Worst Ever First XI In Charlton Colours

LenGlover

As the best is running just now.

Will do mine later.

TN15

I witnessed Mike Small, at Millwall if I remember correctly. He would have to be in any team. Alongside Barry Endean from the early 70's probably.

blackpool72

Ralph Milne 

Leroy Ambrose

Traore

Talal

Amdy Faye, obviously. 

redcarter

Tahar El Khalej

DaveMehmet

Dave Mehmet

Pelling1993

As bad as some of the ex-players were in the premier league days, they were still in the premier league. It'll be a team of championship/ league 1 rejects really

orpingtonRED

Surely Thuram in goal. Cant think of a worse keeper we had?

RedManS

Makienok - The only 7ft footballer to lose every aerial dual. 

Callumcafc

Callumcafc

Anyone name the match from the line up above?

ricky_otto

Thuram
Paul Bacon
Tom Hovi
El Khalej
Rhys Williams
Milne
Lepoint
Faye
Mark Tivey (he only played 1 game, but I played against him a few times as a kid (he lived 3 doors away from me) he couldn’t even beat lumps of dog shit down the playing fields)

Abbott
Small


I’m sure that there are many more that I’ve forgotten (probably for the best).

sunbury-addick

Callumcafc said: Nouble, lol, worst Charlton player I ever saw

Pedro45

Ray Tumbridge
Alan Davies (only played 45 mins for us on loan from Man Utd)
Rhys Williams

orpingtonRED

Callumcafc said:

Anyone name the match from the line up above?

When we lost to Dagenham?

iaitch

Cory Gibbs never seen him put in a good performance, mind you nobody else has either.

Callumcafc

Spot on. Well done.

Chris_from_Sidcup

For me i think premier league players are out, has to be shit we've had from the last few years.

Players like Cedric Evina, Frank Nouble, Pawel Abbott, Mikel Alonso, Thuram, Lepoint and Kaikai would be strong contenders.

A few years before that lot, but a special mention must go to Mark McCammon, he was terrible.

wmcf123

Thuram

Cranie , El Khalej, Williams, Seabourne,

Petrucci, Faye, Mustoe

Nouble, L Clarke, Fleetwood 

Henry Irving

Philips - poor distribution
Solly - knees gone, too short
Sarr - "used to be shite"
Pearce - Sold by Wigan as not good enough for Championship
Page - Sick note
Lapslie  - Headless chicken
Pratley - "Worse player I've seen since Westminster v Eton game in 2005"
Aribo - overrated
Grant - "Crawley is his level"
Taylor "that Wimbledon striker is the worst player I've ever seen"
Bonne - can't head the ball.

Not my choices but comments from CL and one song.

: - )

wmcf123

Henry Irving said:

Philips - poor distribution
Solly - knees gone, too short
Sarr - "used to be shite"
Pearce - Sold by Wigan as not good enough for Championship
Page - Sick note
Lapslie  - Headless chicken
Pratley - "Worse player I've seen since Westminster v Eton game in 2005"
Aribo - overrated
Grant - "Crawley is his level"
Taylor "that Wimbledon striker is the worst player I've ever seen"
Bonne - can't head the ball.

Not my choices but comments from CL and one song.

: - )

Is the Taylor comment genuine ?!

se9addick

orpingtonRED said:

Surely Thuram in goal. Cant think of a worse keeper we had?

Absolutely - it’s nuts that he’s actually had a fairly respectable career, he seemed like an Ali Dia at that away game against Wigan.

Henry Irving

wmcf123 said:

Henry Irving said:

Philips - poor distribution
Solly - knees gone, too short
Sarr - "used to be shite"
Pearce - Sold by Wigan as not good enough for Championship
Page - Sick note
Lapslie  - Headless chicken
Pratley - "Worse player I've seen since Westminster v Eton game in 2005"
Aribo - overrated
Grant - "Crawley is his level"
Taylor "that Wimbledon striker is the worst player I've ever seen"
Bonne - can't head the ball.

Not my choices but comments from CL and one song.

: - )

Is the Taylor comment genuine ?!

 I'm paraphrasing but he got a lot of negative comments when they played us.

wmcf123

Henry Irving said:

wmcf123 said:

Henry Irving said:

Philips - poor distribution
Solly - knees gone, too short
Sarr - "used to be shite"
Pearce - Sold by Wigan as not good enough for Championship
Page - Sick note
Lapslie  - Headless chicken
Pratley - "Worse player I've seen since Westminster v Eton game in 2005"
Aribo - overrated
Grant - "Crawley is his level"
Taylor "that Wimbledon striker is the worst player I've ever seen"
Bonne - can't head the ball.

Not my choices but comments from CL and one song.

: - )

Is the Taylor comment genuine ?!

 I'm paraphrasing but he got a lot of negative comments when they played us.

Ah fair play . Didn’t think anyone on here was that daft! 

hoof_it_up_to_benty

Chris_from_Sidcup said:

For me i think premier league players are out, has to be shit we've had from the last few years.

Players like Cedric Evina, Frank Nouble, Pawel Abbott, Mikel Alonso, Thuram, Lepoint and Kaikai would be strong contenders.

A few years before that lot, but a special mention must go to Mark McCammon, he was terrible.

Thought Evina was okay and Alonso played a single game and looked unfit so difficult to judge.

killerandflash

Obviously not the worst keeper ever, but Tony Caig was pretty poor considering we were in the PL at the time!

bigman backstick

Souleymane Diawara best centre half you have never heard of...............

PaddyP17

GK: Yohann Thuram-Ulien
RB: Martin Cranie
CB: Roger Johnson
CB: Tahar El-Khalej
LB: Djimi Traore
RM: Keith Gillespie
CM: Amdy Faye
CM: Chris Bart-Williams
LM: Jesper Blomqvist
ST: Izale McLeod
ST: Andy Gray

I'd say this is probably bad in terms of expectation vs performance, though maybe not necessarily the worst actual players per position. Still crap though.

Goonerhater

Ralph Milne waddled out with a beer gut only seen on a poor Sunday league team in the lower Woolwich and District League. 

PaddyP17

Oh god, Makienok for Andy Gray in the above team.