Just watched it back. Never a penalty! Shocking decision tbf.
Why do you think no penalty?
Too close IMHO
I always say it's a pen if the oppo player stop the ball going to another player. If his arm wasn't in the way the ball would have either been on target or gone to a team mate. It's one we don't usually get but imo was the correct decision.
Also surprised the other incident that got my goat hasn't been mentioned......the injured player who after been treated by their physio didn't go off the pitch !! Ref was a complete numpty.
As for the rest of the game. Turgid. No real attacking threat apart from Taylor in the 15 mins before he was sent off. LB has the sending off & the penalty to save him from getting pelters this evening. Shocking performance all round.
This forum would be in absolute meltdown if such a soft decision had been given against us. There is no way the accy player deliberately handled the ball.
Meh. We won. Everything else doesn’t matter a jot.
And we’re a few points off first place! How many points were we behind Pompey 10 weeks ago? We’re the best team in this league-we just need to keep it rolling.....
Learn the (newish) rules @golfaddick- if a player requires treatment after a FOUL, he no longer has to leave the pitch.
When did that rule come in ?? Not seen a player this season NOT have to go off after being treated.......and if you are injured & need treatment it is usually because you have been fouled.
This forum would be in absolute meltdown if such a soft decision had been given against us. There is no way the accy player deliberately handled the ball.
Rubbish. He had his arm up in the penalty area and it got in the way of an attacking pass/ shot. Penalty every day.
This forum would be in absolute meltdown if such a soft decision had been given against us. There is no way the accy player deliberately handled the ball.
Surprised nobody has singled Bielik out for special praise in the brawl. Went charging in to aid Taylor, knocking a few around in the process. Think he realised he might have overstepped the mark so retreated to the halfway line rather sheepishly
This forum would be in absolute meltdown if such a soft decision had been given against us. There is no way the accy player deliberately handled the ball.
Rubbish. He had his arm up in the penalty area and it got in the way of an attacking pass/ shot. Penalty every day.
And his arm was moving when in contact with the ball, so should be a clear case of hand to ball - penalty.
Prior to the sending off and the holding up of the corner for jostling involving Taylor and Maxted, I said to the people around me Taylor has got to keep out of the way, course he didn't and then was sent off 30 seconds later, I don't agree with either sending off but sometimes you have to use common sense.
This forum would be in absolute meltdown if such a soft decision had been given against us. There is no way the accy player deliberately handled the ball.
Not even nearly as soft as the pen Peterborough won against us!
Blimey what a contrasting afternoon from a very civilised pre match Q&A with their gent of an owner to a mass brawl. Shouted myself hoarse - meant to be on Charlton Live show tomorrow so better keep quiet this evening to make sure I have a voice. Can't call us Southern Softies after that.
I was in family stand sort of behind the Lino with a “birds eye view” and shouted penalty but in reality I’d have been fuming if it was the other way , I don’t think you can expect players to have their arms glued to their body as they’re looking for balance and to push one way or the other as players run at them but we’ll take it . Stanley clearly have a few proper helmets playing for them but I don’t know if some expect a team prollly with a budget less than half or more than that of ours to play like Brazil against us . They’re gonna have to mix it up to try and beat clearly better footballing teams . We had a little bit of pressure today but their keeper made one save of note I thought whilst Philips first save was a certain goal stopped with his Peter Schmeicel style block from just a few yards out and another spectacular tip over second half . As for the sending off I couldn’t really see because I was sitting down as everyone else jumped up . I knew immediately the ref was gonna blow up against Lyle after having a word previously . In the build up to that corner Lyles hand off was ridiculous and make no mistake if all these incidents had happened the other way round the tear drops from our fans on here would be endless . Everyone saying this bloke that bloke should have been sent off , in reality during real time without having looked at the replays who in all honesty on here could have called what happened in that melee , it was carnage . Karlan Grant , wow , I am one of his biggest doubters and I really didn’t fancy him to score that pen after the two previous not so convincing efforts but he struck that so cleanly under that amount of pressure , it was brilliant. Then the celebrations , we had a personality , boys on the pitch I love it , all clubs apart from dull old us do that and it was brilliant to see , although I understand it may not be everyone’s cup of tea . It was my eldest sons 13th and he had a shout out at half time that I actually didn’t hear cos was too busy handing cakes out to friends and family (boycotts broken by a few of my family cos Kids For A Quid and to see my son , although I was disgusted at the fucking purchasing of food and beverages by them !! ) And he was buzzing his nuts off with the late winner and said it was the best birthday present .
Anyway being a miserable fucker let’s end on a sour note , saw a few bottles being lobbed on/towards the pitch , proper muggy behaviour and I understand everyone’s got the hump but we’d been given a penalty ffs when one bottle was thrown on . Leave that cuntishness to our neighbours down the road .
Anyway a celebratory Pizza Express finished off a fine day and has reignited my IBS at 4.30am
Just watched it back. Never a penalty! Shocking decision tbf.
I can't believe how many people on here think it was obvious. It was obviously not. How can you take your arm away from the ball when it is smacked at you from 4 yards away?
I'm obviously delighted that we won, but you would be absolutely fuming if you were you a Stanley fan.
He is in the box with his hands in the air and the shot is on target I don’t know how more obvious you can get! You block a shot like that with your arms to your sides! He may have only been 4 yards away but it wasn’t a shot out of nowhere he was shaping to shoot all along and the defender knew this!
Solly deserves a lot of credit for sprinting over and shielding the lino after their players absolutely went for him. Surprised it hasn’t been mentioned.
If you look at the footage of the celebrations directly after KG scores a certain someone comes onto the pitch out of the NW Quadrant.....a very big fella with a bald head. Can it be.....surely not?
Solly deserves a lot of credit for sprinting over and shielding the lino after their players absolutely went for him. Surprised it hasn’t been mentioned.
I saw this clearly - the Accy players behaviour towards the lino was pretty awful. The ref failed to take action.
Comments
Also surprised the other incident that got my goat hasn't been mentioned......the injured player who after been treated by their physio didn't go off the pitch !! Ref was a complete numpty.
As for the rest of the game. Turgid. No real attacking threat apart from Taylor in the 15 mins before he was sent off. LB has the sending off & the penalty to save him from getting pelters this evening. Shocking performance all round.
And we’re a few points off first place! How many points were we behind Pompey 10 weeks ago? We’re the best team in this league-we just need to keep it rolling.....
I've watched it in slo-mo and froze it at various points ..... as Reeves prepares to shoot, the Stanley defender has his arm down low by his side.
Freeze the frame immediately after Reeves shoots, the arm has moved higher.
Freeze at the moment of contact with the ball, the arm is higher still.
IMO it's quite clear that the arm is moving, and the correct decision is hand to ball - penalty.
Slow mo
Stanley clearly have a few proper helmets playing for them but I don’t know if some expect a team prollly with a budget less than half or more than that of ours to play like Brazil against us .
They’re gonna have to mix it up to try and beat clearly better footballing teams .
We had a little bit of pressure today but their keeper made one save of note I thought whilst Philips first save was a certain goal stopped with his Peter Schmeicel style block from just a few yards out and another spectacular tip over second half .
As for the sending off I couldn’t really see because I was sitting down as everyone else jumped up .
I knew immediately the ref was gonna blow up against Lyle after having a word previously .
In the build up to that corner Lyles hand off was ridiculous and make no mistake if all these incidents had happened the other way round the tear drops from our fans on here would be endless .
Everyone saying this bloke that bloke should have been sent off , in reality during real time without having looked at the replays who in all honesty on here could have called what happened in that melee , it was carnage .
Karlan Grant , wow , I am one of his biggest doubters and I really didn’t fancy him to score that pen after the two previous not so convincing efforts but he struck that so cleanly under that amount of pressure , it was brilliant.
Then the celebrations , we had a personality , boys on the pitch I love it , all clubs apart from dull old us do that and it was brilliant to see , although I understand it may not be everyone’s cup of tea .
It was my eldest sons 13th and he had a shout out at half time that I actually didn’t hear cos was too busy handing cakes out to friends and family (boycotts broken by a few of my family cos Kids For A Quid and to see my son , although I was disgusted at the fucking purchasing of food and beverages by them !! )
And he was buzzing his nuts off with the late winner and said it was the best birthday present .
Anyway being a miserable fucker let’s end on a sour note , saw a few bottles being lobbed on/towards the pitch , proper muggy behaviour and I understand everyone’s got the hump but we’d been given a penalty ffs when one bottle was thrown on .
Leave that cuntishness to our neighbours down the road .
Anyway a celebratory Pizza Express finished off a fine day and has reignited my IBS at 4.30am
e i e i e i o
Can it be.....surely not?
The ref failed to take action.
a player is injured as the result of a physical offence for which the opponent is cautioned or sent off (e.g. reckless or serious foul challenge), if the assessment/treatment is completed quickly
http://www.thefa.com/football-rules-governance/lawsandrules/laws/football-11-11/law-5---the-referee