Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton Only - January 2022 Transfer Rumours (Deadline Day p.97)
Comments
-
Great post, couldn't agree more.Addick_8 said:
So let me get this right, if the manager thinks players playing for the club that we as fans pay good money to support up and down the country as well as spend so much of our time on, aren’t pulling their weight and taking the piss so calls them out for it he’s pulled a “dick move” ?Leuth said:
Yeah, and it was both a misdiagnosis and a dick move. So glad he's not our manager, and hopefully never will be againAddick_8 said:This quote from Bowyer back when we lost 4-2 to Burton last season (first defeat in 9) couldn’t be more true about a majority of this squad right now:
“They are playing for a great club and some of the players we have in this dressing room were struggling to find clubs – this club took you out of that problem. The club expects you to rebound with hard work – that’s all”You seem to have forgot who took us to Wembley & out of this gutter of a league then almost kept us up with everything stacked against him? Think he deserves a lot more then your post.
Not going to get on everyone’s nerves and make this all about Bowyer on a transfers thread so I’ll just leave it with the above.
11 -
Bowyer thought the answer to everything was hard work. The problem when things are bad? Not enough effort. The solution? Work harder, train harder. What at first galvanises and inspires, such as in the promotion season (when things are going well, and we have the best midfield in the league) and the start of the Championship season (when things are going well, and Chelsea kindly lend us the best midfielder in the league) becomes wearying, divisive, petty and ultimately rotten when it doesn't go so well (everything from about November in the Championship season onward; everything the season after when Inniss got injured). Yes, he showed an ability to get (admittedly overpowered) players playing, fighting, unified. But when it unravelled it unravelled completely and he showed abysmal man-management in a crisis. 'Calling out' your players? No truly successful manager does it, or very rarely. Certainly not to the extent Bowyer did it. I think he fell into a genuinely abusive relationship with our squad, if not in the Championship season then certainly the season after, and quotes that paraphrase to 'you were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when I met you' fall squarely into the 'abusive' category imo. I don't want us with a manager who will do that, simple as that really. This isn't to denigrate his achievements, which were, initially, considerable.11
-
You could be onto something there ................... footballers running, whatever next ?addick1956 said:
I was watching something about Charlton's 10p best goals and was reminded about the pace of our players like Robinson, Powell, Warren, Newton and the skill. Also the ability to move up with the attack and press. I was struck by the superb way Leaburn held up the ball, moved and passed it. We don't have this now and I am told the game us faster etc. I wonder. Is it this keep running idea that is knackering players .Simonsen said:Agree with Ken Shabby; too many touches in the final 3rd and without Stockley the more direct approach is hopeless.0 -
I’ve seen this line before about everything unraveling for Bow, but both instances this happened also coincided with crippling injuries - that has to be considered.Leuth said:Bowyer thought the answer to everything was hard work. The problem when things are bad? Not enough effort. The solution? Work harder, train harder. What at first galvanises and inspires, such as in the promotion season (when things are going well, and we have the best midfield in the league) and the start of the Championship season (when things are going well, and Chelsea kindly lend us the best midfielder in the league) becomes wearying, divisive, petty and ultimately rotten when it doesn't go so well (everything from about November in the Championship season onward; everything the season after when Inniss got injured). Yes, he showed an ability to get (admittedly overpowered) players playing, fighting, unified. But when it unravelled it unravelled completely and he showed abysmal man-management in a crisis. 'Calling out' your players? No truly successful manager does it, or very rarely. Certainly not to the extent Bowyer did it. I think he fell into a genuinely abusive relationship with our squad, if not in the Championship season then certainly the season after, and quotes that paraphrase to 'you were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when I met you' fall squarely into the 'abusive' category imo. I don't want us with a manager who will do that, simple as that really. This isn't to denigrate his achievements, which were, initially, considerable.
I’m pretty when he left us we were around the playoffs and had won 3/4 on the spin? So he had recovered the dressing room or whatever.
So I’m not sure that narrative sits well or rings true.But what was clear with Bow was he spoke to openly, emotionally and too soon after games and made some absolute howlers because of it
Personally I found Bows truth refreshing and sometimes awkward but preferred that over the banal lies most trot out.16 -
Yes we do without a doubt, will we sign one ? I doubt it.LTKapal said:Real question is when Stockley returns will we look better? I can't help but feel like Lee's downturn in form has occurred when the Stockley Injury occurred and he does help the linkup play a lot, if that is the case do we need another striker?0 -
Do you mean "I was pretty" ?Maccn05 said:
I’ve seen this line before about everything unraveling for Bow, but both instances this happened also coincided with crippling injuries - that has to be considered.Leuth said:Bowyer thought the answer to everything was hard work. The problem when things are bad? Not enough effort. The solution? Work harder, train harder. What at first galvanises and inspires, such as in the promotion season (when things are going well, and we have the best midfield in the league) and the start of the Championship season (when things are going well, and Chelsea kindly lend us the best midfielder in the league) becomes wearying, divisive, petty and ultimately rotten when it doesn't go so well (everything from about November in the Championship season onward; everything the season after when Inniss got injured). Yes, he showed an ability to get (admittedly overpowered) players playing, fighting, unified. But when it unravelled it unravelled completely and he showed abysmal man-management in a crisis. 'Calling out' your players? No truly successful manager does it, or very rarely. Certainly not to the extent Bowyer did it. I think he fell into a genuinely abusive relationship with our squad, if not in the Championship season then certainly the season after, and quotes that paraphrase to 'you were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when I met you' fall squarely into the 'abusive' category imo. I don't want us with a manager who will do that, simple as that really. This isn't to denigrate his achievements, which were, initially, considerable.
I’m pretty when he left us we were around the playoffs and had won 3/4 on the spin? So he had recovered the dressing room or whatever.
So I’m not sure that narrative sits well or rings true.But what was clear with Bow was he spoke to openly, emotionally and too soon after games and made some absolute howlers because of it
Personally I found Bows truth refreshing and sometimes awkward but preferred that over the banal lies most trot out.
1 -
We do and fee already agreed …Athletico Charlton said:6 -
We won 2 and drew 2 of his last 4 games. Those 2 wins were wins 5 and 6 of his last 26 games. We were 8th.Maccn05 said:
I’ve seen this line before about everything unraveling for Bow, but both instances this happened also coincided with crippling injuries - that has to be considered.Leuth said:Bowyer thought the answer to everything was hard work. The problem when things are bad? Not enough effort. The solution? Work harder, train harder. What at first galvanises and inspires, such as in the promotion season (when things are going well, and we have the best midfield in the league) and the start of the Championship season (when things are going well, and Chelsea kindly lend us the best midfielder in the league) becomes wearying, divisive, petty and ultimately rotten when it doesn't go so well (everything from about November in the Championship season onward; everything the season after when Inniss got injured). Yes, he showed an ability to get (admittedly overpowered) players playing, fighting, unified. But when it unravelled it unravelled completely and he showed abysmal man-management in a crisis. 'Calling out' your players? No truly successful manager does it, or very rarely. Certainly not to the extent Bowyer did it. I think he fell into a genuinely abusive relationship with our squad, if not in the Championship season then certainly the season after, and quotes that paraphrase to 'you were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when I met you' fall squarely into the 'abusive' category imo. I don't want us with a manager who will do that, simple as that really. This isn't to denigrate his achievements, which were, initially, considerable.
I’m pretty when he left us we were around the playoffs and had won 3/4 on the spin? So he had recovered the dressing room or whatever.
So I’m not sure that narrative sits well or rings true.But what was clear with Bow was he spoke to openly, emotionally and too soon after games and made some absolute howlers because of it
Personally I found Bows truth refreshing and sometimes awkward but preferred that over the banal lies most trot out.
Our results for over the last year, most seasons, would leave us about 14th-16th.
Bar 3 10 games spells, when we have had title form, over the last 18 months we have been, mainly, in relegation form. It's the fact we switch on and off so regularly that's the biggest problem.1 -
So marcus brown were still working on
We're out the running for defoe
And browne is the last transfer of this window.
Well this window was a lot of fun and building for next season !!!2 -
I’m not sure I feel comfortable without a dramatic deadline day with unexpected signings and departures.Can’t we at least sign another Matt Smith before he moves to Doncaster in the summer?1
- Sponsored links:
-
I agree with the first line.Leuth said:Bowyer thought the answer to everything was hard work. The problem when things are bad? Not enough effort. The solution? Work harder, train harder. What at first galvanises and inspires, such as in the promotion season (when things are going well, and we have the best midfield in the league) and the start of the Championship season (when things are going well, and Chelsea kindly lend us the best midfielder in the league) becomes wearying, divisive, petty and ultimately rotten when it doesn't go so well (everything from about November in the Championship season onward; everything the season after when Inniss got injured). Yes, he showed an ability to get (admittedly overpowered) players playing, fighting, unified. But when it unravelled it unravelled completely and he showed abysmal man-management in a crisis. 'Calling out' your players? No truly successful manager does it, or very rarely. Certainly not to the extent Bowyer did it. I think he fell into a genuinely abusive relationship with our squad, if not in the Championship season then certainly the season after, and quotes that paraphrase to 'you were working as a waitress in a cocktail bar when I met you' fall squarely into the 'abusive' category imo. I don't want us with a manager who will do that, simple as that really. This isn't to denigrate his achievements, which were, initially, considerable.
This current squad would aggravate Bowyer no end. One of the big problems with this squad, IMO, is they are at their level. More importantly they know it was well.1 -
No longer in running for Defoe - SLP4
-
0 -
Bowyer was absolutely spot on here.Leuth said:
Yeah, and it was both a misdiagnosis and a dick move. So glad he's not our manager, and hopefully never will be againAddick_8 said:This quote from Bowyer back when we lost 4-2 to Burton last season (first defeat in 9) couldn’t be more true about a majority of this squad right now:
“They are playing for a great club and some of the players we have in this dressing room were struggling to find clubs – this club took you out of that problem. The club expects you to rebound with hard work – that’s all”
It was when he started calling out individuals that there was an issue.6 -
Agreed. But he was right in his assessments.Croydon said:
Bowyer was absolutely spot on here.Leuth said:
Yeah, and it was both a misdiagnosis and a dick move. So glad he's not our manager, and hopefully never will be againAddick_8 said:This quote from Bowyer back when we lost 4-2 to Burton last season (first defeat in 9) couldn’t be more true about a majority of this squad right now:
“They are playing for a great club and some of the players we have in this dressing room were struggling to find clubs – this club took you out of that problem. The club expects you to rebound with hard work – that’s all”
It was when he started calling out individuals that there was an issue.2 -
If we ever was ?iamdan said:No longer in running for Defoe - SLP4 -
https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-athletic-manager-interested-in-deal-for-jermain-defoe/RonnieMoore said:
If we ever was ?iamdan said:No longer in running for Defoe - SLP
2 -
So some fringe (rightly or wrongly) players out on loan.
Some youth players out on youth loans to get experience
Money spent on a proven league one goal scorer.
A 22 year old loanee with little playing team and perhaps isn't match fit who might become a permanent deal.
An 18 year old loanee with little first team experience but an England international and recommended by SCP
Chasing a striker/attacking midfielder proven in league 1 but coming back from a long injury lay-off that might also become a perm deal.
So without seeing any of them play for us, Browne deal not done and no idea how Kirk does at Blackpool how have we done?
Marks out of ten?
0 -
A big old meh of a 5. None of the new signings particularly excite me, Davison and Kirk going on loan doesn't bother me, none of our players are good or fit enough for someone to try and prise away from us with a cheeky bid, and we have 0 chance of going up and very little chance of going down.Henry Irving said:So some fringe (rightly or wrongly) players out on loan.
Some youth players out on youth loans to get experience
Money spent on a proven league one goal scorer.
A 22 year old loanee with little playing team and perhaps isn't match fit who might become a permanent deal.
An 18 year old loanee with little first team experience but an England international and recommended by SCP
Chasing a striker/attacking midfielder proven in league 1 but coming back from a long injury lay-off that might also become a perm deal.
So without seeing any of them play for us, Browne deal not done and no idea how Kirk does at Blackpool how have we done?
Marks out of ten?0 -
Too early to say - a lot depends on how well the new guys actually settle (if at all) but on paper it's fairly good. A proper wing back and some creativity/fresh legs in midfield are things most of us have been wanting to see, and now we (may) have them.Henry Irving said:So some fringe (rightly or wrongly) players out on loan.
Some youth players out on youth loans to get experience
Money spent on a proven league one goal scorer.
A 22 year old loanee with little playing team and perhaps isn't match fit who might become a permanent deal.
An 18 year old loanee with little first team experience but an England international and recommended by SCP
Chasing a striker/attacking midfielder proven in league 1 but coming back from a long injury lay-off that might also become a perm deal.
So without seeing any of them play for us, Browne deal not done and no idea how Kirk does at Blackpool how have we done?
Marks out of ten?
That said, another striker and maybe a right footed wing back would ALSO be very useful but need to be aware of the limitations of a January window.
I'd give it maybe a 6-7/10 but could be a 5 or an 8 depending on how the new players go.4 - Sponsored links:
-
Out goings 7/10Henry Irving said:So some fringe (rightly or wrongly) players out on loan.
Some youth players out on youth loans to get experience
Money spent on a proven league one goal scorer.
A 22 year old loanee with little playing team and perhaps isn't match fit who might become a permanent deal.
An 18 year old loanee with little first team experience but an England international and recommended by SCP
Chasing a striker/attacking midfielder proven in league 1 but coming back from a long injury lay-off that might also become a perm deal.
So without seeing any of them play for us, Browne deal not done and no idea how Kirk does at Blackpool how have we done?
Marks out of ten?
In comings far far to early to tell 1 has played 2 games 2 have played no games and 1 hasn't even signed yet. All massive gambles that could, or couldn't pay off.
I suppose if they pay off Gallen has worked a miracle, if they don't.....
Best case scenario they all stay fit and the two young lads come back next season. That's almost half a team.0 -
https://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/shirty5 said:
https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-athletic-manager-interested-in-deal-for-jermain-defoe/RonnieMoore said:
If we ever was ?iamdan said:No longer in running for Defoe - SLP
Page 57 says we wasn't.5 -
Browne off!!!
Back to the Bowyer chat then, everyone actually ignored the actual rumour on the previous page.......0 -
7 -
Now those who were unhappy it was happening can switch to being unhappy it hasn't happened.69
-
So that leaves us a player short compared to what JJ wants. If he's so crocked we don't even want him, he should consider a career change4
-
RedRobin said:The South London Press has been told that Charlton closely scrutinised a deal for Browne but eventually decided the switch was not right for them at this point.
Browne wanted too much money, the club didnt agree given his injury record perhaps?
God help us if he joins Oxford and scores against us next month1 -
Would hope we go for someone with more match fitness, but beggars can’t be choosers.0
