Jay Dasilva Signs on loan from Chelsea
Comments
-
Size isn't important. I insist on believing that.ross1 said:
Danny Rose at Spurs at about 5ft 7in (which is not tall), seems to be able to do well for Spurs and Englandcolthe3rd said:
Why? Plenty of teams use pacey wing backs, Spurs for example. There seems to be an impression that playing at the back is somewhat of a lesser position. I'm sure KR will know exactly who where his best position is and who is supposed to be replacing.Macronate said:
I think that's fair enough but I wonder if he will be used at left back even when Fox leaves. His pace could be a weapon in this league and may be wasted at the back.ShootersHillGuru said:Shouldn't we perhaps take this at face value for once. We've signed a Premier League youngster who is very well thought of by his club. He fits the bill in being able to play left back if Fox leaves and has enough about him to play other roles where we have been lacking.
I think I'm dismissing the negatives being spouted by everyone and just going to be happy that for once we've appeared to sign the top end of the youngster loan market.
Well done Robinson and the club.
6 -
I'm sure he will, I didn't suggest otherwise.colthe3rd said:
Why? Plenty of teams use pacey wing backs, Spurs for example. There seems to be an impression that playing at the back is somewhat of a lesser position. I'm sure KR will know exactly who where his best position is and who is supposed to be replacing.Macronate said:
I think that's fair enough but I wonder if he will be used at left back even when Fox leaves. His pace could be a weapon in this league and may be wasted at the back.ShootersHillGuru said:Shouldn't we perhaps take this at face value for once. We've signed a Premier League youngster who is very well thought of by his club. He fits the bill in being able to play left back if Fox leaves and has enough about him to play other roles where we have been lacking.
I think I'm dismissing the negatives being spouted by everyone and just going to be happy that for once we've appeared to sign the top end of the youngster loan market.
Well done Robinson and the club.
Spurs don't use wing backs, Rose and Walker are full backs who get forward.
Not been this season but doesn't KR favour 4 at the back? Was just wondering if he intends to deploy Chicksen at left back with DaSilva further forward as part of the 3 if he plays a 4-2-3-1.2 -
Hopefully he's a real top player, assuming Foxy bingo is dancing out the door.0
-
Great. Lucky Charlton fans will get to see a premiership star of the future ! Just as Daisy promised. Who can call her a liar now ?9
-
Lolricky_otto said:
And if he's not, he will be by the end of his stay.cafcdave123 said:I'm going to get it out of the way nice and early, he's shit!
0 -
I'm sure it's aspirationalShootersHillGuru said:1 -
This could potentially be a blinding signing, an up and coming youngster joining us from one of the countries biggest clubs, gives Morgan Fox a lot more competition, and means we can take him out of the firing line occasionally, can't wait to see what other treats are in store in January.1
-
Looks quite alright but look where relying on youth has us.0
-
Sheffield is certainly out of the firing line.Mendonca In Asdas said:This could potentially be a blinding signing, an up and coming youngster joining us from one of the countries biggest clubs, gives Morgan Fox a lot more competition, and means we can take him out of the firing line occasionally, can't wait to see what other treats are in store in January.
1 -
He's coming in because Fox is going though.Mendonca In Asdas said:This could potentially be a blinding signing, an up and coming youngster joining us from one of the countries biggest clubs, gives Morgan Fox a lot more competition, and means we can take him out of the firing line occasionally, can't wait to see what other treats are in store in January.
I hope da Silva is a success because if he is then it gives us a decent chance of getting another promising Chelsea kid on loan next season.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Welcome Jay! Looks a tidy player with a very attacking head on!0
-
Well said!ShootersHillGuru said:Shouldn't we perhaps take this at face value for once. We've signed a Premier League youngster who is very well thought of by his club. He fits the bill in being able to play left back if Fox leaves and has enough about him to play other roles where we have been lacking.
I think I'm dismissing the negatives being spouted by everyone and just going to be happy that for once we've appeared to sign the top end of the youngster loan market.
Well done Robinson and the club.2 -
Sounds, promising, I can't see us playing a 5ft 4 18 year old at LB in a back 4 so I imagine he'll have a more attacking role. I don't see him as a replacement for Fox.
5ft 4 eh, I imagine Solly will be walking around feeling 10ft tall now! Seriously, it's hard to imagine any player that small in the modern Premier League.3 -
Dear GodChris_from_Sidcup said:
He's coming in because Fox is going though.Mendonca In Asdas said:This could potentially be a blinding signing, an up and coming youngster joining us from one of the countries biggest clubs, gives Morgan Fox a lot more competition, and means we can take him out of the firing line occasionally, can't wait to see what other treats are in store in January.
I hope da Silva is a success because if he is then it gives us a decent chance of getting another promising Chelsea kid on loan next season.1 -
Looks useful in those you tube clips, providing he can make the step up to men's football, could be exactly what we've been looking for and sadly lacking in terms of an attacking threat, from left back.
Joking aside the 'too small' comments could be a concern however if he and Solly become the full back pairing as I'm sure @Tutt-Tutt will agree opposition scouts will favour overload with their tall players at the far posts from set pieces, especially as apart from the CBs and CF we are not blessed with too many six footers. It's not KRs favoured formation but maybe three CBs and two wing backs might be the way to go?
Chicksen (a bit taller at 5'8'') of course acquitted himself well at Bradford as LB recently and could be the replacement for Fox with JD playing further forward.
Welcome and good luck Jay.1 -
I imagine this is the sort of loan signing we wouldn't have got under Slade, as Robinson has a reputation of playing young players and playing "proper" football. Whether 18 year olds PL loanees will help us remains to be seen...3
-
Erhun Otzumer is I'm pretty sure 5'3 and has 8 goals this season. Honestly I don't see why he'd stifle anywhere along the left side.2
-
hard to find a better pitch than the Valley nowadaysChizz said:I hope he has a spectacularly successful loan spell for the rest of the season. But he doesn't seem to be the "sort" of player we need to recruit to drag us up the table.
Shouldn't we be looking for hardened, experienced players that have proven themselves to be up for the battle over many seasons? The sort that Lennie used to sign: hungry and angry.
He will be used to perfect pitch conditions, spectacular facilities, brilliant team-mates in peak physical condition, the highest standards of preparation, fitness and medical oversight. He's never played in L1 before.
I'm underwhelmed.1 -
He doesn't even have a Wikipedia page.
Get rid.5 -
No point in having a nice table setting when crap food is being served upCrusty54 said:
hard to find a better pitch than the Valley nowadaysChizz said:I hope he has a spectacularly successful loan spell for the rest of the season. But he doesn't seem to be the "sort" of player we need to recruit to drag us up the table.
Shouldn't we be looking for hardened, experienced players that have proven themselves to be up for the battle over many seasons? The sort that Lennie used to sign: hungry and angry.
He will be used to perfect pitch conditions, spectacular facilities, brilliant team-mates in peak physical condition, the highest standards of preparation, fitness and medical oversight. He's never played in L1 before.
I'm underwhelmed.
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Height has never affected Solly. He's small by any defender height test, but he's one of the best AND MOST LOYAL player's we've had over the last 10 years. Sadly this youngster is only on loan so won't be here to earn legend status, however if he puts in a shift, he will earn our respect. Welcome aboard the skylark young Jay.
He won't know what 'the skylark' is will he??3 -
From viewing the video compilation he certainly seems to be a good option coming forward although he needs to work on his final ball into the box. Not enough footage if him in defensive mode to judge that. I suspect Chelsea's youth team aren't under the cosh very often.2
-
He is set to become the 40th Chelsea player currently out on loan.
Absolutely disgusting how clubs are allowed to stock pile like this.
still, We only get to see our own youngsters for a maximum of 6 months so we might as well see those at bigger clubs.
Expect him to be good, but I've seen a lot of players that are 'good' arrive for us on short term deals over the last 12 months (Fanni, Suk-Young, Motta) and we don't seem to have shown any sign of moving forward with them.
Here's hoping this where the trend starts to buck.8 -
They are wing backs tbf, Spurs don't play with traditional wingers more attacking mids in wide areas. Rose and Walker spend as much time in the opposition half as they do in their own. Pretty much the definition of a wing back.Macronate said:
I'm sure he will, I didn't suggest otherwise.colthe3rd said:
Why? Plenty of teams use pacey wing backs, Spurs for example. There seems to be an impression that playing at the back is somewhat of a lesser position. I'm sure KR will know exactly who where his best position is and who is supposed to be replacing.Macronate said:
I think that's fair enough but I wonder if he will be used at left back even when Fox leaves. His pace could be a weapon in this league and may be wasted at the back.ShootersHillGuru said:Shouldn't we perhaps take this at face value for once. We've signed a Premier League youngster who is very well thought of by his club. He fits the bill in being able to play left back if Fox leaves and has enough about him to play other roles where we have been lacking.
I think I'm dismissing the negatives being spouted by everyone and just going to be happy that for once we've appeared to sign the top end of the youngster loan market.
Well done Robinson and the club.
Spurs don't use wing backs, Rose and Walker are full backs who get forward.
Not been this season but doesn't KR favour 4 at the back? Was just wondering if he intends to deploy Chicksen at left back with DaSilva further forward as part of the 3 if he plays a 4-2-3-1.0 -
Maradonna was only an inch taller - I'm sure he would have given it a good go in the PL. Not necessarily the height but more the strength on the ball.killerandflash said:Sounds, promising, I can't see us playing a 5ft 4 18 year old at LB in a back 4 so I imagine he'll have a more attacking role. I don't see him as a replacement for Fox.
5ft 4 eh, I imagine Solly will be walking around feeling 10ft tall now! Seriously, it's hard to imagine any player that small in the modern Premier League.0 -
believe it's actually over 50Chris_from_Sidcup said:
Chelsea have more players out on loan than in anyones squad! Think it's something like 35 players they have loaned out nowblackpool72 said:Without being bothered to check, i reckon Chelsea must have more players out on loan than we have in our squad.
As for the young chap we have signed i believe he is a replacement for lookman not fox.
Welcome to the madhouse and good luck
0 -
You know there's a button for that?ElfsborgAddick said:
Lolricky_otto said:
And if he's not, he will be by the end of his stay.cafcdave123 said:I'm going to get it out of the way nice and early, he's shit!
2 -
Good luck to the lad, I think if Fox is off (and I believe he is), then Chickson at LB and this lad playing in front of him. With pace like he has he will scare the living daylights out of League 1 defenders.0
-
Ask Otto why.AddicksAddict said:
You know there's a button for that?ElfsborgAddick said:
Lolricky_otto said:
And if he's not, he will be by the end of his stay.cafcdave123 said:I'm going to get it out of the way nice and early, he's shit!
0 -
When Charlton have the likes of Dier, Wanyama or Dembele in midfield, then perhaps we can have attacking full backs like they do!colthe3rd said:
They are wing backs tbf, Spurs don't play with traditional wingers more attacking mids in wide areas. Rose and Walker spend as much time in the opposition half as they do in their own. Pretty much the definition of a wing back.Macronate said:
I'm sure he will, I didn't suggest otherwise.colthe3rd said:
Why? Plenty of teams use pacey wing backs, Spurs for example. There seems to be an impression that playing at the back is somewhat of a lesser position. I'm sure KR will know exactly who where his best position is and who is supposed to be replacing.Macronate said:
I think that's fair enough but I wonder if he will be used at left back even when Fox leaves. His pace could be a weapon in this league and may be wasted at the back.ShootersHillGuru said:Shouldn't we perhaps take this at face value for once. We've signed a Premier League youngster who is very well thought of by his club. He fits the bill in being able to play left back if Fox leaves and has enough about him to play other roles where we have been lacking.
I think I'm dismissing the negatives being spouted by everyone and just going to be happy that for once we've appeared to sign the top end of the youngster loan market.
Well done Robinson and the club.
Spurs don't use wing backs, Rose and Walker are full backs who get forward.
Not been this season but doesn't KR favour 4 at the back? Was just wondering if he intends to deploy Chicksen at left back with DaSilva further forward as part of the 3 if he plays a 4-2-3-1.
Rooney was stocky at 18 already, whereas this kid looks pretty puny at the moment!Addick Addict said:
Maradonna was only an inch taller - I'm sure he would have given it a good go in the PL. Not necessarily the height but more the strength on the ball.killerandflash said:Sounds, promising, I can't see us playing a 5ft 4 18 year old at LB in a back 4 so I imagine he'll have a more attacking role. I don't see him as a replacement for Fox.
5ft 4 eh, I imagine Solly will be walking around feeling 10ft tall now! Seriously, it's hard to imagine any player that small in the modern Premier League.2
