Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Portsmouth v Charlton | Post-match thread | Saturday 31st October 2020
Comments
-
It was one-footed. Out of control and if he'd hit the guy he'd have been off, but it wasn't quite as bad as you're making outFishCostaFortune said:
So if you make a two footed, studs up challenge, and the opposition player is fortunate enough to jump out the way just in time you don't think it should be a red - even though the intent was the same?Leuth said:Surprised at all the comments saying Pratley should have been off. I think it was a yellow but to get a red for that you need to make contact5 -
Next game hopefully mate.happyvalley said:It's about time we had some bloody 4-0 wins.0 -
Not sure I agree with that, can be sent off for a reckless challenge without making contact can’t you?Leuth said:Surprised at all the comments saying Pratley should have been off. I think it was a yellow but to get a red for that you need to make contact2 -
For me personally if you are admitting the tackle was reckless enough that he would have been sent off if he made contact with the player, then he should have been sent off. The intent is exactly the same in both instances.Leuth said:
It was one-footed. Out of control and if he'd hit the guy he'd have been off, but it wasn't quite as bad as you're making outFishCostaFortune said:
So if you make a two footed, studs up challenge, and the opposition player is fortunate enough to jump out the way just in time you don't think it should be a red - even though the intent was the same?Leuth said:Surprised at all the comments saying Pratley should have been off. I think it was a yellow but to get a red for that you need to make contact
3 -
odds now slashed to 9/2.....after Doncaster defeat we went out to 33/1 to win the league.2
-
Idk, I think there's a massive difference. If you make a lunging tackle in such a way as to still avoid hitting the opponent, I think that is very different to a lunging tackle where you clean them out1
-
It's All Hallows Eve, the night of ghosts, spirits, phantoms, and Leuth passionately defending Darren Pratley15
-
Not if you're big Dazza Pratley obviously. 😁cafcfan1990 said:
Not sure I agree with that, can be sent off for a reckless challenge without making contact can’t you?Leuth said:Surprised at all the comments saying Pratley should have been off. I think it was a yellow but to get a red for that you need to make contact0 -
10/1 with William HillWhenIwasLittleBoy said:odds now slashed to 9/2.....after Doncaster defeat we went out to 33/1 to win the league.0 -
You're right it wasn't a clear red, but it was a clear yellow that with some refs could've been a red, and was completely unnecessary.5
- Sponsored links:
-
Very generous odds0
-
Its helped you've finally seen that any crossfield passes Naby can do... Darren can do them betterLeuth said:It's All Hallows Eve, the night of ghosts, spirits, phantoms, and Leuth passionately defending Darren Pratley2 -
His passing was actually really good today, it was weird.1
-
I think Pratley scared the sh*t out of the ref! Was at least a yellow.1
-
Fancy this, an owner who is not only interested in the outcome of games but also actually follows the game while it’s happening..ross1 said:24 -
Some posters pretty adamant that Pratley should have been sent off.
The referee, of course, is the sole arbiter and his decision is always final. After an offence, this what he must consider before making his decision:
This is what the Laws of the game say: Law 12 -Fouls and misconduct
https://www.thefa.com/football-rules-governance/lawsandrules/laws/football-11-11/law-12---fouls-and-misconductDirect free kick
A direct free kick is awarded if a player commits any of the following offences against an opponent in a manner considered by the referee to be careless, reckless or using excessive force:- charges
- jumps at
- kicks or attempts to kick
- pushes
- strikes or attempts to strike (including head-butt)
- tackles or challenges
- trips or attempts to trip
If an offence involves contact it is penalised by a direct free kick or penalty kick.- Careless is when a player shows a lack of attention or consideration when making a challenge or acts without precaution. No disciplinary sanction is needed
- Reckless is when a player acts with disregard to the danger to, or consequences for, an opponent and must be cautioned
- Using excessive force is when a player exceeds the necessary use of force and endangers the safety of an opponent and must be sent off
5 -
It's probably been said already, but let's not forget dear Thomas Sandgaard in all of this. A man who spent millions of pounds on us and without whom, we would not be where we are niw.29
-
I believe you're getting warm, @Leuth.Leuth said:Idk, I think there's a massive difference. If you make a lunging tackle in such a way as to still avoid hitting the opponent, I think that is very different to a lunging tackle where you clean them out
Would you consider that Pratley's offence was considered by the referee to be:
a) careless
b) reckless
c) using excessive force
NB: You may refer to my post (re Law 12) above.
0 -
Wonder why an experienced player like Pratley thought it was worth risking a red card to win a throw-in on the halfway line. Bizarre.2
-
Ha ha somebody laughs because I post an extract from the Laws of the Game.
I know, that has no place on a football forum.
1 - Sponsored links:
-
Leuth said:His passing was actually really good today, it was weird.
What is that saying about converts being the most strident supporters of a cause.4 -
As always its nice to hear some decent comments towards us on Quest
As the bloke has pointed out from the podcast, whats impressive about us at the moment is we're barely even giving sides chances to score
Its not even last ditch defending like what we saw @ Portsmouth in 18/19 with Lapslie taking it in the face3 -
in Jackett’s interview he said their fella felt his hamstring at half time so they took him off
Bowyer said ‘he (Famewo) was tight the other night. We thought It might be from his back and with it being Saturday, Tuesday, Saturday, Tuesday… it’s tough. Unfortunately, he’s just tweaked it there a little bit I think."
You just know their fella will be back quicker than ours2 -
So would you have dropped him and played Pratley in his place?oohaahmortimer said:in Jackett’s interview he said their fella felt his hamstring at half time so they took him off
Bowyer said ‘he (Famewo) was tight the other night. We thought It might be from his back and with it being Saturday, Tuesday, Saturday, Tuesday… it’s tough. Unfortunately, he’s just tweaked it there a little bit I think."
You just know their fella will be back quicker than ours0 -
9
-
10/1 with Skybet too. Portsmouth 8/1!cafcfan1990 said:
10/1 with William HillWhenIwasLittleBoy said:odds now slashed to 9/2.....after Doncaster defeat we went out to 33/1 to win the league.
Don't quite understand that.0 -
A small collection of Pompey comments
http://thepompeychimes.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=78777&sid=48be5f039155e8fb350fdf95faf4d5f6
0 -
If your getting 10/1 on promotion you should jump on thatcafcfan1990 said:
10/1 with William HillWhenIwasLittleBoy said:odds now slashed to 9/2.....after Doncaster defeat we went out to 33/1 to win the league.0 -
Indeed, being able to grind out comfortable wins is a very nice habitForeverAddickted said:As always its nice to hear some decent comments towards us on Quest
As the bloke has pointed out from the podcast, whats impressive about us at the moment is we're barely even giving sides chances to score
Its not even last ditch defending like what we saw @ Portsmouth in 18/19 with Lapslie taking it in the face
Interesting that they didn't mention the Pratley challenge, and Jackett didn't make much out of it either, but then he's always been a classy manager4 -
Yeah was great to hear Jackett focusing on what his team did wrong and what we did well rather than moaning about what could have beenkillerandflash said:
Indeed, being able to grind out comfortable wins is a very nice habitForeverAddickted said:As always its nice to hear some decent comments towards us on Quest
As the bloke has pointed out from the podcast, whats impressive about us at the moment is we're barely even giving sides chances to score
Its not even last ditch defending like what we saw @ Portsmouth in 18/19 with Lapslie taking it in the face
Interesting that they didn't mention the Pratley challenge, and Jackett didn't make much out of it either, but then he's always been a classy manager9
