Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Adkins Out? - Match Thread
Comments
-
I'm not saying appoint him. Sack Adkins and give him the job as a caretaker. Then it is up to him to win games straight away.5
-
I'm not one for protests against individuals. Only one I've agreed with, was against Pardew. Made absolutely no difference to us that season. I'm certain Adkins has been a failure, and I'm certain he's a good person.
I think Euell and Jackson need to be given the reins from early next month, with Curbishley providing advice. No I don't think the squad is a good blend, but I don't think it's hopeless like our 08/09 squad. We need to be hard to beat, and then worry about wins. Mid-table is a fantasy at this moment.1 -
Be curious to see how quick we get someone in if Adkins does get replaced.
If we have some kind of "black box" approach that copies Southampton then I imagine we'll already have a list of names.
Wasnt that partly how Adkins got the role in the first place
As didnt Sandgaard | Roddy | Gallen basically sit down and discuss what would happen if Bowyer suddenly left.
I'll be interested to see who replaces him, Jackson would be the bookies favourite whilst you might find Neil Harris on there - We all have our wishlists but equally have to remember that Sandgaard opted for Adkins because of his experience both as a Manager and promoting youth
Maybe its my brain that isnt working properly but cant think of too many other Managers that are a combination of that.
Those who usually promote youth arent always successful due to a lack of experience in the team0 -
Are we sure they turned on the black box yet?
Its a difficult one really as many managers in our budget will have a similar sort of win ratios, and will likely have had years where they have done outstanding and other more lean years. I think there's so many variables that went into these peak and lean years that picking the correct manager it makes the task devilishly hard.
To be honest I'm just at the point where I want someone in who means at least try and play decent passing football though the thirds even if we lose some games and end up mid table. Fed up of seeing us trapped in corners with our full backs.0 -
He will be gone in the morning, or at worst after defeat at Fleetwood.Feel a bit sad for him (nice guy), but he has lost the support of the fan base. He should do the decent thing and walk on Weds morning in a mutual consent styleee (he’s got previous for that).2
-
Not joined in on this thread as this club needs stability and growth for a while but tonight was one poor game too.many. needs to be gone tomorrow. Pack off Roddy, Schwartz and Watson with him.
5 -
time after time an unknown (except to those REALLY in the know) takes over a role and excels for a while .. it seems to me that the tenures of managers, especially in the lower divisions are getting shorter and shorter, disgruntled owners and fans quickly turn on he who was yesterday's heroPrincessFiona said:Who are the viable alternatives?
The obvious candidate, or perhaps the one most mooted on here is Chris Wilder, though he is an example of a manager who rose quickly through the ranks only to burn out like the Hindenburg and he was gone in an instant, bewitched, bothered and bewildered.. Adkins was a good manager 10 years ago and look at him now.
To answer your question, I don't think there is an obvious candidate and unfortunately I don't think that D O F Roddy has his ear close enough to the ground to be able to metaphorically unearth a Nathan Richardson (Wigan) or a Mark Cooper (Barrow) or even an old experienced hand like Simon Grayson, he who's had more clubs up north than (name any famous golfer here) and still has the nous to sometimes turn around a club's fortunes.
Me ? .. I'd go for Mark Robinson the Wimbledon manager. Been around the Wimbledon set up for years and years, knows the lower leagues inside out and would be as good an appointment as anyone. Problem is, he is not a 'name' and we wouldn't get him anyway0 -
.0
-
Curbs was saying its frustrating for them in the studio as they're all Charton supporters. I reckon he might be up for it if asked4
- Sponsored links:
-
Hearing you loud and clear - thanks for your input 😉Ferryman said:.4 -
Wouldn't so sure- I said 3 games ago he needs to get 5 points, so you never know they could loose both those games, and he won't be sacked.CAFCTrev said:He's got 2 games at most, anything less than 2 wins and surely he's gone.0 -
Bloody hell, 200 posts since yesterday lunch time...
1 -
I didn't think he'd announce resignation during his post match interview, he owes it to Thomas to have a conversation with him first. But I think he'll sleep on this result and go tomorrow.Valiantphil said:He will be gone in the morning, or at worst after defeat at Fleetwood.Feel a bit sad for him (nice guy), but he has lost the support of the fan base. He should do the decent thing and walk on Weds morning in a mutual consent styleee (he’s got previous for that).0 -
How about Roy Kent from Ted Lasso?Leaburn Forever said:Isn't Roy Keane looking for a job? 😆1 -
he won't walk, he'll not get his contract paid up, he'll hang on despite the flack and possible humiliation until he is sacked and leaves with a good few quid in his bank a/cFerryman said:
I didn't think he'd announce resignation during his post match interview, he owes it to Thomas to have a conversation with him first. But I think he'll sleep on this result and go tomorrow.Valiantphil said:He will be gone in the morning, or at worst after defeat at Fleetwood.Feel a bit sad for him (nice guy), but he has lost the support of the fan base. He should do the decent thing and walk on Weds morning in a mutual consent styleee (he’s got previous for that).1 -
Whatever they put in those biscuits at the fans forum, they I would like a nibbleScoham said:3 -
I’m sure it’s contrary to popular opinion but I actually feel sorry for Thomas. He had to deal with the situation where Bowyer was making more enemies than friends, and then jumping at a way out. He thought he’d hired a good communicator with lots of experience, empathy and people management skills, and a proven track record at this level. If Bowyer was felt as a bit of an unskilled novice, this very much was a case of ‘getting an adult in charge’. He wouldn’t have been my choice but I can see why that appealed.But I think it is becoming abundantly clear that he backed the wrong horse.39
-
Maybe Ronnie Schwartz will get another chance under his third Charlton manager😂1
-
He has backed the wrong horse mate - no doubt about it!
TS should get Curbs on the phone first thing, and ask him "Can you sort this shit out for me, as we are going down the khazi and I don't know what to do!"
Those that remember the pre-Premier League Curbs will remember that the first thing he made all of his teams, were that they were hard to beat and horrible to play against, with a solid back four and an unbelievable work ethic and desire, that ensured that we were ALWAYS competitive.
I would bet my house that Curbs would turn this lot round and have us in the top six by the end of the season.7 - Sponsored links:
-
3 games later- he has lost it for me now.Callumcafc said:I'm inclined to think he's got 3 games to save his job but needs 5 points minimum from those to buy himself time until Christmas.1 -
My fear is that we become a club which becomes renowned for protests and calling out things, when actually it would be counterproductive given where we are now
Yes - it’s quite normal for football fans to demand a manager is sacked etc
But, I fear people hounding TS - and social media makes this much easier of course - could see him say to himself ‘sod this’ and give us the Spanish Archer
On the pitch, yes it’s awful at the moment
BUT we ALL nearly ended up with NO Charlton Athletic at all not so long ago……
There are some real idiots out there who could - if people get silly - drive away what is clearly the best owner we have had since Alwen et al who got us back home
Some on here saying TS knows nothing about owning a football club - I reckon that is the case for 100% of businessmen who buy football clubs - they have to learn on the job
@JamesSeed is right - he needs a CEO and Varney would be a shoe in for that
Maybe we need to take some on the pitch pain, before the football nurse comes and gives us some nice warm care and attention, and we feel all lovely and warm again about our football TEAM
But I tell you what - even if it goes down the poo pipe football wise - I would rather watch Charlton Athletic in League 2 rather than having no Charlton Athletic at all…..
And before people pile in - I do not believe we will be relegated18 -
It really irritates me that Adkins doesn’t come over, ever to the fans and thank them. Bow did it every game no matter the result - it creates a bond and earns respect
It’s certainly a reason I’ve not warmed to him. It makes him look like a coward IMO7 -
I'd give JJ and Euell a go. I can't see anyone else out there who shouts out as a realistic appointment.
Fans will get behind them and we're in league one. It worked with Powell and Bowyer, so why not?2 -
This, this, this. With bells on and a Scouse "walking's brilliant!" sound effect.AFKABartram said:I’m sure it’s contrary to popular opinion but I actually feel sorry for Thomas. He had to deal with the situation where Bowyer was making more enemies than friends, and then jumping at a way out. He thought he’d hired a good communicator with lots of experience, empathy and people management skills, and a proven track record at this level. If Bowyer was felt as a bit of an unskilled novice, this very much was a case of ‘getting an adult in charge’. He wouldn’t have been my choice but I can see why that appealed.But I think it is becoming abundantly clear that he backed the wrong horse.
The really sad thing is that this has been a train crash that a few people saw coming when Sandgaard declined to have a chief executive running the club for him - someone he could entrust with his investment, someone with their ear to the ground, someone who tonight could be making that call to sort things out to put Adkins' time as manager out of its misery (or could have made a better appointment in the first place).
Maybe he thought that would be Roddy - and yes, I get there's a broader long-term idea with him and both the men's and women's teams - but if the core business is failing, then everything fails. In financial terms. Charlton Athletic have been in deep peril before - but in football terms, Thomas Sandgaard has led us to peril not seen in living memory. As have Ged Roddy and Nigel Adkins.
Sandgaard needs to be grown-up enough to admit he has screwed up and needs help.
On the pitch, we'e got players who look like they listen to anti-motivation podcasts all week, telling them they're shit. The slightest setback, it all falls apart. Adkins comes across as a nice guy, but what the chuff is going on during training if they have so little confidence? They were brittle under Bowyer, but this is something worse.
It's clear that Adkins needs to go. This season hasn't been a ringing endorsement of Roddy's capabilities either.
Sandgaard needs to think again. Most people here will be eternally grateful he saved the club. He now needs to save it from himself.
20 -
You’re joking right?Maccn05 said:It really irritates me that Adkins doesn’t come over, ever to the fans and thank them. Bow did it every game no matter the result - it creates a bond and earns respect
It’s certainly a reason I’ve not warmed to him. It makes him look like a coward IMO1 -
This worries me too - Sandgaard has an almost touching belief that him being active on social media is a good thing.Lordflashheart said:
But, I fear people hounding TS - and social media makes this much easier of course - could see him say to himself ‘sod this’ and give us the Spanish Archer2
This discussion has been closed.
