Saturday will be interesting selection wise, no Watson, Oshilaja, Pearce or Inniss, so I can see us going with a back 4 of Gunter, Pratley, Famewo and Maatsen, or maybe even adding Matthews right wing back and going 5 at the back
How we've longed for a cultured and positive player like Shinnie. We expect miracles from players (Alfie, Aribo, Gallagher) in the final 3rd but he brings structure by glueing the ball to feet and keeping head up to spot a pass.
Great result. Another clean sheet. Team performance was that. Thought Shinnie was great. Smyth and Washington had their best games. With Pratley in central defence and Watson out on Saturday, we could be forced to go very attacking with JW and Maddison coming in. Aneke also should feature. Bogle has put in a good couple of shifts. Red army!
Any Watson doubters - look how we controlled that game when we went down to 10. I imagine he was a major contributing factor to that - it's almost like we got better when we had 10.
On the other hand he was pretty invisible in the first half, and could have easily got another yellow. He played well when we went down to 10 men, but then so did everyone else in the field, and they contributed more elsewhere during the game
It's a fair enough point, but I would argue its not Watson's job to contribute elsewhere on the pitch. Its his job to be the shield in front of the defence breaking up play, by making tackles and interceptions and then distribute the ball to a player like Shinnie or Smyth who can then link up the attack.
And whatever you think of him, he clearly does that very well - as well as adds something even more important and what Bows wants - leadership and experience.
A weird 1st half in that we weren't very good, but scored 2 good goals, one after a nice bit of play, the other from a good shot that their keeper should have saved. Indeed the biggest difference between the teams was Amos vs Eastwood, Eastwood really struggled tonight while Amos was dominant
I don't like Pratley and Watson together in midfield, and would have much preferred to have one on the bench and someone more progressive in midfield. By all means bring the other one off the bench when you need to tighten things up (e.g. after the sending off), but you don't need to start with both. Now, with Watson suspended and Pratley likely to be in defence, we will have neither in midfield vs Pompey.
We actually played better in the second half, Inniss was perhaps a bit unlucky to be sent off BUT his first booking was stupid and the second one fell into the "often given but the referee usually gives you the benefit of the doubt if you're on
Smyth looks more suited as a winger than as a striker
Smyth hasn't scored for 28 games in this division (including for Wycombe last season) so I would worry if we are going to rely on him for too many goals
Really good three points and still feel more to come from this team but laying the foundations now.
Worked so hard all across the pitch and shinnie showing a touch of class that was difference.
Typical Robinson team we see many times in that they had a lot of the ball looked in control without asking enough and then was undone at the back when questions asked.
Smyth worked his socks off and his best game for us.
Easy win really. Will be interesting to see how we go vs Pompey with Watson and Innis missing. Gunter in the middle with Matthews RB I guess. Shinnie looks a great signing.
Slightly worrying first 20 minutes or so but no panic, Mr Mainwaring. Just teasing Robbo that his lads were in control.
And once again, a superlative performance by THE team on a roll.
Never mind that we finished with 10 against 12, or that we'll be without 2 of our finest on Saturday ......this squad of battlers fear no-one.
Setbacks ? Nah. Take them in their stride.
Very difficult again to name my MOM but SG and the gaffer have made some blinding signings despite the disadvantage of a late start to proceedings. And not to forget Sir Thomas who has given his seal of approval.
But have to say I DO like @KillersBeard 's posh son .....runs his little cotton socks off every time he plays.
The humbugs were on standby tonight but not required until Ryan's red card. Even then, I should have kept the faith.
Eagerly looking forward to facing the old foe in 4 days time but sad we won't be meeting up with our gang for a bite to eat before walking to the ground for what is usually one of our favourite away trips. So many good memories , whether seated in the covered away end or the numerous times out in the open.
Let's hope that Marquis has an off day and is foolishly complacent that he's not facing our new stalwart at the back.....strength in depth, old son.
Pity we won’t go into the Pompey game at full strength. Could have been a defining game for where we currently are. Instead we go into the game already on the back foot.
Let’s see. We are no pushovers. I can see Matthews and Gunter playing in that game.
Any Watson doubters - look how we controlled that game when we went down to 10. I imagine he was a major contributing factor to that - it's almost like we got better when we had 10.
On the other hand he was pretty invisible in the first half, and could have easily got another yellow. He played well when we went down to 10 men, but then so did everyone else in the field, and they contributed more elsewhere during the game
We got better straight after half time and it was not down to Watson. It was Pratley who stepped up, winning the ball more in midfield and not letting Oxford play.
Any Watson doubters - look how we controlled that game when we went down to 10. I imagine he was a major contributing factor to that - it's almost like we got better when we had 10.
On the other hand he was pretty invisible in the first half, and could have easily got another yellow. He played well when we went down to 10 men, but then so did everyone else in the field, and they contributed more elsewhere during the game
It's a fair enough point, but I would argue its not Watson's job to contribute elsewhere on the pitch. Its his job to be the shield in front of the defence breaking up play, by making tackles and interceptions and then distribute the ball to a player like Shinnie or Smyth who can then link up the attack.
And whatever you think of him, he clearly does that very well - as well as adds something even more important and what Bows wants - leadership and experience.
But he wasn't doing that shielding job very well in the 1st half, Oxford carved us open several times
Portsmouth have won 6 of their last 7 in all competitions and scored 18 goals in that time. That will be a real test and a draw would be a great result especially as we will be missing Inniss
Watching the end of the replay of the Innis sending off, none of the Charlton players protested, which suggests that they thought it was a second yellow as well
Or ...
The Charlton players sussed out that the ref was such a twonk that he'd start booking all of them for dissent and then start sending them off as well.
This ref truly was the bastard love-child of Stroud and Kettle, and adopted by Linnington.
Even with the numerical disadvantage (us a player sent off plus them having the ref) we didn't look troubled, Oxford wouldn't have broken through our back five if they'd carried on playing for another couple of weeks.
Shinnie was my MotM but there were good shifts from Smyth, Prats, and, of course, the defensive unit.
It's a shame that Inniss won't be available for Saturday so Lord Bowyer will have to re-shuffle his pack but with the belief in this squad at the moment I don't think it'll bother them.
Comments
- Amos
- Matthews Gunter Famewo Maatsen
- Williams Forster-Caskey Shinnie
- Smyth Aneke Washington
To start maybe, not too bad, Pratley rested,And whatever you think of him, he clearly does that very well - as well as adds something even more important and what Bows wants - leadership and experience.
If we can keep a right mark on the Marquis of Portsmouth we will be fine.
Amos
Matthews | Gunter | Pratley | Famewo | Maatsen
Forster-Caskey | Shinnie
Aneke
Smyth | Washington
Is how I'd go
https://londonnewsonline.co.uk/charlton-boss-lee-bowyer-reveals-details-of-alfie-doughtys-injury-it-doesnt-look-good-at-all/
Haven't looked that up but it's probably true.
Fanny cut off in her prime !!?
OK, I'll try again.....
Slightly worrying first 20 minutes or so but no panic, Mr Mainwaring. Just teasing Robbo that his lads were in control.
And once again, a superlative performance by THE team on a roll.
Never mind that we finished with 10 against 12, or that we'll be without 2 of our finest on Saturday ......this squad of battlers fear no-one.
Setbacks ? Nah. Take them in their stride.
Very difficult again to name my MOM but SG and the gaffer have made some blinding signings despite the disadvantage of a late start to proceedings. And not to forget Sir Thomas who has given his seal of approval.
But have to say I DO like @KillersBeard 's posh son .....runs his little cotton socks off every time he plays.
The humbugs were on standby tonight but not required until Ryan's red card. Even then, I should have kept the faith.
Eagerly looking forward to facing the old foe in 4 days time but sad we won't be meeting up with our gang for a bite to eat before walking to the ground for what is usually one of our favourite away trips. So many good memories , whether seated in the covered away end or the numerous times out in the open.
Let's hope that Marquis has an off day and is foolishly complacent that he's not facing our new stalwart at the back.....strength in depth, old son.
Can't wait !!!!!!
And occasionally you get an interview with the managers as well later on.
So I will wouldn't be shocked to see
Amos
Gunter Famewo Purrington
Matthews Maatsen
Pratley Williams JFC
Smyth Aneke
The Charlton players sussed out that the ref was such a twonk that he'd start booking all of them for dissent and then start sending them off as well.
This ref truly was the bastard love-child of Stroud and Kettle, and adopted by Linnington.
Even with the numerical disadvantage (us a player sent off plus them having the ref) we didn't look troubled, Oxford wouldn't have broken through our back five if they'd carried on playing for another couple of weeks.
Shinnie was my MotM but there were good shifts from Smyth, Prats, and, of course, the defensive unit.
It's a shame that Inniss won't be available for Saturday so Lord Bowyer will have to re-shuffle his pack but with the belief in this squad at the moment I don't think it'll bother them.