Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Post-match Thread: Charlton Athletic vs Oxford United | Saturday 19th February 2022
Comments
-
I would like to erase 2020 & 2021 from my memory but not 2019.paulg1947 said:The last time that we were promoted out of this third tier was with Chris Powell- With a defense minded formation -1-0 wins were the norm and draws away Not pretty but progress never the less. Can we learn something from this Powell era?-- I spoke over the fence briefly to Carl Jensen after a Melbourne City match, 2 nights ago ( on loan from Notts Forest) He asked are you a Charlton supporter? Best team in London.i said. Oh i don't know about that ,he replied .After this performance, I have my doubts now.2 -
It’s not watching ex players on the Quest hi light show that gets me it’s the way other teams pass, open up defensives, score goals from outside the box and excite. And I am talking about from the Championship down to League Two.JamesSeed said:Hanlan, Kirk, Taylor, Grant, Davison, Williams all doing well elsewhere.Watching Quest is thoroughly depressing. Watching other clubs doing well is depressing. Why them, not usFinding solace in others doing badly though. Fulham lost. Yay! Man City lost. Palace lost. Yay. Schadenfreude is all we have at the moment.
Its like we are playing another game.2 -
I Think Robinson and Jacko will be close and what Robinson has told us, if we care to listen, is that the problems at this club are not Jacko's doing which I never thought they would be. I can't be sure but if you have somebody who doesn't know anything about the game who thinks they do in a position of power, you are more likely to get cock up after cock up. I'm not saying I know everything about the game, but I am not in a position to do any damage. We need a good CEO. Money is clearly being spent but possibly without any real strategy to it.1
-
Gave up watching after Bolton, one of the more decent decisions I've made of late. I did set out to try and watch every game this season, getting up at 1.50am for 3pm kick offs just became too much of a chore considering the drudgery served up on the field.Not sure where we go from here.... a complete clear out would make sense, but this is Charlton.Once again, I do hope Facebook isn't flooded with images of our players pissing about and having a laugh after training. I'd love to see a level of professionalism restored, right now what we are seeing on the pitch is a disgrace.0
-
Swindon would beat us.EveshamAddick said:
4 goals and 3 assists. But it is League 2 of course.Chunes said:
Williams has started 12 games this season.JamesSeed said:Hanlan, Kirk, Taylor, Grant, Davison, Williams all doing well elsewhere.Watching Quest is thoroughly depressing. Watching other clubs doing well is depressing. Why them, not usFinding solace in others doing badly though. Fulham lost. Yay! Man City lost. Palace lost. Yay. Schadenfreude is all we have.0 -
Yeah. I reckon for most people suffering outweighs the good times.se9addick said:
Agree, but the ratio as a Charlton fan seems a bit off!seth plum said:Yesterday was dreadful but I will still go on Tuesday and I expect it to be worse.
I have always felt that suffering times like these legitimises celebrating the good times.
Luton Town fans have suffered majorly in the past so their present joy has every right to be unconfined.
Perhaps that is what makes a lot of people gravitate towards big and successful clubs. Avoiding suffering comes before other considerations like local loyalty for example.
My experience of football and life is it is mainly suffering.1 -
We actually started okay knocking the ball around and looking fairly confident for 15mins or so, but without really creating anything. Oxford looked like they were expecting an early flurry from us and sat back. Once they realised it wasn't coming they took control and started ruthlessly dismantling our "defence". At 1 nil it was all over as we were never going to score! The reaction after the 2nd was the most telling thing. Not one player geeing them up. Heads down, hands on hips, players fucking around with their socks, rearranging themselves etc. Absolutely disgracefully, we have no guts in this side. And three centre halves on the bench with one in the 1st 11? Piss off Jackson. Getting fed up with it all now. Will probably go on Tuesday though haha!0
-
I will be there Tuesday but like today I have no belief that we will get anything from the game - it’s illogical to keep going if u just go to watch a winning team but being logical isn’t what be a football supporter is about - it’s mainly about meeting up with friends and family, enduring big chunks of crap with the odd good spell no and then - I’m sure things will pick up once the injured are back but yesterday was a real low - there have been many lower points though, even if not by league position / status. Maybe I’m mad but I’m expecting a promotion push next year still1
-
One of Richard Cawley’s articles on LondonNewsOnline website is titled ‘Players need to show me they want to be here next season’ – Charlton boss Johnnie Jackson reacts to Oxford loss.
With the exception of George Dobson I don’t want any of the other players to be at the club next season. God help us if the majority are still here next season.1 -
We need to be in this division next season which is not a certainty by any means.3
- Sponsored links:
-
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?1 -
Just prior to their third, I noted Inniss electing to stay up field as the ball was returned to Mac.
It made sense as a decent kick could put us on the attack - and we were chasing the game. In the event it was a poor kick, it went unchallenged and 12 seconds later, MacGillivray was digging the ball outta the net.
Had Stockley been playing there would have been a challenge and it wouldn't have happened Equally hadMac's kick reached Inniss it wouldn't have happened.
In the final analysis I think we are a mess.
0 -
Even if he could he’s still exceptionally average.Fortune 82nd Minute said:
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?1 -
Really? The number of minutes he can play is a massive issue, but his goals to minutes ratio is pretty good at this level.paulfox said:
Even if he could he’s still exceptionally average.Fortune 82nd Minute said:
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?4 -
I appreciate your opinion, however IMO he is one of the most over rated footballers I’ve seen in Charlton shirt.se9addick said:
Really? The number of minutes he can play is a massive issue, but his goals to minutes ratio is pretty good at this level.paulfox said:
Even if he could he’s still exceptionally average.Fortune 82nd Minute said:
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?0 -
Fair enoughpaulfox said:
I appreciate your opinion, however IMO he is one of the most over rated footballers I’ve seen in Charlton shirt.se9addick said:
Really? The number of minutes he can play is a massive issue, but his goals to minutes ratio is pretty good at this level.paulfox said:
Even if he could he’s still exceptionally average.Fortune 82nd Minute said:
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?0 -
Charlton's squad is large and probably near the top end of the pay scale in this division but there are still major deficiencies in the squad. Our best centre back rarely completes a season, his replacement is 35 years old. Out of the three first choice forwards, one we know can't manage two games a week, the other is thirty years of age and if he refused a contract this year it's hard to see him going upwards a division and upwards in earnings. Stockley has been restricted due to a freak injury. The wing backs have been altered since Jacko played this system which tells you something about his confidence in those picked in that position. Of the three in midfield only Dobson has been consistent and we can only hope Fraser produces the goods when fit, Gilbey, Morgan and maybe Foster Caskey, if he recovers fitness and gets a contract, have not produced consistent form over the season and yes I know Forster Caskey hasn't played. At one time I would have said five players to replace and galvanise the squad, at this point I think it's more likely to be ten.MuttleyCAFC said:I Think Robinson and Jacko will be close and what Robinson has told us, if we care to listen, is that the problems at this club are not Jacko's doing which I never thought they would be. I can't be sure but if you have somebody who doesn't know anything about the game who thinks they do in a position of power, you are more likely to get cock up after cock up. I'm not saying I know everything about the game, but I am not in a position to do any damage. We need a good CEO. Money is clearly being spent but possibly without any real strategy to it.1 -
12th January 1974 I remember it quite well.DartfordAddick said:
I remember us getting beat 4-0 and absolutely played off the park by Brighton. I’m pretty sure they went on to win the league that season though.se9addick said:
30 odd years, we can’t have lost at home 4-0 in the third division too many times in that period?ShootersHillGuru said:
A bloke called Ronnie Howell scored a hat trick.
Brighton were also mid tableish, certainly weren't a promotion contender.
https://www.11v11.com/teams/charlton-athletic/tab/opposingTeams/opposition/Brighton and Hove Albion/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Howell_(footballer,_born_1949)
http://www.swindonfc1879.com/WhereAreTheyNowDetail.asp?PersonID=HOWELLRO
"Clough took over in the November and Ron did his best to impress by netting a hat-trick in a 4-0 away win at Charlton just after Christmas. But after 27 League appearances for Albion he found himself excluded from the team sheet and, on daring to question that decision, was told “Young man, take the wife and kids and go for a long walk down the pier !” But Ron’s journey took him instead to Tooting".
1 -
And why was Inniss upfield?Raith_C_Chattonell said:Just prior to their third, I noted Inniss electing to stay up field as the ball was returned to Mac.
It made sense as a decent kick could put us on the attack - and we were chasing the game. In the event it was a poor kick, it went unchallenged and 12 seconds later, MacGillivray was digging the ball outta the net.
Had Stockley been playing there would have been a challenge and it wouldn't have happened Equally had
In the final analysis I think we are a mess.
Because the whole passage of play started from our bloody free kick a few seconds before!
Albie's ball into the box was headed out by the defence, collected near the centre-circle by the most undeserving player to have his own song, Eliott Lee, who instead of passing forward to one of the nine team-mates more advanced than him, decided to send it back to MacKeeper to lump forward.
And the rest is history.
As should be Lee.7 - Sponsored links:
-
3 things that specifically irritated me yesterday:
- Notice the difference in first touch from Gilbey and their players in the penalty area. Putting the ball out for a goal kick shows composure and attacking level.
- Clare has shown that he has needed a "rest" for a few games now. Being at fault for goals during games and now a 3 match ban. I think a Manager needs to work out these kind of things. The better ones do.
- I'd like to see Jacko take some more accountability for results too. The fans deserve an apology for yesterday.5 -
Gilbey's touch is so poor. He's like Carl Tiler with an engine. No quality.
8 -
It's the formation and playing players out of position in that formation.Exiled_Addick said:
Agreed. We have to stop trying to attack our way out of these ruts. Bowyer started doing it, Adkins did it, and now Jacko is doing it. No one wants to hear it, but the bottom line we have to start defending better and winning some points. If that means playing ugly football with men parked behind the ball and snatching a few goals from set pieces then so be it. Goals win you games but successful sides are always built on an ability to not concede a lot of goals, and particularly not soft ones. Defensively we are a really soft touch right now and we shouldn’t be because players like Innis, Famewo, Dobson, Lavelle are not bad players. Even Matthews and Purrington are better than the absolute shite they put out today. We are so vulnerable to just a simple long ball and every time we lose it in the attacking third I fear there will be a shot on our goal following shortly after.Covered End said:
If JJ had set the team up properly and kept it tight, we may have made a game of it.EveshamAddick said:
This. Even more recently we won 3 games in a row. Keep saying it, but if your 3 strikers are out you’re fucked, even if you’re Klopp.usetobunkin said:Can’t believe this is the same manager who produced a performance against Sunderland away and we looked well set for a cracking “Do or Die” season. What the f@&k has gone wrong?
The players are average, but they are set up wrong and playing in the wrong positions.I don’t know if it’s shape, where we’re setting the defensive line, personnel, when and how we’re using the press, or what, but something is not right at the back.
The players then lose confidence and it gets worse.
The same loss of confidence led to the spiral under Adkins.3 -
It’s weird I thought he started to look a player a couple of months ago, I think it was the Ipswich game, he scored to cap off the game. He was really good that game but since he’s been poor. But in general as a team the Jekyll and Hyde nature of all of the players, except Dobson within reason is something I can’t understand, is it just a case of that’s why these players are playing in league one?. But in over instances it’s not unknown for league one level players to step up to championship players comfortably. I’m very confused and disappointed by Charlton as a whole at the moment.Chunes said:Gilbey's touch is so poor. He's like Carl Tiler with an engine. No quality.0 -
They preferred to talk about Oxford, probably unsurprisingly, followed by a bit about Joey Beauchamp.Weegie Addick said:Just about everything been said already. But I am puzzled re the sending off. From my vantage high in NU, could have sworn I saw Innis throw and connect with a punch. Yet he only got yellow. Have no inclination to watch Quest or highlights - has this been picked up at all or was I seeing things?
0 -
Agreed, although we’re watching the highlights on Quest which tends to exaggerate the quality of the football being played. What worries me watching matches live is how other teams don’t seem to make as many mistakes as we do. We can have a good spell of possession but they keep us at bay, and when we do get crosses in they defend them well.eaststandmike said:
It’s not watching ex players on the Quest hi light show that gets me it’s the way other teams pass, open up defensives, score goals from outside the box and excite. And I am talking about from the Championship down to League Two.JamesSeed said:Hanlan, Kirk, Taylor, Grant, Davison, Williams all doing well elsewhere.Watching Quest is thoroughly depressing. Watching other clubs doing well is depressing. Why them, not usFinding solace in others doing badly though. Fulham lost. Yay! Man City lost. Palace lost. Yay. Schadenfreude is all we have at the moment.
Its like we are playing another game.Hopefully Fraser might be our missing link, but knowing our luck he’ll get long covid.Can’t decide about Tuesday. Haven’t missed a home match for some time, and don’t want to miss one of those unexpected wins, but it might be a painful night.0 -
Our players are disgraceful, they chew with their mouths open.addick1956 said:
The problem is the other teams have players who ate better than ours .cabbles said:
Captain Pointer. All this bloke does is point, runs that don’t go anywhere and the occasional tweet bigging up his other mediocre team mates.Simonsen said:
Yes. Hid superbly in the 1st half.Leuth said:Wait, Gilbey was CAPTAIN?! Sack him. Sack him nowGenuinely baffles me how he’s gotten such a good rep among a lot of the fans.2 goals this season. 2. One of those was in the Papa John’s. Imo, he’s a big part of the problem because he’s considered one of the ‘better’ players. It’s why we’re in this mess. These are our ‘better’ players.Got another year of him to put up with as well0 -
The only decent thing all day that showed one iota of credibility was the announcement of the crowd being somewhat in the region of believability...
Clutching at straws here.0 -
His crap form started as soon as his partner gave birth to their child.EveshamAddick said:
People are knocking him because certainly for the last 3 games he had been at fault for at least one of the goals each game.colthe3rd said:
I know it's trendy to knock him at the moment but this is nonsense.Croydon said:Those highlights are appalling. We were undone but one long ball so many times.
Craig at fault for at least two of those goals, maybe even 3 if you count his pass poor kick which led to their 3rd.
Utterly predictable.0 -
Surely that award could be given to various members of Dowie’s team - Faye, Traore, Jimmy Floyd et al !!!paulfox said:
I appreciate your opinion, however IMO he is one of the most over rated footballers I’ve seen in Charlton shirt.se9addick said:
Really? The number of minutes he can play is a massive issue, but his goals to minutes ratio is pretty good at this level.paulfox said:
Even if he could he’s still exceptionally average.Fortune 82nd Minute said:
Chuks can't play 90 minutes 3 times a month. Or should I say season.Cafc43v3r said:
No reason we couldn't have kept Davison and signed Aneke. Surely the club could have made an educated guess that Stockley wouldn't be back any time soon and Chuks couldn't play 90 minutes 3 times a week. Even if Washington was fit we would still be short.wmcf123 said:I know Davison isn’t great yet but it’s a nonsense that we let him go on loan.Also, unpopular opinion, but why did we re-sign Aneke for so much money, knowing that he’s likely to be regularly injured. Surely there were better options from cash strapped clubs for less money ?2
Mac's kick reached Inniss it wouldn't have happened. 
