Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Away fans housed in West Stand Upper - Testing in 25/26 season

2456710

Comments

  • Starinnaddick
    Starinnaddick Posts: 4,345
    I f we get back in the Championship I can see a situation where clubs with big away support are allocated the Jimmy Seed and the South end of the West stand. 
    I seem to remember this being done in the past. 
    Possibly Bournemouth? 
  • ElfsborgAddick
    ElfsborgAddick Posts: 29,073
    I think in the long term it could be a good idea to gradually get more Charlton fans behind the other goal, it would be easy with access.
    The acoustics are much better there so hopefully could create a better atmosphere.
    I would say for games where less than a thousand away supporters are expected using the West Upper could work out well.  Not too difficult to police and supporters coaches park in the same place.
    Plus we'd be able to charge them more being along the side.
  • cabbie8
    cabbie8 Posts: 341
    MrOneLung said:
    cabbie8 said:
    I’d like to see the north upper fans/noise closer to the pitch and situated in the north lower. I had a conversation with Bowyer previously and he wanted this to happen for same reasons 
    why would those in north upper move to a worse view ?
    Is it a worse view? 
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,222
    Makes sense to me, if in The Championship we're playing a well supported team like Sheff Weds and we can't sell the home tickets ourselves then it's a no-brainer to sell the tickets to away fans instead and generate more revenue. Not much different really to what Peterborough are doing for our game this week.

    If we're in League One then most away supports should fit into the West Upper and with the Jimmy Seed looking empty most weeks anyway it won't make much difference in reality how empty it might or might not look so I don't think it matters really what division we're in. 
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,222
    The other thing i'm pleased with is the fact the club are actually considering this, would love for us to reclaim the Jimmy Seed.

    Can't remember when it was said but I remember seeing something said a few years ago about how the JS was the 'traditional' away end. Hopefully that line of thinking is no longer at the club.
  • Valleysarr
    Valleysarr Posts: 1,098
    Stupid idea - keep them in JS as the sensible place to house them.
    and when in Championship we don’t sell out either .. 
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    I think in the long term it could be a good idea to gradually get more Charlton fans behind the other goal, it would be easy with access.
    The acoustics are much better there so hopefully could create a better atmosphere.
    I would say for games where less than a thousand away supporters are expected using the West Upper could work out well.  Not too difficult to police and supporters coaches park in the same place.
    Plus we'd be able to charge them more being along the side.
    Airman's gonna throw a spanner in the works, i can feel it coming but on the face of it, if workable, it could also allow us to give big away teams the jimmy seed and a bit of the west upper if we get into the championship      
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    I wonder if the 16-20 'yoof' section is gonna be attempted again in the north west quad ? Wasn't a massive success this year but... :D   
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,013
    clive said:
    The club doesn't seem to be confident of promotion by making this announcement at the moment, as most Championship clubs would probably bring much bigger followings than clubs in league 1.
    Also, why not just say this might save a few bob, instead of the following bullshit.

    As we work toward becoming the UK's most cohesive, sustainable community-driven club competing at elite level, we're considering ways to improve The Valley's atmosphere and matchday experience, and to make it a more efficient stadium to run.

    To be fair if there's a possibility of S/T holders being displaced on occasions then it should be announced before the tickets go on sale (and has).
  • Sponsored links:



  • JustFloydRoad
    JustFloydRoad Posts: 1,625
    clive said:
    The club doesn't seem to be confident of promotion by making this announcement at the moment, as most Championship clubs would probably bring much bigger followings than clubs in league 1.
    Also, why not just say this might save a few bob, instead of the following bullshit.

    As we work toward becoming the UK's most cohesive, sustainable community-driven club competing at elite level, we're considering ways to improve The Valley's atmosphere and matchday experience, and to make it a more efficient stadium to run.

    The Club needs to plan it's operations promotion or not.

    Season Ticket prices are frozen till 2nd May (after the Wrexham and Wycombe games interestly).
    This is around I said that if those games go in our favour (and we have a decent run till then) then I wouldn't be surprised if the prices get wacked up by quite a bit.


    If we are fighting for auto in May then I wouldn't be surprised they change tac.
  • Airman Brown
    Airman Brown Posts: 15,742
    edited March 20
    DOUCHER said:
    I think in the long term it could be a good idea to gradually get more Charlton fans behind the other goal, it would be easy with access.
    The acoustics are much better there so hopefully could create a better atmosphere.
    I would say for games where less than a thousand away supporters are expected using the West Upper could work out well.  Not too difficult to police and supporters coaches park in the same place.
    Plus we'd be able to charge them more being along the side.
    Airman's gonna throw a spanner in the works, i can feel it coming but on the face of it, if workable, it could also allow us to give big away teams the jimmy seed and a bit of the west upper if we get into the championship      
    The only access likely for home supporters to the JS Stand is via the Bartram Gate. I can’t see why you’d bother as very few Charlton fans will want to sit there for preference. Using the upper west would facilitate higher prices if they jacked them up in home areas too. The cost saving on small numbers won’t be that significant so there will be more to it.

    People like to tinker because they can. Warrick was the guy who wanted to close stands when he turned up.
  • Markg2004
    Markg2004 Posts: 405
    I can hear it now from the Oxford Utd fans "You only use 3 stands".
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    DOUCHER said:
    I think in the long term it could be a good idea to gradually get more Charlton fans behind the other goal, it would be easy with access.
    The acoustics are much better there so hopefully could create a better atmosphere.
    I would say for games where less than a thousand away supporters are expected using the West Upper could work out well.  Not too difficult to police and supporters coaches park in the same place.
    Plus we'd be able to charge them more being along the side.
    Airman's gonna throw a spanner in the works, i can feel it coming but on the face of it, if workable, it could also allow us to give big away teams the jimmy seed and a bit of the west upper if we get into the championship      
    The only access likely for home supporters to the JS Stand is via the Bartram Gate. I can’t see why you’d bother as very few Charlton fans will want to sit there for preference. Using the upper west would facilitate higher prices if they jacked them up in home areas too. The cost saving on small numbers won’t be that significant so there will be more to it.

    People like to tinker because they can. Warrick was the guy who wanted to close stands when he turned up.
    I agree, it wouldn't be somewhere i'd choose to sit and would only dilute the home end atmosphere. I know you could sit / stand anywhere back in the day but it hasn't been a home end in modern times - however, I don't think its a bad idea to have the option of sticking a  few hundred away fans on a tuesday night ion a stand that is already open and having potential overspill if a big team has sold out and can take additional seats and if we get in the playoofs against a minnow and we can have the JS as well.  
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 33,635
    Bad idea.

    Always like away fans to have an "end".....even if they only bring a few hundred. And playing a match with just 3 sides open always seems to be that "your grounds to big for you" or you are cost cutting.

    Obviously wont happen in the Championshio so let's just hope we get promoted this season. 
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,013
    If we're playing a team with about 100 supporters then there will be no atmosphere from their fans wherever they sit.
  • barstool
    barstool Posts: 1,352
    Is it a ploy to get more fans in the Fans Zone outside The west before the game 
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    DOUCHER said:
    clive said:
    The club doesn't seem to be confident of promotion by making this announcement at the moment, as most Championship clubs would probably bring much bigger followings than clubs in league 1.
    Also, why not just say this might save a few bob, instead of the following bullshit.

    As we work toward becoming the UK's most cohesive, sustainable community-driven club competing at elite level, we're considering ways to improve The Valley's atmosphere and matchday experience, and to make it a more efficient stadium to run.

    not necessarily - might also be thinking ahead towards the play offs ? 
    ignore taht - i misread it said next season  :/
  • Taxi_Lad
    Taxi_Lad Posts: 3,771
    Thought @Airman Brown always maintained that closing parts of the ground doesn’t really save money 
  • When a goal goes in the highlights will show it against an empty stand.  That'll look more like shit ground no fans than the UK's most cohesive, sustainable community-driven club competing at elite level. 
  • Sponsored links:



  • JustFloydRoad
    JustFloydRoad Posts: 1,625
    Imagine next season we get promoted and Millwall fans in the Upper West Stand.
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    barstool said:
    Is it a ploy to get more fans in the Fans Zone outside The west before the game 
    be good to see a bit of fighting round the back of the main stand reintroduced 
  • Croydon
    Croydon Posts: 12,728
    I'd like home fans back in the JS, but only with away fans there too, like it used to be.

    This seems to me like a cost cutting exercise to just close the stand and not need to use any catering staff or stewards there, rather than an opportunity to get home fans in there. 
  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 13,922
    cabbie8 said:
    I’d like to see the north upper fans/noise closer to the pitch and situated in the north lower. I had a conversation with Bowyer previously and he wanted this to happen for same reasons 
    They are poor seats compared to uptop or fans would have naturally moved down.
  • Hartleypete
    Hartleypete Posts: 4,699
    As long as you are not sitting in lower west of course and getting all sorts lobbed at you.


  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 7,907
    shine166 said:
    cabbie8 said:
    I’d like to see the north upper fans/noise closer to the pitch and situated in the north lower. I had a conversation with Bowyer previously and he wanted this to happen for same reasons 
    They are poor seats compared to uptop or fans would have naturally moved down.
    and as has been said on many occasions, you need to be close to the roof to get an atmosphere going  
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 4,891
    edited March 20
    I can only assume it’s the brain child of one of the seemingly many outgoing employees and it’s their parting gift. 

    Nonsense idea which will do more harm than good. 

    Penny pinching in the extreme. 

    Will assume the fans  forum / supporter liaison role will quash it. Or maybe CAST could do something more tangible than a survey ?
  • Lincsaddick
    Lincsaddick Posts: 32,355
    Not a good idea
  • valleynick66
    valleynick66 Posts: 4,891
    Is CM on the beers or something whilst on his gardening leave letting this happen? 😉😆
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,860
    As a general rule, I detest away fans being stuck in the gods, away from the pitch. Your team score, and the players have to celebrate with fans 3 flights of stairs above them.

    The PL have tried to restrict this, though the likes of Newcastle have some sort of get out clause.