Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Macauley Bonne joins QPR for £2m (Ed. Joined Ipswich on loan)
Comments
-
Not sure about the comments of him being a good finisher.. He missed some absolute sitters for us, and some big big chances towards the back end of the championship season, if he had put them away, it may have been a different story.
Given maybe his finishing has been better for Ipswich(we only see the highlights) even then, he has miss of the season.... would like to see his goals to chances ratio...3 -
Mid table league one player. Glad he got his ‘bigger’ move.2
-
Fatty BonneBonne looked very average. I was with my brother in law who is an Ipswich fan and he was more frustrated with Bonne complaining and waving his arms around rather than trying to make things happen. We both thought Bonne looked overweight.
If you’re the single striker you have to make the centre backs work and our guys could have been sharing a cigar.1 -
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/league-one/top-scorers
His stats compare well with the other L1 leading scorers2 -
He spent 90% of the match in off side positions. At one point in the second half he looked down the line, saw he was offside and just stood there. He didn't get service but even if ipswich did offer anything, they couldn't play him in because of his poor positioning.
I loved it late on the game when Pearce went down, Bonne stood there with his arms in the air to say "that wasn't a foul",the ref didn't give it, Pearce stood up and came away with the ball with Bonne still standing there arms aloft1 -
Ipswich overall were shite last night, even playing the magic Charlton Reject duo of Piggot and Bonne together at the end didn't culminate in anything1
-
Piggot moves around with the ball a bit better than I expected. He'll be stuck there on high wages now unless really loves football and moves.0
-
Bonne was never worth the fee we got for him. Daylight robbery. He’ll carve a career for himself and good luck to him. If he gets a Championship gig again I’ll be amazed. League one at best. I suspect he’ll be a perennial loanee.3
-
At least Bonne has made it in the game unlike lower league goalscorers like Chris Dickson! Good on him and for getting his club such a fee.7
-
11 goals in 20 for a rubbish Ipswich side and we still right him off lol based on one game (ok probably his history with us too), in the championship he got 11 from 30 irrc which was again decent in a poor side. He doesn't offer much off the ball or build up like our strikers did but one poor performance cant dismiss he is clearly more of a natural striker. Would i have him instead of Stockely or Washington? No chance6
- Sponsored links:
-
He's not as bad as people make out and he did well for us considering he was signed for the future. I wouldn't have him ahead of Stockley or Washington though.8
-
Thought he was poor last night but fucking hell he hardly had one decent pass all game! Nothing against the fella really, good luck to him, but I enjoyed the fact he had a frustrating evening. Makes a change from former players returning to haunt us time and time again.2
-
He didn't get a pass because Dobson, Lee and Gilbey absolutely dominated their midfield, that and even if he got the pass, he was constantly 2 yards off side, and never checked/bent a run to be onside when those balls came. Compared to Connor who backed his pace and was happy to be on the move against the centre half1
-
I'd take Bonne back for sure, whether he'd start over Stockley/Washington is another matter but the guy can finish!5
-
I thought he was very poor last night but tbf had little service,
Enjoyed him complaining about the ref giving a free kick to Jason P, he hadn't, and Pearcy played on and left him in his rear view still moaning.
Glad the sex offender song fell flat throughout however, rubbish, generic, nonsense.0 -
Wouldn't have him ahead of Stockley or Washington no, but, on the bench instead of Davison, Yes.
5 -
I'd rather have 2 million pounds than a substitute striker, though3
-
oohaahmortimer said:He’s pony - move on
Would you swap Stockley or Washington for him …. NopeIt's interesting how things can change isn't it. I've always liked Washington and Stockley, but I wonder how many people would have agreed with you back at the end of October before Jackson took over, when Bonne had 10 goals in 12 games (playing for a fairly crap Ipswich side), Washington had 1 in 10 (a penalty) and Stockley had 4 in 13 and had been dropped for a back-up 22 year old. I think the reality is that most strikers at this level are really dependent on a lot of factors around their play including set-up, playing style and their own happiness. If they could keep up their form and score no matter what they'd be playing at a higher level.Looking at Bonne's goals, it's also quite interesting that his 11 goals this season have only really directly been worth 8 of their 27 points. He saved a point against Morecambe and got both in a draw against MK Dons, scored the only goal in a win against Lincoln and the winner against Shrewsbury. Other than that he scored in losses or total shellackings, getting 1 each time in wins of 4-1, 4-0 and 6-0. Despite all his goals he's not deciding matches, which is a problem we had with him at the tail end of the last Championship season when Lyle went on sabbatical. I don't watch Ipswich because life is hard enough as it is, but I wonder how many key chances he's missed in the matches where they've dropped points.2 -
If he came in on loan in January I would be pleased.2
-
When Washington or Bonne get a one on one chance I never think they’ll score0
- Sponsored links:
-
If I had to choose, I'd re-sign Pigs ahead of Bonne. In a positive team he adds more.0
-
I'd have him back in a heartbeat, incredible finisher9
-
Except when he was 1 on 1 with the millwall keeper. Except when we were 1 up at Birmingham and the ball fell to him 5 yards out with the goal at his mercyPelling1993 said:I'd have him back in a heartbeat, incredible finisher3 -
Wouldnt want him back. Goes missing too much in games and ends up being a passenger.2
-
No other strikers ever miss chances.Todds_right_hook said:
Except when he was 1 on 1 with the millwall keeper. Except when we were 1 up at Birmingham and the ball fell to him 5 yards out with the goal at his mercyPelling1993 said:I'd have him back in a heartbeat, incredible finisher2 -
Pigs would be a better backup to Stockley certainly than DavisonJonniesta said:If I had to choose, I'd re-sign Pigs ahead of Bonne. In a positive team he adds more.0 -
Judge him on his record so far this season not just last night.
Another example would be Michael Smith at Rotherham, got a great record over the last few seasons but didn't really trouble us when we played them recently.3 -
Of course. I just think using the word incredible to describe Macauley bonnes finishing skills is over the top. Ronaldo, messi and Robert Rosario can be described as incredible but Bonne?hoof_it_up_to_benty said:
No other strikers ever miss chances.Todds_right_hook said:
Except when he was 1 on 1 with the millwall keeper. Except when we were 1 up at Birmingham and the ball fell to him 5 yards out with the goal at his mercyPelling1993 said:I'd have him back in a heartbeat, incredible finisher
he is a good league 1 player but if he was incredible, he would be playing in the champions league.1 -
https://twitter.com/socceram/status/1427978596765818884?s=21Pelling1993 said:I'd have him back in a heartbeat, incredible finisher
2 -
Pigott would be a better backup to Stockley than Bonne. But why would he consider coming here. If he is frustrated with playing time there better options than us1
