Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton Rumours Rumours Rumours - The Big Kahuna

16465676970307

Comments

  • edited June 2015
    Deleted this one - got it wrong!
  • People might not like this perspective but I've noticed a few saying that Gudmundsson won't like the supposed lack of ambition being shown by selling Gomez; I think it might be the opposite. Imagine if Johann went to Katrien to discuss whether he'd sign a new contract and she said that we'd just sold a player who played 24 times for us for over £6 million and that was all going back into the playing squad. I'd see that as more ambitious than holding on to Gomez and bringing hardly any new players in
  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?
  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?

    If he comes back on loan then he does. If not we'll have to get someone else. Ffs chill.
  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?

    If he comes back on loan then he does. If not we'll have to get someone else. Ffs chill.
    I am. I'm not bothered about him coming back on loan. I'd rather have a big fee. Chill.
  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?

    If he comes back on loan then he does. If not we'll have to get someone else. Ffs chill.
    I am. I'm not bothered about him coming back on loan. I'd rather have a big fee. Chill.
    6 million up front for a player that has only experienced one season in the Championship is a big fee... Why would you not want him back on loan...?
  • We need 8/9 players, assuming Gomez doesn't come back: right back competition, 2 centre backs, 2 centre mids, arguably a right mid , a left mid and at least 1 striker . Should be doable with 6 million, especially given what we have lost from the wage bill. Obviously we will need more than this if Cousins and JBG leave
  • If Gomez and Bikey leave, we will need more than 2 CB's
  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?

    If he comes back on loan then he does. If not we'll have to get someone else. Ffs chill.
    We should be assertive enough to make the case that we are good at developing young players - quote Wenger and the resurrection of Coquelin as a reference. I'm sure that Gomez as a 17 year old will develop better in a set up and with coaches that he know already - than being loaned out to some other outfit. Sure the Premiership club might wish to place some limits on the number of games he plays, the treatment of any injuries, emergency recalls whatever - but that is all part of the negotiations and the give and take that would be necessary.

  • Last pre season this thread was taken over by a player supposedly signing for us that never happened and now this season it's taken up by a player supposedly leaving us......so judging from last season no one knows what's gonna happen. So can we all stop moaning and crying until something actually happens and can we now start having some rumours of who is coming to us rather then who's leaving us!!
  • Sponsored links:


  • ross1 said:

    If Gomez and Bikey leave, we will need more than 2 CB's

    True
  • Southampton in for Joe, £6m.
  • Sell him to Arsenal for 6-8m. Get a loan back in the first year and a first refusal on any loans in his second season.

    That'll do for me! They should be receptive to that idea after what we did for Coquelin! And Song! And Jenkinson! And Frimp... oh wait, never mind.
  • Southampton in for Joe, £6m.

    Higher !!!

  • And examples of when Charlton managed to negotiate a loan back?

    If he comes back on loan then he does. If not we'll have to get someone else. Ffs chill.
    I am. I'm not bothered about him coming back on loan. I'd rather have a big fee. Chill.
    6 million up front for a player that has only experienced one season in the Championship is a big fee... Why would you not want him back on loan...?
    I'd love him back but it's not going to happen. I meant I'd rather have a big fee and no loan than a low fee and a loan back for one season.
  • Last pre season this thread was taken over by a player supposedly signing for us that negver happened and now this season it's taken up by a player supposedly leaving us......so judging from last season no one knows what's gonna happen. So can we all stop moaning and crying until something actually happens and can we now start having some rumours of who is coming to us rather then who's leaving us!!

    I heard Delort is interested in a move to us... His Dad reckons so too.
  • Agree with the 'Sell Him' side of the debate on here, much as I'd like to keep young Joe, you could argue that his value is at a premium now, before he hit's the notorious 'second season' syndrome. I think that with the kind of numbers being talked about here ($6M), you should be able to build a side that is finishing comfortably top half.

    Not sure going there is the best thing for his career, but that is another debate entirely.
  • Sponsored links:


  • If they really are 3 or 4 clubs after him, we should be getting more than £6m. Let the bidding begin.
  • Southampton in for Joe, £6m.

    That would be amazing. Sell him to Saints to £6 million and include a sell-on fee. When a Champions League team inevitably buy him off Saints we'll get even more cash
  • A bidding war is what we want. It means we hold the aces. The loan back option could be, if he is going to be loaned to a Championship side – it has to be us. I can’t see any buyer not being happy to sign up to that.
  • And with a nice sell on - much better chance of him being sold when he gets too good for them.
  • jams said:

    Would feel much happier about him going to Southampton than Liverpool - much better chance of good development

    plus they will sell him for £25m+ in a few years and we'll get our 20%
  • Shut up about Gomez!!! Leave the rumours page for rumours!
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!