Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Has Bowyer lost it?

15859616364158

Comments

  • cafctom said:
    The whole “where are the Bowyer in/out crowd” type comments quite common on social media after a game are becoming tedious.

    I’m not “Bowyer out”, but I’m more along the lines of “I really want it to work under Bowyer, but can’t see it happening long term”. Thankfully it’s not my decision as to whether he stays, goes, who replaces him etc. 

    What I will say though is that a 2-0 win away at Rochdale doesn’t change my view on Bowyer for better or worse, because quite frankly, that’s a result we should be getting.

    Where I’ll judge Bowyer is over a string of games or a period of time. Over the past year it hasn’t been good enough - and yes, I do put some of the Championship relegation on him. 

    If he gets to the end of the season, then so be it, it’s not as if the club is going to fold if we stay in League One for another season and we don’t go up. 

    But if we take the rose-tinted glasses off and stop talking about loyalty and the excuses - he hasn’t been good enough for about 12 months. Again - a win away at Rochdale doesn’t change that all of a sudden 
    Superb post young man.
  • Sunderland view on Lee Johnson after they replaced their Manager...


  • Sunderland view on Lee Johnson after they replaced their Manager...


    That’s because they employed Lee Johnson. Highly overrated.
  • Sunderland view on Lee Johnson after they replaced their Manager...


    That’s because they employed Lee Johnson. Highly overrated.
    Better than sex? 
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited February 2021
    cafctom said:
    cafctom said:

    Where I’ll judge Bowyer is over a string of games or a period of time. Over the past year it hasn’t been good enough - and yes, I do put some of the Championship relegation on him. 
    This is insane. Even Pep Guardiola would’ve struggled to keep us up.
    “Insane”...really? Ok.

    In my post I stated that I put some of the responsibility for the relegation on Bowyer. Not all of it. He was dealt a tough hand.

    But it was still his decision making which lead to us throwing away points in injury time on many occasions.

    Would Pep Guardiola have gone into a must win final game of the season against the champions elect and started an inexperienced Josh Davison up front, instead of Chuks Aneke?

    When we were relegated, I did not state that I wanted Bowyer out. He deserved the chance to have a clean slate and start afresh. But now that the same excuses cannot be put in his favour for our poor performances, it does shine bit of a light on how Bowyer’s decision making likely did have an impact on our Championship relegation.
    I don't think we would have got anything from Leeds however we played or set up. There were a few games where we went ultra negative which cost us points.
  • edited February 2021
    I note that Lockdown in the UK started almost exactly two years after Lee Bowyer became manager of Charlton Athletic.

    Two years, shy of one week.

    Just saying.
  • What age bracket do football managers statistically "peak"?

    It's got to be relevent experience and enthusiasm combined.

    If and when you hit the 60s 70s bracket...you probably hit a personal decline and or the games moved on from what you brought to the table.

    Alladyce is on that road
  • Dazzler21 said:
    Personally we need to have one or two formations not 6 or 7 we try to move between.
    What 6 or 7 have we played with this season?
  • edited February 2021
    SamE7 said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    Personally we need to have one or two formations not 6 or 7 we try to move between.
    What 6 or 7 have we played with this season?
    The 6 or 7 reported on BBC Sport and Transfermarkt. 

    4-1-4-1 (4-5-1 on BBC) Used 2 times
    4-4-2 F Used 7 times
    4-4-2 D Used 5 times
    3-5-2 F Used 1 time
    4-3-3  Used 6 times
    4-3-1-2 (Could argue this was a 4-4-2 diamond) Used 5 times
    3-4-3 Used 1 time
  • Not in the Bowyer out camp or he must stay. Rochdale was what we need to reproduce week in week out from now on. We do that and everybody’s happy. We don’t and just like every other manager who doesn’t meet expectations he’ll be gone. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • cafctom said:
    cafctom said:

    Where I’ll judge Bowyer is over a string of games or a period of time. Over the past year it hasn’t been good enough - and yes, I do put some of the Championship relegation on him. 
    This is insane. Even Pep Guardiola would’ve struggled to keep us up.
    “Insane”...really? Ok.

    In my post I stated that I put some of the responsibility for the relegation on Bowyer. Not all of it. He was dealt a tough hand.

    But it was still his decision making which lead to us throwing away points in injury time on many occasions.

    Would Pep Guardiola have gone into a must win final game of the season against the champions elect and started an inexperienced Josh Davison up front, instead of Chuks Aneke?

    When we were relegated, I did not state that I wanted Bowyer out. He deserved the chance to have a clean slate and start afresh. But now that the same excuses cannot be put in his favour for our poor performances, it does shine bit of a light on how Bowyer’s decision making likely did have an impact on our Championship relegation.
    I don't think we would have got anything from Leeds however we played or set up. There were a few games where we went ultra negative which cost us points.
    I agree - But the point being that going into a must win game against a top side, why would you still be tinkering with a line up to put in a largely inexperienced player when you have your best available player on the bench? It doesn’t add up. 
  • edited February 2021
    Yes, but against Leeds it is natural to try to find a way. I think that in itself is a quality. Always look for a way. When you play against a team much better than you it is right to be negative. I have more of a problem when we are negative and we don't need to be. 

    I thought we were positive against Rochdale, but it is just one game. I need to see that approach a few more times, starting on Saturday. Not having a midweek match should allow Stockley and Aneke to start again. I think we need to see this and get the ball forwards to them quicker with less passes. like we did against Rochdale. I think our passing game has been painful to watch at times this season.
  • Even though I can’t stand that big geezer Steve Evans he’s a very good manager for this division and will have studied us in great detail for Saturday game. 

    Need to ensure we don’t give away a silly goal on Saturday. Hoping Bowyer will be addressing that to the players throughout the week. as if we go 1-0 down the time wasting tactics will be out in full force.
  • Even though I can’t stand that big geezer Steve Evans he’s a very good manager for this division and will have studied us in great detail for Saturday game. 

    Need to ensure we don’t give away a silly goal on Saturday. Hoping Bowyer will be addressing that to the players throughout the week. as if we go 1-0 down the time wasting tactics will be out in full force.
    How many teams has he got promoted from it?

    He's a very average manager at this level, decent the level beneath though.
  • Dazzler21 said:
    Even though I can’t stand that big geezer Steve Evans he’s a very good manager for this division and will have studied us in great detail for Saturday game. 

    Need to ensure we don’t give away a silly goal on Saturday. Hoping Bowyer will be addressing that to the players throughout the week. as if we go 1-0 down the time wasting tactics will be out in full force.
    How many teams has he got promoted from it?

    He's a very average manager at this level, decent the level beneath though.
    Bit harsh, he didn’t get a full season at  Peterborough and now at Gillingham who don’t have the resources to get top players for this league. 
  • SamB09 said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    Even though I can’t stand that big geezer Steve Evans he’s a very good manager for this division and will have studied us in great detail for Saturday game. 

    Need to ensure we don’t give away a silly goal on Saturday. Hoping Bowyer will be addressing that to the players throughout the week. as if we go 1-0 down the time wasting tactics will be out in full force.
    How many teams has he got promoted from it?

    He's a very average manager at this level, decent the level beneath though.
    Bit harsh, he didn’t get a full season at  Peterborough and now at Gillingham who don’t have the resources to get top players for this league. 
    A very good manager doesn't need the best players 
  • Dazzler21 said:
    SamB09 said:
    Dazzler21 said:
    Even though I can’t stand that big geezer Steve Evans he’s a very good manager for this division and will have studied us in great detail for Saturday game. 

    Need to ensure we don’t give away a silly goal on Saturday. Hoping Bowyer will be addressing that to the players throughout the week. as if we go 1-0 down the time wasting tactics will be out in full force.
    How many teams has he got promoted from it?

    He's a very average manager at this level, decent the level beneath though.
    Bit harsh, he didn’t get a full season at  Peterborough and now at Gillingham who don’t have the resources to get top players for this league. 
    A very good manager doesn't need the best players 
    So how do you rate Klopp, Guardiola, Wenger(when arsenal were good), Chris Powell when he had the backing to sign the best players in league one, Alex Ferguson. I could go on on for a while here.

    yes there will be the odd exception like leicester but you get the general idea.
  • How did they get to those roles? They worked up to them, winning things with lesser players.
  • edited February 2021
    cafctom said:
    cafctom said:
    cafctom said:

    Where I’ll judge Bowyer is over a string of games or a period of time. Over the past year it hasn’t been good enough - and yes, I do put some of the Championship relegation on him. 
    This is insane. Even Pep Guardiola would’ve struggled to keep us up.
    “Insane”...really? Ok.

    In my post I stated that I put some of the responsibility for the relegation on Bowyer. Not all of it. He was dealt a tough hand.

    But it was still his decision making which lead to us throwing away points in injury time on many occasions.

    Would Pep Guardiola have gone into a must win final game of the season against the champions elect and started an inexperienced Josh Davison up front, instead of Chuks Aneke?

    When we were relegated, I did not state that I wanted Bowyer out. He deserved the chance to have a clean slate and start afresh. But now that the same excuses cannot be put in his favour for our poor performances, it does shine bit of a light on how Bowyer’s decision making likely did have an impact on our Championship relegation.
    I don't think we would have got anything from Leeds however we played or set up. There were a few games where we went ultra negative which cost us points.
    I agree - But the point being that going into a must win game against a top side, why would you still be tinkering with a line up to put in a largely inexperienced player when you have your best available player on the bench? It doesn’t add up. 
    A bit of revisionism going on here IMO. There were people on this forum calling him 1 goal Chuks up until September even. Davison had played well in cameo appearances and scored as many goals as Chuks had at that point.
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!