Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
I am going to say it!! Yes I am, Nathan Jones......................
Comments
-
Maybe not with the current momentum. Things don't have so be so binary.NabySarr said:50 points, 3 games to go. We’d all have taken that in August1 -
The playing 11 either lacking confidence or motivation/desire. I can't work out which!3
-
Wing backs are a top priority too as Clarke and Chambers are on loan and part of the problem - their good moments going forward have been far too rare.Sword65pf said:
Our midfield has been our problem all season, nothing we can do now, but if it’s not the priority to replace all of it I’ll be pretty pissed off. Keep Carey but he would need to be scared of his place in the team at the very least.Chunes said:
I agree. Our midfield is absolutely honking, with or without him.Scoham said:
I’m not convinced any of our midfielders are good enough really, other than Carey when he’s on form.Leuth said:
He's good enough for our midfield, but Jones blames him for a goal or two so he's dropped him for the foreseeable even when he'd obviously have been the best choice todayScoham said:
It’s debatable but let’s not turn Conor Coventry into the Championship Pirlo.Leuth said:
He has Conor Coventry and he's decided to hold a grudge against him. IdiotCrispywood said:When you play to win in the moments you need your players to not be donkeys Jones has way too many of those at this level
Had we got the same result (or worse) with Coventry, others would have said why not play Coady with his experience and his record with us.0 -
Can’t believe this negativity re Jones stabilised the club then got us promoted and now looks like keeping us in the Championship that as far as I am concerned is a great record yet we have people on here wanting him out I really don’t know what they expect
We are new to the Championship and although the football has not been great we have remained competitive. We have one of the smallest budgets and arguably one of the poorest squads so we are overachieving
Hopefully the squad will be improved over the summer and we can be more pleasing on the eye next season
I for one am delighted to have NJ as our manager and have confidence that he is the man to continue our improvement
Some fans have such short memories before Jones we has a Valley with small crowds and a toxic atmosphere look at the situation now thank you Nathan and your team and COYR5 -
ForeverAddickted said:
We're more than six points clear of Leicester...Oakster2 said:I feel Jones has taken us as far as he can - need fresh ideas and Championship class coaching team next season. Very appreciative for what he’s done but the Sheffield Wednesday factor and points deductions to rivals has been our saviour this season
But if Leicester hadnt have had points deducted, i would hazard a guess they would have picked up more points elsewhere.
Im not retrospectively turning them into PSG, but its clearly had an impact on the team beyond the initial points lost.4 -
Id definitely give him another season, but if it goes anything like this one then its got to be his last. Excuses like 'promoted too early' and 'missed out on players due to the playoffs' will no longer be valid. Weve pretty much wasted 2 windows with this year's recruitment.5
-
paulsturgess said:
I'm sorry you're deviating from the point here:ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
If you didn’t expect us to be doing better, then you have not been watching any of our matches. Fact. People need to get a grip and stop banging on about budget and playing football manager , looking at bits of paper.ForeverAddickted said:LittleAddick said:
I don't necessarily agree with those calls - but in my view we're past the point of calling them idiotic and pathetic. We genuinely can't score more than one goal, even against a team on -4 points.ForeverAddickted said:Should be thankful that people are calling for Jones' head againAs each time its happened so far, he's made those comments look idiotic and patheticThe question that always struggles to get answered with the Jones out callsIs what did you all expect at this stage of the season, that is being done differently?If you expected us to be doing worse, then we're doing betterIf you expected us to be doing better, then am sorry thats just naivity
look at the players on the pitch and how effing pitiful they are playing. If you don’t think they could and/or should be doing better, then you are the naive one!Survival is the target, its been the aim all season nothing more... nothing lessYet despite how pittiful we're playing, we're still in control of our destiny, we've still not entered the bottom threeSorry but those are the facts I'm looking at
Your comment - " if you expected us to be doing better, than am sorry thats just naivety"
my response is this a single simple question - "do you think the team should be playing better than they are?"
Please answer with one word only - yes or no
(and before answering would urge you to reflect on today's opponents, Preston and Watford's recent/current form)Its not a Yes or No answer... and you know it.Of course we all want to see Charlton playing better, but against opposition at this level with experience and nous, we'd get f**king slaughtered - So instead we play within our means, we grind our results by any means necessarily, and provided that we achieve the target that is survival... I dont care how that is achieved.Talking of form, as you've mentioned it, that (as I've stressed of late) is a lazy line, its another useless stat that has absolutely no meaning on future games... What happens in the past, has absolutely zero bearing on the future.Let me ask YOU this... Would you accept things, if we were playing better, but in Leicester's position currently?Losing more games, but of course we'd be showing more spirit and fight, but thats what is important... Right?6 -
That wins the prize for the biggest understatement of the year.superdulvertonred said:Can’t believe this negativity re Jones stabilised the club then got us promoted and now looks like keeping us in the Championship that as far as I am concerned is a great record yet we have people on here wanting him out I really don’t know what they expect
We are new to the Championship and although the football has not been great we have remained competitive. We have one of the smallest budgets and arguably one of the poorest squads so we are overachieving
Hopefully the squad will be improved over the summer and we can be more pleasing on the eye next season
I for one am delighted to have NJ as our manager and have confidence that he is the man to continue our improvement
Some fans have such short memories before Jones we has a Valley with small crowds and a toxic atmosphere look at the situation now thank you Nathan and your team and COYR4 -
They were in free fall long before the deduction I thinkDamoNorthStand said:ForeverAddickted said:
We're more than six points clear of Leicester...Oakster2 said:I feel Jones has taken us as far as he can - need fresh ideas and Championship class coaching team next season. Very appreciative for what he’s done but the Sheffield Wednesday factor and points deductions to rivals has been our saviour this season
But if Leicester hadnt have had points deducted, i would hazard a guess they would have picked up more points elsewhere.
Im not retrospectively turning them into PSG, but its clearly had an impact on the team beyond the initial points lost.4 -
Yeah the deduction was just the nail in the coffin , they were relying so much on Fatawu wonder goals before thatfenaddick said:
They were in free fall long before the deduction I thinkDamoNorthStand said:ForeverAddickted said:
We're more than six points clear of Leicester...Oakster2 said:I feel Jones has taken us as far as he can - need fresh ideas and Championship class coaching team next season. Very appreciative for what he’s done but the Sheffield Wednesday factor and points deductions to rivals has been our saviour this season
But if Leicester hadnt have had points deducted, i would hazard a guess they would have picked up more points elsewhere.
Im not retrospectively turning them into PSG, but its clearly had an impact on the team beyond the initial points lost.2 -
Sponsored links:
-
Yes agree, I’m pretty sure I like Clarke, but he’s become very erratic, he does something really good or really bad with not much in between 🤷🏻♂️Scoham said:
Wing backs are a top priority too as Clarke and Chambers are on loan and part of the problem - their good moments going forward have been far too rare.Sword65pf said:
Our midfield has been our problem all season, nothing we can do now, but if it’s not the priority to replace all of it I’ll be pretty pissed off. Keep Carey but he would need to be scared of his place in the team at the very least.Chunes said:
I agree. Our midfield is absolutely honking, with or without him.Scoham said:
I’m not convinced any of our midfielders are good enough really, other than Carey when he’s on form.Leuth said:
He's good enough for our midfield, but Jones blames him for a goal or two so he's dropped him for the foreseeable even when he'd obviously have been the best choice todayScoham said:
It’s debatable but let’s not turn Conor Coventry into the Championship Pirlo.Leuth said:
He has Conor Coventry and he's decided to hold a grudge against him. IdiotCrispywood said:When you play to win in the moments you need your players to not be donkeys Jones has way too many of those at this level
Had we got the same result (or worse) with Coventry, others would have said why not play Coady with his experience and his record with us.0 -
He will rightly say that the way we set up today should have got us the win. Wednesday are atrocious and chucking a few long throws and flick ons into the penalty area should have been enough. When we countered and Carey got a chance for a second that should have been it but he missed. Defensively we were settled enough that one goal should have been enough but Mannion decided he was bored or something I guess. Jones has two big problems - one is that his players aren't really good enough so he can't rely on quality football, he's reliant on players taking the few chances they create, which they are currently allergic to doing. Second, when his way of playing doesn't work it is several magnitudes worse to witness than your average bad game under another manager. If we'd battered them, been unlucky not to win and dropped two points because of a goalkeeper error we would feel a bit more like Coventry probably felt the other day, but we're such a tough watch at the moment the temperature changes much quicker for him than for others.8
-
All I can say is if NJ is to continue with us he has to improve things, which to be fair playing style wise wouldn’t take a lot, however if he doesn’t he deserves all the pelters coming his way, because a repeat in approach next season we will be fucked!!0
-
Are you drunk?ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
I'm sorry you're deviating from the point here:ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
If you didn’t expect us to be doing better, then you have not been watching any of our matches. Fact. People need to get a grip and stop banging on about budget and playing football manager , looking at bits of paper.ForeverAddickted said:LittleAddick said:
I don't necessarily agree with those calls - but in my view we're past the point of calling them idiotic and pathetic. We genuinely can't score more than one goal, even against a team on -4 points.ForeverAddickted said:Should be thankful that people are calling for Jones' head againAs each time its happened so far, he's made those comments look idiotic and patheticThe question that always struggles to get answered with the Jones out callsIs what did you all expect at this stage of the season, that is being done differently?If you expected us to be doing worse, then we're doing betterIf you expected us to be doing better, then am sorry thats just naivity
look at the players on the pitch and how effing pitiful they are playing. If you don’t think they could and/or should be doing better, then you are the naive one!Survival is the target, its been the aim all season nothing more... nothing lessYet despite how pittiful we're playing, we're still in control of our destiny, we've still not entered the bottom threeSorry but those are the facts I'm looking at
Your comment - " if you expected us to be doing better, than am sorry thats just naivety"
my response is this a single simple question - "do you think the team should be playing better than they are?"
Please answer with one word only - yes or no
(and before answering would urge you to reflect on today's opponents, Preston and Watford's recent/current form)Its not a Yes or No answer... and you know it.Of course we all want to see Charlton playing better, but against opposition at this level with experience and nous, we'd get f**king slaughtered - So instead we play within our means, we grind our results by any means necessarily, and provided that we achieve the target that is survival... I dont care how that is achieved.Talking of form, as you've mentioned it, that (as I've stressed of late) is a lazy line, its another useless stat that has absolutely no meaning on future games... What happens in the past, has absolutely zero bearing on the future.Let me ask YOU this... Would you accept things, if we were playing better, but in Leicester's position currently?why are you trying to associate playing better with being in a worse position?! Playing better is generally likely to result in being in a better position. 😂
as I’ve said throughout the entire season, I’m not actually calling for Jones to be sacked. However, some of the contrived arguments people come out with to try and protect jones from criticism at all costs are mental.Disaggregate this from accounts; disaggregate this from our league position in February 2024; disaggregate this from Leicester’s playing style.Just look exclusively at the players/ squad we have and the matches we have been playing; I have watched pretty much every minute of every game this season. We have been toilet since October, pretty much entirely. I’m not even saying we should be playing a great style of football, we can play ugly- fine! But our players and squad should have been putting in, on average and over that period, better performances, and we should have been getting, on average and over that period, better results. 🤷♂️2 -
paulsturgess said:
Are you drunk?ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
I'm sorry you're deviating from the point here:ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
If you didn’t expect us to be doing better, then you have not been watching any of our matches. Fact. People need to get a grip and stop banging on about budget and playing football manager , looking at bits of paper.ForeverAddickted said:LittleAddick said:
I don't necessarily agree with those calls - but in my view we're past the point of calling them idiotic and pathetic. We genuinely can't score more than one goal, even against a team on -4 points.ForeverAddickted said:Should be thankful that people are calling for Jones' head againAs each time its happened so far, he's made those comments look idiotic and patheticThe question that always struggles to get answered with the Jones out callsIs what did you all expect at this stage of the season, that is being done differently?If you expected us to be doing worse, then we're doing betterIf you expected us to be doing better, then am sorry thats just naivity
look at the players on the pitch and how effing pitiful they are playing. If you don’t think they could and/or should be doing better, then you are the naive one!Survival is the target, its been the aim all season nothing more... nothing lessYet despite how pittiful we're playing, we're still in control of our destiny, we've still not entered the bottom threeSorry but those are the facts I'm looking at
Your comment - " if you expected us to be doing better, than am sorry thats just naivety"
my response is this a single simple question - "do you think the team should be playing better than they are?"
Please answer with one word only - yes or no
(and before answering would urge you to reflect on today's opponents, Preston and Watford's recent/current form)Its not a Yes or No answer... and you know it.Of course we all want to see Charlton playing better, but against opposition at this level with experience and nous, we'd get f**king slaughtered - So instead we play within our means, we grind our results by any means necessarily, and provided that we achieve the target that is survival... I dont care how that is achieved.Talking of form, as you've mentioned it, that (as I've stressed of late) is a lazy line, its another useless stat that has absolutely no meaning on future games... What happens in the past, has absolutely zero bearing on the future.Let me ask YOU this... Would you accept things, if we were playing better, but in Leicester's position currently?why are you trying to associate playing better with being in a worse position?! Playing better is generally likely to result in being in a better position. 😂
as I’ve said throughout the entire season, I’m not actually calling for Jones to be sacked. However, some of the contrived arguments people come out with to try and protect jones from criticism at all costs are mental.Disaggregate this from accounts; disaggregate this from our league position in February 2024; disaggregate this from Leicester’s playing style.Just look exclusively at the players/ squad we have and the matches we have been playing; I have watched pretty much every minute of every game this season. We have been toilet since October, pretty much entirely. I’m not even saying we should be playing a great style of football, we can play ugly- fine! But our players and squad should have been putting in, on average and over that period, better performances, and we should have been getting, on average and over that period, better results. 🤷♂️Apologies for not falling for your lazy "Yes" or "No" trapAm curious - Why SHOULD we have been puttng in better performances and results...?What is the reason for that... ?0 -
I don't buy into this "if we played any different we'd be worse" narrative.
6 -
Well as you love referring to accounting; because we have a championship budget but a number of the perfomances including today’s have been more akin to a league 2 budget!ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
Are you drunk?ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
I'm sorry you're deviating from the point here:ForeverAddickted said:paulsturgess said:
If you didn’t expect us to be doing better, then you have not been watching any of our matches. Fact. People need to get a grip and stop banging on about budget and playing football manager , looking at bits of paper.ForeverAddickted said:LittleAddick said:
I don't necessarily agree with those calls - but in my view we're past the point of calling them idiotic and pathetic. We genuinely can't score more than one goal, even against a team on -4 points.ForeverAddickted said:Should be thankful that people are calling for Jones' head againAs each time its happened so far, he's made those comments look idiotic and patheticThe question that always struggles to get answered with the Jones out callsIs what did you all expect at this stage of the season, that is being done differently?If you expected us to be doing worse, then we're doing betterIf you expected us to be doing better, then am sorry thats just naivity
look at the players on the pitch and how effing pitiful they are playing. If you don’t think they could and/or should be doing better, then you are the naive one!Survival is the target, its been the aim all season nothing more... nothing lessYet despite how pittiful we're playing, we're still in control of our destiny, we've still not entered the bottom threeSorry but those are the facts I'm looking at
Your comment - " if you expected us to be doing better, than am sorry thats just naivety"
my response is this a single simple question - "do you think the team should be playing better than they are?"
Please answer with one word only - yes or no
(and before answering would urge you to reflect on today's opponents, Preston and Watford's recent/current form)Its not a Yes or No answer... and you know it.Of course we all want to see Charlton playing better, but against opposition at this level with experience and nous, we'd get f**king slaughtered - So instead we play within our means, we grind our results by any means necessarily, and provided that we achieve the target that is survival... I dont care how that is achieved.Talking of form, as you've mentioned it, that (as I've stressed of late) is a lazy line, its another useless stat that has absolutely no meaning on future games... What happens in the past, has absolutely zero bearing on the future.Let me ask YOU this... Would you accept things, if we were playing better, but in Leicester's position currently?why are you trying to associate playing better with being in a worse position?! Playing better is generally likely to result in being in a better position. 😂
as I’ve said throughout the entire season, I’m not actually calling for Jones to be sacked. However, some of the contrived arguments people come out with to try and protect jones from criticism at all costs are mental.Disaggregate this from accounts; disaggregate this from our league position in February 2024; disaggregate this from Leicester’s playing style.Just look exclusively at the players/ squad we have and the matches we have been playing; I have watched pretty much every minute of every game this season. We have been toilet since October, pretty much entirely. I’m not even saying we should be playing a great style of football, we can play ugly- fine! But our players and squad should have been putting in, on average and over that period, better performances, and we should have been getting, on average and over that period, better results. 🤷♂️Apologies for not falling for your lazy "Yes" or "No" trapAm curious - Why SHOULD we have been puttng in better performances and results...?What is the reason for that... ?1 -
Couple of scenarios at play here, in terms of aspects to consider about how the football being served up impacts our club.
- Lets focus on the commercial impact on us as a club. The football being served up is inarguable dross, and whilst the hardcore will always go along, we are going to be relying on the remaining, say, 50% of our matchday fanbase to keep on coming too. Its boring and depressing to watch - we cant hide from that. If you are travelling 2 hours each way in the depths of winter and you know whats about to be served up....... well its only going to go one way.
There are signs its already having an effect. Loads of season ticket seats around me are empty every week. And commercially, our sponsorship revenue isn't exactly stellar. Any new deal this year came before the shake up. The football wont be helping if a lead comes along and watches Jones ball for 90 mins.
- Now performance on the pitch. We got found out this season from about late October onwards. So it will have to change this year as I am pretty sure if you extrapolate the season since November outwards we would be in the bottom 3. So if we dont go down - we will have to change things. Can NJ coach a side that plays more expansively? Honestly I dont know - but the people making the decisions will have to consider that.
If we go down? To bounce back everything about the club will need to be optimal because it isnt easy. When we bounced back to the prem in 99/2000 even after relegation there was energy at the club. It felt like we had momentum on the pitch, the fans were onside, and we came down with total clarity about what we stood for.
This time we would have snatched relegation from the jaws of safety. if you combine that with the football staying like this, we will lose the fanbase and struggle to recover.1 -
How many defenders does NJ start against Ipswich? It’s gonna be backs to the wall like at Boro2
-
I don't know, there's been a few things recently where I think as much as his game management isn't great at the moment some of Jones' judgments on the squad have been borne out. No-one wanted Dykes or Coady, especially not as a midfielder, but those have worked out well. People were calling for Mannion to come back in over Kaminksi, who he was apparently much better than, and now I think we've seen the reality of that. I think someone said it was 'scandalous' that we hadn't used Fullah more, but then he got more minutes against Preston and kept giving the ball away in dangerous areas which led to their goal. I think Jones sees the risks in certain ways of playing and takes the cautious route. Given that these players just refuse to score more than one goal I think the increasing stodge is a reaction to that. I don't think we'd like the version of this team that can't score goals AND is very openCroydon said:I don't buy into this "if we played any different we'd be worse" narrative.6 -
Sponsored links:
-
Try skill, athleticism and ability . We look_uptheaddicks said:The playing 11 either lacking confidence or motivation/desire. I can't work out which!
mid table league one0 -
Given the points deductions this is the most avoidable relegation ever. If it does happen it is an abject failure whichever way you look at it.5
-
I think we’ve also lost the surprise factor when we first came up, and teams have found ways around our high press, including games like Southampton at home which completely ripped it apart. We don’t look like Jones wants to risk playing that way again.Garrymanilow said:
I don't know, there's been a few things recently where I think as much as his game management isn't great at the moment some of Jones' judgments on the squad have been borne out. No-one wanted Dykes or Coady, especially not as a midfielder, but those have worked out well. People were calling for Mannion to come back in over Kaminksi, who he was apparently much better than, and now I think we've seen the reality of that. I think someone said it was 'scandalous' that we hadn't used Fullah more, but then he got more minutes against Preston and kept giving the ball away in dangerous areas which led to their goal. I think Jones sees the risks in certain ways of playing and takes the cautious route. Given that these players just refuse to score more than one goal I think the increasing stodge is a reaction to that. I don't think we'd like the version of this team that can't score goals AND is very openCroydon said:I don't buy into this "if we played any different we'd be worse" narrative.
If we stay up I hope we’ll become a higher pressing team again. With the right signings we could develop into a mid table side and progress from there. Make the wrong signings and it’ll be more of the style we’ve seen recently, and that won’t ever achieve anything more than being in relegation battles.
5 -
Why do we take 10 mins to make subs? They seem to strip off, then seemingly have to pick their lunch options on an iPad, have a 5 mins pep talk from Curtis Fleming, then play with their boots and socks for another 2 mins before allowed to come on, it's bizarre5
-
We've been fairly awful for a lot of the season and two of the bottom sides have had points deducted. Some of our victories have been more down to luck in games where we've been battered and have relied on our opponents missing numerous chances.
We play with limited possession, create very little and just invite pressure...
I'm not clear if NJ can play a different style. It is a depressing watch and very pedestrian...6 -
Not really though. Wednesday have been a weird one but they've also pushed up the average points needed. We'd be ahead of Leicester even without their points deduction and we've got one of the lowest budgets in the league. The reality is if we stay up we've done it with a team mostly made up of last season's L1 team and other players who stood out in L1 as well as a bit more experience added in January. We spent as much on all our transfer business as some teams have spent on individual players in the past few years. The fact that we're three games from the end and six points clear is a brilliant position to be in and survival would be a great achievement. The weakest, poorest team up from L1 last season going back down would not be an abject failure by any stretchAberystwythAddick said:Given the points deductions this is the most avoidable relegation ever. If it does happen it is an abject failure whichever way you look at it.4 -
Exceeding pre-season expectations and people are dissatisfied. Please can you all stop embarrassing yourselves.2
-
Aim low and we shouldn’t miss
2 -
It’s not a high press. There was absolutely zero attempts to press higher and win the ball back quickly when we lost it in the final third.Scoham said:
I think we’ve also lost the surprise factor when we first came up, and teams have found ways around our high press, including games like Southampton at home which completely ripped it apart. We don’t look like Jones wants to risk playing that way again.Garrymanilow said:
I don't know, there's been a few things recently where I think as much as his game management isn't great at the moment some of Jones' judgments on the squad have been borne out. No-one wanted Dykes or Coady, especially not as a midfielder, but those have worked out well. People were calling for Mannion to come back in over Kaminksi, who he was apparently much better than, and now I think we've seen the reality of that. I think someone said it was 'scandalous' that we hadn't used Fullah more, but then he got more minutes against Preston and kept giving the ball away in dangerous areas which led to their goal. I think Jones sees the risks in certain ways of playing and takes the cautious route. Given that these players just refuse to score more than one goal I think the increasing stodge is a reaction to that. I don't think we'd like the version of this team that can't score goals AND is very openCroydon said:I don't buy into this "if we played any different we'd be worse" narrative.
If we stay up I hope we’ll become a higher pressing team again. With the right signings we could develop into a mid table side and progress from there. Make the wrong signings and it’ll be more of the style we’ve seen recently, and that won’t ever achieve anything more than being in relegation battles.0 -
I'd stick with him but if the ownership have serious ambition of propelling this club up the league then I don't think it will be with Jones at the helm..His passive-passive war of attrition football only gets u so far...It might get us relegated yet.
My one concern is progression of attacking talent within the squad. He is , to my mind incapable of improving them. Fine. It's not his bag. He needs to be honest with himself and the club and get someone competent enough to improve that area.1










