Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Worst Ever First XI In Charlton Colours
Comments
-
Bit harsh. Only played one game for us. Let in a penalty, kept a clean sheet for the rest of the game iirc.killerandflash said:Obviously not the worst keeper ever, but Tony Caig was pretty poor considering we were in the PL at the time!0 -
Only thing I remember is that save that bounced up off his chest.MrLargo said:
Bit harsh. Only played one game for us. Let in a penalty, kept a clean sheet for the rest of the game iirc.killerandflash said:Obviously not the worst keeper ever, but Tony Caig was pretty poor considering we were in the PL at the time!0 -
Surely the ultimate insult for any pre-2014 ex-Charlton player is if you still make it into this worst 11 ahead of any of Roland's recruits (pre-Bowyer).2
-
Johnny Ostergaard
0 -
One player I remember always feeling was utter dross was Simon Francis, was glad when we sold him onto League One mid-tablers Bournemouth...then he went on to over 100 PL appearances...
Nouble was woeful, Simon Church likewise, and whatever happened to Polish Pete?0 -
Amdy Faye is without doubt the worst player ever in my lifetime to play for Charlton.0
-
Step forward Tahar El-Khalej.MrLargo said:Surely the ultimate insult for any pre-2014 ex-Charlton player is if you still make it into this worst 11 ahead of any of Roland's recruits (pre-Bowyer).2 -
Dreadful but not worse than Cranie or lepointBedsaddick said:Amdy Faye is without doubt the worst player ever in my lifetime to play for Charlton.1 -
El Khalej was shockingly bad
1 -
How about this team?0 -
Sponsored links:
-
McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.1
-
But at the time it seemed really weird for a PL side to sign a journeyman 4th tier goalkeeper. He didn't inspire much confidence eitherMrLargo said:
Bit harsh. Only played one game for us. Let in a penalty, kept a clean sheet for the rest of the game iirc.killerandflash said:Obviously not the worst keeper ever, but Tony Caig was pretty poor considering we were in the PL at the time!0 -
Yeah but do you know what match that one is from?MrLargo said:McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.0 -
I disagree . I watched him in one game purposely go to parts of the pitch where the ball wasn’t . That’s unforgivable for a midfielder. He was so bad it looked like he was trying to throw the games . I’m not sure if I dreamt this but I think at one point he was arrested on corruption charges while at another club . He should have been arrested for impersonating a footballer !wmcf123 said:
Dreadful but not worse than Cranie or lepointBedsaddick said:Amdy Faye is without doubt the worst player ever in my lifetime to play for Charlton.
0 -
Spongefoot and Makeniok shoe ins upfront. Redfern given what he cost.0
-
Is it the nightmare at Northwich Victoria @ForeverAddickted ?ForeverAddickted said:
Yeah but do you know what match that one is from?MrLargo said:McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.1 -
Fraid so...MrLargo said:
Is it the nightmare at Northwich Victoria @ForeverAddickted ?ForeverAddickted said:
Yeah but do you know what match that one is from?MrLargo said:McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.1 -
Hmmm. Well that performance sits alongside the home League Cup quarter final defeat against Wycombe, when we were in the Premier League and they were in League 2, as the most pathetic showing I've ever seen from a Charlton side.ForeverAddickted said:
Fraid so...MrLargo said:
Is it the nightmare at Northwich Victoria @ForeverAddickted ?ForeverAddickted said:
Yeah but do you know what match that one is from?MrLargo said:McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.
So maybe a few of them do deserve a place in our worst ever eleven.1 -
Didnt help us having this bloke on the bench for that FA Cup gameMrLargo said:
Hmmm. Well that performance sits alongside the home League Cup quarter final defeat against Wycombe, when we were in the Premier League and they were in League 2, as the most pathetic showing I've ever seen from a Charlton side.ForeverAddickted said:
Fraid so...MrLargo said:
Is it the nightmare at Northwich Victoria @ForeverAddickted ?ForeverAddickted said:
Yeah but do you know what match that one is from?MrLargo said:McLeod and Omozusi are the only ones in that list who should be anywhere near this conversation.
So maybe a few of them do deserve a place in our worst ever eleven.
1 -
McBobbin said:Amdy Faye once had a good game, when he went into defence against Bolton. The reason I remember that was because the rest of the time he was crap. El Khalej was the worst I've ever seenspot on with amdy faye! im sure it was agaisnt bolton.apart from that jimmy floyd hasssel was poor! i never rated barness although was young at the time so could be basing that off 1 gamewho rememebrs yassin moutakil? what happened to him?!0
-
Sponsored links:
-
Church and Sordell have to be the worst strike partnership I've ever seen.
I usually have a soft spot for any player that gives 100%, but Church was just far too fucking shite. Sordell even worse... Still an absolute myth how he ended up getting a transfer to the Premier league the season after. Truly bizzare.1 -
To be fair Sordell has come out and said he was suffering from depression and other mental health issues while with us . Church on the other hand , while popular with the other players , was absolute pony .JoshrewCAFC said:Church and Sordell have to be the worst strike partnership I've ever seen.
I usually have a soft spot for any player that gives 100%, but Church was just far too fucking shite. Sordell even worse... Still an absolute myth how he ended up getting a transfer to the Premier league the season after. Truly bizzare.0 -
I cannot remember a Binks. Presumably a keeper. Tell me more.ForeverAddickted said:
How about this team?0 -
Jack Binks, who never made a first team appearance if I remember correctly.Aethelstan said:
I cannot remember a Binks. Presumably a keeper. Tell me more.ForeverAddickted said:
How about this team?
We should probably have a Cameo/Ghost XI, too.
Luke Daniels, Omar Pouso, Cory Gibbs, Karim Bagheri, names like that...2 -
Nouble was shocking.sunbury-addick said:Callumcafc said: Nouble, lol, worst Charlton player I ever saw
0 -
That's a big claim, I can think of plenty worse.Bedsaddick said:Amdy Faye is without doubt the worst player ever in my lifetime to play for Charlton.2 -
Nouble, Jerome Thomas? (Left wing) Scott Sinclair? (Right wing)0
-
No it’s absolute fact . The main word being “MY” .drewman said:
That's a big claim, I can think of plenty worse.Bedsaddick said:Amdy Faye is without doubt the worst player ever in my lifetime to play for Charlton.0 -
Jerome Thomas?!creepyaddick said:Nouble, Jerome Thomas? (Left wing) Scott Sinclair? (Right wing)
Was absolutely quality for a couple of years.12 -
Thuram
Omozuzi, El Khalej, Williams, Seabourne
Kaikai, Lepoint, Kerkar
Nouble, Church, McCammon
Beat that (with a Sunday league team).0
