England Cricket 2021 (excluding Ashes)
Comments
-
Addick Addict said:Todds_right_hook said:If the covid outbreak was amongst the coaching staff and back room set up, why couldn’t India put a team out?
they should be heavily fined and next years 1 dayers should be given to Australia instead.0 -
killerandflash said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
I would question the timing of the matches though. Yet again we play NZ, the World Test Champions, in June, as if they were a second rate team. I'm not a fan also of these mini white ball series against countries, instead of a proper set of matches against one country. Instead of yet more matches against India, why not Tests, ODIs and T20s against NZ, with the Tests in July?0 -
So the Indian players are showing the same lack of professionalism and sporting decorum as continually shown by their arrogant prick captain on the pitch. What a shock1
-
There should, imo, always be championship games whilst England are playing test matches. If an England player drops out of form he could regain it in the counties and if a young up and comer starts blitzing runs or wickets he could get a test call. You know, like how it has always been.4
-
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
0 -
mendonca said:I haven't seen the new calendar but I guess that;s the slot for the 100 / ODI Cup. They're suggesting that India can play the test in that slot as they're over for ODI / T20 anyway.That schedule is truly pathetic! That is exactly when we should be having test cricket!
I said this 2 months ago when I ranted that there was no Test cricket this "summer".
People now just coming around to my way of thinking. Might take yous lot some time but you get there in the end.
#teamgolfie.2 -
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?1 -
Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).7 -
LenGlover said:Addick Addict said:mendonca said:I try not to listen to Vaughan much. Surprisingly, he shows different personas according to which media outlets and audience he is with.
I know he has become persona non grata but I'd like to hear Boycott's take on it all.0 -
The view of the Barmy Army re today's events:
3 - Sponsored links:
-
golfaddick said:mendonca said:I haven't seen the new calendar but I guess that;s the slot for the 100 / ODI Cup. They're suggesting that India can play the test in that slot as they're over for ODI / T20 anyway.That schedule is truly pathetic! That is exactly when we should be having test cricket!
I said this 2 months ago when I ranted that there was no Test cricket this "summer".
People now just coming around to my way of thinking. Might take yous lot some time but you get there in the end.
#teamgolfie. #teamgolfie
0 -
golfaddick said:mendonca said:I haven't seen the new calendar but I guess that;s the slot for the 100 / ODI Cup. They're suggesting that India can play the test in that slot as they're over for ODI / T20 anyway.That schedule is truly pathetic! That is exactly when we should be having test cricket!
I said this 2 months ago when I ranted that there was no Test cricket this "summer".
People now just coming around to my way of thinking. Might take yous lot some time but you get there in the end.
#teamgolfie. Next you'll be telling us that Charlton don't have any goal scorers and claiming that you said that all along0 -
The BCCI and the ECB have finally put the final nail in the coffin.This has nothing whatsoever to do with covid.Greed is the winner here.R.i.p test match cricket.Thanks for the memories.5
-
Covid obviously has something to do with it.
The players did not want to run the risk of contacting Covid and miss out on the IPL.
Bearing in mind both physios have Covid and have probably been in close contact with most if not all the players, the concern is real.
The main issue was arranging the last Test too close to the start of the IPL.0 -
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).0 -
2022 schedule is here.
https://ecb-comms.co.uk/2SX2-16U49-B0FB4F1CFD70AF76NRV5WAB5E1653B45DA7C0/cr.aspx
0 -
Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.0 -
Covered End said:Covid obviously has something to do with it.
The players did not want to run the risk of contacting Covid and miss out on the IPL.
Bearing in mind both physios have Covid and have probably been in close contact with most if not all the players, the concern is real.
The main issue was arranging the last Test too close to the start of the IPL.5 -
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.
Typically, seamers - specifically fast-medium and medium-fast seamers - always do well in English conditions. It's why 17 of the 20 players who have taken the most wickets against England in this country, this century, are seamers. So, I would guess that the atmospheric conditions are significantly relevant. Most wickets are taken by seamers, because most wickets fall to seamers.
Spinners tend to take more wickets later in the season, when pitches are more worn. So, it would be interesting to see if there are more wickets taken by spinners in the county championship in the days to come.
Steve Reingold, 23 year old offspinner from Glamorgan and Rob Jones, the 25 year old Lancashire leg-spinner are the top two bowlers in the county championship averages this summer, which, I guess, may, ultimately be good news for the England Test team in the future.
0 -
Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.
Typically, seamers - specifically fast-medium and medium-fast seamers - always do well in English conditions. It's why 17 of the 20 players who have taken the most wickets against England in this country, this century, are seamers. So, I would guess that the atmospheric conditions are significantly relevant. Most wickets are taken by seamers, because most wickets fall to seamers.
Spinners tend to take more wickets later in the season, when pitches are more worn. So, it would be interesting to see if there are more wickets taken by spinners in the county championship in the days to come.
Steve Reingold, 23 year old offspinner from Glamorgan and Rob Jones, the 25 year old Lancashire leg-spinner are the top two bowlers in the county championship averages this summer, which, I guess, may, ultimately be good news for the England Test team in the future.
The words "clutching at straws" spring to mind allied with desperation because we are now reliant on a few days at the end of September for our spinners to take wickets.
The fact that you have chosen to pick Reingold and Jones as being prospective England players is I believe both a reflection of your cricketing knowledge and evidence that you have no valid argument whatsoever as you have chosen to promote two bowlers who have picked up FOUR wickets this season between them.
0/10 Must do better5 - Sponsored links:
-
Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
It's not how many tests it's when they should be played.
Moving test matches about to make way for the hundred is totally bollox.
Play the hundred in April and May if we have to play it at all.
But leave the tests to be played when they should be.4 -
By all accounts India previously asked for the Manchester Test moved to the end of July. The ECB didn't want to do that because of how it would impact on The Hundred with Manchester being one of the grounds being used.
As a result, Harrison couldn't then kick off today about India returning early because of the IPL as the accusation of hypocrisy would have made.4 -
blackpool72 said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
It's not how many tests it's when they should be played.
Moving test matches about to make way for the hundred is totally bollox.
Play the hundred in April and May if we have to play it at all.
But leave the tests to be played when they should be.
the problem is that schools are open in April, may, parts of June and September. The 100 wants you younger people to watch it and if kids are at school, night time games are a no no0 -
Todds_right_hook said:blackpool72 said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
It's not how many tests it's when they should be played.
Moving test matches about to make way for the hundred is totally bollox.
Play the hundred in April and May if we have to play it at all.
But leave the tests to be played when they should be.
the problem is that schools are open in April, may, parts of June and September. The 100 wants you younger people to watch it and if kids are at school, night time games are a no no
It should still be finished by the time kids go to bed.
My grandkids stay up later than me now most nights 😁0 -
Todds_right_hook said:blackpool72 said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
It's not how many tests it's when they should be played.
Moving test matches about to make way for the hundred is totally bollox.
Play the hundred in April and May if we have to play it at all.
But leave the tests to be played when they should be.
the problem is that schools are open in April, may, parts of June and September. The 100 wants you younger people to watch it and if kids are at school, night time games are a no no0 -
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.
Typically, seamers - specifically fast-medium and medium-fast seamers - always do well in English conditions. It's why 17 of the 20 players who have taken the most wickets against England in this country, this century, are seamers. So, I would guess that the atmospheric conditions are significantly relevant. Most wickets are taken by seamers, because most wickets fall to seamers.
Spinners tend to take more wickets later in the season, when pitches are more worn. So, it would be interesting to see if there are more wickets taken by spinners in the county championship in the days to come.
Steve Reingold, 23 year old offspinner from Glamorgan and Rob Jones, the 25 year old Lancashire leg-spinner are the top two bowlers in the county championship averages this summer, which, I guess, may, ultimately be good news for the England Test team in the future.
The words "clutching at straws" spring to mind allied with desperation because we are now reliant on a few days at the end of September for our spinners to take wickets.
The fact that you have chosen to pick Reingold and Jones as being prospective England players is I believe both a reflection of your cricketing knowledge and evidence that you have no valid argument whatsoever as you have chosen to promote two bowlers who have picked up FOUR wickets this season between them.
0/10 Must do better
You've asked me questions about why players might develop more skills by playing cricket in more months and why, in England, there are more bowlers taking wickets with seam bowling than with spin bowling this year, as there has been for many, many years. I answered them, but I can't see how they lead to a logical "argument".
I don't have much interest at all in county cricket. For those that do - great! I like other formats. And my preference is for the highest-standard of cricket, which is tests, obviously. But if some people want to continue to sit and watch their teams play long-format, low-standard (in the main) county cricket, then all power to them.1 -
Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.
Typically, seamers - specifically fast-medium and medium-fast seamers - always do well in English conditions. It's why 17 of the 20 players who have taken the most wickets against England in this country, this century, are seamers. So, I would guess that the atmospheric conditions are significantly relevant. Most wickets are taken by seamers, because most wickets fall to seamers.
Spinners tend to take more wickets later in the season, when pitches are more worn. So, it would be interesting to see if there are more wickets taken by spinners in the county championship in the days to come.
Steve Reingold, 23 year old offspinner from Glamorgan and Rob Jones, the 25 year old Lancashire leg-spinner are the top two bowlers in the county championship averages this summer, which, I guess, may, ultimately be good news for the England Test team in the future.
The words "clutching at straws" spring to mind allied with desperation because we are now reliant on a few days at the end of September for our spinners to take wickets.
The fact that you have chosen to pick Reingold and Jones as being prospective England players is I believe both a reflection of your cricketing knowledge and evidence that you have no valid argument whatsoever as you have chosen to promote two bowlers who have picked up FOUR wickets this season between them.
0/10 Must do better
You've asked me questions about why players might develop more skills by playing cricket in more months and why, in England, there are more bowlers taking wickets with seam bowling than with spin bowling this year, as there has been for many, many years. I answered them, but I can't see how they lead to a logical "argument".
I don't have much interest at all in county cricket. For those that do - great! I like other formats. And my preference is for the highest-standard of cricket, which is tests, obviously. But if some people want to continue to sit and watch their teams play long-format, low-standard (in the main) county cricket, then all power to them.
No interest in county cricket = no interest in the ultimate performance of the Test team. Because when we play next to no CC matches when there are optimum conditions for spinners and batsmen (July and August), you end up with what we have at Test level i.e. batsmen that can't bat time and spinners that haven't developed their game. The knock on effect of that is not just low standard county cricket but low standard Test cricket hence the reason we only have one player in our side who averages more than 34 with the bat.
You might be interested to learn that, as recently as 2010, no less than 8 of the top 30 bowlers in the CC were spinners. And guess what? In that season, counties each played half a dozen CC games in July and August.
5 -
If anyone wants any evidence that Tom Harrison has no interest whatsoever in anything other than himself and why he didn't stick the boot in on India today take a read of this:Shastri held a launch for his new book Stargazing: The Players In My Life on Tuesday August 31, two days before the Fourth Test between his India team and England at the Kia Oval.
ECB Chief Executive Tom Harrison attended the London launch for Ravi Shastri’s new book that took place a few days before the India Head Coach tested positive for Covid-19, triggering a sequence of events that led to the cancellation of the final Test at Old Trafford.
Standard Sport can reveal that Harrison, the ECB Chief Executive, also attended the event.
News of the event has angered many staff at the ECB, who believe that it was not sanctioned by those on the ground organising the tour’s logistics, including Covid-19 guidelines. England’s players feel that they have observed the rules more closely than India this summer. There have even been rumours that India players were out and about in Manchester on Thursday as they awaited the results of their PCR tests that were said to determine the fate of the Test.It is understood that he received an invitation from Shastri and the Board of Control for Cricket in India and wore a mask throughout, except when consuming food and drink. He had not seen the guest list and expected a Covid-safe event, in line with the safer living guidelines that were laid out for both teams by the ECB this summer.
When asked about the book launch on Friday, Harrison opted not to condemn it.
“The position we have had is for people to make decisions on what they think they are able to do or not,” he said. “It’s not for ECB to say, in the context of trying to let people live more freely, we’re not influencing how they live their lives in the constraints of those living standards. That’s not how we operate.”
This comes at an awkward time for Harrison. Last month it was revealed by the Guardian that he and other senior figures at the ECB would share £2.1m Long-Term Incentive payments next year, despite the board having to make 62 redundancies. That angered staff, while relations with England men’s players – weary of the demands placed on them by playing in the pandemic – are tense over this winter’s tour of Australia for the Ashes.
5 -
Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Chizz said:killerandflash said:Chizz said:Addick Addict said:Trying to work out why there are no England Test matches in the seven weeks between 27th June and 17th August next year i.e. the height of the summer. Is there anything else going on during that time?
Straight question that doesn't require a question to answer it: do you think a spin bowler will play more red ball matches and develop his game by playing in April/May and September or in July/August?
A spinner will develop his or her red ball skills by playing. So they more games they play, the more they will develop their skills. In England, the skills required for a spinner are significantly different in April than in September. So, players - not just spinners - should develop their skills appropriately, according to the time of year and the conditions that exist when they are most needed. However, players who have been developing their skills in April and May will likely be in better condition and form than those who, as your question states, develop their game in July/August.
As for whether that player will play more or fewer red ball games in the months you ask, it would very much be dependent on how many were scheduled. But April, May and September could probably accommodate more days' play than July and August.
Red ball cricket isn't the only form of cricket and we shouldn't be driven solely by that format. Not least because England are the ODI World Champions and the current best T20 team in the world. Exclusively developing one format of cricket will be damaging to others. Imagine how difficult it would be for the England women to win the Ashes if they were only to concentrate on one format.
Spinners aren't even picked a lot of the time in April/May and even September because bowlers bowling at 69mph like Stevens on slow tracks with a swinging and seaming ball are king. Equally, being a successful white ball spinner requires a totally different skillset. A white ball spinner will bowl a different pace, length and line to a red ball one because they are trying to achieve different things to different fields.
Which is why, of the top 20 English qualified wicket takers this summer, we have one (yes ONE) that is a spinner. Go on - explain that one without being too verbose and by perhaps offering a logical and coherent explanation for 19 out of 20 being seamers.
Edit - just checked Kent's bowling stats. Out of 148 wickets, just 19 have taken by spinners with the top number from a front line spinner being Logan with 8. The rest, apart from one from Qadri, have been taken by the part timers Denly (4) and Leaning (6).
So, now please explain why 19 of the top English wicket takers in the CC are seamers.
Typically, seamers - specifically fast-medium and medium-fast seamers - always do well in English conditions. It's why 17 of the 20 players who have taken the most wickets against England in this country, this century, are seamers. So, I would guess that the atmospheric conditions are significantly relevant. Most wickets are taken by seamers, because most wickets fall to seamers.
Spinners tend to take more wickets later in the season, when pitches are more worn. So, it would be interesting to see if there are more wickets taken by spinners in the county championship in the days to come.
Steve Reingold, 23 year old offspinner from Glamorgan and Rob Jones, the 25 year old Lancashire leg-spinner are the top two bowlers in the county championship averages this summer, which, I guess, may, ultimately be good news for the England Test team in the future.
The words "clutching at straws" spring to mind allied with desperation because we are now reliant on a few days at the end of September for our spinners to take wickets.
The fact that you have chosen to pick Reingold and Jones as being prospective England players is I believe both a reflection of your cricketing knowledge and evidence that you have no valid argument whatsoever as you have chosen to promote two bowlers who have picked up FOUR wickets this season between them.
0/10 Must do better
You've asked me questions about why players might develop more skills by playing cricket in more months and why, in England, there are more bowlers taking wickets with seam bowling than with spin bowling this year, as there has been for many, many years. I answered them, but I can't see how they lead to a logical "argument".
I don't have much interest at all in county cricket. For those that do - great! I like other formats. And my preference is for the highest-standard of cricket, which is tests, obviously. But if some people want to continue to sit and watch their teams play long-format, low-standard (in the main) county cricket, then all power to them.
No interest in county cricket = no interest in the ultimate performance of the Test team. Because when we play next to no CC matches when there are optimum conditions for spinners and batsmen (July and August), you end up with what we have at Test level i.e. batsmen that can't bat time and spinners that haven't developed their game. The knock on effect of that is not just low standard county cricket but low standard Test cricket hence the reason we only have one player in our side who averages more than 34 with the bat.
You might be interested to learn that, as recently as 2010, no less than 8 of the top 30 bowlers in the CC were spinners. And guess what? In that season, counties each played half a dozen CC games in July and August.0 -
I know I'm a big mouth, but I've said it before and I'll say it again.
Chizz is basically looking to put up a counter view.
He's not particularly bothered what the subject matter is or what side of the "argument" he takes, as long as he can string everyone along.
It's called sealioning and he's very very good at it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning
2