t be the forward thinking / big ticket change which perhaps a new regime might bring. Have the ‘men in suits’ behind the scenes cautioned against big changes and instead extolling the virtues of stability?

    The ‘accidentally leaked’ news this week appears to be no change to CGT and an uplift in the Banks surcharge / levy despite earlier assurances we wouldn’t get leaks / kite flying. 

    So is the budget going to be a surprise as we likely need or are we back to slow and steady?

    I did wonder if NI was going to be introduced on private pension drawdowns/ withdrawals as part of the move towards a National Care Service (coupled with a correction to the tax thresholds so that state pension isn’t taxed, higher tax relates to a genuine higher income and we get lower income families therefore having a bit of extra money to spend within the economy) but I’m thinking something that bold won’t happen and instead will be lost to the ‘consultation’ on the proposed National Care Service rather than implemented ASAP. 

    Id like to believe a surprise is coming but the ‘leaks’ suggest otherwise. 
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 24,980
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    I am 100% not calling you a liar Canters and I always enjoy your input  
    But how a postman who's wife did not work could afford to buy a house in south London and bring up 3 kids all on a postmans wage  i just cannot believe. 
    I have  several friends who were or in some cases still are postmen and without doing a second job or getting help from elsewhere it would not be possible. 
    I'm going to guess that my wage as a fireman was probably similar to that of a postman and I had to pretty much do 2 full time jobs throughout my career as well as giving up holidays for about 10 years and it was still a struggle to get by. 

  • Sponsored links:



  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    The Budget

    So I’m wondering if the budget is again going to be a damp squib of tweaks and twiddles after all. 
    The ‘mood music’ currently feels like it won’t be the forward thinking / big ticket change which perhaps a new regime might bring. Have the ‘men in suits’ behind the scenes cautioned against big changes and instead extolling the virtues of stability?

    The ‘accidentally leaked’ news this week appears to be no change to CGT and an uplift in the Banks surcharge / levy despite earlier assurances we wouldn’t get leaks / kite flying. 

    So is the budget going to be a surprise as we likely need or are we back to slow and steady?

    I did wonder if NI was going to be introduced on private pension drawdowns/ withdrawals as part of the move towards a National Care Service (coupled with a correction to the tax thresholds so that state pension isn’t taxed, higher tax relates to a genuine higher income and we get lower income families therefore having a bit of extra money to spend within the economy) but I’m thinking something that bold won’t happen and instead will be lost to the ‘consultation’ on the proposed National Care Service rather than implemented ASAP. 

    Id like to believe a surprise is coming but the ‘leaks’ suggest otherwise. 
    I was actually reflecting recently that until about a week ago it did feel like the policy by leak approach did seem to be much less used. In the last week or so there have been a few much much less than in the last 5 or 10 years. 

    On it being more "tweaks and twiddles" I didnt expect anything else. Burnham is backed by the Labour together group who are teh same group that backed Starmer, with the same people funding him as funded Starmer. The same key ministers in key roles. Yes messaging has softened on a lot of issues and communication has massively improved. But there was never going to be any kind of radical or forward thinking big ticket change. Would love to be wrong on this but from the start despite how it was presented it was always going to be more of the status quo with a bit better PR and some tactical concessions.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    I am 100% not calling you a liar Canters and I always enjoy your input  
    But how a postman who's wife did not work could afford to buy a house in south London and bring up 3 kids all on a postmans wage  i just cannot believe. 
    I have  several friends who were or in some cases still are postmen and without doing a second job or getting help from elsewhere it would not be possible. 
    I'm going to guess that my wage as a fireman was probably similar to that of a postman and I had to pretty much do 2 full time jobs throughout my career as well as giving up holidays for about 10 years and it was still a struggle to get by. 
    Thats the story they told me. I accept it probably left out a bit of detail who knows if they had some inheritance or something in there to help. They bought the place in 76 so maybe its a timing thing? not sure if that would make then older than you (I imagine it does). Even if there was a bit of artistic lisence in their story  it still shows the massive rate of change in a generation. 
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 23
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 14,818
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
    Agreed, which is why I pointed out they were both at home (I do charge rent though 😉) and they didn’t need to save that amount (other than to lower costs).

    but they could buy a £250k flat rather than a £450k house, so would have needed say £35k saved between them, call it £18k each which in a 5 year period that’s £3,600 a year/£300 a month (or 25% less ie £240 a month if you put in a LISA). If you invested/obtained interest probably £200 ish a month each would have likely got there. My daughter saves that easily by not buying a Pret lunch or similar 20 days a month but instead takes in a packed lunch.

    of course different situations mean different things and many don’t/can’t live at home with parents (like I didn’t). But 2x people living with parents should be able to save 2-300 a month which will after 5 years easily get them on the property ladder.

    I have graduates who don’t live at home but rent a room and manage to save after 5 years to buy (yes often with a partner but not always, one lad who works for me started at 18, bought a flat in Chislehurst at 24 on his own and now at 30 is buying a house in Battersea with girlfriend)
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    edited October 23
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
  • Diebythesword
    Diebythesword Posts: 1,151
    There’s definitely some “more affordable” areas in south east London (see the Woolwich thread for me waxing lyrical about the place) that aren’t as expensive as the rest of London still with good transport links etc to work (thank god for the lizzie line, infrastructure spending as well as house building is literally the answer to the housing crisis), but it’s still extremely difficult. Rents are usually around the same amount as mortgage payments would be and new build flats (that has the majority of the government incentives for FTB) even in south east London don’t go for under 450k, which unless you’re earning a good middle class income as a couple you won’t be able to afford. That’s before you even consider having to stump up a decent wedge as a deposit.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.

    My last paragraph wasn't suggesting we have achieved equality of opportunity (in fact I was making the point we haven't, i.e. why I don't really agree with private education as it is probably the biggest stifle of equal opportunity for young people).

    People often assume equal opportunity results in equality of outcomes, it doesn't. I'm sure we all know many people who had equal opportunity/upbringing but have seen very different outcomes. I often talk to groups who come from underprivileged backgrounds, that point resonates with them, in that we can flip it to be just because they haven't had the same opportunity (i.e. education opportunity) as someone else doesn't mean they have to have worse outcomes. They may just have to do things differently to get to that place. We need to stop putting people in buckets based on accident of birth and saying that means they can't do well, yes as a society we need to do more but there is also personal responsibility.

    If you honestly both earn north of £100k and even take off gross your student loans (which at that level will be paid back pretty quickly), then no offence but at those salary levels (or even take 85% of) you should really be very well set up financially. You must be clearing towards a 5 figure sum between you a month, top of the DINKY's, so you shouldn't need worry about doing justice to raising children or need help with childcare.