Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

The mathematics of relegation

1235789

Comments

  • As interesting an exercise as this is, if we do go down it will have nothing to do with the mathematics. It will be because we have wasted the numerous chances that we have had to get enough points - by winning games. 6 points gained from the first 2 games back has now turned into 7 from 6.

    But the real mathematics are that we have scored 3 goals in our last 9 games - this return is an "F" for failure!
    Will also be because of our inability to see out games.

    Injury time goals conceded to Bristol City, Millwall, Sheff Weds, Huddersfield, Hull cost us 6 points. We'd already be safe.
  • stoneroses19
    stoneroses19 Posts: 7,221
    As interesting an exercise as this is, if we do go down it will have nothing to do with the mathematics. It will be because we have wasted the numerous chances that we have had to get enough points - by winning games. 6 points gained from the first 2 games back has now turned into 7 from 6.

    But the real mathematics are that we have scored 3 goals in our last 9 games - this return is an "F" for failure!
    Will also be because of our inability to see out games.

    Injury time goals conceded to Bristol City, Millwall, Sheff Weds, Huddersfield, Hull cost us 6 points. We'd already be safe.
    Someone worked this out last week and with the goals we’ve scored late on, we’d only be 1 point up. Of course that 1 point would be helpful.
  • Dave Rudd
    Dave Rudd Posts: 2,865
    As interesting an exercise as this is, if we do go down it will have nothing to do with the mathematics. It will be because we have wasted the numerous chances that we have had to get enough points - by winning games. 6 points gained from the first 2 games back has now turned into 7 from 6.

    But the real mathematics are that we have scored 3 goals in our last 9 games - this return is an "F" for failure!
    Well, going by @Dave Rudd's thinking then we are just about to hit the goal trail & finish with 5 goals in our last 3 games.l 😃
    That's more like it, golfie.

    There's hope for you yet.
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 94,318
    So many twists and turns still to come.

    Stoke v Birmingham.
    Wigan v Hull. 
    Hull v Luton.
    Charlton v Wigan.

    Then we still have the points deduction hanging over Sheffield Wednesday. 12 points puts them 2nd bottom.

    The only thing looking fairly certain right now is that with their remaining games (Leeds/Forest/Brentford) Barnsley will almost certainly go down.
    Thing is time Barnsley play their last 2 games, Forest wil be safe in the play offs, with no chance of getting into the top 2 so may rest players or take it easy. Same for Brentford on the last day, knowing that they cant catch the top 2 & 3rd it is.

    If we don't win on Wednesday then I fear we are down. Wigan have only lost once in the last 11 games or so & not conceded many.....I believe its something like 5 clean sheets out of 6 or 7 games. 
    Brentford are three behind West Brom with a better Goal Difference - Realistically Brentford have to win all three games and pray West Brom lose one
  • Valiantphil
    Valiantphil Posts: 6,410
    I think we need Brum to win at Stoke and hope they switch off safe in midweek. 
  • As interesting an exercise as this is, if we do go down it will have nothing to do with the mathematics. It will be because we have wasted the numerous chances that we have had to get enough points - by winning games. 6 points gained from the first 2 games back has now turned into 7 from 6.

    But the real mathematics are that we have scored 3 goals in our last 9 games - this return is an "F" for failure!
    Will also be because of our inability to see out games.

    Injury time goals conceded to Bristol City, Millwall, Sheff Weds, Huddersfield, Hull cost us 6 points. We'd already be safe.
    Someone worked this out last week and with the goals we’ve scored late on, we’d only be 1 point up. Of course that 1 point would be helpful.
    Who have we scored injury time goals against to save us points?

    I can only think of the away games at West Brom and QPR to save us a draw. So that's 2 points saved and 6 lost. 
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,846
    So many twists and turns still to come.

    Stoke v Birmingham.
    Wigan v Hull. 
    Hull v Luton.
    Charlton v Wigan.

    Then we still have the points deduction hanging over Sheffield Wednesday. 12 points puts them 2nd bottom.

    The only thing looking fairly certain right now is that with their remaining games (Leeds/Forest/Brentford) Barnsley will almost certainly go down.
    Thing is time Barnsley play their last 2 games, Forest wil be safe in the play offs, with no chance of getting into the top 2 so may rest players or take it easy. Same for Brentford on the last day, knowing that they cant catch the top 2 & 3rd it is.

    If we don't win on Wednesday then I fear we are down. Wigan have only lost once in the last 11 games or so & not conceded many.....I believe its something like 5 clean sheets out of 6 or 7 games. 
    Brentford are three behind West Brom with a better Goal Difference - Realistically Brentford have to win all three games and pray West Brom lose one
    West Brom play Fulham on Tuesday, that's the big one
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,628
    As interesting an exercise as this is, if we do go down it will have nothing to do with the mathematics. It will be because we have wasted the numerous chances that we have had to get enough points - by winning games. 6 points gained from the first 2 games back has now turned into 7 from 6.

    But the real mathematics are that we have scored 3 goals in our last 9 games - this return is an "F" for failure!
    Will also be because of our inability to see out games.

    Injury time goals conceded to Bristol City, Millwall, Sheff Weds, Huddersfield, Hull cost us 6 points. We'd already be safe.
    Someone worked this out last week and with the goals we’ve scored late on, we’d only be 1 point up. Of course that 1 point would be helpful.
    Who have we scored injury time goals against to save us points?

    I can only think of the away games at West Brom and QPR to save us a draw. So that's 2 points saved and 6 lost. 
    Not only that, but the last minute equaliser that Hull got at the Valley could prove very vital. That's 3 more points we would have over them in that game alone.
  • sralan
    sralan Posts: 2,031
    Birmingham are there for the taking next week. If we can't beat them we don't deserve to stay up.
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,628
    sralan said:
    Birmingham are there for the taking next week. If we can't beat them we don't deserve to stay up.
    Again, as @Dave Rudd says, all runs have to end sometimes. Birmingham are on a bad run atm so expect to see them come good on Wednesday. I'm thinking of bunging on £5 for them to win. 
  • Sponsored links:



  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,007
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,740
    sralan said:
    Birmingham are there for the taking next week. If we can't beat them we don't deserve to stay up.
    Again, as @Dave Rudd says, all runs have to end sometimes. Birmingham are on a bad run atm so expect to see them come good on Wednesday. I'm thinking of bunging on £5 for them to win. 
    You'll make £6 profit . They are favourites at 11-8
  • iainambler
    iainambler Posts: 963
    Dave Rudd said:
    R and R' should reduce further in midweek and new teams will take the place of Luton and Hull, so them playing each other next week is not likely to be as significant as it currently looks.
    Thank you, my child.

     :) 
    Blimers ! 

    You're now a man of the cloth as well as a maths genius !

    Is there no end to your talents ? 
    I think there will be considerable touching of cloth in the coming days given our league position combined with the utterly perilous state of our ownership  
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,846
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
  • Stig
    Stig Posts: 29,024
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    Don't forget, they're playing us. Mystery solved.
  • 1968CAFC
    1968CAFC Posts: 577
    I feel Sorry for Lee Bowyer,
    he has no proper management,  no proper Strikers
    and No luck against stupid referee decisions
    .
    Lyle Twat Taylor if he was intelligent would have scored at least three Goals since we started back.
    made a name for himself and kept us up.
    then he could get a better deal elsewhere and his new boss would trust him.

    we have a 50/50 change of survival we cannot score goals so it’s going to be very difficult 👎
  • Webbja77
    Webbja77 Posts: 1,104
    I think 3 more points will see us safe... either Wednesday or Saturday, obvs would take 6😝
  • Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    It's actually 11 games now after yesterday.

    Birmingham are winless post-lockdown, have only 1 home win in 14 games, no clean sheet at home since October and have conceded 3 goals in each of their last 5 home games.

    Also post lockdown, we've won at Hull, got a good draw at Cardiff and lost narrowly at Brentford.

    Cannot see why Birmingham should be favourites.
  • StigThundercock
    StigThundercock Posts: 3,722
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    It's actually 11 games now after yesterday.

    Birmingham are winless post-lockdown, have only 1 home win in 14 games, no clean sheet at home since October and have conceded 3 goals in each of their last 5 home games.

    Also post lockdown, we've won at Hull, got a good draw at Cardiff and lost narrowly at Brentford.

    Cannot see why Birmingham should be favourites.
    you've not watched our last 4 games then?
  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,525
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    It's actually 11 games now after yesterday.

    Birmingham are winless post-lockdown, have only 1 home win in 14 games, no clean sheet at home since October and have conceded 3 goals in each of their last 5 home games.

    Also post lockdown, we've won at Hull, got a good draw at Cardiff and lost narrowly at Brentford.

    Cannot see why Birmingham should be favourites.
    you've not watched our last 4 games then?
    in fairness, we have remained competitive in each and every game. Millwall are a curse, we gave Brentford a scare and should have at least earned a draw from Reading. Our destiny remains in our hands.
  • Sponsored links:



  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,846
    Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    It's actually 11 games now after yesterday.

    Birmingham are winless post-lockdown, have only 1 home win in 14 games, no clean sheet at home since October and have conceded 3 goals in each of their last 5 home games.

    Also post lockdown, we've won at Hull, got a good draw at Cardiff and lost narrowly at Brentford.

    Cannot see why Birmingham should be favourites.
    you've not watched our last 4 games then?
    Have you watched Birmingham's last 4 matches...
  • Brum are hot favs at 13/10.
    The draw & CAFC to win 5/2.
    That's baffling for a team which hasn't won any of its last 10 matches!
    It's actually 11 games now after yesterday.

    Birmingham are winless post-lockdown, have only 1 home win in 14 games, no clean sheet at home since October and have conceded 3 goals in each of their last 5 home games.

    Also post lockdown, we've won at Hull, got a good draw at Cardiff and lost narrowly at Brentford.

    Cannot see why Birmingham should be favourites.
    you've not watched our last 4 games then?
    Yes. Good point at Cardiff, admittedly shit v Millwall as usual but Bonne should've scored and a draw would've probably been fair, led Brentford (form team in the division) for ages and could've got a point, robbed by the ref v Reading and a draw would've been fair.

    We're always in games. Birmingham are getting soundly beaten most games.
  • Addick Addict
    Addick Addict Posts: 39,790
    sralan said:
    Birmingham are there for the taking next week. If we can't beat them we don't deserve to stay up.
    Again, as @Dave Rudd says, all runs have to end sometimes. Birmingham are on a bad run atm so expect to see them come good on Wednesday. I'm thinking of bunging on £5 for them to win. 
    You'll make £6 profit . They are favourites at 11-8
    Yes but think of the knock on affect of this recommendation going out to all Golfie's clients in his weekly newsletter - "How to more than double your investment in just a couple of hours!"
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,148
    So if we fail to beat them we are shit 
  • So if we fail to beat them we are shit 
    It depends whether they find their form for one night or not. It all hinges on the ref. Apparently.
  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,089
    sralan said:
    Birmingham are there for the taking next week. If we can't beat them we don't deserve to stay up.
    Again, as @Dave Rudd says, all runs have to end sometimes. Birmingham are on a bad run atm so expect to see them come good on Wednesday. I'm thinking of bunging on £5 for them to win. 
    You'll make £6 profit . They are favourites at 11-8
    Don't let it change you Golf.
  • Addick Addict
    Addick Addict Posts: 39,790
    When you've only scored 3 goals in over 14 hours of football every decision does tend to matter. Whether it should to that extent is another question.
  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,261
    edited July 2020
    I love this thread. It brings calm as death approaches, much like Buddhism I expect.
  • iaitch
    iaitch Posts: 10,230
    Are we going to slowly slip away or go down screaming?
  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 13,918
    iaitch said:
    Are we going to slowly slip away or go down screaming?
    Fall like a fat bloke on ice (or Gemma collins)