“Then, someone he knew had Covid.And obviously he had that ankle injury, didn’t he. So, Marcus Maddison is not training.
“I’ve not seen him for a few days. I think I saw him yesterday from a distance with the fitness people, ticking boxes.
“Ticking the box to see if he could start training again. But he’s not been in and around us for a few days now.”
The last time I saw comments as ambiguous as those was when I last read one of Maddison's tweets about being on the bench. It's all a game isn't it using journos and social media to suit their respective purposes.
Maddison was always a strange signing. Not because he doesn't have the talent to make a difference but because he's not an LB type player. It is always the sum of the total and what he perceives to be a professional approach to playing and training that matters.
There is a reason why skilful players such as Williams (started 36 games in over two years), Oztumer (4 in 18 months) and Maddison (4 this season) are used so sparingly - LB is not prepared to compromise on effort and industry. But he did sign them all and none of them are at an age where it is easy to change them.
Both Maddison's previous two clubs have both done well without him. I'm sure that we can too but it is disappointing to have used up a meaningful proportion of the cap on someone who LB isn't really that bothered about, who also has a massive ego and who was always likely to be a poor fit.
There again, it might just be that he was a gamble LB was prepared to make given that we were in October when signing him and that there wasn't an abundance of alternatives around. Bogle followed a week later and he seems to have been a panic purchase too.
Weird, Bowyer was surely part of our pursuit of Maddison over two transfer windows - odd that you would so quickly write off a player that you wanted for so long.
Don't think that's necessarily the case.
The first approach was only to give Southall a bit of credence. Bowyer wasn't to know that. But he didn't know how much shyte Southall was about to chat.
Then second time round, when you've got to get a squad together quick, you can understand him approaching a player he effectively knew. Still a bit of a gamble though
I've never got the impression he was a player that Bowyer was desperate to sign.
Lee can keep moaning about the salary cap, but he's wasted a fair chunk of it himself here by alienating Maddison
Bowyers the boss, shape up or ship out. How do you know he doesn’t like him, what’s that assumption based on? Maddison has got previous for being a disruptive influence hasn’t he? Why couldn’t he get into the Hull team 2nd half of last season? No smoke without fire.
Bowyer sees him in training (when he’s fit) and if his attitude is not right why should he be mollycoddled? The bloke is taking up a salary and no wonder LBs moaning about the cap. The fella needs to get his act together and roll his sleeves up.
I'm concerned as to why we spent so much time and effort chasing him if he's that disruptive.
Scouts, players and other managers would have given opinions on him.
I'm concerned if we've still put in the effort to sign him and he's as bad as some are insinuating.
That’s fair comment Daz but I’m sure you’ve bought things before despite having researched the product fully but been disappointed with its performance. Maybe Bowyer thought he could make him a better team player however jumping out of tackles, is like a red rag to a bull to LB.
As a kid you’re told go in committed or else your going to get hurt, basic stuff. Personally I don’t think he was injured when he bottled that infamous challenge and as I said at the time, if he was he should’ve gone down beforehand. And again when you start playing at a higher level you are told to do so therefore he was his own worst enemy. So the ‘I don’t care’ remark after the game to me was more directed towards the reasoning why he jumped rather than about the players welfare.
Unfortunately it seems that the manager and player don’t have the same view on how the game should be played and unless they have a meeting of minds Maddison will be an outcast. It won’t be the first in the history of the game or the last.
Somethings not quite right there is it. If he was ill then fair enough but that’s not actually what Bowyer says. “He says he is ill”, that doesn’t sound like he believes him to me.
I wouldn’t be surprised if he doesn’t play for us again but we’ll see.
Talking about his newest addition, Addicks boss Lee Bowyer added: “Marcus is someone we tried to bring here in January, but obviously the embargo was in place. We’ve finally got our man and got it over the line.
“He brings goals. His stats over the last few years are excellent, he regularly gets to double figures in goals and gets a lot of assists, so he brings about 25 goals to a team in a season.
"He’s an experienced player that knows this league inside out.”
Why would a manager not just bat that question away? "Maddison had his ankle I jury and has been unwell, we will see when he returns", simple. His words make this a story and headline the club just don't need.
Talking about his newest addition, Addicks boss Lee Bowyer added: “Marcus is someone we tried to bring here in January, but obviously the embargo was in place. We’ve finally got our man and got it over the line.
“He brings goals. His stats over the last few years are excellent, he regularly gets to double figures in goals and gets a lot of assists, so he brings about 25 goals to a team in a season.
"He’s an experienced player that knows this league inside out.”
Reminds of the old saying that you never really know a partner 'til you've lived with them. That doesn't stop you doing proper research as to why they split up with their previous partners though!
Why would a manager not just bat that question away? "Maddison had his ankle I jury and has been unwell, we will see when he returns", simple. His words make this a story and headline the club just don't need.
Especially after a good victory away from home. Shouldn’t really be a story about an injured midfielder whose not recovered from his injuries.
Throw in the comments on the article about Symth when Bowyer says we only have one winger at the club in Millar. Wonder what he class Maddison as.
Lee can keep moaning about the salary cap, but he's wasted a fair chunk of it himself here by alienating Maddison
Maybe Maddison is to blame ? Heaven forfend that the manager might know more than us.
But everybody knew what Maddison was like. Bowyer signed him anyway and then seems to have done nothing but moan about him. Unless he's just like my cousin. Loves a bad boy, thinks he can change him and then sits up all night crying into a pillow when they're proved otherwise.
I think there's a lot of assumptions being made about Maddison being a disruptive character but I think it might be something less to do with him being a dick per se, and more his willingness to adapt. Bowyer knew what he was getting with Maddison; a player with flair and a creative spark who wants to play an advanced role. He had a great time at Peterborough on the pitch because they don't care about defending as a unit, they just want goals. It's why they never get anywhere despite often looking good. In an ideal world Bowyer would sign a creative player who is also willing to put in the work with his defensive responsibilities, but as has often been the case the money or time isn't there to get that player, so he has to sign a creative player in the hopes that he is willing to learn the defensive side. Of all our players Maddison has looked the least interested in adapting his game to fit the style; Bowyer's tactical style requires players working all over the pitch to press, close down and win back the ball out of possession or it doesn't work. When a midfielder decides he can't be arsed chasing back, or shirks a challenge the opposition get a chance at our goal and Bowyer hates that because it can wreck our whole game. If Maddison won't adapt his game then he doesn't fit into how we're playing. All the people saying that Bowyer 'knew what he was getting' with Maddison are missing the point; he knew, told the player what he needed to work on to be successful and hasn't seen the change he's demanded. Contrast that with Albie who has been told what to do, has been taken to task for not doing it, and has shown willingness to learn and looks a better player for it. It might be that Maddison is stropping around the place chucking cold slices of Dominos at people in training, but I think it's more likely that Bowyer wants him to adapt his game and he either can't or won't, which is a shame.
Fosu, Williams, Oztumer and Maddison. Flair players unable to be managed by Bowyer.
Conor Gallagher, Joe Aribo, ahem, Lyle Taylor, Andrew Shinnie, and now Liam Miller. All flair players who flourish(ed) under Bowyer, but they all also work their bollocks off for the team. Anyone who listened to Liam Miller's post-match interview last night could not fail to be impressed by his attitude too.
Fosu, Williams, Oztumer and Maddison. Flair players unable to be managed by Bowyer.
Conor Gallagher, Joe Aribo, ahem, Lyle Taylor, Andrew Shinnie, and now Liam Miller. All flair players who flourish(ed) under Bowyer, but they all also work their bollocks off for the team. Anyone who listened to Liam Miller's post-match interview last night could not fail to be impressed by his attitude too.
Fosu, Williams, Oztumer and Maddison. Flair players unable to be managed by Bowyer.
Conor Gallagher, Joe Aribo, ahem, Lyle Taylor, Andrew Shinnie, and now Liam Miller. All flair players who flourish(ed) under Bowyer, but they all also work their bollocks off for the team. Anyone who listened to Liam Miller's post-match interview last night could not fail to be impressed by his attitude too.
Yes I agree. You can compare Taylor and Maddison, two flair players who I would regard to be quite stroppy. One like you say, works their bollocks off for the team. My issue is that Bowyer tracked Maddison for a year and knew what he was getting, now seems to be quite stroppy himself!
For the record, I'm Bowyer over Maddison. Really not sure the latter wants to be here at all and had little choice but to accept our offer. I'm just really confused as to why we signed him.
Talking about his newest addition, Addicks boss Lee Bowyer added: “Marcus is someone we tried to bring here in January, but obviously the embargo was in place. We’ve finally got our man and got it over the line.
“He brings goals. His stats over the last few years are excellent, he regularly gets to double figures in goals and gets a lot of assists, so he brings about 25 goals to a team in a season.
"He’s an experienced player that knows this league inside out.”
1st stage of building his confidence and very good management; especially considering he was a ‘free’ who nobody had touched with a barge pole - even though he had been available all summer.
I am sure that ‘issues’ were mentioned when we signed him, and I don’t think there can be many who were not at least puzzled at why he was still available. The inner football world would have known and so would have SG, Bows etc. But was it worth a risk in the position we were in? I would say yes and think that if anyone could get him back on track it would have been Bowyer. Tweets in the middle of the night whilst scoffing pizza suggests to me that his issues are deeper than just not liking training or similar.
Others said something about Bowyer as a manager should have gone over to see how is was. I don’t know what organisation you work for, but if you are not going into work you call your boss and explain the problem. You update them while you are off. When you are fit to return you call them. The first thing you do when you get in you go to see them and let them know you are back. You don’t expect your manager to have to come looking for you. It doesn’t work both ways.
Signing him was worth the risk. Some you lose. It would take a fantastic change of attitude for him to get himself back into the squad. Unfortunately I don’t think he has that in him, and there is nobody else to blame for that.
Fosu, Williams, Oztumer and Maddison. Flair players unable to be managed by Bowyer.
Conor Gallagher, Joe Aribo, ahem, Lyle Taylor, Andrew Shinnie, and now Liam Miller. All flair players who flourish(ed) under Bowyer, but they all also work their bollocks off for the team. Anyone who listened to Liam Miller's post-match interview last night could not fail to be impressed by his attitude too.
Yes I agree. You can compare Taylor and Maddison, two flair players who I would regard to be quite stroppy. One like you say, works their bollocks off for the team. My issue is that Bowyer tracked Maddison for a year and knew what he was getting, now seems to be quite stroppy himself!
For the record, I'm Bowyer over Maddison. Really not sure the latter wants to be here at all and had little choice but to accept our offer. I'm just really confused as to why we signed him.
I constantly wonder if Bowyer thought he could turn Maddison around
Taylor didnt really need turning around as much prior to joining but Bowyer definitely improved him
Its the only reason I can think of
Either that or quite bluntly they've sat down and gone: "Well he's the only real option"
Fosu, Williams, Oztumer and Maddison. Flair players unable to be managed by Bowyer.
Conor Gallagher, Joe Aribo, ahem, Lyle Taylor, Andrew Shinnie, and now Liam Miller. All flair players who flourish(ed) under Bowyer, but they all also work their bollocks off for the team. Anyone who listened to Liam Miller's post-match interview last night could not fail to be impressed by his attitude too.
Yes I agree. You can compare Taylor and Maddison, two flair players who I would regard to be quite stroppy. One like you say, works their bollocks off for the team. My issue is that Bowyer tracked Maddison for a year and knew what he was getting, now seems to be quite stroppy himself!
For the record, I'm Bowyer over Maddison. Really not sure the latter wants to be here at all and had little choice but to accept our offer. I'm just really confused as to why we signed him.
I constantly wonder if Bowyer thought he could turn Maddison around
Taylor didnt really need turning around as much prior to joining but Bowyer definitely improved him
Its the only reason I can think of
Either that or quite bluntly they've sat down and gone: "Well he's the only real option"
I think it's a combination of both; 'we need creativity, he's the only realistic option. Let's see if we can turn him round'.
TS will hear constant references to the salary cap that's "killing us" and then see his money wasted on a player who was meant to put goals on a plate for forwards, that's no longer being talked about with the same expectation and skillset on offer.
Comments
“Then, someone he knew had Covid. And obviously he had that ankle injury, didn’t he. So, Marcus Maddison is not training.
“I’ve not seen him for a few days. I think I saw him yesterday from a distance with the fitness people, ticking boxes.
“Ticking the box to see if he could start training again. But he’s not been in and around us for a few days now.”
The last time I saw comments as ambiguous as those was when I last read one of Maddison's tweets about being on the bench. It's all a game isn't it using journos and social media to suit their respective purposes.
Maddison was always a strange signing. Not because he doesn't have the talent to make a difference but because he's not an LB type player. It is always the sum of the total and what he perceives to be a professional approach to playing and training that matters.There is a reason why skilful players such as Williams (started 36 games in over two years), Oztumer (4 in 18 months) and Maddison (4 this season) are used so sparingly - LB is not prepared to compromise on effort and industry. But he did sign them all and none of them are at an age where it is easy to change them.
Both Maddison's previous two clubs have both done well without him. I'm sure that we can too but it is disappointing to have used up a meaningful proportion of the cap on someone who LB isn't really that bothered about, who also has a massive ego and who was always likely to be a poor fit.
There again, it might just be that he was a gamble LB was prepared to make given that we were in October when signing him and that there wasn't an abundance of alternatives around. Bogle followed a week later and he seems to have been a panic purchase too.
The first approach was only to give Southall a bit of credence. Bowyer wasn't to know that. But he didn't know how much shyte Southall was about to chat.
Then second time round, when you've got to get a squad together quick, you can understand him approaching a player he effectively knew. Still a bit of a gamble though
I've never got the impression he was a player that Bowyer was desperate to sign.
As a kid you’re told go in committed or else your going to get hurt, basic stuff. Personally I don’t think he was injured when he bottled that infamous challenge and as I said at the time, if he was he should’ve gone down beforehand. And again when you start playing at a higher level you are told to do so therefore he was his own worst enemy. So the ‘I don’t care’ remark after the game to me was more directed towards the reasoning why he jumped rather than about the players welfare.
his injuries.
Throw in the comments on the article about Symth when Bowyer says we only have one winger at the club in Millar. Wonder what he class Maddison as.
For the record, I'm Bowyer over Maddison. Really not sure the latter wants to be here at all and had little choice but to accept our offer. I'm just really confused as to why we signed him.
Tweets in the middle of the night whilst scoffing pizza suggests to me that his issues are deeper than just not liking training or similar.
Taylor didnt really need turning around as much prior to joining but Bowyer definitely improved him
Its the only reason I can think of
Either that or quite bluntly they've sat down and gone: "Well he's the only real option"