Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

PLAYER OF THE YEAR DINNER - CANCELLED

12357…10

Comments

  • RedChaser
    RedChaser Posts: 19,886
    edited March 2017
    sm said:

    RedChaser said:

    Covered End said:

    ElfsborgAddick said:

    I think we should do the voting for POTY as in previous years(outside before home games).

    At the Swindon game the fans then wait outside the players entrance after the game to present the winner with his goodies.

    What do other people think to this idea?

    I quite like this as an idea. We could all meet in the West Stand Car Park after the game and hold "an award ceremony".

    POTY. Young POTY. Worst run club in England. Worst owner in England. Worst CEO in England.

    We could just announce the awards by megaphone, that will do for the time being.
    I know just the man :wink: .
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cu0prnzW8AA92a4.jpg
    Why do it outside our stadium?
    I wouldn't classify in the car park / outside the players entrance as 'outside the stadium'; see Covered End's original post.
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,021
    sm said:

    RedChaser said:

    Covered End said:

    ElfsborgAddick said:

    I think we should do the voting for POTY as in previous years(outside before home games).

    At the Swindon game the fans then wait outside the players entrance after the game to present the winner with his goodies.

    What do other people think to this idea?

    I quite like this as an idea. We could all meet in the West Stand Car Park after the game and hold "an award ceremony".

    POTY. Young POTY. Worst run club in England. Worst owner in England. Worst CEO in England.

    We could just announce the awards by megaphone, that will do for the time being.
    I know just the man :wink: .
    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cu0prnzW8AA92a4.jpg
    Why do it outside our stadium?
    A themed demonstration.
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,021
    edited March 2017
    FORD said:

    Meire is ego based, there's no logic or reason involved in her decision. There's no strategic approach, it's just her ego being bruised and her instinctive reaction that highlight her true character.

    Yet again another good thing associated with the club has been well and truly meired.

    There's her legacy...that term (to meire) will live on beyond her days in charge. In years to come we will meet up and talk about the game...bloody hell that Smith in defence really meired that tackle.

    Make it part of the valley vocabulary and you get to that ego. It's through her ego that CARD gets it's headlines.

    Oh dear, that was a Meire of a shot.

    2 up and we lost. We really Meired that up.

    The legacy she deserves.
  • cabbles
    cabbles Posts: 15,257
    It seems to me the last desperate and dying act of vindictiveness and spite from someone potentially on their way out.

    From reading Fanny's posts on here I cannot imagine the content of the email being anything other than a very matter of fact opinion of someone who is unfit to to do their job. I bet it wasn't aggressive or particularly offensive. Again this just shows a complete lack of class on KM's part. If you hold office in a public facing organisation, and that organisation goes into decline for a sustained period, you're going to get criticism. The one tactic that KM should've been employing in all of this CARD era is to simply ignore it.

    Just when you think she may be getting the hang of it, (her interview on radio4, and comparatively speaking) she goes and does this.

    I've said on here before that this will always be their biggest downfall. They cannot stop putting their foot in their mouths with their constant vendettas against CARD.

    Pitch, Rubashow, bevington, all these PR and comms people. An utter waste of resources, time and money.

    This whole decision to say they won't run it with Fanny's help is again highlighting the incompetence and short - sightedness of the regime
  • Horsfield9
    Horsfield9 Posts: 3,082
    I echo everyone else, very sad, but the correct decision.
  • ozaddick
    ozaddick Posts: 2,846
    edited March 2017
    AFKABartram said:

    Firstly, a massive thank you to @killerjerrylee for staying resolute and loyal to Jean. I'm sure 99% of true Charlton fans fully support the stand you have ridiculously been boxed into a corner and forced to make.

    This will stem from two things; firstly the club wanting to get control of this event after being spectacularly knocked back when they tried last year, and secondly, an opportunity that take forward a spiteful and vindictive approach to Jean simply because she is someone who has made her feelings clear previously on the regime's failures.

    These people have come into our club and within the space of a few years ripped out its foundations and completely dismantled the club. Individuals who have worked from the club, volunteered for the benefit of the club, or simply supported the club for decades have walked away under this stewardship. And that lot don't care a jot as they are so insular and caught up with 'beating' those they see as against them, they haven't a clue or a moments thought in considering what what is actually best for the club.

    Jean is someone who must have put 30 years service into things that aid and benefit the club or fellow supporters; organising and running a supporters group, representing at fans forums, organising player of the year, maintaining the memorial garden at the Training Ground. All the way down to scraping shit off the seats at The Valley in summer so the club didn't have to pay out for cleaners.

    But what most resonates most for us average Joes with 'people like Jean' is not really the above, it's more the 3am posts after a midweek away defeat, searching for a positive. increasingly strugglng to find one, bit still searching for it.

    Whilst Meire and co have been here for two minutes and don't give a damn, we all know 'people like Jean' who have been doing these 3am away day returns when we've taken 200 away, or given up their Matchday to collect votes, or given up their midweek evening for some supporters committee organising meeting.

    And we know they do care.

    When this mob go there is going to need to be a massive effort to rebuild what actually was not that long ago good about it. Until then, the supporters more than ever needs to stand resolute and unified against it.

    Sad times. Here's hoping more than anything the increased speculation he is seeking to sell will deliver something positive

    You nailed it AFKA. Jean represents everything that IS Charlton.
  • bigstemarra
    bigstemarra Posts: 5,098
    A few years back I had the pleasure and the privilege of attending the POTY dinner due to getting lucky in the ticket lottery for CL members. It was when we had just won the League and the bonds between fans, players and the club were strong - we were as one and it was fantastic. Part of what epitomised this was the incredible effort put in by Fanny et al to organise the event; their love for the club shone through and was reflected by the players, management, fans and those working for the club.

    It makes me so sad when I think of where we are now compared to back then. They have largely succeeded in 'de-Charltonising' almost every aspect of the club....effectively ripping the heart out it. People who care have been replaced with soul-less yes men and women to whom working for the club is 'just a job'. Those with a passion for Charlton have been disenfranchised and shunned. It appears that they feel threatened by people who care, as this sad development shows. Couple that with an obsessive need to control everything and the most important bond is severed; that between the club and its fans. Now, I'm no businessman, but that doesn't strike me as either desirable or sustainable - in fact, it is the very definition of incompetent administration.

    My message to the spiteful halfwits who have taken this step?

    You bought the wrong club.
    You are a complete and utter incompetent shambles.
    Sell up now and let people who actually care about CAFC repair the senseless vandalism that you have committed.
  • Croydon
    Croydon Posts: 12,737
    How sad that this is what Charlton has become.

    Sell the club, OUR club, you're not wanted.
  • ElfsborgAddick
    ElfsborgAddick Posts: 29,098
    HarryLime said:

    I think the correct decision has been made by Ian Jean and Marilyn. I do find it weird and I possibly mean unique probably both that a CEO would want to get involved at all. She is mad.

    Squirrel face even had the front to attend last years event.

    She deliberately sets out to antagonise people, a dreadful woman.
  • Six-a-bag-of-nuts
    Six-a-bag-of-nuts Posts: 8,127
    Stig said:

    Stig said:

    JohnnyH2 said:

    Is anyone able to work out the last time there was no Player of the Year Do. Can't think of single season this had happened in the previous 35 seasons past.

    Great credit to the organisers for telling the club where to go.

    1972. The the award was retrospectively given to Keith Peacock, I believe as part of the Centenary celebrations in 2005.
    Sorry, that's the last time there wasn't an award. I don't know if there's always been a do in that time or whether there had been one in 1972 an no-one bothered recording the result.
    '72 was a shit season and we got relegated to the 3rd division for the first time since 1935.
    I'd never begrudge Keith Peacock any award, but Ray Treacy got about 20 goals in that shit season and was my hero at the time, so he would have got my vote.

  • Sponsored links:



  • ElfsborgAddick
    ElfsborgAddick Posts: 29,098
    Has anybody on here sent an email to squirrel face and received a reply?
  • iainment
    iainment Posts: 8,040
    Covered End said:

    I'd like to thank Ian & Jean for all their efforts. Personally, I think you've made the correct decision and it just shows Meire once again, for the spiteful vindictive person that she is.

    Anyway, this will provide excellent media news, I can see the headlines now.

    "Charlton CEO Katrien Meire causes Charlton's POTY event to be cancelled after refusing permission for the Supporter of The Year to organise it as usual"

    Just sell the club. Shame on you Katrien.

    What papers/sites do you read? I can't think of any using that or a similar headline.

    It's a bit of a non story really. I'm against Duchatelet, pro CARD et al but completely indifferent to a POTY dinner. As I think are most addicks.

    Only those who like schmoozing with players and staff care much about this.
  • Airman Brown
    Airman Brown Posts: 15,745
    iainment said:

    Covered End said:

    I'd like to thank Ian & Jean for all their efforts. Personally, I think you've made the correct decision and it just shows Meire once again, for the spiteful vindictive person that she is.

    Anyway, this will provide excellent media news, I can see the headlines now.

    "Charlton CEO Katrien Meire causes Charlton's POTY event to be cancelled after refusing permission for the Supporter of The Year to organise it as usual"

    Just sell the club. Shame on you Katrien.

    What papers/sites do you read? I can't think of any using that or a similar headline.

    It's a bit of a non story really. I'm against Duchatelet, pro CARD et al but completely indifferent to a POTY dinner. As I think are most addicks.

    Only those who like schmoozing with players and staff care much about this.
    I don't think the issue here is the PotY as such. It's the conduct and judgement of Katrien Meire.
  • DA9
    DA9 Posts: 11,091
    The lib will hold it :-)
  • se9addick
    se9addick Posts: 32,056
    iainment said:

    Covered End said:

    I'd like to thank Ian & Jean for all their efforts. Personally, I think you've made the correct decision and it just shows Meire once again, for the spiteful vindictive person that she is.

    Anyway, this will provide excellent media news, I can see the headlines now.

    "Charlton CEO Katrien Meire causes Charlton's POTY event to be cancelled after refusing permission for the Supporter of The Year to organise it as usual"

    Just sell the club. Shame on you Katrien.

    What papers/sites do you read? I can't think of any using that or a similar headline.

    It's a bit of a non story really. I'm against Duchatelet, pro CARD et al but completely indifferent to a POTY dinner. As I think are most addicks.

    Only those who like schmoozing with players and staff care much about this.
    Really ? I'm not a member of the Junior Addicks but I'm aware it's important for the future of our club and as part of our history and traditions just as the POTY is. That's what this is about, not only is it a terrible decision made as a reaction against someone who has done so much for our club with very little in return but it's just another example of them not only not caring about our traditions but actually demolishing them, please don't be indifferent about that.
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,021
    ElfsborgAddick said:

    Has anybody on here sent an email to squirrel face and received a reply?

    I've sent a few. I wasn't expecting a reply :wink:
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,021
    edited March 2017
    iainment said:

    Covered End said:

    I'd like to thank Ian & Jean for all their efforts. Personally, I think you've made the correct decision and it just shows Meire once again, for the spiteful vindictive person that she is.

    Anyway, this will provide excellent media news, I can see the headlines now.

    "Charlton CEO Katrien Meire causes Charlton's POTY event to be cancelled after refusing permission for the Supporter of The Year to organise it as usual"

    Just sell the club. Shame on you Katrien.

    What papers/sites do you read? I can't think of any using that or a similar headline.

    It's a bit of a non story really. I'm against Duchatelet, pro CARD et al but completely indifferent to a POTY dinner. As I think are most addicks.

    Only those who like schmoozing with players and staff care much about this.
    I'm not surprised. I don't often agree with your judgement (no offence intended).

    Mind you I posted that last night, past midnight, when I was somewhat tired. I do realise that the suggested title was rather long and would need to be shortened.

  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,235
    ElfsborgAddick said:

    Has anybody on here sent an email to squirrel face and received a reply?

  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,140
    Absolutely the right decision to pull the plug on this. Thanks to @killerjerrylee for putting us in the picture.

    What a thoroughly petty and vindictive approach by the club towards someone who has made such a huge and selfless contribution over so many years - not just in organising the POTY dinner, but on so many other fronts, such as tending to the Pierre Bolangi memorial garden.

    Fanny has never been anything but candid in her views on the regime and ignoring the email would have shown a bit of common sense on their part. However, this lot are incapable of getting anything right and I expect the opportunity to try and throw their weight about proved too great to resist.

    Lamentable.
  • iainment
    iainment Posts: 8,040
    What was said in the email?

  • Sponsored links:



  • stonemuse
    stonemuse Posts: 34,018
    Correct decision made, this cannot be handed over to the SMT.
  • Davo55
    Davo55 Posts: 7,838
    Two blinding posts on the subject by @AFKABartram Well said mate.
  • Hartleypete
    Hartleypete Posts: 4,701
    Henry Irving said:

    Just an example of how principled Ian and Jean are.

    When they took it over the POTY was loss making in large part because so many people got free tickets.

    They changed that and said "everyone pays including us".

    That's right Ian and Jean pay for their own tickets to the event they organise.

    But Meire is unhappy that Jean is so publicly critical of the regime and this is her childish, spiteful way of getting back at her.

    Meire doesnt care about the POTY she just has to "win" even if that means no event and everyone including the club losing.

    Pathetic.

    Were the Perks involved when all the freebies were given out?
  • Hartleypete
    Hartleypete Posts: 4,701
    Instead of a POTY, let's present Meire with a POTTY so she can shit somewhere without it being on the fans.
  • Dave2l
    Dave2l Posts: 8,871
    Airman Brown said:

    From what I've heard the email doesn't amount to anything that would do any more than make people on here laugh and nod in agreement. It's the club that would be more embarrassed if it came out this is what they were complaining about rather than the author.

    Incrediblely thin skinned human being.

    Just shows Meire is so easily defeated.

    Wonder how she sleeps at night. She must "want revenge" against every Charlton fan that dared cross her. Must be awful.

    It is just about her winning.

    She's gotta be the worst CEO of this calibre of any business.

    Perhaps quite a historic achievement I would say.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 16,951
    Worthingred said:

    My very first post after following all the comments on here over the past few years. A shame that the fans yet again suffer at the hands of total incompetence and regrettebly the only decision they could make. Incedibly petty and it just gave me that nudge to register here and add my support. Let's get them out

    Welcome! :)

    How this works right. Every time you see a post of mine you have to either like or lol it!

    Got it!? :p
  • Isawsummersplay
    Isawsummersplay Posts: 1,428
    Ditto what canters said.
  • stonemuse
    stonemuse Posts: 34,018
    edited March 2017
    Dave2l said:

    Airman Brown said:

    From what I've heard the email doesn't amount to anything that would do any more than make people on here laugh and nod in agreement. It's the club that would be more embarrassed if it came out this is what they were complaining about rather than the author.

    Incrediblely thin skinned human being.

    Just shows Meire is so easily defeated.

    Wonder how she sleeps at night. She must "want revenge" against every Charlton fan that dared cross her. Must be awful.

    It is just about her winning.

    She's gotta be the worst CEO of this calibre of any business.

    Perhaps quite a historic achievement I would say.
    Whatever happens she will use 'post-truth' to demonstrate how she 'beat' us.

    However, I couldn't care less what she does once she has gone, although I would find it a little galling if she gets away with it. Although with Uncle Roly, how can she fail.

Categories

“Marketplace”