Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton Athletic vs Pre-Season Friendlies | Preview & Match Threads (Welling p59, Swansea p67 )

1568101183

Comments

  • Gilbey should be the one surplus to requirements
  • supaclive said:
    Gilbey should be the one surplus to requirements
    Yup... the Morgan vs Gilbey debate was a non contest based on their performances today
  • And yeah, Gilbey did manage one forward run, in the same phase of play where he'd just passed it straight to Kilmarnock on the edge of our box
  • I knew Garner was the wrong appointment. HMS Wet the Bed ready to set sail again.
  • Only saw the second half but Kirk and Fraser looked good. Stockley did fairly well also in holding it up. 

    Disappointing not to see much link up between the 3 midfielders. Gilbey was pointless. Henry, obviously not a right back but his deliveries were awful. Wallacot didn't convince but looked comfortable with the ball at his feet when he wasn't miscontrolling it, that is.


  • Anyone know whether the Colchester friendly Terry kept mentioning on the commentary is actually happening? Nothing on our website or their's? Think he said it was a midweek game.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Cafc43v3r said:
    It's a clear back 3 there but then both wing backs were well advanced.  Confused but interged. 

    When a back 3 is played the idea is your wings backs get forward in attacking mode other wise you end up as 5 at the back ?

  • ‘Gilbey puts in effort ‘

     sick and tired of seeing these type of comments. He isn’t a very good footballer 
  • edited July 2022
    Garner out.

    You win 🥇 for the first person to say the obvious.
    You were 16/1.
  • Its a training session lads

    Gary, it's what many fans do,
    They will never change.


  • GIlbey wasn't great but wasn't crap either today.
  • I once lost 3 out of 5 pre seson friendlies  on Championship Manager 99/00 and went on to qualify for the Champions League that season so worth noting for some perspective.

    Send your CV to Dangerfield at Sparrows lane and he will pass it on.
  • Valley11 said:
    Why is Egbo playing left back?
    Because we dont have a left back
  • Sponsored links:


  • GIlbey wasn't great but wasn't crap either today.
    Yeah, these are my thoughts. In that second half he was no worse, and no better, than most of the other individuals on the pitch.


  • GIlbey wasn't great but wasn't crap either today.
    Not really sure how you can be classed as great, crap or average in a pre season knock about.
  • Lucky for them Lafferty isnt Scottish... Had he been then I wouldnt have put money on him finishing.
  • Not watching but it sounds like our finishing in front of goal is still pants as per the last few seasons. Early doors though, its only a training session
    So we're not missing Connor Washington, then ?
  • Sounds like we wanted a left back & a finisher.

    # just saying  
  • Sounds like we wanted a left back & a finisher.

    # just saying  
    Don’t need Garner to confirm we’re trying to sign players to fill those positions. No club in our league has a finished squad when they play their first friendly.
  • GIlbey wasn't great but wasn't crap either today.
    Not really sure how you can be classed as great, crap or average in a pre season knock about.
    Well you either played great, crap or average. It doesn't define their overall class, but a comment can be made about how they were today. 

    FWIW first half team looked good, stick Stockley in that side and I think we score. 
  • Love the footballing minds pointing out we still need players, TS should have just posted his manager search in here. 
  • Leuth said:
    supaclive said:
    Gilbey should be the one surplus to requirements
    Today was textbook. Aside from sloppiness in possession and utter ineffectiveness in attack, this was a case study in how he hides from being available for the ball in positions where he can play forward passes, and then makes himself available when the option is a five-yard wall-pass, achieving nothing. Watching him play is fucking torture 
    You have this weird obsession with the Albie vs Gilbey debate.  Neither are going to be starting for us this year and neither were the problem today.  The problem today was how uncomfortable our defense in the second half looked, the lack of depth at the wide positions such that we had to play Henry, Leaburn and Egbo out of position and the lack of finishers up front
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!