Offside should also be daylight between attacker and defender. Overlap = onside
The problem is that’s arguably even more subjective than the current rule.
How would you measure that?
With the lines, as before. You now compare the rearmost, not the foremost, point of the striker to the foremost point of the defender
But you’re still going to have the same problem?
If an attackers toe is touching the line or even a hair on his head, it’ll be offside. I think you’d still get the same arguments.
Yea you would get head to ankle with daylight between the 2 players. Then you will get end of defenders toe to attacking players heel, no daylight. Var will be zooming into the players feet to see if they can find some daylight.
Offside should also be daylight between attacker and defender. Overlap = onside
The problem is that’s arguably even more subjective than the current rule.
How would you measure that?
With the lines, as before. You now compare the rearmost, not the foremost, point of the striker to the foremost point of the defender
But you’re still going to have the same problem?
If an attackers toe is touching the line or even a hair on his head, it’ll be offside. I think you’d still get the same arguments.
Of course you will, even if you had a 30cm grey area which allows for the really tight calls - Eventually your going to have a player that will be offside by because they'll be 1cm beyond that limit meaning we'll have another tight call, which "wont be good enough"
VAR isnt perfect, and will make mistakes but thats going to happen if it exists or if it does
What people need to realise is that they're looking for perfection which is an impossibility in this game. So should stop trying to alter the rules every five minutes because what thats doing is creating confusion and more error.
Watched Spain the other night who the pundits raved about but they were so ponderous. Italy are getting the ball forward with far more intent and pace.
Offside should also be daylight between attacker and defender. Overlap = onside
The problem is that’s arguably even more subjective than the current rule.
How would you measure that?
With the lines, as before. You now compare the rearmost, not the foremost, point of the striker to the foremost point of the defender
But you’re still going to have the same problem?
If an attackers toe is touching the line or even a hair on his head, it’ll be offside. I think you’d still get the same arguments.
Yea you would get head to ankle with daylight between the 2 players. Then you will get end of defenders toe to attacking players heel, no daylight. Var will be zooming into the players feet to see if they can find some daylight.
Yeah but the distinction here is between 'kind of offside' and 'totally offside' so people won't mind as much
The FA should get the cheque book out and try and get Conte as England manager. Imagine how he could get our squad playing with the attacking talent that's there
Italy looking really good and a joy to watch. It's so frustrating as this is how we should be attacking games rather than all that sideways, backwards shite
The FA should get the cheque book out and try and get Conte as England manager. Imagine how he could get our squad playing with the attacking talent that's there
Why Conte? - Its Roberto Mancini in charge of the current Italy team
The FA should get the cheque book out and try and get Conte as England manager. Imagine how he could get our squad playing with the attacking talent that's there
Why Conte? - Its Roberto Mancini in charge of the current Italy team
Italy looking really good and a joy to watch. It's so frustrating as this is how we should be attacking games rather than all that sideways, backwards shite
The FA should get the cheque book out and try and get Conte as England manager. Imagine how he could get our squad playing with the attacking talent that's there
Why Conte? - Its Roberto Mancini in charge of the current Italy team
Because he's available?
We thought Capello could do the same, but was shocking when it mattered along with his out dated Sergeant Major style approach.
Comments
VAR isnt perfect, and will make mistakes but thats going to happen if it exists or if it does
What people need to realise is that they're looking for perfection which is an impossibility in this game. So should stop trying to alter the rules every five minutes because what thats doing is creating confusion and more error.
Loads of great passing but with an end product.