Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton Summer Transfer Rumours 2024
Comments
-
I'm sure Ipswich will consider our position as their potential feeder Club 😪0
-
Or they just want to keep him - even as backup.ShootersHillGuru said:
I take it that Ipswich know of our (other) interest and want a fee.Athletico Charlton said:RonnieMoore said:
Walton of Ipswich …. Is the keeper we wantshirty5 said:
Ruddy hell it’s Soft CellSir Chrissy said:You'll be Ruddy suprised when you find out who the n.1 GK is planned to be.
....Is what Reams on ITTV has hinted at this afternoon0 -
He didn't do a lot wrong at Pafos.ElfsborgAddick said:Leuth said:
Right.Braziliance said:
He isn't young, 26 isn't young for a footballer, irrespective of a footballers career being prolonged by playing in goal.Leuth said:He's young and extremely highly rated ftr
I also doubt he's extremely highly rated, as extremely highly rated goalkeepers aren't 26 years old with less than 30 league appearances playing for Cambridge, and potentially, moving to League 1 Charlton on a free.
Wherever he ends up being good or not is anyone's guess, but I don't see who is rating him extremely highly..
He was a young and very promising keeper at Premiership/Championship Hull, yes?
Then three things happened at once. Hull went down to League One. Covid pandemic struck. Mannion's contract expired.
So he was let go in the worst possible circumstances. And with the whole world, let alone football, in chaos. It was the worst possible timing.
Do you really blame him for going to Pafos (which is a lovely place into the bargain) and restarting his career that way in the circumstances?
It means he's had to build again from scratch. But 26 is still young for a keeper, and he's been getting a bunch of very good reviews.
I'd still say he's young and very highly rated. He hasn't played much yet for a bunch of reasons, many of which were beyond his control.Years Team Apps (Gls) 2016–2020 Hull City 0 (0) 2017 → Plymouth Argyle (loan) 0 (0) 2018–2019 → Aldershot Town (loan) 22 (0) 2019–2020 → Kidderminster Harriers (loan) 17 (0) 2020–2021 Pafos 0 (0) 2021– Cambridge United 29 (0) 2021–2022 → Havant & Waterlooville (loan) 11 (0 Not the most impressive of stats, and nothing screaming of "highly rated".Still, as is correctly put on here by a few posters, a player can be judged when they put on the shirt.15 -
well that's not happening then.Athletico Charlton said:RonnieMoore said:
Walton of Ipswich …. Is the keeper we wantshirty5 said:
Ruddy hell it’s Soft CellSir Chrissy said:You'll be Ruddy suprised when you find out who the n.1 GK is planned to be.
....Is what Reams on ITTV has hinted at this afternoon6 -
Spursshirty5 said:
John Boy?RonnieMoore said:
Walton of Ipswich …. Is the keeper we wantshirty5 said:
Ruddy hell it’s Soft CellSir Chrissy said:You'll be Ruddy suprised when you find out who the n.1 GK is planned to be.1 -
Callumcafc said:It’s a gamble but it’s what we have to start doing to get an advantage over the competition.
There’s always talk of being first to uncover good players - needing to find them 12 months before they break out after which the whole EFL wants them. It’s a strategy that means some won’t work out and be flops.
It sounds as if Mannion was being tipped for Cambridge no. 1 next season. If he kept 15+ clean sheets and we’re still mid table League One then suddenly he has many more attractive options than us.
The issue with gambles is we need probably 8-10 new players; many of those need to be first team 11 players as we already have enough squad depth ones.
As you say, taking gambles means some work out, some don't. Best recruitment of this type of player is probably 50% success. If we bring in 10 players, 5 are a success and 5 fail we likely stay down and our owners write off another £10M to stay in L1.
Of course if Mannion is to be 2nd choice keeper the risk is minimal.0 -
Charlton Athletic and Bristol Rovers have both reportedly met the asking price for full-back Josh Edwards from Dunfermline, according to The Courier.
The defender is set to hold talks with the Addicks and The Gas over a potential move after both clubs reportedly had bids accepted by the Scottish club.
17 -
Actual rumour with a legitimate source, credit where its due Ronnie Moore!RonnieMoore said:Charlton Athletic and Bristol Rovers have both reportedly met the asking price for full-back Josh Edwards from Dunfermline, according to The Courier.
The defender is set to hold talks with the Addicks and The Gas over a potential move after both clubs reportedly had bids accepted by the Scottish club.
25 -
Indeed, that's the way to do it.cafcsinger said:
Actual rumour with a legitimate source, credit where its due Ronnie Moore!RonnieMoore said:Charlton Athletic and Bristol Rovers have both reportedly met the asking price for full-back Josh Edwards from Dunfermline, according to The Courier.
The defender is set to hold talks with the Addicks and The Gas over a potential move after both clubs reportedly had bids accepted by the Scottish club.
1 -
You'd think we're more appealing but Bristol could offer him guaranteed playing time which we won't I don't think.3
- Sponsored links:
-
-
Things seem to be moving at least although not new names.
A test for Jones and Scott to get Edwards and a few more over line.8 -
fenaddick said:
Rovers have money now too, still hope he have more pulling power thoughButtleJR said:You'd think we're more appealing but Bristol could offer him guaranteed playing time which we won't I don't think.
Rovers aren't super minted, their owner is but he's never really put large sums in at one time just steadily given budget increases to improve their squad0 -
Maybe but the key thing to get right is the spine of the team, which is currently completely lacking.Dazzler21 said:Assuming we are getting 2 keepers in that's now a shopping list of:
Mannion
GK
RWB
CB
CB
LWB
CM (Luke Berry?)
CM
CM
STR
Maybe even more!?
By spine I mean
-Goalkeeper who dominates the penalty area
-Centre back who leads and organises the defence
-Midfield General (like Cullen)
-Striker whom Alfie can play off.(Maybe Leaburn if fit)
We have to get all these 4 positions right, everybody else is second order.4 -
To sum up the last 75 pages. IF there’s a rumour, and IF it’s true, and IF it happens and IF they play, I will judge the useless fucker then.14
-
But if we target 8-10 sure successes (they don’t exist but let’s assume) then you quite often lose out to teams in a better position than you. Aaron Collins to Bolton in January springs to mind. Meanwhile someone who was attainable has just signed for someone else and has a good season.Athletico Charlton said:Callumcafc said:It’s a gamble but it’s what we have to start doing to get an advantage over the competition.
There’s always talk of being first to uncover good players - needing to find them 12 months before they break out after which the whole EFL wants them. It’s a strategy that means some won’t work out and be flops.
It sounds as if Mannion was being tipped for Cambridge no. 1 next season. If he kept 15+ clean sheets and we’re still mid table League One then suddenly he has many more attractive options than us.
The issue with gambles is we need probably 8-10 new players; many of those need to be first team 11 players as we already have enough squad depth ones.
As you say, taking gambles means some work out, some don't. Best recruitment of this type of player is probably 50% success. If we bring in 10 players, 5 are a success and 5 fail we likely stay down and our owners write off another £10M to stay in L1.
Of course if Mannion is to be 2nd choice keeper the risk is minimal.
We should be shopping in both markets at the same time really.0 -
He gets a lot of rumours right. Rumours are rumours. So of course some will fall through..Bedsaddick said:
well that's not happening then.Athletico Charlton said:RonnieMoore said:
Walton of Ipswich …. Is the keeper we wantshirty5 said:
Ruddy hell it’s Soft CellSir Chrissy said:You'll be Ruddy suprised when you find out who the n.1 GK is planned to be.
....Is what Reams on ITTV has hinted at this afternoon1 -
Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.1
-
A dozen things go into a signing, it's not just who throws more money at the playerBR7_addick said:Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.11 - Sponsored links:
-
...Unless your name is Lyle Taylor...🙄sam3110 said:
A dozen things go into a signing, it's not just who throws more money at the playerBR7_addick said:Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.2 -
We seen London not the pull it use to be ..even offering double the money can’t persuade players and more important their family to move to a troubled capital cityBR7_addick said:Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.24 -
How many of our players actually live in London? Maybe some of the younger ones might want to, but I’d imagine most live in nicer places further outRonnieMoore said:
We seen London not the pull it use to be ..even offering double the money can’t persuade players and more important their family to move to a troubled capital cityBR7_addick said:Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.2 -
Whilst my comment was tongue in cheek. I disagree in general. Wrexham and Ipswich regularly beat teams in leagues above to signings with cold hard consideration.sam3110 said:
A dozen things go into a signing, it's not just who throws more money at the playerBR7_addick said:Well if he goes Bristol rovers over us is this legitimate grounds for a small meltdown? The budget should, if promotion worthy, be beating them to a signing you’d hope.3 -
Since August, 2023.ross1 said:Many still on holiday3 -
six weeks this weekend since our last game. It's felt like an eternity. With not a single bit of significant news to chew over since the retained list. Desperate for a signing not due to incontinence issues but due to boredom.0
-
11 -
mart77 said:
WIOTOS, then I might believe it..🙄2 -
eastterrace6168 said:mart77 said:
WIOTOS, then I might believe it..🙄
He's on holiday ATM so unless it was agreed before he went I doubt that's true.0 -
This discussion has been closed.
