Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Summer 2022 transfer rumours (Gilbey loan confirmed p513, a signing falls through last minute p541)
Comments
-
I’d be amazed if we made an offer to Jack Payne without offloading someone. We have 3 midfield spots covered by JFC, Morgan, Gilbey, Fraser, Macgrandles and Dobson.
Im sure we’d love Payne to join us but there’s definitely 2-3 other priorities that need fixing.5 -
Just as rumours around players coming in has been very quiet it might be the same for outgoings.
I’d say 5 or 6 CMs is enough:
DM - Dobson (Reed/JFC?)
LCM - Fraser and JFC (or Payne?)
RCM - McGrandles and Gilbey/Morgan (or Williams?)
That’s without Henry, Anderson etc or anyone else they might be looking at outside of Swindon.
We may want to go with 5 so the u23s have more of a pathway and we’re not spending decent wages on CMs who can’t make the bench when everyone’s available.
0 -
Remember Blair's education, education, education.
Left back, Left back, Left back should be every Charlton fan's mantra.
LWB in a 3-5-2. Attacking LB in 4-3-3, 4-2-3-1 etc, Left back who can get up and down that left flank who is a natural LEFT footed player.
Since the day Ged Roddy left, Roddy junior has disappeared off the scene. He was an u18 or possible U23 but he was well out of his depth when he was our only fit LB at the club. You would've thought there was nepotism occuring ?
The lesson learnt from last season was don't play a RB at LB if you have any ambition of attacking and it's a nightmare when defending if the opposition have Pacey forwards, RWB or midfielders who charge down the right flank.
A natural LB will join ASAP or otherwise Clayden is the only option ? JFC doesn't have the pace to play there though in a friendly against a non League side it won't matter but you are wasting another game where you could bed in the new LB.
3 -
Morgan and Gilbey are not good enough for a promotion push.SOTF said:I’d be amazed if we made an offer to Jack Payne without offloading someone. We have 3 midfield spots covered by JFC, Morgan, Gilbey, Fraser, Macgrandles and Dobson.
Im sure we’d love Payne to join us but there’s definitely 2-3 other priorities that need fixing.
Offload one of them or possibly offer one in part exchange.
Either way Payne is better than both of them and is one we should try to sign.0 -
Any names for this LWB or attacking LB position? It doesn't have to be from a town in Wiltshire with the magic Roundabouts.0
-
A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.8 -
Course they can. We can ring Swindon and offer them cash plus Davison for Reed for example. Davison of course doesn’t have to accept the move but nothing wrong with informing clubs that X is available and Y is available to loan. That’s exactly what being transfer/loan listed meansseth plum said:A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.7 -
Seth, since the Bosman ruling pro players are in such a better position since the days I was talking to Mark Stuart at London Bridge station after training as he made his way back to west London where he lived.
Mark told me he was collecting the keys for his new house nearer to Sparrows lane in a week's time.
That will be better for you I said to Stuart.
Six weeks later Mark Stuart was sold to Plymouth !1 -
So what movements are we expecting to see over the next couple of weeks? No rumours, but surely we must be looking at:
Ins:
2 x left back/wing back
1 x centre back
1 x winger (ideally a player comfortable on both sides)
1 x central midfielder
1 x striker
outs:
Davison - hardworking but unconvinced at league one level let alone, if we get promoted
Morgan - full season loan at league one or top league two level - will do him and us better than him being in an out of the side which I don’t think is good for his confidence and he is a confidence player it would appear
Keeps: Dependent on the type of left back/left wing back we get, we know that Kirk can be pretty useful at this level (particularly on the assists front) and did not shame himself by all accounts at Blackpool, so personally I would keep him.
Leaburn and Kanu - if Davison goes, I would prefer to keep hold of and use Leaburn and Kanu as needed throughout the season, combined with Stockley, Chuks and another new forward. Hopefully our main strikers will remain fitter this season, but equally our gems ought to be given their chances too and am excited to see them play at senior level.3 -
Interesting view of signings made across L1, with four so far we’re doing pretty well. Already out of date as Derby have started signing players.7
-
Sponsored links:
-
Of course you are right.cafcfan1990 said:
Course they can. We can ring Swindon and offer them cash plus Davison for Reed for example. Davison of course doesn’t have to accept the move but nothing wrong with informing clubs that X is available and Y is available to loan. That’s exactly what being transfer/loan listed meansseth plum said:A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.
Which would make the position of the player even worse if treated that way without their agreement.
Josh Davison is trucking along doing his work at Charlton and behind his back he is offered out as available.
Really?
If he is formally listed as available for loan or transfer that is another thing, but that particular formality surely has to be agreed by the contracted player.
For others to suggest a player can be used as ballast in a deal is a nasty cavalier approach to the player/worker.12 -
No it’s not. It’s a pragmatic approach to solving issues with players and squads. No player can be forced out on either loan or as a makeweight in a transfer unless they agree to it. The reality is players go where the work is and where they think they’ll get games. If the loan and makeweight process suits all parties then it’s absolutely fine.seth plum said:
Of course you are right.cafcfan1990 said:
Course they can. We can ring Swindon and offer them cash plus Davison for Reed for example. Davison of course doesn’t have to accept the move but nothing wrong with informing clubs that X is available and Y is available to loan. That’s exactly what being transfer/loan listed meansseth plum said:A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.
Which would make the position of the player even worse if treated that way without their agreement.
Josh Davison is trucking along doing his work at Charlton and behind his back he is offered out as available.
Really?
If he is formally listed as available for loan or transfer that is another thing, but that particular formality surely has to be agreed by the contracted player.
For others to suggest a player can be used as ballast in a deal is a nasty cavalier approach to the player/worker.7 -
Saw Derby’s four signings, not moved at all by any of them, they’ll be lucky to make top half IMO.Scoham said:Interesting view of signings made across L1, with four so far we’re doing pretty well. Already out of date as Derby have started signing players.0 -
How do you know that Davison hasn’t been told that he’s surplus to requirements and his agent isnt currently trying to find him a new club? Also, do you think that Washington got his move that quickly? His agent would have been working on things since at least January. I know he was out of contract but it works both ways. Football is unlike most businesses when it comes to workers rights and in my opinion players generally hold the cards when it comes to moves.seth plum said:
Of course you are right.cafcfan1990 said:
Course they can. We can ring Swindon and offer them cash plus Davison for Reed for example. Davison of course doesn’t have to accept the move but nothing wrong with informing clubs that X is available and Y is available to loan. That’s exactly what being transfer/loan listed meansseth plum said:A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.
Which would make the position of the player even worse if treated that way without their agreement.
Josh Davison is trucking along doing his work at Charlton and behind his back he is offered out as available.
Really?
If he is formally listed as available for loan or transfer that is another thing, but that particular formality surely has to be agreed by the contracted player.
For others to suggest a player can be used as ballast in a deal is a nasty cavalier approach to the player/worker.9 -
No doubt he’d improve us. But we’re not in a fantasy league. It’s real money, of which our owner is losing a lot already.blackpool72 said:
Morgan and Gilbey are not good enough for a promotion push.SOTF said:I’d be amazed if we made an offer to Jack Payne without offloading someone. We have 3 midfield spots covered by JFC, Morgan, Gilbey, Fraser, Macgrandles and Dobson.
Im sure we’d love Payne to join us but there’s definitely 2-3 other priorities that need fixing.
Offload one of them or possibly offer one in part exchange.
Either way Payne is better than both of them and is one we should try to sign.
As I said I’m sure we’d love to sign him, but you can’t force players under contract to leave and if we can’t shift someone whose spot do we sacrifice? Another striker? A Left back?
Until someone leaves it’s a financial gamble.1 -
Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.2 -
Pompey interested in Jack Payne and Dorking's striker Alfie Rutherford.
http://d3d4football.com/exclusive-portsmouth-face-fight-to-land-30-goal-non-league-ace/
Suggests Rutherford's attracted a lot of interest from third tier clubs, I wonder if that includes us?0 -
If Davison has been told something regarding his future does anybody know?LargeAddick said:
How do you know that Davison hasn’t been told that he’s surplus to requirements and his agent isnt currently trying to find him a new club? Also, do you think that Washington got his move that quickly? His agent would have been working on things since at least January. I know he was out of contract but it works both ways. Football is unlike most businesses when it comes to workers rights and in my opinion players generally hold the cards when it comes to moves.seth plum said:
Of course you are right.cafcfan1990 said:
Course they can. We can ring Swindon and offer them cash plus Davison for Reed for example. Davison of course doesn’t have to accept the move but nothing wrong with informing clubs that X is available and Y is available to loan. That’s exactly what being transfer/loan listed meansseth plum said:A Charlton player can’t be offered to anybody without their agreement.
If players feel they are being treated like chattels they need to up their Trade Union game, stand by one another, and take industrial action if it is warranted and if the Trade Union laws are followed.
Which would make the position of the player even worse if treated that way without their agreement.
Josh Davison is trucking along doing his work at Charlton and behind his back he is offered out as available.
Really?
If he is formally listed as available for loan or transfer that is another thing, but that particular formality surely has to be agreed by the contracted player.
For others to suggest a player can be used as ballast in a deal is a nasty cavalier approach to the player/worker.
Certainly not me, but I do know he is under contract.
I am curious about your comment regarding workers ‘rights’. Isn’t the law supposed to work the same for all workers unless there are specific contractual clauses?
As for Washington, for whatever reason he has achieved a good transfer to a higher grade.2 -
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.3 -
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?1 -
Sponsored links:
-
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.6 -
To be fair, he’s been here a while so he probably does need to change his pants and put some deodorant onHenry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.8 -
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.2 -
Does it? Or just that they're not at new clubs yet.Henry Irving said:
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.
I hope you're right of course!1 -
He needs to put the bins out too. He doesn't want to miss the Monday green bin collection._MrDick said:
To be fair, he’s been here a while so he probably does need to change his pants and put some deodorant onHenry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.3 -
Which I said further up.Dazzler21 said:
Does it? Or just that they're not at new clubs yet.Henry Irving said:
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.
I hope you're right of course!
No, it's not proof that they have signed for us but indicates strongly they haven't signed elsewhere.1 -
Encouraging sentiments Henry but lets wait until WIOTOSHenry Irving said:
Which I said further up.Dazzler21 said:
Does it? Or just that they're not at new clubs yet.Henry Irving said:
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.
I hope you're right of course!
No, it's not proof that they have signed for us but indicates strongly they haven't signed elsewhere.4 -
I wish I'd said thatSensei said:
Encouraging sentiments Henry but lets wait until WIOTOSHenry Irving said:
Which I said further up.Dazzler21 said:
Does it? Or just that they're not at new clubs yet.Henry Irving said:
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.
I hope you're right of course!
No, it's not proof that they have signed for us but indicates strongly they haven't signed elsewhere.7 -
You will Henry, you will!Henry Irving said:
I wish I'd said thatSensei said:
Encouraging sentiments Henry but lets wait until WIOTOSHenry Irving said:
Which I said further up.Dazzler21 said:
Does it? Or just that they're not at new clubs yet.Henry Irving said:
So all appear at Deal (done Deal) or were in Spain.Scoham said:
https://www.charltonafc.com/news/view/6286075ee9cf5/academy-update-retained-and-released-playersHenry Irving said:
Cheers, not on the OS but seems likely they have signed.Athletico Charlton said:
Adigun, Toure, Reilly and Ladapo all played. Leaburn is in Spain. Anderson is already signed up professionally. Not sure on the keeper or older two who were offered extensions (Williams one I think)Henry Irving said:Bumped into Thomas on Friday at The Valley. He was waiting for a taxi to the Airport as he was flying home then flying coming back Tuesday so don't expect any signings until Wednesday 😉
Re: the U23s game at Deal yesterday. Did any of the academy players offered deals back in May play? Or not as the case maybe.
Adigan? Anderson? Leaburn was in Spain but who else hadn't signed.
Even if still negotiating they certainly haven't signed elsewhere.
@scoham or anyone? Who were the academy players named on the OS as having been offered deals?The club have offered contracts to Euan Williams and Nathan Harvey.
Jason Adigun, Tolu Ladapo, Miles Leaburn, Mack Reilly and Seydil Toure have all been offered new contracts with the club.
Seems a good pointer that they have all signed.
I hope you're right of course!
No, it's not proof that they have signed for us but indicates strongly they haven't signed elsewhere.3 -
This thread seems quite uneventful, a bit beige these days, I guess that’s a good thing.2
