That's a handball from most of the refs at this tournament, far enough away from Musiala and hand isn't right next to his body
Cucurella’s arm was right in the grey area of “making his body unnaturally bigger” BUT was bringing his arm into his torso, not away from. With the current rules that’s saved Cucurella there…
Bizarre rule isn't it. Leaves far too much up to interpretation
Agree, it does seem unfair that for instance Denmark conceded a penalty to Germany but Germany didn’t get this one against Spain.
Unfortunately I don’t know how you remove the subjectivity of what is and isn’t deliberate handball without significantly changing the rules. The problem is that the punishment of a penalty is often way too harsh for what actually happened.
One suggestion has been to look at making all instances of ball to hand across the pitch (deliberate or not) a handball offence, awarding indirect free kicks instead of penalties when it occurs in the penalty area.
That way you can be more black and white about saying “ok ball hit the arm here, free kick” without worrying about over punishing defenders for a cross brushing their hand on the way through etc…
One extra piece, you could say only handballs inside the six yard box are penalties, that ensures you still stop defenders from using their hands on the line etc.
Comments
One suggestion has been to look at making all instances of ball to hand across the pitch (deliberate or not) a handball offence, awarding indirect free kicks instead of penalties when it occurs in the penalty area.
One extra piece, you could say only handballs inside the six yard box are penalties, that ensures you still stop defenders from using their hands on the line etc.
Just a slightly more solid-looking boring.
I was just thinking can we have Ally McCoist again
Murphy has no sense of the occasion, no excitement, he's just a miserable bastard
If you were stood next to him in the pub you'd think about moving
Our refs are shit