https://youtu.be/qEGo97JefUM
MacGillivray
Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
**Adkins Gone - Jackson Caretaker**
Comments
-
It’s called the Match Preview thread and @ForeverAddickted is a bit behind with this weeks Sunderland version as he’s been skiving in Eastbourne 😉.colthe3rd said:Any chance of a dedicated thread for people to post fantasy lineups?3 -
Try living in Plymouth!Oggy Red said:
I know. Count yourself lucky that you don't live down here in Cornwall.Mendonca In Asdas said:20 points behind Plymouth!!! Plymouth!!!
And all your mates are GREEN ARMY!
To be fair, they haven't really rubbed my nose in it.
More like, "WTF is going on at your club? I had them down as a good bet for promotion."
Mind you, we go to Argyle in a few weeks. Might be a bit different then!
…and Argyle come to the valley first don’t they?
…and my house is worth £320,000 😉1 -
Alot of people starting Dobson in their lineups! Not saying I disagree as I could never fathom why he disappeared he played ok I though before he was dropped. Interesting to see if we do have a new structure and lineup this weekend2
-
He had an absolute nightmare at MK Dons, but since then he's also looked like Pirlo against Crawley and some kids so deserves some B.O.D.AndyG said:Alot of people starting Dobson in their lineups! Not saying I disagree as I could never fathom why he disappeared he played ok I though before he was dropped. Interesting to see if we do have a new structure and lineup this weekend0 -
Ferryman said:
Is it only me that finds it hard to take someone seriously when he's recording it from his bedroom studio? I half expected his mum to walk in with a cup of tea and a choccy biscuit..........................
4 -
Yup but others have also had a nightmare game and havent been sent to Siberia! On that basis Albie would be on Jupiter by now 😂Leuth said:
He had an absolute nightmare at MK Dons, but since then he's also looked like Pirlo against Crawley and some kids so deserves some B.O.D.AndyG said:Alot of people starting Dobson in their lineups! Not saying I disagree as I could never fathom why he disappeared he played ok I though before he was dropped. Interesting to see if we do have a new structure and lineup this weekend2 -
Dobson was a CB in his youth at West Ham and has the defensive mindset we need at CDM. He can pick a pass and was well thought of at Wimbledon but Pirlo he ain’t.AndyG said:Alot of people starting Dobson in their lineups! Not saying I disagree as I could never fathom why he disappeared he played ok I though before he was dropped. Interesting to see if we do have a new structure and lineup this weekendIf he can temper the urge to dive in on occasions perhaps with help from an old head like Arter Watson or Pearce talking talking him through a game he could nail that position down.2 -
I believe Lee is ill.Starinnaddick said:Have you deliberately left Lee out?0 -
Dobson would certainly have something to prove against his old club.6
-
Make sure there is a laundry basket in the dressing room .......................... just in case.seth plum said:From memory Jackson has played under or observed a lot of managers since he has been at Charlton.
Phil Parkinson
Keith Peacock
Chris Powell
Jose Riga
Bob Peeters
Damian Matthew
Guy Luzon
Karel Fraeye
Russell Slade
Karl Robinson
Kevin Nugent
Lee Bowyer
Nigel Adkins
I wonder what the single best quality Jacko could take as a learning point from each person on that list.
Hmm beaten to the punch about 6 hours ago0 - Sponsored links:
-
He's GK.there.soapboxsam said:church-lane said:I reckon JJ will look to stop the rot and will pick a side something like this.
Macgillivray Henderson HarnessLavelle Famewo PearceGunter Matthews Souare PurringtonStockley
This is the last time I say this ?
Stockley isn't a lone striker
2 -
Not true. You're looking at the team for the second half. I was suggesting the starting line up.Dazzler21 said:
He's GK.there.soapboxsam said:church-lane said:I reckon JJ will look to stop the rot and will pick a side something like this.
Macgillivray Henderson HarnessLavelle Famewo PearceGunter Matthews Souare PurringtonStockley
This is the last time I say this ?
Stockley isn't a lone striker1 -
Looks like I’ve got to change my avatar again 🤦🏻♀️12
-
I'm not a massive Dobson fan, but on that basis he has to be pickedStarinnaddick said:Dobson would certainly have something to prove against his old club.
"Having dominated the game, but hit the woodwork 8 times, Sunderland were stunned in the 89th minute when former player George Dobson came back to haunt them, dribbling past 5 players before curling the ball into the top corner from 25 yards to score a brilliant winner."8 -
Blackpool here, always keep an eye out for you lot. Desperate times but you will pull through. There is always light at the end of the tunnel . Keep the faith52
-
RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣Matthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?
5 -
Funny how Stockley is everyone’s number one choice, when Davison has been the better option all season. Is he really seen as a safer bet?0
-
Stockley was shocking the other night. Granted he scored, but dear oh dear. He has no pace, he can’t hold up the ball, he can’t flick it on to team mates. And he even missed a headed sitter. Plus we just look so poor when he’s the sole striker.JamesSeed said:Funny how Stockley is everyone’s number one choice, when Davison has been the better option all season. Is he really seen as a safer bet?6 -
Let's forget what the players have done up to this point. Fresh start for all.11
-
You do know you can get 3 beds in Plymouth for £100,000.EugenesAxe said:
Try living in Plymouth!Oggy Red said:
I know. Count yourself lucky that you don't live down here in Cornwall.Mendonca In Asdas said:20 points behind Plymouth!!! Plymouth!!!
And all your mates are GREEN ARMY!
To be fair, they haven't really rubbed my nose in it.
More like, "WTF is going on at your club? I had them down as a good bet for promotion."
Mind you, we go to Argyle in a few weeks. Might be a bit different then!
…and Argyle come to the valley first don’t they?
…and my house is worth £320,000 😉4 - Sponsored links:
-
Winning post.charltonbob said:RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣MacGillivrayMatthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?
Get rid of the non contributing light weight wingers.
It's like playing with 9 men and when NA brought on CBT for Lee at Lincoln, it was like playing with 8 players.
Then he couldn't understand why we barely got a kick for 70 mins.0 -
Thanks for that.DagenhamAddick said:Here is the Talkshite Interview With Thomas this morning LINK0 -
Better be bloody comfy for over £33k each!clb74 said:
You do know you can get 3 beds in Plymouth for £100,000.EugenesAxe said:
Try living in Plymouth!Oggy Red said:
I know. Count yourself lucky that you don't live down here in Cornwall.Mendonca In Asdas said:20 points behind Plymouth!!! Plymouth!!!
And all your mates are GREEN ARMY!
To be fair, they haven't really rubbed my nose in it.
More like, "WTF is going on at your club? I had them down as a good bet for promotion."
Mind you, we go to Argyle in a few weeks. Might be a bit different then!
…and Argyle come to the valley first don’t they?
…and my house is worth £320,000 😉12 -
CBT has been a genuine bright spark when used well. He's looked superb when Lee has been on the field and less good when Lee hasn't, but ruling him out is very weird.Covered End said:
Winning post.charltonbob said:RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣MacGillivrayMatthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?
Get rid of the non contributing light weight wingers.
It's like playing with 9 men and when NA brought on CBT for Lee at Lincoln, it was like playing with 8 players.
Then he couldn't understand why we barely got a kick for 70 mins.
As for Leko, he's been arguably our best player this season.
What's wrong with wide forwards? If you play a midfield 3 behind them, they should be able to cover the full-backs adequately and the wingers should be free to attack2 -
'non contributing lightweight wingers' is some Bowyer talk. At some point you have to back attacking play. Really annoyed by that phrase. Leko, CBT, even DJ really not contributed? Look at our goals and assists...2
-
Kirk and Leko barely touched the ball at Lincoln and CBT didn't either until late on.Leuth said:
CBT has been a genuine bright spark when used well. He's looked superb when Lee has been on the field and less good when Lee hasn't, but ruling him out is very weird.Covered End said:
Winning post.charltonbob said:RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣MacGillivrayMatthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?
Get rid of the non contributing light weight wingers.
It's like playing with 9 men and when NA brought on CBT for Lee at Lincoln, it was like playing with 8 players.
Then he couldn't understand why we barely got a kick for 70 mins.
As for Leko, he's been arguably our best player this season.
What's wrong with wide forwards? If you play a midfield 3 behind them, they should be able to cover the full-backs adequately and the wingers should be free to attack
What percentage of time has CBT been used well?
We need 100%, but I'd reckon it's around 25%, so not contributing 75%.
The wide forwards have not been doing any defensive duties and not much offensive either.
Leko played well against Accrington, but CBT barely figured again until late on.
What is needed is players that can offer 100% from first to last whistle.
Not players that contribute every 4 or 5 games and even then only for a small part of the game.
Our full backs have been 2v1 all season and boy could they do with some protection.
We're 3rd from bottom, not 3rd from top.9 -
They only get my respect if it is a jazz studiotangoflash said:Ferryman said:
Is it only me that finds it hard to take someone seriously when he's recording it from his bedroom studio? I half expected his mum to walk in with a cup of tea and a choccy biscuit..........................7 -
Or 10 years ago Scott Wagstaffcharltonbob said:RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣MacGillivrayMatthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?3 -
Don't have a lot to add other than good luck to NA. Seemed like a thoroughly decent bloke. And there were signs last season that he was a decent manager. But it didn't work out, and this needed to happen. Arguably sooner than it did, but certainly no later than it did.
As for Jacko, I certainly wish him the best. I'm not convinced he's the answer. He's been a part of three coaching regimes now, all three of which have fallen apart (with success mixed in under Bowyer). And not just fallen apart, but fallen apart in terms of tactics and organization. I know some say he's the defensive and set pieces coach, I'm not sure if that's true or perceived, but if it is true then he certainly has to take a fair share of the blame for our results this season.
All that said, given his ties to the club and the fact that he is a young and hungry coach, I do think he deserves a few games as an audition. But if I were TS/Roddy/Gallen et al, I would be looking for a back up in case Jackson doesn't work out.
This is the job he wanted after Bows left, maybe even after Robbo left. He's got it now. Hope he smashes it.9 -
If you play 3 in midfield, it is surely the absolute basics that the two wider of the 3 cover their respective fullbacks. Adkins hasn't had us doing that for some reasonCovered End said:
Kirk and Leko barely touched the ball at Lincoln and CBT didn't either until late on.Leuth said:
CBT has been a genuine bright spark when used well. He's looked superb when Lee has been on the field and less good when Lee hasn't, but ruling him out is very weird.Covered End said:
Winning post.charltonbob said:RedChaser said:
Not sure about persevering with 2 wingers again Daz so I’ve made a couple of changes to make us a bit more solid and experienced 😉Dazzler21 said:Starinnaddick said:Can't wait to see the team JJ picks for Sunderland. He's had Thursday to get them fit. 🤣MacGillivrayMatthews - Lavelle - Famewo Pearce - Purrington
Jaiyesime- Leko - Dobson - Arter - GilbeyWashington - Stockley
Henderson, Gunter, Pearce, Morgan, Watson, Leko, Davison, Famewo, DJ,
That'd be my pick. If DJ isn't doing it, easy to rotate him with Leko and Morgan has also done a job from LM before now.
Exactly we've already seen you can't play with two wingers, even more with two wingers who won't chase back. What we need is a Johnny Robinson who'll run up & down all day long & a Graham Stuart who'll give you width but can also tuck in & again will chase back. Well I can dream can't I ?
Get rid of the non contributing light weight wingers.
It's like playing with 9 men and when NA brought on CBT for Lee at Lincoln, it was like playing with 8 players.
Then he couldn't understand why we barely got a kick for 70 mins.
As for Leko, he's been arguably our best player this season.
What's wrong with wide forwards? If you play a midfield 3 behind them, they should be able to cover the full-backs adequately and the wingers should be free to attack
What percentage of time has CBT been used well?
We need 100%, but I'd reckon it's around 25%, so not contributing 75%.
The wide forwards have not been doing any defensive duties and not much offensive either.
Leko played well against Accrington, but CBT barely figured again until late on.
What is needed is players that can offer 100% from first to last whistle.
Not players that contribute every 4 or 5 games and even then only for a small part of the game.
Our full backs have been 2v1 all season and boy could they do with some protection.
We're 3rd from bottom, not 3rd from top.2
