Wendies at war (Madine sent down)
Comments
-
Not a clear sending off for me – but one you have no chance of winning if you appeal. If the ref has seen it and thinks it was a sending off – no way a panel will overturn, even if it is harsh. There has to be a clear error somewhere!0
-
Was there an increase in the ban for a frivolous appeal? I'm sure there would have been if he'd still been our player.0
-
Agree with this.MuttleyCAFC said:Not a clear sending off for me – but one you have no chance of winning if you appeal. If the ref has seen it and thinks it was a sending off – no way a panel will overturn, even if it is harsh. There has to be a clear error somewhere!
That’s why appeals are deemed to be frivolous and bans increased, you are basically saying the ref doesnt know what he's doing rather than pointing something out that was missed ie no contact and a player diving.0 -
MuttleyCAFC said:
Not a clear sending off for me – but one you have no chance of winning if you appeal. If the ref has seen it and thinks it was a sending off – no way a panel will overturn, even if it is harsh. There has to be a clear error somewhere!
Agreed. Amazed they appealed it and lucky not to have it increased to 4 games.0 -
don't you mean unlucky not to have it increased to 4 games? Be better off without him imo.Chris_from_Sidcup said:MuttleyCAFC said:Not a clear sending off for me – but one you have no chance of winning if you appeal. If the ref has seen it and thinks it was a sending off – no way a panel will overturn, even if it is harsh. There has to be a clear error somewhere!
Agreed. Amazed they appealed it and lucky not to have it increased to 4 games.
0 -
Just because you dont agree doesn't make you right.operationpig said:Speechless, stunned, shocked, saddened, sickened, - f.a = spineless.
0 -
To be honest that's a fair comment but it really wasn't as bad as even the TV footage shows, had it been live on TV there would've been other angles that would've change peoples opinions I'm sure.MuttleyCAFC said:Not a clear sending off for me – but one you have no chance of winning if you appeal. If the ref has seen it and thinks it was a sending off – no way a panel will overturn, even if it is harsh. There has to be a clear error somewhere!
No increase in the ban though, so it stands at 3 games - Semedo still might be able to get out of it - he's magic you know
0 -
That's a surprise - I would have thought they'd need at least 20 cameras for every game you play, you're so massive!operationpig said:To be honest that's a fair comment but it really wasn't as bad as even the TV footage shows, had it been live on TV there would've been other angles that would've change peoples opinions I'm sure.
But seriously, how can you claim to know this? You've only seen it live (I presume), which is only one angle and not slowed down at all? It seems to be you are in no better position to judge than anyone else, really.0 -
Okay.0
-
i reckon operationpig IS semedo.
he comes on here because he misses charlton and he's banging on about the sending off as he's gutted he lost his appeal/is suspended0 - Sponsored links:
-
some of you give my nthn pal a hard time , shame on you
he alrite that op0 -
It's quite okay NLA, I don't mind the 'southern' banter from you guys, I don't mind Charlton if i'm honest, i've always saw you as a proper old football club with tradition, and is rare for me to have a soft spot for a London club but it goes back to the days of when you were at the old Valley and had to share at SP, the days when Lennie Lawrence used to always manage to pull of a miracle and save you from the drop.0
-
Talking of which op he signed Peter Shirtliff who done us a 'massive' turn against 'dirty' Leeds in the 86/87 replay play off final ;0)operationpig said:It's quite okay NLA, I don't mind the 'southern' banter from you guys, I don't mind Charlton if i'm honest, i've always saw you as a proper old football club with tradition, and is rare for me to have a soft spot for a London club but it goes back to the days of when you were at the old Valley and had to share at SP, the days when Lennie Lawrence used to always manage to pull of a miracle and save you from the drop.
0 -
It's still the old Valley mate, we just tidied it up a bit....................operationpig said:It's quite okay NLA, I don't mind the 'southern' banter from you guys, I don't mind Charlton if i'm honest, i've always saw you as a proper old football club with tradition, and is rare for me to have a soft spot for a London club but it goes back to the days of when you were at the old Valley and had to share at SP, the days when Lennie Lawrence used to always manage to pull of a miracle and save you from the drop.
0 -
18 month sentence 5 months ago and Madine's out already and allegedly talking to the Wendies about a return.
www1.skysports.com/football/news/11688/9175641/sky-bet-championship-sheffield-wednesday-set-to-talk-to-striker-gary-madine0 -
How is he out already if he was sentenced to 18 months? I don't know why they say 18 months because it never is. But he hasn't even served half of it0
-
How they do it Brazilian style;
http://blog.foxsoccer.com/post/78572857478/convicted-felon-signs-contract-with-brazilian-team?cmpid=tsmtw:fscom:foxsoccer0 -
Seems like they've put too many 'L's in the club President's name.0
