Wendies at war (Madine sent down)
Comments
-
Are you blind? Watch it again, he clearly makes contact with the guy's ankle and his foot is high. Correct decision.operationpig said:Look at the Semedo tackle again, he never even touched him, he won the ball and still had one foot on the ground, we were robbed again yesterday by the officials.
Tell you what, the state of football with the officials is shocking.0 -
Sheffield Wednesday are gash. Even Yeovil have won a game.0
-
Pigs looking for a bite as usual.EpsomAddick said:
Are you blind? Watch it again, he clearly makes contact with the guy's ankle and his foot is high. Correct decision.operationpig said:Look at the Semedo tackle again, he never even touched him, he won the ball and still had one foot on the ground, we were robbed again yesterday by the officials.
Tell you what, the state of football with the officials is shocking.0 -
Not looking for a bite at all mate, you look at the tackle and you'll see he never made contact, the ref was conned, Semedo left the pitch in tears as he couldn't actually believe he was shown the red card, if we don't get it rescinded then something is wrong.0
-
Too many draws mate, but we've had some unbelievable bad luck, if we could just get a couple of back to back wins and kick on from there, don't worry, it's coming.I_Saw_Semedo_Score said:Sheffield Wednesday are gash. Even Yeovil have won a game.
0 -
I think most football fans who follow a losing team say thisoperationpig said:
Too many draws mate, but we've had some unbelievable bad luck, if we could just get a couple of back to back wins and kick on from there, don't worry, it's coming.I_Saw_Semedo_Score said:Sheffield Wednesday are gash. Even Yeovil have won a game.
0 -
I've watched it on iPlayer, he clearly makes a lot of contact with his ankle and his foot is high. There's bias, and then there's refusing to see what's right in front of you.operationpig said:Not looking for a bite at all mate, you look at the tackle and you'll see he never made contact, the ref was conned, Semedo left the pitch in tears as he couldn't actually believe he was shown the red card, if we don't get it rescinded then something is wrong.
0 -
On here, the saying is Sheff U will come good.operationpig said:
Too many draws mate, but we've had some unbelievable bad luck, if we could just get a couple of back to back wins and kick on from there, don't worry, it's coming.I_Saw_Semedo_Score said:Sheffield Wednesday are gash. Even Yeovil have won a game.
0 -
0
-
I don't think it was a sending off, Semedo get's the ball first but as his sliding with the ball it hits the players ankle.0
- Sponsored links:
-
-
He clearly gets the player on the Right ankle. To say he doesn't make contact is just embarrassingly blinkered and rediculous. No way will it, or should it be rescinded.....Oh and the disallowed goal was also the correct decision.0
-
If they refuse to see what's right infront of them on a video it's unlikely they'll admit they're wrong with a pic. But good effort anyway.EpsomAddick said:I hope this image comes out large enough to see
0 -
Sending off or not it what the 85th min wasn't it? Wouldn't have made a difference.0
-
Was a harsh sending off but no chance of a successful appeal.0
-
We'll see, I think it will be overturned but I'll not hold my breath.
Looking at still images doesn't say anything, he never made any contact, the Bolton player got him sent off, simple as that.
As for it being in the 85th minute, we were on top for most of the game but we totally lost momentum after Semedos sending off, It was a shame because Semedo was absolutely brilliant all game, and I've been a big critic of his in the championship.0 -
Personally, I can't see Semedo got the ball, as the ball continues in the opposite direction to Semedo's slide.
Semedo definitely took the player & it was a reckless challenge. Definitely a yellow & most refs in this day and age would give a red.
Similarish challenge to the one Pritch did at Bournemouth, 1st game of the season & got a red card.0 -
Shocking tackle, deserved the red.
Miss Piggy must have borrowed Wengers rose tinted contacts.0 -
If he appeals that then he deserves a longer ban for a trivial appeal.0
- Sponsored links:
-
These days it doesn't matter if the player does get a piece of the ball, it was the aggressiveness / recklessness call it what you like, of the challenge resulting in a dangerous follow through which has been outlawed. Sorry Piggy, straight red and no point in appealing IMO.
Edit: FIFA Fouls and Misconduct law 12.9 refers and check out part II 63 & 64 http://www.fifa.com/mm/document/afdeveloping/refereeing/law_12_fouls_misconduct_en_47379.pdf0 -
Can't believe Wendy will appeal once they have a good look at the footage. Waste of money. Not a chance in a million it will be rescinded.0
-
Guys, you're using images and videos to make your point, which is clearly biased and not a true reflection of the events.... ; )0
-
Yeah true. Semedo cried so what more evidence can there be?SELR_addicks said:Guys, you're using images and videos to make your point, which is clearly biased and not a true reflection of the events.... ; )
0 -
Obviously cares a lot for this club - fair play, hope the appeal goes his way, he's worked hard to get back into the side and with a crucial trip away at Barnsley next saturday I hope he gets to play in it.DRAddick said:
Yeah true. Semedo cried so what more evidence can there be?SELR_addicks said:Guys, you're using images and videos to make your point, which is clearly biased and not a true reflection of the events.... ; )
0 -
He used to cry when he got sent off for us too, which happened more regularly than I likedoperationpig said:
Obviously cares a lot for this club - fair play, hope the appeal goes his way, he's worked hard to get back into the side and with a crucial trip away at Barnsley next saturday I hope he gets to play in it.DRAddick said:
Yeah true. Semedo cried so what more evidence can there be?SELR_addicks said:Guys, you're using images and videos to make your point, which is clearly biased and not a true reflection of the events.... ; )
0 -
What's that got to do with the fact it was a bad tackle and you and the other Wednesdayites are ignoring all evidence to that fact with your only arguement to the contrary being that he cried?operationpig said:
Obviously cares a lot for this club - fair play, hope the appeal goes his way, he's worked hard to get back into the side and with a crucial trip away at Barnsley next saturday I hope he gets to play in it.DRAddick said:
Yeah true. Semedo cried so what more evidence can there be?SELR_addicks said:Guys, you're using images and videos to make your point, which is clearly biased and not a true reflection of the events.... ; )
0 -
Like I said, in my opinion it wasn't a bad tackle, I've seen it live and saw it on TV, it looks much worse on TV but he won the ball, no point was two feet off the pitch he had one foot on the deck, the kid made a meal of it, about 2 minutes before that Buxton was chopped down from behind and the Bolton player wasn't even shown a yellow.
Going round in circles on here anyway, as it's plainly obvious you all think it's a red.
Goodnight.0 -
Dont matter if he got the man or the ball, he was was reckless.
When he starts the challenge both feet are off the ground. Straight red.
Saying he didn't touch the man is crazy, it don;t make any difference. Do people want injured players before the ref can act?
Makes mad when so called experts say, the player got a bit of the ball. You can't play through a man to get the ball.0 -
That's not what you said, you said "he never touched him" and "He never made contact".operationpig said:Like I said, in my opinion it wasn't a bad tackle, I've seen it live and saw it on TV, it looks much worse on TV but he won the ball, no point was two feet off the pitch he had one foot on the deck, the kid made a meal of it, about 2 minutes before that Buxton was chopped down from behind and the Bolton player wasn't even shown a yellow.
Going round in circles on here anyway, as it's plainly obvious you all think it's a red.
Goodnight.
Night night.0
