Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

++Charlie Kelman signs on a 4 year deal++

1212224262736

Comments

  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,359
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    How many do you think Kone would have scored for us this season with the chances we’re creating?
  • CAFCsayer said:
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    It's far too early to call still. He needs decent service.
    4 games in (not including cup), I’m not sure it’s to early any more.
    Lol
    What’s funny? It’s professional football in one of the most competitive leagues in the world. You sink or swim. Strikers work off confidence, he’s not scored…
  • carly burn
    carly burn Posts: 19,442
    If he was getting chances and missing them I'd be more concerned.
    Could he do a bit more to engineer chances? Possibiy
  • RonnieMoore
    RonnieMoore Posts: 4,493
    If he had the chances Campbell had last week and today we would have won both games .. he cant score sitting in the bench 
  • CL_Phantom
    CL_Phantom Posts: 5,512
    Needs the right partner and to play, would have him starting alongside Leaburn but doubt Jones will drop Campbell to make way. 

    Alternatively, a formation change to fit both but that's just as unlikely to happen.

  • Rothko
    Rothko Posts: 18,779
    Thought he looked good in the flesh today, don’t see the issue unless your carrying a need not to be proven wrong 
  • I’d try him and Tanto
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,816
    Rothko said:
    Thought he looked good in the flesh today, don’t see the issue unless your carrying a need not to be proven wrong 
    Thought he looked reasonable today and Tuesday. 

    The Kone comparison is a fair one though, whether people like it or not.  I think Kone would work well in our system, as a mobile but physical no 9.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 16,903
    Definitely better today. We played a little differently given we were chasing the game (or going for the win for a fair). QPR left more space in behind than we have got so far this season and a couple of balls through showed more what he was about. Positive signs I think
  • Rothko said:
    Thought he looked good in the flesh today, don’t see the issue unless your carrying a need not to be proven wrong 
    Thought he looked reasonable today and Tuesday. 

    The Kone comparison is a fair one though, whether people like it or not.  I think Kone would work well in our system, as a mobile but physical no 9.
    Agreed. Kones a bastard to play against and runs all game. Kelman is a good player but we just don’t play to his strengths.
  • Sponsored links:



  • Rothko
    Rothko Posts: 18,779
    It’s Kone v Leaburn/Tanto, and didn’t think Kone was that wonderful today, despite the goal 
  • Exiled_Addick
    Exiled_Addick Posts: 17,167
    Kone did fuck all today until Jones went up front for the last 5 minutes. Apart from try to break Jones’ nose. 
  • stoneroses19
    stoneroses19 Posts: 7,204
    After Wycombe games last season and today, I don't understand why so many people still think he's great and would want him in our side. If Jones is in his usual position at end today, then Kone doesn't score. 
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,359
    After Wycombe games last season and today, I don't understand why so many people still think he's great and would want him in our side. If Jones is in his usual position at end today, then Kone doesn't score. 
    The same people would probably have wanted Kelman had we signed Kone.
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,816
    After Wycombe games last season and today, I don't understand why so many people still think he's great and would want him in our side. If Jones is in his usual position at end today, then Kone doesn't score. 
    I don't recall Kelman doing much against us last season either, if that's the criteria.
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,286
    After Wycombe games last season and today, I don't understand why so many people still think he's great and would want him in our side. If Jones is in his usual position at end today, then Kone doesn't score. 
    I don't recall Kelman doing much against us last season either, if that's the criteria.
    Is that not a good thing? ;)
  • Danny Addick
    Danny Addick Posts: 3,930
    If he had the chances Campbell had last week and today we would have won both games .. he cant score sitting in the bench 
    Totally agree 
  • msomerton
    msomerton Posts: 2,968
    He is to static, makes very few runs off the ball, does not bust a gut to keep up with game or to get into the area.
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,816
    Kone did fuck all today until Jones went up front for the last 5 minutes. Apart from try to break Jones’ nose. 
    https://www.skysports.com/football/video/26947/13421333/queens-park-rangers-3-1-charlton-athletic-championship-highlights

    Watching the highlights, he should have had an assist right at the start, when Dembele missed a sitter. And then his dummy let the ball run to Smyth for their 1st goal. 
  • I thought Kone was a big physical but very limited lump today.  Wouldn't have scored if we weren't pilling forwards.  His pass to Dembele at the start was very simple, the skill in the move was before that. His dummy was ok but Apter's defending very very poor.

    Kelman looks a very tidy player with a much better touch. Sadly we have bought him then not played to any of his strengths.  I still hope he comes good. It's way too early to judge.

    What I don't understand is the point of Chappel so far.  Apparently he has a massive knowledge of footballers but everyone we have bought in looks like a Jones purchase to me so far.
  • Sponsored links:



  • DamoNorthStand
    DamoNorthStand Posts: 10,933
    I would like us to make better use of the European and foreign markets. Lots of clubs in our leagues have picked out some gems from the Dutch league (remember JBG), Portugal, Germany, Belgium and France. You can often get much better value if we can scout effectively.
  • I would like us to make better use of the European and foreign markets. Lots of clubs in our leagues have picked out some gems from the Dutch league (remember JBG), Portugal, Germany, Belgium and France. You can often get much better value if we can scout effectively.
    Found Tommy driesen’s alt. 
  • stop_shouting
    stop_shouting Posts: 3,678
    Dunno what game people were watching if they didn’t think kone made an impact today.
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 616
    Kone was alright today but had to drop so deep because any 1 on 1 with Jones he practically lost. The problem was not that Kone was brilliant it was that Kelman played for 30 mins and besides the trip in the corner from Mbengue you wouldn’t have known he was on the pitch 
  • MarcusH26
    MarcusH26 Posts: 8,016
    I would like us to make better use of the European and foreign markets. Lots of clubs in our leagues have picked out some gems from the Dutch league (remember JBG), Portugal, Germany, Belgium and France. You can often get much better value if we can scout effectively.
    Think this will come next summer if we stay up. Maybe January if the right player was available.

  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,272
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    To be fair, if a QPR defender had jumped over a simple clearance and left Kelman completely through on goal I'm pretty confident he would have finished it. Other than that the only real contribution I can remember from Kone today was him leaving a nasty one on Jones that the ref didn't handle
    Very nice dummy for the first goal. He lost every header against Jones, but that isn’t really a fair judgement on how well he played because Jones is an absolute beast in the air. I thought he was a handful, held it up a few times when it was played to his feet and linked play well. When they went to a front 2 we couldn’t deal with them and that’s why they won the game 

    Kone has 2 goals in 156 minutes of championship football. Kelman has 0 in many more minutes. 

    Don’t want to slag Kelman off too much as I still think he will come good for us, but think it’s mental some of our fans think he’s a better signing than Kone. Kone is already a better all-round player, and has so much more potential 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 10,945
    NabySarr said:
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    To be fair, if a QPR defender had jumped over a simple clearance and left Kelman completely through on goal I'm pretty confident he would have finished it. Other than that the only real contribution I can remember from Kone today was him leaving a nasty one on Jones that the ref didn't handle
    Very nice dummy for the first goal. He lost every header against Jones, but that isn’t really a fair judgement on how well he played because Jones is an absolute beast in the air. I thought he was a handful, held it up a few times when it was played to his feet and linked play well. When they went to a front 2 we couldn’t deal with them and that’s why they won the game 

    Kone has 2 goals in 156 minutes of championship football. Kelman has 0 in many more minutes. 

    Don’t want to slag Kelman off too much as I still think he will come good for us, but think it’s mental some of our fans think he’s a better signing than Kone. Kone is already a better all-round player, and has so much more potential 
    Kelman has played 12 more Championship minutes and his only starts have been against well established Championship teams, he just needs more time
  • Off_it
    Off_it Posts: 28,821
    fenaddick said:
    NabySarr said:
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    To be fair, if a QPR defender had jumped over a simple clearance and left Kelman completely through on goal I'm pretty confident he would have finished it. Other than that the only real contribution I can remember from Kone today was him leaving a nasty one on Jones that the ref didn't handle
    Very nice dummy for the first goal. He lost every header against Jones, but that isn’t really a fair judgement on how well he played because Jones is an absolute beast in the air. I thought he was a handful, held it up a few times when it was played to his feet and linked play well. When they went to a front 2 we couldn’t deal with them and that’s why they won the game 

    Kone has 2 goals in 156 minutes of championship football. Kelman has 0 in many more minutes. 

    Don’t want to slag Kelman off too much as I still think he will come good for us, but think it’s mental some of our fans think he’s a better signing than Kone. Kone is already a better all-round player, and has so much more potential 
    Kelman has played 12 more Championship minutes and his only starts have been against well established Championship teams, he just needs more time
    Sounds like he could do with starting a game against us ....
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,272
    edited August 30
    fenaddick said:
    NabySarr said:
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    To be fair, if a QPR defender had jumped over a simple clearance and left Kelman completely through on goal I'm pretty confident he would have finished it. Other than that the only real contribution I can remember from Kone today was him leaving a nasty one on Jones that the ref didn't handle
    Very nice dummy for the first goal. He lost every header against Jones, but that isn’t really a fair judgement on how well he played because Jones is an absolute beast in the air. I thought he was a handful, held it up a few times when it was played to his feet and linked play well. When they went to a front 2 we couldn’t deal with them and that’s why they won the game 

    Kone has 2 goals in 156 minutes of championship football. Kelman has 0 in many more minutes. 

    Don’t want to slag Kelman off too much as I still think he will come good for us, but think it’s mental some of our fans think he’s a better signing than Kone. Kone is already a better all-round player, and has so much more potential 
    Kelman has played 12 more Championship minutes and his only starts have been against well established Championship teams, he just needs more time
    Kelman has played 560 minutes of championship football in his career. 

    I’m not slagging Kelman off too much, though he has been poor so far, I still think it could turn out to be a very good signing. Just think it’s crazy people thought he was a better signing than Kone 
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,286
    NabySarr said:
    fenaddick said:
    NabySarr said:
    NabySarr said:
    Anyone still going to argue he’s a better signing than Kone? 

    Couple of bright moments today with runs in behind. Definitely better playing him with Leaburn. Really needs a chance to fall to him so he can get off the mark 
    To be fair, if a QPR defender had jumped over a simple clearance and left Kelman completely through on goal I'm pretty confident he would have finished it. Other than that the only real contribution I can remember from Kone today was him leaving a nasty one on Jones that the ref didn't handle
    Very nice dummy for the first goal. He lost every header against Jones, but that isn’t really a fair judgement on how well he played because Jones is an absolute beast in the air. I thought he was a handful, held it up a few times when it was played to his feet and linked play well. When they went to a front 2 we couldn’t deal with them and that’s why they won the game 

    Kone has 2 goals in 156 minutes of championship football. Kelman has 0 in many more minutes. 

    Don’t want to slag Kelman off too much as I still think he will come good for us, but think it’s mental some of our fans think he’s a better signing than Kone. Kone is already a better all-round player, and has so much more potential 
    Kelman has played 12 more Championship minutes and his only starts have been against well established Championship teams, he just needs more time
    Kelman has played 560 minutes of championship football in his career. 

    I’m not slagging Kelman off too much, though he has been poor so far, I still think it could turn out to be a very good signing. Just think it’s crazy people thought he was a better signing than Kone 
    Majority of those minutes were cameos here and there for QPR, and often utilised as a winger... bit like saying Karlan Grant played a ton of Football for us, before he went off on loan for Crawley Town. His start on the opening day of the season against Watford, was something like his second ever as a Striker at this level.