Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Has Bowyer lost it?

16970727475158

Comments

  • Scoham said:
    MrOneLung said:
    Let’s not forget we should have stayed up last season. No other team was as goalless as us during the run in. 
    Corrected for you, was always going to be very difficult to stay up when Bonne was our only player left who scored more than 3 goals last season. Plenty of managers would have got relegated long before the last game with the limited resources and other issues Bowyer had to deal with.
    We won 5 games after boxing day and only won 6 after the 19th of October. 


  • edited February 2021
    Scoham said:
    MrOneLung said:
    Let’s not forget we should have stayed up last season. No other team was as goalless as us during the run in. 
    Corrected for you, was always going to be very difficult to stay up when Bonne was our only player left who scored more than 3 goals last season. Plenty of managers would have got relegated long before the last game with the limited resources and other issues Bowyer had to deal with.

    I mean it was Barnsley and Luton who finished ahead of us on the final day, hardly like they were spending millions themselves. Then the same again with Wigan who only finished behind us because of a points deduction.
  • (Had put this on the wrong thread) 

    I still think ‘life’ is playing a massive part in accentuating the unrest.

    We’re all f***ed off having to endure with these living life limitations and the overall depressive backdrop. We’ve all got a lot less to focus on, the fortunes of our football team are being magnified, and our unhappiness with it all is, by default, being escalated. It was additionally escalated because we had a new owner with what we think is a few quid. Yet, in reality, due to the salary cap that has had no impact.

    Sandgaard however has been given a massive lesson in just how fickle football fans can be. 2-3 months ago he was constantly bombarded with people ensuring he recognised Bowyer was a Mr Charlton legend that needed protection and preservation. A disappointing two months has been all that’s needed to see that almost completely unwound

    Accurate.

    I hope everyone reads this takes it in and can think in an objective and realistic way.

    Bowyer is likely to be overwhelmed and is finding things to be a bizarre internal challenge. They are struggling and messing it up a bit.

    Allow everyone at the valley to re-charge and have some time.

    I do understand the need for high expectations and we've got good players but it's simply just an awful sh*t season anyway. 

    It is a diarrhea mosh pit. For a lot of reasons.

    Bowyer has lost it a bit but he can and will get it back. The players also know he's had it rough and they should all stick together and be on the same side.

    I doubt that will happen but it needs to.

    It will only happen if the fans reach out and make it clear that we know how sh*t things have been. We know we won't be at our best, at present...due to a lot of off field problems and distractions.

    Allow the pressure to minimise for this season.

    If necessary, get on their backs next season.



  • Does getting changed in a lounge make a difference? Whatever it may be, Bow seems a lot more nervy and irrational in SE7 than out of it.
    And as has been mentioned previously, genuinely don't know the answer but the thought is there - how was the January window managed - and how much input? 
    I was wondering if changing in the lounges was one factor.
    Why don't we have the changing room?
    It can't hurt can it?
  • Scoham said:
    MrOneLung said:
    Let’s not forget we should have stayed up last season. No other team was as goalless as us during the run in. 
    Corrected for you, was always going to be very difficult to stay up when Bonne was our only player left who scored more than 3 goals last season. Plenty of managers would have got relegated long before the last game with the limited resources and other issues Bowyer had to deal with.

    I mean it was Barnsley and Luton who finished ahead of us on the final day, hardly like they were spending millions themselves. Then the same again with Wigan who only finished behind us because of a points deduction.
    We had even lower budgets and them plus all the off the field nonsense to deal with. Can’t win games without goals - where were they coming from after the season restarted, other than Bonne?
  • So are you saying we had a squad with only one forward last season ?


  • Sponsored links:


  • edited February 2021
    As for the theory that managers really don't matter much and that player quality, as reflected by how much they demand in the marketplace (club wage bill) is what matters.... CAFC's rank the last 3 years in each division ...
    SEASON..............wage bill rank............league finish
    2018-19..................2................................3
    2019-20..................23.............................23
    2020-21.............capped............................8
    This kind of data has been shown to be true for some time across all leagues, although within any one season, or within any one club, there is obvious variation. Over the long term though, better players... win. We don't have them at the moment. I like Lee, but he was not as good as we gave him credit for two seasons ago and he is not as bad as some think now. We need better.... players, not a manager change.
  • As for the theory that managers really don't matter much and that player quality, as reflected by how much they demand in the marketplace (club wage bill) is what matters.... CAFC's rank the last 3 years in each division ...
    SEASON..............wage bill rank............league finish
    2018-18..................2................................3
    2019-20..................23.............................23
    2020-21.............capped............................8
    This kind of data has been shown to be true for some time across all leagues, although within any one season, or within any one club, there is obvious variation. Over the long term though, better players... win. We don't have them at the moment. I like Lee, but he was not as good as we gave him credit for two seasons ago and he is not as bad as some think now. We need better.... players, not a manager change.
    We almost certainly have a top six wage bill, this season, for this league....... 
  • Plus we badly missed Gallagher after he left, I think it’s a safe bet to say if we had kept Gallagher & had Taylor for the run in we wouldn’t have gone down. Neither of those were ultimately Bowyers fault. I think it’s really harsh to say it was Bowyers fault we got relegated, if he’d kept us up it would of been a miracle
    Every word of that is true.  Of course it is not his fault, that's very different to saying he was faultless though. 
  • I do believe there’s an element of our support that if they caught Bowyer shagging their missus they would not only not kick up a fuss but they’d also make him a brew and light him up a Marlboro afterwards.
     TBF I'd probably do that if I caught Steve Evans having a crack.
  • I'm still in the stick with Bowyer camp. He's made some mistakes but I'm sure he has learnt a few lessons. The management team wanted 2 players for each position , unfortunately 2 of the 4 central defenders aren't good enough for a promotion team and that was not addressed in January. Thomas S will make any decision for the good of the club , if he still has faith in LB he should stick with him.
  • Plus we badly missed Gallagher after he left, I think it’s a safe bet to say if we had kept Gallagher & had Taylor for the run in we wouldn’t have gone down. Neither of those were ultimately Bowyers fault. I think it’s really harsh to say it was Bowyers fault we got relegated, if he’d kept us up it would of been a miracle
    Is anyone actually saying “it was Bowyer’s fault we got relegated” last season? I haven’t actually seen that written anywhere, feels a bit strawman. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • times have changed , players longevity of contract and the amount of loans mean it’s all a complete merry go round , football isn’t players/managers  staying at clubs for most of their careers 


  • From someone on twitter.

    Maybe Arsenal should have stuck with Bruce Rioch, United with Ron Atkinson, Liverpool with with Rodgers, Bournemouth with Paul Groves etc. Or indeed us when Parky was sacked and Powell brought in

    There are plenty of examples of clubs benefiting from being patient, but there are also examples where making the change turned out to be the right decision
    Liverpool were almost certainly wrong to sack Phil Taylor........
  • I think Bowyer will start next season. He’ll be backed in a rebuild we haven’t seen the like since Chris Powell’s promotion season. Thomas will have to do that if he wants promotion. That will be the minimum requirement. If we’re not right up and at it by November then I think Lee will be gone but I’m quite happy for that time and confidence to be given. This season was dead three weeks ago and the funeral was yesterday.
    I think you are wrong.  I think Bowyer will start next season.  He will take on a handful of new players.  We will totter along in or near the play off places.  Calls for his sacking will be met with accusations of a lack of loyalty.  Rinse and Repeat.
  • edited February 2021

    From someone on twitter.

    "I hope they are wrong now".  The worst get out clause ever.


  • Cafc43v3r said:
    As for the theory that managers really don't matter much and that player quality, as reflected by how much they demand in the marketplace (club wage bill) is what matters.... CAFC's rank the last 3 years in each division ...
    SEASON..............wage bill rank............league finish
    2018-18..................2................................3
    2019-20..................23.............................23
    2020-21.............capped............................8
    This kind of data has been shown to be true for some time across all leagues, although within any one season, or within any one club, there is obvious variation. Over the long term though, better players... win. We don't have them at the moment. I like Lee, but he was not as good as we gave him credit for two seasons ago and he is not as bad as some think now. We need better.... players, not a manager change.
    We almost certainly have a top six wage bill, this season, for this league....... 
    And we are 8th now and was 6th just 48 hours ago. Sounds about right.
  • esseffect said:
    For those saying “no one here said it was Bowyers fault for getting us relegated” 

    You are the same people referencing his ‘downfall’ as starting last season.

    stop backtracking 
    Ah right, so no one has actually said it was Bowyer’s fault we got relegated. Thought so.
This discussion has been closed.

Roland Out Forever!