Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

POST-MATCH THREAD: Charlton Athletic v Mansfield Town: Saturday 14th December 2024: KO 15:00

178101213

Comments

  • Uboat said:
    Delfin said:
    Just 1 word since pre season Goalscorer!
    Have I stumbled onto the cryptic crossword thread?
    I thought it was an anagram, but I can't fit 'shite team' in so I'm stuck.
  • Leuth said:
    Mansfield seemed to have more method in their play than us. Luckily they missed at least three sitters in the first half, with Anderson fluffing our big chance. I think we miss Dobbo controlling our midfield. Better second half but far from great. I am puzzled that Coventry and Taylor are unable to create clear cut chances. Plus, most of Taylor's set pieces were poor today. The referee was even more dire than the action.


    'Dobbo' was about the one thing we didn't miss. What we miss is creative attacking play, effective wingplay, effective finishing, hold up play, movement when a midfielder is on the ball and full back support. We didn't miss defensive midfielders who distribute calmly - we had two on for most of the game 
    We are missing him considering his replacement isn't as good as him defensively or on the front foot, mainly cos he's constantly slowing it down by passing backwards.

  • Another 2 points dropped against a poor Mansfield team. A better second half but their keeper had an easy afternoon as we barely threatened their goal

    3 wins in the last 16 league games, less than a goal a game. Midtable football once again 
  • Torn between sticking with him giving him another window or having to go through another complete reset. Mess
  • The optimist in me says those periods of decent play show that they CAN play decent, we just have to question why they aren't so often. 

    As long as we're bumping along with enough to stay mid-table and keep us out of trouble, Jones at least gets the rest of the year to see if anything in January can turn it around.  Ditching yet another manager when we are mid table just seems unrealistic about what anybody else would achieve this year.
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited December 15
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
  • se9addick said:
    I'd like a pound for every time Nathan mentions the 'lack of quality in the final third' in his post match interviews,
    There’s a lack of quality in the final third because he let the one player who had bloody quality in the final third go. 
    This x 100.
  • Peter_G said:
    Can’t wait for December’s goal of the month line up. 
    Probably going to be replaced by a Goal a Month compilation in May...
  • ct_addick said:
    When a players wrestles down another player in the area how is that not a penalty……….
    It was a stonewall penalty - I have no idea what the lino and ref were watching. Unbelievable....
  • Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
    I'll add - Leaburn didn't utter a peep after the first one but was screaming at the ref after the second
  • Leuth said:
    Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
    I'll add - Leaburn didn't utter a peep after the first one but was screaming at the ref after the second
    Oshilaja wrestled Leaburn to the ground - not sure what sport I was watching. Ref let so much go...
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited December 15
    Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway

    Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
    The commentator was adamant that it was a clear penalty. Unfortunately, there’s no commentary on these highlights. Oh, and they edited out Oshi wrestling Miles to the ground. 
    Shared from Sky Sports: Charlton Athletic 0-0 Mansfield Town | League One highlights https://www.skysports.com/football/video/26947/13273705/charlton-athletic-0-0-mansfield-town-league-one-highlights
  • Agree with everyone re boring shit football tactics etc,BUT I’m hoping that NJ can see /realise that his recruitment was not very good and try’s to address that in January cause I don’t want another change and it all starts again,
    if we get any players in where we so obviously need them that will in my book give NJ more time, if not bye bye. 
  • Not read the full thread but if we are questioning the officials over the ‘penalty’ then we should be looking more closely at the two tackles where it looked like the Mansfield player(s) stopped the attacking Charlton player(s) by putting their arms around the neck of the charlton player and pulling them back. The first time it happened it got a free kick and a yellow, the second time it got nothing. Tackles like that should be straight reds. The club should take a good look at both those tackles and if they were what I thought they looked like to me then they should be asking the FA/EFL to investigate.
  • Not read the full thread but if we are questioning the officials over the ‘penalty’ then we should be looking more closely at the two tackles where it looked like the Mansfield player(s) stopped the attacking Charlton player(s) by putting their arms around the neck of the charlton player and pulling them back. The first time it happened it got a free kick and a yellow, the second time it got nothing. Tackles like that should be straight reds. The club should take a good look at both those tackles and if they were what I thought they looked like to me then they should be asking the FA/EFL to investigate.
    I think the Mansfield players worked out they could get away with pretty much anything...
  • 1968CAFC said:
    As a fan from 1968 and a season Ticket holder 
    I cannot remember anything as bad as this shite!!!
    Taffy must FO !!!
    Is the horrible worded reference to his place of birth relevant or needed? 

    Why not Jones must FO?
  • Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
    It wasn’t really an even wrestling contest, as Oshi was trying to stop Leaburn getting anywhere near the ball and instigated all contact. If Miles had a hand in Oshi it was to break free. I guarantee Oshi couldn’t believe he got away with it. 
    Not that it makes a real difference. 
    Our only hope is that somehow we’re trying to play football again. 
  • Leuth said:
    Which is the penalty on Leaburn that is obvious? The first where they were wrestling each other (I'd say about evenly, not a stinking decision) or the second on the edge of the box that happened off the ball? DGMW the ref had an absolute howler anyway
    Problem was that Leaburn kept throwing himself to the ground, probably a lack of fitness and/or confidence, and when the wrestle came the ref just thought it was more of the same. 

    All in all, another afternoon of utter garbage, if Mansfield had anyone who could shoot we would have lost. 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!